The case files

Episodes

Looking for a particular fallacy? Try the Fallacy A–Z.

  • Ad Fidentia – FT#204

    Ad Fidentia FT#204

    The Ad Fidentia fallacy occurs when someone attacks their opponent’s self-confidence instead of their argument, and take any doubt expressed as evidence in their favor.

  • David and Goliath Fallacy – FT#203

    David and Goliath Fallacy FT#203

    The David and Goliath Fallacy occurs when someone suggests that the underdog in any dispute is good or right merely because they are the underdog, and…

  • Original Position Fallacy – FT#202

    Original Position Fallacy FT#202

    The Original Position Fallacy occurs when someone supports a potentially harmful policy because they assume they won’t be among the people harmed by it.

  • Tu Quoque (Redux) – FT#201

    Tu Quoque (Redux) FT#201

    Tu Quoque literally means “You too.” It’s a particular type of Red Herring fallacy where the speaker avoids responding to a criticism by distracting the listener…

  • False Uniqueness – FT#200

    False Uniqueness FT#200

    False Uniqueness occurs when someone overestimates how rare their positive traits, abilities, or experience are.

  • Appeal to Pity – FT#199

    Appeal to Pity FT#199

    The Appeal to Pity Fallacy occurs when someone tries to convince others by making them feel sympathetic instead of using evidence.

  • Blinded by AI – FT#198

    Blinded by AI FT#198

    The Blinded by AI Fallacy occurs when someone bases their claim on an unrealistic view of what artificial intelligence is currently capable of reliably achieving.

  • The Courtier’s Reply – FT#197

    The Courtier’s Reply FT#197

    The Courtier’s Reply occurs when someone dismisses their opponent’s opinion by claiming they lack sufficient expertise on the subject to be allowed to opine.

  • Conspiracy Theory Thinking (Redux) – FT#196

    Conspiracy Theory Thinking (Redux) FT#196

    Conspiracy theorists often create unfalsifiable arguments, using a combination of goalpost moving, arguments from ignorance and circular logic.

  • Exact Definition Fallacy – FT#195

    Exact Definition Fallacy FT#195

    The Exact Definition Fallacy occurs when someone disingenuously demands their opponent provide a definition solely to score debate points when they can’t provide one that meets…

  • Appeal to Definition – FT#194

    Appeal to Definition FT#194

    The Appeal to Definition Fallacy occurs when someone relies on a specific definition, from a dictionary or other authority, which supports their argument, and ignores the…

  • Definist Fallacy – FT#193

    Definist Fallacy FT#193

    The Definist Fallacy occurs when someone deliberately redefines a term in a way that’s favorable to their own argument (and is probably a stretch of the…