Show Notes
The Appeal to Definition Fallacy occurs when someone relies on a specific definition, from a dictionary or other authority, which supports their argument, and ignores the possibility that other definitions are also reasonable.
Trump
We started out by discussing this clip of Trump pretending MAGA only means one thing:
Then we talked about this clip of Trump being wrong about 86:
Mark’s British Politics Corner
Mark talked about Boris Johnson quibbling over the definition of checks at the border after Brexit, and his later clarification:
And then we looked at Theresa May explaining what Brexit means:
Fallacy in the Wild (Sting: Supertramp – The Logical Song)
In the Fallacy in the Wild, we looked at this clip from Taskmaster:
Then we discussed this clip from an Autechre track:
And finally, we talked about this clip from Bill Clinton’s deposition:
Fake News
Here are the statements from this week’s Fake News game:

Spoiler
Statement 1 is Fake News. Mark chose number 1Mark got it right this week and is still on 48%!
Prosecutorial misconduct is not a logical fallacy
We talked about the case of the Broadview Six.
The stories we really didn’t have time to talk about
- America’s 250th birthday bash on the National Mall will feature an event called The Great American State Fair, a 16 day expo organized by Freedom 250 – a public-private partnership spawned by one of Trump’s executive orders to rival the actual, congressionally mandated America250 committee. On Wednesday, Freedom 250 proudly announced its lineup of nine musical acts for the Fair, which included country music superstar Martina McBride, funk/soul group the Commodores, and several much less famous performers. Almost immediately, they frantically sprinted to social media to announce that no the fuck they wouldn’t be performing. The lovely and talented McBride, the only one I gave two shits about, said she was told when she agreed to perform that it would be a nonpartisan event to celebrate America, and that “is, in fact, not what is happening.” I’ve got a feeling that the public backlash might have had a bit more to do with it, but at least she came to her senses. Young MC, the Commodores, and Poison frontman Bret Michaels also cited the shocking revelation that there might be a political angle to something Trump does as their reason for peacing out, while Morris Day of Morris Day and the Time simply channeled Simon Cowell and said “It’s a no from me”. Two of the other acts announced were C+C Music Factory, of Gonna Make You Sweat fame, and Milli Vanilli, of massive fraud fame. Neither act is technically performing, because neither act technically ever was, despite the announcement. Freedom Williams, the rapper from C+C, who owns the trademark to the group’s name, announced in a seven minute Instagram rant from his toilet, that he will still be performing despite the backlash because, in his words, “I don’t fuck with Trump. I don’t give a fuck about Trump. I don’t give a fuck about Trump’s family. I know the type of fucking anarchy he creates. But the day I let you motherfuckers tell me what to do is the day I die”. As for Milli Vanilli, the people who actually sang the songs released a statement confirming that they will not be performing, so if you manage to get tickets you’ll only see the lip-synching fakes. Well, one of them anyway, as the other one’s been dead for nearly 20 years. Not sure if that was Milli or Vanilli. Luckily, you will still get to see Flo Rida and Vanilla Ice, so not all is lost. And, of course, the festivities will also include a 110-foot Ferris wheel, special screenings of “National Treasure” and its sequel, “National Treasure: Book of Secrets,” and every kid’s favorite part of a state fair, “CEO and innovator-led conversations and demonstrations”. Faced with an empty stage and a massive lineup deficit, Trump handled the mass exodus with his signature grace and humility. Taking to Truth Social, he suggested canceling the “overpriced, boring singers who nobody wants to hear anyway” and replacing them with a much better, totally non-musical alternative: himself. Because what the people really want is a furious spoken-word performance about crowd sizes and biased federal judges, with occasional air-accordion solos.
- In a deal not- unlike Baroness Mone’s dodgy PPE contract fast-tracked by mates in the Tory party during covid – after all who better to make hospital approved medical grade PPE than a former lingerie influencer, the Pentagon announced a $620 million loan last year to a small North Carolina startup Vulcan Elements. Of the dozens of companies the Pentagon was considering funding at the time, Vulcan’s was the only deal initiated by a top aide to the president, remember Peter Navarro?- yep him. Okay weird howcumzit Navarro was able to fasttrack funding to this particular startup we-eelll about three months before the Pentagon announced plans to lend money to Vulcan Elements, Donald Trump Jr.’s venture capital firm took an undisclosed stake in the company. The $620m loan was a massive financial commitment from the Pentagon in its effort to fund companies that could help the U.S. reduce dependence on China’s critical mineral supply chains. The deal was a dramatic win for Vulcan, a North Carolina rare-earth magnet company launched just two years earlier. Estimates of its valuation grew tenfold after the deal was announced. Don Jr had visited Navarro in prison while he served time for defying a subpoena from lawmakers investigating the Jan. 6, 2021, Capitol riot. Trump Jr. was one of the small group of people Navarro dedicated his latest book to for having “my back when it was against the wall.” And a week before the Vulcan deal was announced, Trump Jr. hosted Navarro — now the president’s senior counselor for trade and manufacturing — on his streaming show, encouraging his nearly 2 million subscribers to buy Navarro’s book. “No company receives preferential treatment,” a Pentagon spokesperson said. “Outside affiliations, investors, or political connections play absolutely no role in the Department’s funding decisions.” The Pentagon’s response did not address how Vulcan was selected, explaining only how the department addresses conflicts that arise from its employees’ financial holdings, not those of the president’s family. The Office of Strategic Capital is expected to deploy billions more in loans in the coming months to critical mineral and military technology companies. Among the companies under review was Unusual Machines, a Florida drone parts maker, a Defense official said. Trump Jr. sits on the company’s advisory board and holds millions of dollars worth of shares. Brodie Sutherland, CEO of Nevada-based tungsten mining company Patriot Critical Minerals, said “It’s like any industry: A lot of what it is, is who you know.” Defense Department records reviewed recently by ProPublica show Sutherland’s company had already been considered for a loan but was rejected. Yep yep yep.
- Let’s check in on the beautiful, unsoiled ecosystem of American campaign finance, which has recently birthed a shiny new Super PAC called “Lead Left.” According to its official mission statement, Lead Left exists to “stand against MAGA extremists who will infect our country with Donald Trump’s agenda.” It sounds ideal, basically a progressive grassroots collective operating out of a yurt. But if you look at their actual spending, Lead Left has a very specific, almost avant-garde strategy: they are dropping millions of dollars into Democratic primaries to back candidates who are completely insane. Take Texas’s 35th District, where Lead Left dumped nearly a million dollars supporting a primary candidate named Maureen Galindo. Galindo is a progressive housing advocate, a sex therapist, and a casual enjoyer of vibrant antisemitic conspiracy theories. In a series of totally normal Instagram posts, she promised that if elected to Congress, she would introduce legislation to convert a local ICE detention center into a literal internment camp for “American Zionists” that would also double as a “castration processing center for pedophiles which will probably be most of the Zionists.” Naturally, mainstream Democrats aggressively backed her sane opponent, Johnny Garcia, who thankfully won the runoff last week. Lead Left has pulled the same stunt in swing House districts in Nebraska and Pennsylvania, backing supposedly progressive candidates with massive political liabilities, or running bizarre TV ads smearing moderate Democrats as secret Trump lovers. It’s almost as if Lead Left isn’t actually run by progressive activists at all. When the investigative journalists at Popular Information started looking into it, they found two Republicans in a trenchcoat instead, For starters, Lead Left structured its filings so it wouldn’t legally have to disclose its real donors until late June—handily after most of these primaries are already over. The PAC registered its official headquarters at a mailbox inside a Staples store in Tallahassee, Florida, and of the 48,000 political committees registered with the FEC over the last decade, only two others have ever used that exact same Tallahassee Staples mailbox. Both of them are directly run by the Crosby Ottenhoff Group, a prominent Republican compliance firm. Furthermore, a quick peek into the metadata of Lead Left’s original website revealed code directly linking it to WinRed, the official fundraising platform for the Republican Party. The man sitting at the top of this entire apparatus is Caleb Crosby, a top-tier Republican operative who concurrently serves as the treasurer for the Congressional Leadership Fund – the primary Super PAC dedicated to electing House Republicans. Yes, the chief fundraising arm of the GOP is secretly laundering millions through shell companies, painting themselves blue, and using a Staples mailbox to fund antisemitic sex therapists and sabotage competitive Democratic primaries from the inside. It’s the kind of cartoonish, multi-layered ratfucking that would make Dick Cheney shed a single, proud tear.
- Since Trump bought between $15,000 and $50,000 worth of shares of stock in TKO, the parent company of UFC, this week, he wants to make sure the TKO event on his front lawn looks good on TV, What better way than to fill out the bleachers with fine examples of strapping young manhood, and where better to go than the military for that following Pete Hogsbreath’s edict told to that room of fat generals and beardos. a memo circulated within the Air Force, eligibility is contingent on meeting “CURRENT WAIST-HEIGHT RATIO and current physical fitness standard.” Another internal message stated that the Department of Defense was looking for junior personnel and officers, specifically. Great okay it’s bit of a jolly, a day out at the White House representing the nation’s prowess, does it really matter that it’s a bit Hitler-youthy in its optics? Except the caveat is that the co-opted aryan specimens have to pay their own way to get there and probably buy their own snacks, though I expect they’re not allowed to be seen holding a coke and a burger – they’d all be on Trumps TV-dinner tray anyway. This despite the fact that the junior troops are the lowest paid in the military. Well I guess AVClub is right in summarising it as there’s no better way to ring in America’s 250th birthday than by humiliating its military while watching some guy have his orbital bone obliterated all in the service of Trump’s share portfolio. Welcome to the American Utopia!
- As we know, if there’s one thing Republicans hate, it’s the weaponization of the Federal government against the President’s enemies. So it must have been a really tough decision for Todd Blanche to launch a criminal perjury investigation into E. Jean Carroll the 82-year-old woman who already beat the deep-fried, spray-tanned stroke hazard in chief twice in civil court and walked away with an $88 million judgment after he was found civilly liable for sexual assault and defamation. The prosecutors’ theory hinges on a 2022 deposition statement by Carroll, that she received no outside funding for her lawsuit, though it was later revealed that billionaire Reid Hoffman had paid some legal fees and expenses. Blanche, the current head of the DOJ, had to recuse himself because he was literally Trump’s personal defense attorney during the Carroll trials. So instead, the DOJ packed up this vindictive little file and shipped it off to prosecutors in Chicago. The moment the story leaked, the Trump-appointed U.S. Attorney in Chicago, Andrew Boutros, sprinted to Twitter to declare that his office “has never opened” an investigation into Carroll and that the rumors were categorically false. Naturally, within minutes, investigative reporters confirmed that the investigation is ongoing, but Boutros says he’s not investigating Carroll, he’s only investigating Hoffman’s nonprofit, American Future Republic. It’s based in Chicago, so there’s the illusion of justification. But that doesn’t make literally any sense. What has American Future Republic done wrong? It’s allowed to donate money to a legal defense fund. I’m not sure Mr. Boutros is telling the truth. Unsurprisingly, this petty act of presidential score-settling is throwing Senate Republicans into an absolute tailspin, because Democrats are already planning to force endless floor votes explicitly condemning the DOJ’s weaponization against an elderly sexual assault survivor, meaning vulnerable Republicans will have to publicly vote to defend this pathetic stunt right on the Senate floor. But hey, that’s the modern American justice system for you. If you’re a private citizen who gets a legal line-item wrong while suing a corrupt administration, they’ll threaten you with a federal cell. If you’re the guy in the Oval Office executing unsolicited multi-million dollar insider trading deals on government supercomputers, they slap your wrist with a devastating $200 fine. Everything is fine, the system works, and the rule of law is totally intact.
- Rather than, say, admit that the self-begun war on Iran is leading to a global economic crisis that’s impacting the American voter’s cost of living and work out a way to call it all over, admit defeat and graciously accept the error and the impact, Trump’s worked out a way to save money at the grocery store; reduce legislation restricting the use of hydro-flourocarbons in refrigerators. Similar to his concerns about showers not working and wind farms noise giving people cancer, Trump’s reversal of Biden-era rules as a way to ease the economic strictures is another way to kill off any and all green policies. Of course it’ll have no such impact as industry groups said it could even raise prices because manufacturers have already redesigned products, retooled factories and trained workers to build and service next-generation refrigerant equipment. But that’s not the point the point is to create another distraction by creating an enemy out of pro-carbon reducing eco-centred net-zero type legislations in order to say that it’s that’ that’s causing the problem and not the large gas-emitting orange bloat himself with an ego that requires so much power it’s dimming the national grid every time he opens his mouth. Inflation in the United States increased to 3.8% annually in April, amid price spikes caused by the Iran war and Trump’s sweeping tariffs. Inflation is now outpacing wage gains as the war has kept oil and gasoline prices high. David Doniger, a senior strategist at the Natural Resources Defense Council, called Trump’s action “a lose-lose for the environment and the economy. It will harm consumers and the climate and reduce American competitiveness in the global markets emerging for environmentally safer refrigerants.” though Kevin McDaniel, whose company operates 14 Piggly Wiggly stores in Florida, Alabama and Georgia (- hmm noticeably Red States I see), said the Biden-era rule would have forced many independent grocers out of business. “It was thrown together too fast,’’ he said. “The technology is not there yet. It’s just way too fast. That’s the problem. Good idea, but it’s terrible.” Oh for a minute there I thought that last bit was a reaction to the notion of making the greediest stupidest failingest reality TV-host President of the United States.
- Well, it looks like Donald Trump’s highly anticipated $1.8 billion right-wing piggy bank has entered hospice care after a brief, magnificent lifecycle of about two weeks. In a stunning display of Trump Always Chickening Out, the White House has officially informed congressional leaders that they are pulling the plug on the “Anti-Weaponization Fund”, the taxpayer-funded vault originally designed to dole out cash rewards to the president’s political cronies and January 6th rioters, thanks to a Republican mutiny and some deeply annoyed federal judges. In case you weren’t paying attention to us in episode 193, the trouble started when Trump decided to file a completely bogus $10 billion lawsuit against the IRS because a contractor leaked his tax returns years ago. But instead of pursuing actual legal damages, Trump’s private lawyers huddled in a room with acting Attorney General and Trump’s previous personal defense lawyer Todd Blanche, and hashed out a “settlement.” The terms? Trump would drop the suit, the IRS would magically waive all ongoing tax audits against him and his sons, and the government would deposit $1.776 billion into a shiny new fund to compensate “victims of lawfare.” Basically, Trump sued his own administration so he could agree to settle with himself, give his family a lifetime tax-evasion pass, and build a massive bribery fund for MAGA loyalists. Somehow, this crossed the line even for Senate Republicans. Mitch McConnell publicly called the fund “utterly stupid” and “morally wrong,” asking why the nation’s top law enforcement official was asking for a slush fund to pay people who assault cops. Senate Majority Leader John Thune told the White House that if they didn’t kill the fund themselves, the Senate would do it for them. Meanwhile, the judicial system decided it wasn’t particularly fond of being used as a prop for administrative money laundering. On Friday, a federal judge in Virginia slapped a temporary restraining order on the fund to freeze any payouts. Simultaneously, Miami federal judge Kathleen Williams, prodded by a bipartisan group of 35 former federal judges, reopened Trump’s original IRS case and demanded answers. The former judges explicitly filed a brief stating that the court had been “deceived” by a collusive, feigned, and fraudulent lawsuit designed entirely to provide a fake veneer of legality to an illegal payout scheme. Faced with a full-blown Senate revolt and two federal judges actively breathing down his neck, Trump did what he always does when a grift goes sideways: he folded. The Justice Department sheepishly released a statement on Monday announcing they would “abide by the court’s ruling” and halt all progress on the fund. So OK, everything’s not fine exactly, and the system’s still broken, but maybe the rule of law has a temporary pulse.
- In another week eclipsed by the announcement that tickets are soon to be on sale to see the visiting cloth narrative from Bayeux, Westminster weaves its own tapestry of hasty tone-deaf non-decision-making and self-important mini-me Machiavellian mis-steps, basically a room full of people having things jabbed directly in their eye and yet they can’t see for looking. Wes Streeting who resigned expecting people to beg him not to, has yet to announce his leadership campaign and has endorsed Andy Burnham as Labour’s Best Chance of Winning as he walks behind Andy’s human shield body into the slaughter that will be the Brexit leave and Reform UK council-voting Makerfield by-election. “Yeah Andy you go ahead I’m not going for the top job” uttered between breaths polishing the tape measure at the crown-makers. It’s going to be expensive; Wes has a huge sticky thumb for a head, just warning you Garrard and Co. If Andy does become leader Jeremy Corbyn said he would not rejoin Labour, I’m surprised anyone asked him really given how shittily he was dealt with under member-of-Keir’s-cabinet-admitted “unpopular” Starmer. A bit like inviting advice from Tony Blair on how to deal with the US President notwithstanding the debacle of the Iraq war – oh no wait that happened. Angela Rayner, recent returnee to the Labour party suggested ministers take action on the upcoming report from the consultation on a social media ban for under-16 year olds, which in some ways whiffs of umbrage that TikTok has successfully raised an entire generation when government has not. Nigel Farage thinks his gift of £5m was not subject to declaring among the declaration of gifts over £300 in the 12 months prior to being elected cos apparently it wasn’t a gift given to him two weeks after he stood for election in Clacton, it was a reward for all the good work he had done on Brexit, and all the good work he’s doing to promote crypto since crypto zillionaire Christopher Harborne gave him the bung. But it’s personal and non-political so that’s alright we shouldn’t even be asking questions about it cos Nige gets upset, even though it’s more than all of his constituents in Clacton could earn in all their lifetimes put together, “yeah but ‘e’s one of us in’ee eeza proper geezer” – will we never learn!
You can now buy Jim’s book, 2000 Mules and One Big Lie: A Stubborn Conspiracy Theory, and you can buy all our t-shirts, mugs, hats and more at our TeePublic Store, including this week’s fallacy:
That’s almost all for this week, but here’s our AI-aided transcript, which is quite accurate, but not totally:
Appeal to Definition – FT#194 Transcript
Read the full transcript
00:23 Jim: Hello and welcome to Fallacious Trump, the podcast where we use the insane ramblings of a melting senior citizen to explain logical fallacies. I'm your host, Jim.
00:30 Mark: And I'm your other host, Mark. A logical fallacy is an error in reasoning that results in bad or invalid arguments. And the logical fallacy we're looking at this week is the appeal to definition, also known as the appeal to the dictionary.
00:43 Jim: Some people might be thinking that we've had a bit of a stroke and are just repeating ourselves from last time. Because we did the definist fallacy last time, which was about redefining terms to suit your argument. Yeah, this is the appeal to definition, which is completely different and, yeah, it's kind of the other way around in ways that it'll be confusing to explain. Yeah, yeah, so, rather than redefining a term to make it often mean something that it doesn't really mean but suits your argument, this is about appealing essentially to the authority of the dictionary or some other authority, right, and using that definition specifically because it fits or helps with your case and also
01:25 Mark: shuts down other people's arguments by saying what you're saying doesn't mean yeah, and in.
01:30 Jim: And in doing so you ignore the fact that sometimes words can mean multiple things, that it can depend on context. There might even be multiple definitions in the dictionary, but if the other definitions that are either used colloquially or one of the other definitions in the dictionary doesn't fit your case or doesn't support your argument, right, well, you're kind of shutting that, that down and saying no, no, no, here's what it says in the dictionary. This is what we must stick to, right, like I say some other authority, one of my favorite dictionaries, incidentally, right, everyone got any tangents this week, but already, immediately, you
02:02 Mark: have a favorite,
02:04 Jim: absolutely my favorite dictionary is the latin dictionary that is kept up to date because new latin words have to be invented because people – mainly the pope, but some people in largely in in the catholic church – speak latin, they give mass in latin and they have to talk about modern concepts right in latin. So there's like a latin word for dishwasher and, and, like you know, there's. They have to come up with new words and so they add those into the modern latin dictionary.
02:34 Mark: Wow, that's excellent, I just like that. There is a, an organization in france, as a Department in the government of france, that invents new french words. So they don't just say the dishwasher washer or look computer, yeah, um, I think it came out as a result of le weekend, so they kind of came up with: probably they hate that. Yeah, yeah, so there are. You know, you can't just say look computer, they won't know what you're talking about.
03:00 Jim: They should have really come up with something for chat gpt, because they call that chat gpt, which means cat, I farted, yeah, in french.
03:07 Mark: I think that's probably really why they kept it. Yeah, maybe, yeah, because it is hilarious. Yeah, yeah, let me just keep that anyway.
03:17 Jim: Yeah, back to the show. So our first example: yeah, for this fallacy is obviously from Trump and it is in response to a kind of bombastic speech that Biden gave in 2022, when he was saying about how, you know, we need to kind of fight back against the fascist forces that are coming for us.
03:37 Clip: Trump pretending MAGA only means one thing
— Biden thinks making America great again is bad for our country. Do you believe it? That was in his speech. MAGA. MAGA. He says we've got to stop MAGA. That's when I defined it because I don't think he knows what it meant. It means make America great again. We have to stop it. Stop MAGA. Stop. Make America great again. He thinks making America great again is a threat to our country. No, making America great again is great for our country.
04:12 Jim: What Trump is doing is appealing to the literal definition of the word to make America great again and pretending that when Biden means, yeah, use that term, Maga, yeah, that must be what he's referring to, because that's the definition. Yeah, and if you're against Maga, then you are obviously automatically, automatically attacking the concept of making America great again. Yeah, but MAGA has a different meaning. It has come to mean different things, and what it means in the context that Biden was using it in was the group of people who show this weird cult -like behavior towards Trump. In fact, he used in his speech he used the word MAGA 13 times. 10 of them were specifically followed by Republicans, so he was talking about MAGA Republicans. He was using it as a descriptor for that group of Republicans. The other times he called them MAGA forces. He called it MAGA ideology and he called something MAGA failure, in a weird version of a sentence that didn't quite make sense, but the times that he was using it to describe the things that we are concerned about, the things that mean that democracy is at risk. He was specifically talking about the group of people who are prepared to do things like January 6th.
05:31 Mark: Yeah, because of their fealty to Trump, in the same way that Maga won't look at the for what? The better term dictionary definition of antifa. Yeah, they are doing what Biden was doing for Maga, for antifa – and if someone points out, well, actually that's just a portmanteau acronymistic word for anti -fascist movement – they, they just oh no, and And Antifa it's a prescribed organisation. They are terrorists.
06:02 Jim: So our next example is trying to define 86 in a very specific way, obviously in response to the whole James Comey prosecution for the seashells on the Beach. Picture of 86 -47.
06:18 Clip: Trump being wrong about 86
— Do you really think that he was endangering your life or threatening your life with that?
— Well, if anybody knows anything about crime time, they know 86. You know what? 86? It's a mob term for kill them. You know, you ever see the movies? 86 them. The mobster says to one of his wonderful associates: 86 them. That means kill them. It's. I think of it as a mob term. I don't know, people think of it as something having to do with disappearing, but the mob uses that term to say when they want to kill somebody. They say 86, the son of a gun. I'm trying to keep the language nice and clear. They don't use that term, son of a gun, they use another term, but that's a mob term for kill.
07:02 Jim: So he's essentially here evoking what he considers to be the mob dictionary, which is learned through watching films.
07:09 Mark: Yeah, where 86
07:10 Jim: is defined as kill. Right, and therefore that must be what Comey meant when he posted that picture of of seashells arranged in 86 47, and this, as we talked about briefly last time, is now included in miriam webster's definition of 86 as a thing that is rarely the case. Right, it has more recently been used to mean kill, but yeah, before that, all of the other definitions in there are the ones you would expect in the kind of American restaurant slash diner, where it's about running out of something or not serving it, or kicking someone out, banning someone from a club or that kind of thing. So you kick someone out, you 86 them, not kill them.
07:57 Mark: Where's it derived from?
07:59 Jim: There is some dispute about its etymology. Among dictionaries, like Merriam -Webster particularly. They suggest that possibly it's to do with rhyming slang for Knicks: uh, okay, yeah, which I don't know what, where nix comes from. But but that means, you know, means get rid of something, essentially, and maybe that's a possibility. There are various folk etymologies which don't sound very plausible. That um Trump suggests one which is like a mob person saying eight miles out, six feet down, meaning take them out to the desert and bury them right. There's no evidence for that whatsoever. The first time it was used, I think in the 20s or or 30s, it was in, among other terms that are used in a like a malt shop kind of thing, where they were like oh, 81 means we're out of straws, or you know, 86 is this, uh, 52 is get them a glass of water. They had like multiple shorthand things for things they needed to say and 86 was that's where I think it's the first kind of written down version of it is, in an article describing that by an employee from that kind of establishment. So yeah, it's not clear exactly why it's 86, but that's what it yeah is most commonly used in. It is in that the kind of catering field. Really he says that mobsters use it. Obviously I don't know that much about mobsters. I know a little bit about mob movies – I've watched a few of them, yeah. But one guy who does know quite a lot about mobsters is um former federal prosecutor, eli honig, who appeared on Cnn and gave his views on this.
09:31 Clip: CNN legal analyst Elie Honig on 86
— Cnn senior legal legal analyst and former federal prosecutor, Ellie Honig. Ellie, you're someone who's prosecuted over what, 100 mob family members? Does 86 mean murder in mob parlance? Tell us.
— Well, Caitlin, there was a point in my life where I spent the better part of my waking hours either talking face to face with real world mobsters or listening to them talk to each other over wire taps or body wires or bugs. I dealt with all five families: Gambino, Genovese, Banana, Lucchese, Daisy, Colombo. I dealt with bosses, underbosses, consiglieres, capos, soldiers, associates, all the way down the line. Never, ever, not once did I hear any real world gangster use the term 86 to refer to a murder or anything. And God knows these guys had colorful lingo, but never that phrase 86. I don't know where the president's getting this from. He said from some movie. They don't use that term in Godfather or Sopranos or Goodfellas, maybe some way old, old -timey movie, but that's not reality.
10:32 Jim: So, yeah, they don't use it in, yeah, in real mob terms. Yeah, they don't use it in those movies that he mentioned, or the sopranos, that kind of thing. It is mentioned in casino, but specifically regarding banning someone. So the robert de niro character uses it in terms of a guy who has previously been banned from the casino showing up again. So he clearly hasn't been killed. He's saying he doesn't know he's been 86. I did a search to see if I could find any mob movies that it was used in to mean killing. Yeah, there's an episode of numbers – not a mob movie, but it's an fbi drama based around matt, where they use 86. I think it's in the context. I didn't watch the entire episode, but from what I could see it's in the context of someone having been killed. Right, it's in little shop of horrors, the, the 80s version. Well, yeah, rick moranis audrey 2 says it. Audrey 2 is not a mobster, it's a plant. Yeah, and the only the only kind of mob case I could find, for it was la confidential, where it's used by like he's an underling who's being beaten up by russell crowe and the information he gives is that he's aware of this team of shooters who who 86ed some lieutenants and that's it. That's the single, single reference I can find anywhere, wow, where it's used, and it sounds like they they've kind of stretched, they've stretched the malt shop version of 86.
11:57 Mark: Yeah, I mean it makes it.
11:59 Jim: Yeah, it's not implausible that anyone would use it for that kind of thing. That I mean it is basically just get rid of this guy and, as we've seen in various, yeah, various – kind of mob, I mean the godfather, they talk about sleeping with the fishes. You know, monsters who might think they're being recorded, as many of them are in real life, might not want to say: kill this guy. So they'll use different things. But for the most part, and if you believe A. Lee Koenig, they don't use 86.
12:26 Mark: If there was a dictionary of mob language, he would be the one that writes it. He's going to know. He's going to know. Yeah, He only
12:34 Jim: just gets away with it being this fallacy, because it's not him trying to redefine it, he's just using a very rare and obscure version and insisting that's the correct definition over the much more established and accepted definitions.
12:47 Mark: Yeah, and lending his authority to the fact that he's saying this is the one, which kind of sweeps aside all other versions of it.
12:56 Jim: Yeah, and when his lawyers attempt to argue that in court against James Comey, I think they will find it hard.
13:02 Mark: Call the guy from Who's the Mob expert.
13:06 [Sting: Mark's British Politics Corner] And now is the time, I think, for Mark's British Politics Corner.
13:12 Mark: There are lots of examples I've found of mainly Jacob Rees -Mogg insisting on using outdated words to mean stuff, but he's never kind of insisted on correcting people. So I think. Generally there's rarely an appeal to dictum definitions, but they frequently seem to insist that their definition of a politically contested term is the only legitimate one. So it's a bit like the definist fallacy, this fallacy, and it sits adjacent to it. What they're saying is this is the acceptable definition. And so it's a bit of an obscure offshoot of Brexit for the first example. But there was a problem with the UK seceding from the EU, because the Republic of Ireland, the Northern Ireland, is part of the UK. The Republic of Ireland, which is in the same island of Ireland, is in the EU. So there would be a border between the EU and the UK, who is no longer part of the EU. The problem is that's the same border that the Northern Ireland Protocol, following the peace agreement, said ought not to exist between the Northern Ireland and Republic of Ireland. And Boris repeatedly claimed that there would be no border in the irish sea and in august 2020, in typical bombastic style, he stated: there'll be no border down the irish sea over my dead body, even though the withdrawal agreement clearly created one, and he insisted that his interpretation of border physical infrastructure was the only valid one and rejected the widely used used administrative definition of the border. And here he is on Sophie Ridge's programme on Sky, insisting that his authority over the definition of checks at the border brooks no other interpretation.
15:18 Clip: Boris Johnson quibbling over the definition of checks at the border
— Last month, you told businesses in Northern Ireland that they would face no forms, no checks, no barriers of any kind under your Brexit deal. Well, how come then that this government document that was leaked this week says that that's not true, that there will be checks and forms? Were you telling the truth?
— Yes, I am. And look at what we say in our manifesto. Look what we're going to deliver. The deal that we've done with the EU… So will there be checks? No, absolutely not. The deal we've done with the EU is a brilliant deal. And it allows us to do all the things that Brexit was about. And the only checks that there would be would be if something was coming from GB via Northern Ireland and was going on to the Republic public, then there might be checks at the border into Northern Ireland.
— So this document is talking about checks both ways and that's wrong because there won't be checks. So you're saying that this, this, is wrong, the government's own impact assessment is wrong, your Brexit secretary is wrong. All these people are wrong. And you're right.
— Yes, because because there's no question of there checks on goods going, uh, nigb or gbni, huh, yeah.
16:28 Mark: So the? I thought he just didn't.
16:31 Jim: He just say: if something's going from gb to ni, to Northern Ireland, yeah, and then on, yeah, that it would be checked. When it's going into Northern Ireland, yeah, so he just.
16:42 Mark: So there he is saying they're wrong. I'm right. Um, the government's own impact assessment, as she suggested, which was ultimately published, was clear. It said goods arriving in Northern Ireland, including from great Britain, would undergo regulatory checks in accordance with the? U rules and indeed, in 2021, there were more than a million external full custom declarations for goods coming the other way, from gp to ni. Of course they fucking were.
17:08 [Unclear]: Yeah, of course this was.
17:10 Jim: This was the thing I was shouting at Brexit voters repeatedly. Every time I came across one, anytime this came up, it's like okay, Okay, explain to me how it's going to work. And they couldn't. Because, obviously they couldn't, because there was no possibility of making a way where it worked, where you didn't have a border and yet there was not a problem with things going across the non -existent border.
17:33 [Unclear]: Oh, God.
17:34 Jim: So obviously the stupidest thing you could try and do.
17:39 Mark: So there you are. And indeed in 2023, after that had all happened.
17:47 Clip: Boris Johnson's later clarification
— He said this and, purely to help the Eu, we agreed to check on those goods, uh, entering Northern Ireland. As I say, that might go on to Ireland and I thought those checks would not be onerous, since there isn't actually that much stuff that falls into that category. Most of the goods stay in Northern Ireland and it's all my fault. I'm fully exceptional, and the protocol itself – and this is why I signed it – contains lots of reassuring phrases about how Northern Ireland remains in the customs territory of the UK and will benefit from participation in the United Kingdom's independent trade policy. But beneath the paint and plaster, there was the cold steel reality.
18:30 Mark: And that cold steel reality was that his he defined borsers and checks according to his own authority and ignored the actual meaning in common use. And of course he did that to sell Brexit it and he's haven't run your deal. Let's just ignore the difficult bits and we're just gonna. That mumbled bit in the middle, by the way, is him throwing away and swallowing. It's all my fault. I fully accept responsibility. The usual meaningless apology for stuff he's made up about things not being true and then said: yes, yes, this is how I'm defining it. Of course that's the definition, despite all the authority figures saying otherwise.
19:12 Jim: I'll let you get away with that, because I suspect that in some version of some government document it was written down that that's how they were interpreting checks and borders and that's the authority that he was therefore going by.
19:25 Mark: But I suspect that he was. He was pretending he'd seen it once somewhere. He just read it and said, oh well, that that painfully means that, and then he could point to it, although – Although yeah, this is how it kind of edges towards Devinist as well. But in the process of listening to that, I realized that if anyone insists that their behavior adheres to the dictionary definition of something, despite all other interpretations, that's when politicians use the word apology. Apology. So they make an apology using the dictionary definition of the word apology, but they're always empty, vacuous and meaningless and not really apology apologies. Technically they've apologized. Yeah, they've used the dictionary definition of apologize in that the word sorry came out of their mouth or they said I, it's all my fault and I fully accept responsibility, except he never does. It's like a covers band doing a fairly good version of another band song song and you and you remember the other band and not them. So if they make an apology, you remember the apology and not the fact that linguistically they walked all around it. So, speaking of Brexit in the similar vein, the mother of all authoritarian insistence on the definition is probably this one from theresa may well.
20:50 Clip: Theresa May explaining what Brexit means
— The reason I've been saying Brexit means Brexit is precisely because it does. And uh, to be very clear – that we are going to deliver on the wishes of the British people and we will respect the vote that took place on the 23rd of June.
21:02 Mark: So Brexit means Brexit, yeah, which seems to me it's a desperate attempt to stamp a definitive and authorised definition on something that was unutterably indefinable. So, if anything, Brexiteers probably committed to define its fallacy in making it mean what they wanted it to mean, according to their political aims, ambitions and leanings, whilst wiping over it with a smear of their own authority. So Brexit mean Brexit was on the back of at least six people who said Brexit means something else. Boris johnson said Brexit means taking back control of our money, boards and laws. David davis says the decision to leave the european union means leaving the single market. Starmer said, said Brexit must mean retaining the benefits of the single market. Changed his tune since then. Nigel Farage, Brexit means independence. It means governing ourselves. Jacob Rees-Mogg, Brexit means full regulatory autonomy. Brexit means the freedom to diverge. And Priti Patel, not unsurprisingly, he said Brexit means controlling immigration.
22:08 Mark: There's all of those.
22:11 Jim: See, interpreting as generously as I think is warranted. Theresa May's Brexit means Brexit. Ultimately, I think what she was probably going for, or relying on, at least, is that Brexit as a concept basically just meant leaving the EU. It was as simple as that. It's an unbelievably complex thing to do. But I think in simplifying it down to Brexit means Brexit, that's what she was saying. She was just saying that we'll be out of the EU. Yeah, there's many other things to talk about and there's many questions of how that works and if it could possibly work and reasons why it definitely can't work. Yeah, but I think when she was saying that and when a few people said Brexit means Brexit, that's kind of what they meant is we'll be out of the Eu, and in that respect, this is absolutely this fallacy, because, yeah, you're just just saying what it literally means. Yeah, I suspect now Brexit is in dictionaries and I expect it means Britain exiting the Eu. Yeah, I don't know, haven't looked it up, but that would make sense, and so that would be, in that case, the definition that she's relying on there, which doesn't answer the question, because when people are asking her, what do you mean by Brexit, they're asking all those other questions:
23:31 Mark: does it mean independent?
23:33 Jim: Yeah, they're asking what are we going to do about borders and what are we going to do about currency and immigration and all of the other questions that surround that, because it's very nuanced and she's just saying, well, it just means Brexit
23:46 Mark: and that's it. Let's all go around being tautological Supertramp there, of course, with the definitive hit, The Logical Song.
26:01 Jim: I mean it should be our theme tune, really, shouldn't it? It should be shouldn't it? Like if it wasn't for the fact that you're in a band that insists we use their music, that would make – and assuming Supertramp were happy for us to just use their music, but you know, it would make sense, yeah, Yeah,
26:18 Mark: it would define the show.
26:21 Jim: So in the Fallacy in the Wild, we like to talk about the fallacy of the week from a non -political perspective, which we'll mostly manage this week. And our first example is from Taskmaster. Because I could have used just Taskmaster for this section. Because basically, one of the things that really fits in well with this fallacy is rules lawyering. The kind of loophole -seeking behaviour that people do. Yeah, do where they, where they're technically doing what they've been told to do. Technically, they're doing something according to the definition of the words – that they've been asked to do – yeah, but they're doing it in a way that works for them, which is just a feature of Taskmaster. Yeah, it's also a feature of malicious compliance when people are instructed to work in a particular way and they do it in a way that pisses off the person who has told them, like their boss or whatever. Yeah, but they can't really get mad because they did exactly what they were told.
27:13 Mark: Yeah, so all of rod gilbert's um contributions fall under that.
27:19 Jim: So so this – this is a Richard osmond one. The task was to get three big yoga balls. When those big, like like meter wide yoga balls, yeah, onto a yoga mat that is on the top of a hill right, and so you can't carry all three at once because they're too big. It's a bit of a windy day and it's tricky to get them all up to the top and and leave them there without them blowing away and rolling down the hill while you go and get the other one. It's just a feeling task. So what Richard Osman does is interprets the task in such a way that the yoga mat on top of the hill is the mat that he has to put them on. So he goes and gets the mat and brings it down to where the balls are and then just puts the balls on the mat. And so here's the conversation that follows that.
28:04 Clip: Taskmaster
— Is Richard Osman a genius or should that not be allowed? There's definitely something in there about the balls and up the hill. What was the exact challenge? Place these three exercise balls on the yoga mat on the top of that hill. Oh! Yeah! On the yoga mat that is on the top of that hill. I mean, is there any way of knowing for sure whether it's in the spirit of the challenge? I think it matters what Susie Dent thinks. Oh! You count, so we ask Susie Dent. She should count down. She said the wording of the task is open to interpretation. She said it's. It's the classically ambiguous English prepositional phrase which is the title of my new wrap -up. She finishes by saying I'd say how Richard decided to understand. It is Unusual, but not impossible.
— So so they evoke
28:52 Jim: a specific authority. Yes, suzy Dent, who for non -uk listeners absolutely is, might as well be the dictionary. She is. She's a lexicographer who is on countdown down a daytime quiz show involving words and is very, very, very much associated in the Uk with the dictionary and words and knowing what they all mean. Yeah, so yeah, they went to suzy Dent to find out if richard's interpretation of this task was, was fair. And while it isn't the common, the most common because obviously the most common interpretation, which is what all the other contestants did – is: yeah, take the balls, put them on top of the hill, on top of that yoga mat. Yeah, It's a reasonable reading of the task. And so he didn't technically do anything wrong.
29:39 Mark: I think they leaned into the ambiguity thing when they did that one task that was set in a sort of church chapel somewhere and it was full of triple negatives and they had to fail to not do the undoing of the something, something, something. And they had got Susie Dent either to write it or to thoroughly check it.
30:01 Jim: They've got her to check what the right answer should have been: yeah, yes, yeah, absolutely because it was.
30:07 Mark: Yes, it's a, it's basically a nest. It was a nested, not statement. So it was kind of computer, computer science, um, nesting of logic, stuff, nice.
30:18 Jim: So our second example is some music. Actually, unusually for me, yeah, this is a reasonably short clip of, uh, what is actually a 10 minute piece of music. So you may have noticed, there weren't any words in that, and usually when we bring music it is about the lyrics. Yeah, but this is not about the lyrics, because that is a, uh, a piece of music called flutter by right or teca. Yeah, and it was made in the 90s in direct response to the criminal justice and public order act 1994. Wow, because, yeah, part of that act was about combating rave culture in the Uk. Right, about people all getting together in one place, dancing all night, taking drugs, disturbing the locals and then moving on, and raves typically were set up in fields or in warehouses or like there wasn't a. You wouldn't go to a nightclub, it was a, an event that they would
31:27 Mark: be, and they weren't disturbing locals because they were generally in disused
31:32 Jim: warehouses a long way out. They were often, yeah, they were often well away from residential areas, sure, but police wanted to crack down on it in whatever way they could. Yeah, and one of the ways they could was in the criminal justice public order act. Section 63 gives the police powers to remove persons attending or preparing for a rave. And obviously, in a law you have to define things. Yeah, because otherwise you don't know if you're breaking the law or not. That's the main reason. But also for when the police are prosecuting the law, that you, they have to have something to kind of go to court and say, look, by the definition of this law, they broke these rules.
32:09 [Unclear]: Yeah, so they
32:11 Jim: said this section applies to a gathering on land in the open Air of 20 or more persons, whether or not trespassers, at which amplified music is played during the night, with or without intermissions, and is such as, by reason of its loudness and duration and the time at which it is played, likely to cause serious distress to the inhabitants of the locality. And they defined music. Because, right, that's part of, yes, what defines the rave? Yeah, and they said it. Music includes sounds wholly or predominantly characterized by the emission of a succession of repetitive beats. So, right, that's where ortega, came in and created this 10 minute track. Didn't repeat at all. It has no bars where the rhythm is the same as any of the other bars. Wow so it. It cannot be said to have repetitive beats. Wow so they produced this music specifically to get around the criminal justice public order act and said that djs could play this on a loop – yeah, for hours on end. To, yeah, to dance at raves – brilliant, yeah, oh, that's brilliant.
33:18 Mark: There was also an early example of, uh, a rave that happened early on on it out in the outskirts of manchester, and the organizer had set it up so that it was a film shoot. So the people that came to it, they bought a ticket for a pound and what that did was buy them, uh, a, um, a kind of backstage pass, a film pass that they were all extras, right, and and he printed – just printed out – a permission slip from somebody – nobody owned the place, so it's a person. So they, they were just felt they were making a film. So the police turned up, yeah, and said what if we've got to break out again? Oh, what are you doing? We're making a film and these are all extras. And they went: no, they're not. Yeah, yeah, they just look. Here's the thing, there's their fee. They've all got a pound. They've all been paid a pound. Yeah, they're all extras. So they weren't just turning up and dancing, they were in a film about people turning up and dancing, so they were acting the completely different. Yeah, that's brilliant. I'm gonna have to look up that entire track. That's fantastic.
34:25 Jim: Yeah, I got a bit bored of it after about 15 seconds, but anyway, yeah, yeah, it's fine.
34:30 Mark: Yeah, I suspect if you were in a in a field in the middle of the night on drugs, it wouldn't make any difference at all. You'd be going.
34:37 Jim: Yeah, no, I think it's still pretty. It would annoy me pretty quickly because
34:42 Mark: there are no patterns happening.
34:44 Jim: No, the stuff was repetitive beats. It annoys me too.
34:47 Mark: Oh okay, oh right, oh, it's not the lack of repetition, right?
34:51 Jim: No, okay, no, no, just, uh, just find that intensely annoying. Um, anyway, our third example is bill Clinton being deposed. Yeah, this is after he had said that he did not have sexual relations. Yeah, with that woman, right? Yes, he's being asked about a, a statement that his lawyer made in a deposition, the statement of, uh, Your attorney, Mr.
35:16 Clip: Bill Clinton's deposition
— Bennett, followed Joe's deposition. Counsel is fully aware, page 54, line 5. Counsel is fully aware that Ms. Lerinsky. His file has an affidavit, which they are in possession of, saying that there is absolutely no sex of any kind, any manner, shape or form, with President Klipp. That statement is made by your attorney and finally Judge Susan Parai, correct?
— That's correct.
— Your back statement is a completely false statement. Whether or not Mr. Bennett knew of your relationship with Ms. Lewinsky, the statement that there was no sex of any kind in any manner, shape or form, President Clinton, was an utterly false statement. Is that correct? Right, it
— depends upon what the meaning of the word is. Yes, if the if, you if is means is and never has been. That is not. That's one thing. If it means there is none, that was a completely true statement.
36:31 Jim: So this is pretty famous.
36:33 [Unclear]: Yeah, yeah, that he's, he's quite.
36:36 Jim: I mean, he's a lawyer. That's the thing. He was a lawyer and so and he understood the legal definitions of stuff. And so when there was a question asking is there a sexual relation of any kind between the President and miss leninsky, his lawyer, truthfully and accurately, yeah, said no. No, because at that time there wasn't. Yeah, if he had said, yeah, has there been, it has ever been, the answer would be yes, yeah, but it does turn on what the definition of is is, and the judge in that case agreed that it. It was a badly worded question and it got. And if you wanted to get the answer that you clearly wanted to get, you should have asked a different question. Yeah, and the same is with the sexual relation thing. When he said I didn't have sexual relations with that woman, the definition of sexual relations at that time in that location did not include oral sex. So, right, yeah, he was, he was legally of relying. He was, you know, very much appealing to the definition, the legal definition, not how people use it colloquially. Yes, yeah, legally speaking, he was being accurate when he said that, um, that's not how anyone would expect that question to be answered, given the facts of the case, in colloquial terms. But yeah, and that's what ken starr and the impeachment team were all about. But, yeah, but yeah, he technically didn't lie.
37:59 Mark: Yeah, well, that's a bit like it. I did go down a rabbit hole with uh Boris johnson and party gate and whether the uh, the thinner and thinner slices of what it was for a party to be defined. But then it became, it's edged over into definist fallacy. Yeah, because they, yeah, they were definitely
38:20 Jim: redefining party to their – yeah, yeah, work
38:23 [Sting: Fake News] events of cheese and wine or things like that.
38:25 Jim: Yeah, yeah, yeah, there are no authorities that that claim in dictionaries or otherwise that that's what a party is.
38:32 [Sting: Fake News] No, that's right. So we're gonna, we're gonna play fake news folks. I love the game. It's a great game. I understand the game as well as anybody. As well as anybody.
38:43 Jim: Yes, it's time for fake news. The game where I read out three Trump quotes, two of which are real and one I made up and Mark has to figure out which one is fake news.
38:50 Mark: So I'm not saying we've been going about it all wrong, but if you look up the definition of game, it does emphasize the straightforward, somewhat enjoyable nature of participating in an exercise that is fairly evenly and a -partisanly – applied equally to both sides. Just saying, just saying that, well, we just have to play the game that we've got here. Yeah, if you want to define it as a game.
39:17 Jim: Yeah, if you want to call it game, yeah, absolutely, yeah. So So, yeah, these these statements from Trump are basically he's talking about his deep, abiding knowledge and love for America and the Civil War and all of that kind of thing. As we know, he's an expert on that era of history. And yeah. So this was a time when he was talking. This was quite recent, actually. It was in it was the end of April of this year in Palm Beach. So statement number one: we gave our soldiers, our war fighters, 1776 dollars as a tax -free payment. We called it a warrior payment, a warrior dividend. They wanted to make it 1500, but I said, what if we add a little bit more and make it 1776, because that's such a great number? And everyone liked that idea, especially the soldiers. They fight for America, and they should, because it's a great country. We're making it great again. I say it all the time: no other country in the history of the the world has been. So we just love America. We love America, don't we?
40:17 Mark: It's really something okay, yeah, I was expecting a sir in there, but yeah, okay.
40:24 Jim: Statement number two: yeah, it's just special. I mean the whole place, it's a special country. But when you look at some of the movies and documentaries about the founding of our country and all of the great people – George Washington, Abraham Lincoln and Thomas Jefferson – Lincoln later – but Thomas Jefferson, all of the original founders – and – and, uh, some of the ones that are least known – are actually the most important and the and the most interesting actually. But when you look at all, then you have the Civil war.
40:54 [Unclear]: What? Okay, oh, brilliant.
41:09 Jim: The Civil war was brutal. It was a brutal. I always said: why couldn't that have been settled? And maybe it could have been, but it was a brutal war. It was supposed to last one day. And because robert e lee was an amazing general – you know I deal with generals a lot and I ask: who was the best general? A lot of them say robert e lee, because he took something that was supposed to end in one day and it went four years and with the exception of Gettysburg, that was not good, that was not a good one, that was not a good day for him. But if that didn't happen he would have actually won.
41:43 Mark: Yeah, so do you think he's trying to be Robert E. Lee with Iran. You know it's only supposed to last a day, but I'm going to make it go on for four years Maybe.
41:58 Mark: So the middle one, with the kind of speedering out and the thing runs out of characters from history, yeah, and tries to describe the ones he doesn't know about as being the most important and the most interesting ever. When you look at it then, so that one feels very real. The brutal one, lots of brutals, brutal, brutal, uh, and yet the 1776 six, no, so they're all equally preposterous and equally feasible. So on is Robert E. Lee one, probably based on the fact that I want to hear him say it. I'm not going to go for an up to I. I think that is it going to. Did he call them war fighters? So toss. All right. I'm going to go with number one is when you made up.
43:03 Jim: So the other two, which you more convinced by number two. And number two.
43:12 Clip: Trump, played during Fake News
— Is real.
— No, it's just special. I mean the whole place. It's a special country, but when you look at some of the movies and documentaries about the founding of our country and all of the great people, George Washington, Abraham Lincoln, Thomas Jefferson – Lincoln later, but Thomas Jefferson, all of the original founders and some of the ones that are least known – are actually the most important and the most interesting actually. But when you look at all, then you have the Civil War. Wow. Wow.
43:46 Mark: He's going George Washington, Abraham Lincoln, Thomas Jefferson. Oh, no, actually, it's Lincoln later. Then it's Lincoln. Yeah, got to get the order right. But that's the only three you can remember. Yeah, yeah, because they've been in movies. Because when you look at some of the movies about them so you think, oh right, he's going to say they don't tell the actual whole story or they oversimplify matters or something. No, no, he just, they're the ones. That's how he knows about those three. Because he's seen the movies. Yeah, as if he watches documentaries. Documentaries, yeah, yeah. Or perhaps he thinks, I think, that he thinks that they are documentaries. Well, he thinks that all movies are true, that's, that's great.
44:31 Jim: I think he's seen bill and ted's excellent adventure and lincoln's in that and he's like, yeah, that's right, that was it, that's what it was all like.
44:37 Mark: Yeah, america's great dude, yeah, yeah.
44:42 Jim: So you also think that number three is is real, yes, and number three, yeah, is real.
44:51 Clip: Trump, played during Fake News
— The Civil war was brutal. It was a brutal. I always said: why couldn't that have been settled? And maybe it could have been, but it was a brutal war. It was supposed to last one day and because robert e lee was an amazing general – you know, uh, I deal with generals a lot and I ask: who was the best general? A lot of them say robert e lee, because he took something that was supposed to end in one day and it went four years and it, with the exception of gettysburg, that was not good, that was not a good one, that was not a good day for him. But, uh, that didn't happen. He would have actually won. I mean, I guarantee that
45:23 Jim: generals – if they are, I I don't question that. He asks the generals: who was the best general? That sounds like exactly the kind of thing he would do. I guarantee they don't regularly say, oh, you know robert ely? Yeah, no, the confederate general who lost. He was the best of all the generals because,
45:41 Mark: you know, if it wasn't for gettysburg, that was a bad day. If it wasn't for that, he would have won. Yeah, but the fact that if he hadn't lost then he would have actually have won – I
45:51 Jim: mean, gettysburg is considered a turning point in the Civil war – yeah, whether it meant that if gettysburg hadn't gone the way it did, lee would have won and the south would have won. That's a counterfactual fallacy. At best there's no way to make that. But they were kind of headed North and that stopped them from going going further North. But I have found nothing to suggest that anyone thought it would ever end in a day. That's exactly the kind of thing. He thinks that you can end a war in a day, yeah, but that's not how wars work. Also, what a a subnormal thing to ask. When you are the commander -in -chief, yeah, and people who've literally risen up the ranks in the armed forces to the point where where they've become generals who work in the same room as the President of the United States. Yeah, when, when you are interacting with those people and the the best thing you can think to ask them is: who was the best general? It's like who would win in a fight between batman and superman. It's like: what kind of fucking stupid person are you? That? That's your conversation. Yeah, you don't have anything better to talk about. You don't have any geopolitical knowledge, obviously, which is the kind of thing they have probably come in to talk to you about, and you know they're here trying to explain why a proportional response to an attack is the best response instead of bombing the fuck out of a Middle Eastern country because it increases the number of terrorists you'll have in 20 years time. And you're like: okay, but who was the best general? Yeah It makes me so want to punch him
47:33 Mark: And for him to say well I always said, why couldn't it have been settled? Like he's the great deal maker and, yeah, he's so good at settling. Yeah, yeah, maybe, maybe it could have been. No, it couldn't have been. And that's what your generals would have told them if you listened to them rather than just butting in and going: yeah, yeah, but who's the best general?
47:59 Jim: Oh God, so we do have some, uh, some, social contestants. Yeah, on Facebook. Yeah, amy says, says blimey Jim, how do you keep doing it? It's hard to tell which of these statements is real, because none references airports during the revolutionary war. So I'm just randomly guessing that number two is fake news. I'm not sure that Trump actually knows that Lincoln wasn't a founding father.
48:18 Mark: Right, there is that. Yes, yeah, yeah, fair on.
48:22 Jim: Patron Richard says: I think these are all real. They're all entirely plausibly written by one of the kids at the back of the class. It's a trick question this week. Either that or c, I just don't know. Yeah, Renee z says I remember him giving members of the military 1776 dollars at Christmas. I think I also recall that he praised robert ely and called the Civil war brutal. Duh, you idiot. 600 000 Americans died. That leaves two as fake news. I like two as real, but I think it's fake with Jim using a great chronological correction by Trump when he realized Lincoln came later and wasn't a founder. Yeah, that was real, yeah, yeah, yeah. Invisible unicorn says: yep, all three are a real. Jim is too good at this, I'll go with two, because you guys like to talk about docs and movies.
49:03 Mark: Oh, oh, there we go sneaking in a bit of yes, that's yeah, a bit of questions setter psychology, nice. Jeremy says: good lord,
49:13 Jim: I'm terrible at this. So three? I mean they both led an unsuccessful interaction, so it only makes sense for Trump to venerate lee. But that much praise seems like a bit much. Yeah and uh. One -eyed nick says scarlet has played this week and thinks number one is is fake. I think the dumb old said that one, though I remember him dribbling some similar such shit about gettysburg out of his famous. So I'm going with number two being fake. Also, tell her that she shouldn't slap her dad, because it's well mean. Well, what else?
49:42 Mark: Carl up picking the right one.
49:43 Jim: And finally, scott says: oh dear, number one has the requisite mid -sentence topic switch. So it could be real. Likewise number two. I think three is fake. I doubt even someone as dumb as Donald would go on and on about a war that was supposed to be done in one day, or would he?
49:56 Mark: But that's, that's the the thing, isn't it? That little mental comma that just just oh, oh, would he yeah? Is that yeah, yeah? And it leads you all back around again. I know, I know those mid -sentence switches and the and the petering out of a thought, and then, yeah, they're all linguistic tricks that you've mastered so well and I don't know why it was observed. Yeah, why was it? I picked number one in the end, I don't know, Just because I wanted the other two to be real. And
50:34 Jim: it's time for the part of the show that, this week at least, is called Prosecutorial Misconduct is Not a Logical Fallacy, because this is the case of the Broadview Six, who were Democratic activists, who were arrested in 2025 at an ICE facility in Broadview, Illinois, who were accused of um impeding a federal immigration agent, and this was, uh, obviously during the kind of major pushes of immigration enforcement, yeah, in Chicago. So there were protests all over the place. This particular one was outside a nice facility and there were accusations of not assault on the agent himself, but like surrounding his car, possibly scrawling pig on his car, something that may not have been one of these six, but it was happened during the protest. Yeah, this got a little bit more publicity than some of these kinds of protests would, because one of the people who was arrested was kat abugazela, who was, at the time, running for congress right in Chicago. She ended up not winning her primary, which was a shame because I thought she was great, but she was running for illinois night congressional district. So she was arrested, along along with five other people and initially charged with felonies. I think they were charged with assault, although they didn't actually harm in any way or threaten the agent themselves.
52:01 Mark: Or do anything to the agent. That would come under the definition of assault, yeah.
52:08 [Unclear]: Yeah, I mean, yeah.
52:09 Jim: Basically, the definitions of assault are weirdly broad. A lot of things can be considered assault legally that you might not colloquially think would be. But anyway they were charged with felonies and while this case was happening the defence had got the impression somehow that some weird stuff might have gone on with the grand jury when this case was presented to the grand jury. And so they asked the judge to request the grand jury transcripts. Because what happens with the grand jury? The prosecutors present the case. They say: this is the evidence that we've got for these people to be charged with this crime crime. And if the grand jury returns a true bill, then they get charged with that crime. So in the grand jury room there isn't a Defense, it's just the prosecutors telling the grand jurors what their case is and the grand jurors decide whether there's enough evidence to take it to trial, basically. So normally those transcripts are sealed right, but the Defense in this case questioned some stuff that might have gone on and asked the judge to have a look at the transcripts, and so. So the judge asked the prosecutors to provide the grand jury transcripts, and they did. Basically what she looked at. This is Judge April Perry. She was looking for whether there were inconsistencies or things wrong with the instructions that the prosecutors gave to the grand jury. Because one of the things that happens in the grand jury process is that the prosecutors explain what the definition of a law is to the grand jurors. So if they're saying: we want to charge these people with assault, here's what you need to have to be charged with assault in Illinois, yeah, and so here's the evidence that we think fits that those criteria. Yeah, and so the judge found that in the transcripts there were some inconsistencies and some mistakes that might have happened with the instructions that were given to the grand jurors, but they were corrected and it wasn't that big a deal. But she also noticed that there were some redactions in the transcripts and, in fact, some some content missing. And initially she said, oh, I think there's been some transcription errors here. This has been right, not quite fully transcribed, yeah, and that – and I knew I would like to see all of it – yeah, which seems reasonable, fair enough.
54:27 Mark: Yeah, it might be one or two bit missing, or yeah, that's right, and that that might fill out the rest of the story.
54:34 Jim: Right, and so what happened next was that the prosecutors, rather than providing her with the unredacted transcripts, said: we're dropping the felony charges. Actually, hello, right, we're. Uh, we have decided not to charge these six people with felonies. We are going to now charge them with misdemeanors, which doesn't require a grand jury to do it. We can do it on what's called information. So everyone thought that was a bit weird and the Defense team said, uh, judge, I think that's a bit of a red flag. I think you should definitely still asked to see the transcripts, yeah, yeah. And so the judge said, yeah, I want to see the unredacted transcripts. Yeah, and so they gave them the unredacted transcripts. Right, she read them and what she found was what she described as significantly more problematic than the information that she had seen in the first version.
55:35 Mark: So what are they? Why they deliberately redacted and Left out and lost a few pages and all that kind of stuff.
55:42 Jim: Because, yeah, they had deliberate, they had, they had fucked up significantly, yeah, and, and taken all of that stuff out of the transcripts when they gave them to the judge the first time. So here's what she said when she uh responded to the unredacted version. She said: I will say I was incredibly shocked by the redactions that were made. I've read hundreds, if not thousands, of grand jury transcripts involving prosecutors who are the most junior of prosecutors to several u .s attorneys who appeared before the grand jury. I have never seen the types of prosecutorial behavior before a grand jury that I saw in those transcripts: wow and wow, that's bad. That's something you don't want to hear. If you're on the prosecution team, yeah, so then she's. She listed some of the things that she had seen which she thought was quite a bad thing. Yeah, she said: first, improper prosecutorial vouching to the grand jurors with the ausa, putting her personal credibility and trustworthiness on the line in support of the charge. So vouching, wow, basically, when a prosecutor says, you can trust me, I, I know what I'm doing, I'm a federal prosecutor and I and these guys are guilty. Yeah, basically, that's you're, you're relying, not on the evidence that you have, yeah, but you're on, yeah, it's a trust me, bro, prosecution. Wow, that's not allowed, you're not, you can't do that and you shouldn't be requesting the trust me, I'm a lawyer. Yeah, yes, their decision on whether to take it to court, on you saying, oh, this is definitely one we should take to court. Yes, that's not how that works, no, no. Second, she continues: uh, improper prosecutorial communications of a substantive nature with the grand jurors outside of the grand jury room. Oh, what? Yeah, that's if you've ever seen any kind of legal drama at all.
57:32 [Unclear]: Yeah, people, you know that
57:33 Jim: lawyers aren't allowed to talk to people involved in the case who aren't like on there, who they're not working for outside of the courtroom, yeah, outside of discussions with the lawyers from the other team or with the judge, or so you can't just talk to the jurors or talk to other people who are, yeah, connected. That's not okay, but the thing is it wasn't. What you're not allowed to do is any kind of communication at all. So if, if one of the jurors comes up to one of the lawyers in a case and goes like, oh, do you know a good place around here that I can get a sandwich, yeah, you, you don't talk to them. But this specifically improper prosecutorial communications of a substantive nature, wow, so they were talking about the case. Yeah, yeah, wow, and it says with the grand jurors, plural, plural, so it wasn't like a single incident. Yeah, outside of the grand jury room. That's, oh my fucking, absolutely unacceptable. There's no way. That should be. Well, it's not allowed, but that shouldn't happen. And as if that was the worst it could possibly get right. The third thing is the prosecutor excusing grand jurors who disagreed with the government's case from the, the deliberations process. Whoa, so the, the government, the prosecutors are presenting their case. They present, they, they're allowed to present various different versions of: like you know, we, we think we can charge these crimes. Yeah, here's our evidence for that. And if they, if they're like, nah, we don't think you can, then they say, okay, well, what about these ones? Here are here's our evidence for that. So in the first round, when they got people to to make their decision and the grand, some of the grand jurors were like, yeah, I think we should take this to to court. And other grand jurors were like, no, I don't think you've got enough. They got rid of those ones. They got rid of the ones who disagreed with them and didn't think they were presenting a strong enough case, brought new grand jurors in, presented the case and did to the, to the new group. Basically, that was composed of some people who already agreed with them, yeah, and some new guys and I'm like like, okay, what about this version?
59:42 [Unclear]: Wow, what they're not like pitching a movie.
59:47 Mark: They're, they're actually wow, wow, so they, it was there. This. They must have had a sense that the case they had with particularly you're not particularly strong. So what they're gonna have to do, yeah, I'd say so. Yeah, gonna have to, but yeah, the thing is the deck.
1:00:05 Jim: That I don't. I don't know how the Defense Defense got hold of the idea that weird shenanigans had gone on, yeah, in the grand jury room. We don't know what that is, I haven't seen anything about, right,
1:00:17 Mark: there weren't any reports from the dismissed jurors, clearly anything like that.
1:00:22 Jim: Well, no, because they're not allowed to talk about it. Right, technically, yeah, yeah. So I don't know what they, I don't know how they got that, but but they got this idea and it turns out, oh, fucking, yes, they were stuff that they that shouldn't have gone went on, and that's really bad.
1:00:37 Mark: It's efficient for them to try and cover it up by saying, no, we won't, we don't need, you don't need the things, because we're dropping the level of stuff to a misdemeanor.
1:00:44 Jim: So, absolutely yeah, and in fact, the, the fact that they tried to cover it up, the the judge, um April perry said was the worst thing. Yeah, they said worst of all was the problematic behavior had been redacted out of the transcript. She said: mistakes happen, they happen to all of us, but, as I tell my children, you own it, you admit it, you apologize and you move on. What you do not do is hide it. Yes, and yeah, they, yeah, they covered up. So what she said that she would do was basically she said: you know, I'll leave it to um, the Defense to figure out what their next step is. Presumably they're going to have some thoughts about what they want to do. I'm going to consider, um, like sanctions against these lawyers who did this stuff. Yep, um, and you know, but, but for now we'll we'll take a break and we'll reconvene and and then figure out what's going to happen next. And so they took a break and when they came back, the uh? U .s attorney for illinois, uh, andrew butros, was there in the court and he was like judge, I can deal with this, we don't need to go, we don't need to hear what your view is on what should happen next, because it's all mooted by. I'm just dismissing this case, I'm not gonna move forward with the prosecution of these misdemeanors. So it's all fine, we can all move on. And he kind of like excused the behavior of his attorneys, yeah, who had done the bad stuff, um, and and like talked up how bad the behavior was of the accused people, but, but and the judge was like, well, that's kind of like undercutting your mayor cult, yeah, but that obviously doesn't preclude her demanding sanctions against these attorneys. That can still, absolutely happen. The accused people who have now been the cases have been dismissed, so they are free, and it's been dismissed with prejudice, so they can't be re -prosecuted for these things. They're free, they're alright, they're good, but they absolutely should sue the Justice Department for mistrial, for malicious prosecution, for all kinds of bad, bad behaviour that should not have been allowed. Well, wasn't allowed, but, yeah, happened anyway. It's unbelievable. Unbelievable that that much came out. Not just it wasn't like they just made a few mistakes or they kind of pushed the envelope a bit on what was allowed. It was multiple different things you're not allowed to do. Yeah, to just get the case to court, let alone. I mean, you know what might have been going on, try it. Yes, otherwise, once it was in court, yeah, so, God, so, fortunately, those protesters who had the right to protest and yeah, um, I mean at most probably reasonably, could have been charged with with misdemeanor criminal damage to to property or something like that, to government property, yeah, um, if one of them was involved in, in damaging the police car or the whatever federal vehicle, um, yeah, that they should not have been in there. And they are now wow um free. But. But you know that's after months of difficulty and expense and all of the stuff that they had to go through with that.
1:03:56 Mark: And it only came out because the defence said, there's something a bit fishy here. I think you should look at the transcripts. And the judge looked at the transcripts and then there was something really fishy about the transcripts themselves and then the contents of what went on.
1:04:15 Jim: The thing is, if they'd been better at redacting them, she probably wouldn't have noticed, because she initially thought they were transcription errors. And when she said that in court, the prosecutors didn't say: no, they're not transcription errors, we just didn't include some stuff. Yeah, they let her continue to believe that it was just a simple mistake. That meant that some of the material hadn't made it into the version that she was given, but they'd they'd actively gone through and removed things that made them look bad.
1:04:46 Mark: Wow, so, and then, rather than saying we'll give you the unredacted stuff, we're going to just lower the charges anyway, so we don't need to go through the process. Yeah, to trying to continue to try and get away with it. That's going. That's just going to. Her spidey senses will be tingling then and she's just gonna go. Yeah, I mean, what did you just say?
1:05:06 Jim: I've definitely can't see them – imagine if they'd had any kind of meeting between them – were like: what, what do we do next? Like when they'd been asked for the transcripts. I don't think that the lawyer just immediately in court went: you know what? We're, we're out, we're leaving, we're, we're going. I think they probably must have had a meeting. Yeah, and how can that have gone where one lawyer was like, well, maybe haven't we just dropped the charges and then? And then they went. I mean, do you think the judge will just buy that? Yeah, it's gonna. It looks dodgy. It's gonna it like if you, well, you'd hope if you're called out on something and you completely back away from your original position. Yeah, it looks like you knew you were wrong. I've been watching too much.
1:05:49 Mark: Better, call saul. I mean, even saul would be a little bit cheery about that. He'd just go. Well, that's not gonna look good. You know he, he's mindful of optics.
1:05:58 Jim: Wow, they didn't need a criminal lawyer. They needed a criminal lawyer.
1:06:05 Mark: Medical soul, wow, yeah, oh, my God, that's so. That's the, the government's side, the, the people prosecuting on the part of the government. Not only is is Trump's government trying to prosecute James Comey for arranging shells on a Beach, they're also trying to stack it so that only people who are pro the cause are on the jury and they're trying to keep their dodgy practices – which has coerced somewhat the jury – away from the eyes of the. It's just utter
1:06:49 Jim: corruption, I think. I think the thing is – and I'm not by any means excusing any of the stuff that they've done. But I think part of the explanation for why they may be behaving in this way is because they are having a really hard time getting indictments, because there's that old saw that a grand jury will indict a ham sandwich. The Trump administration could not have proved that more wrong, because they have taken so many cases to court or to the grand jury room at least to try and get indictments, and have failed because they're bullshit cases and they are being being, uh, they're attempting to prosecute things just because it is anti -trump, yeah, when it isn't against the law, and that includes first amendment cases and all kinds of stuff.
1:07:37 [Unclear]: Yeah and um,
1:07:38 Jim: yeah, and they're. They're having a, a really bad time trying to get grand juries to actually indict people that they want to prosecute, uh, and so they're. They are stooping to essentially cheating to get them to do that.
1:07:51 Mark: Yeah, and Trump won't be happy until he is the law. Thankfully, there is the definition – an objective definition – of right and wrong under the law that people can point to and say: well, what you're doing, it isn't, yeah, isn't what we're supposed to be doing, wow, yeah. And finally, some things we really don't have
1:08:14 Jim: time to talk about: America’s 250th birthday bash on the National Mall will feature an event called The Great American State Fair, a 16 day expo organized by Freedom 250 – a public-private partnership spawned by one of Trump’s executive orders to rival the actual, congressionally mandated America250 committee. On Wednesday, Freedom 250 proudly announced its lineup of nine musical acts for the Fair, which included country music superstar Martina McBride, funk/soul group the Commodores, and several much less famous performers. Almost immediately, they frantically sprinted to social media to announce that no the fuck they wouldn’t be performing. The lovely and talented McBride, the only one I gave two shits about, said she was told when she agreed to perform that it would be a nonpartisan event to celebrate America, and that “is, in fact, not what is happening.” I’ve got a feeling that the public backlash might have had a bit more to do with it, but at least she came to her senses. Young MC, the Commodores, and Poison frontman Bret Michaels also cited the shocking revelation that there might be a political angle to something Trump does as their reason for peacing out, while Morris Day of Morris Day and the Time simply channeled Simon Cowell and said “It’s a no from me”. Two of the other acts announced were C+C Music Factory, of Gonna Make You Sweat fame, and Milli Vanilli, of massive fraud fame. Neither act is technically performing, because neither act technically ever was, despite the announcement. Freedom Williams, the rapper from C+C, who owns the trademark to the group’s name, announced in a seven minute Instagram rant from his toilet, that he will still be performing despite the backlash because, in his words, “I don’t fuck with Trump. I don’t give a fuck about Trump. I don’t give a fuck about Trump’s family. I know the type of fucking anarchy he creates. But the day I let you motherfuckers tell me what to do is the day I die”. As for Milli Vanilli, the people who actually sang the songs released a statement confirming that they will not be performing, so if you manage to get tickets you’ll only see the lip-synching fakes. Well, one of them anyway, as the other one’s been dead for nearly 20 years. Not sure if that was Milli or Vanilli. Luckily, you will still get to see Flo Rida and Vanilla Ice, so not all is lost. And, of course, the festivities will also include a 110-foot Ferris wheel, special screenings of “National Treasure” and its sequel, “National Treasure: Book of Secrets,” and every kid’s favorite part of a state fair, “CEO and innovator-led conversations and demonstrations”. Faced with an empty stage and a massive lineup deficit, Trump handled the mass exodus with his signature grace and humility. Taking to Truth Social, he suggested canceling the “overpriced, boring singers who nobody wants to hear anyway” and replacing them with a much better, totally non-musical alternative: himself. Because what the people really want is a furious spoken-word performance about crowd sizes and biased federal judges, with occasional air-accordion solos.
1:11:02 Mark: Oh, and I'm just gonna turn it into a rally. Yeah, yeah, and then lie about how big the crowd was. In a deal not- unlike Baroness Mone’s dodgy PPE contract fast-tracked by mates in the Tory party during covid – after all who better to make hospital approved medical grade PPE than a former lingerie influencer, the Pentagon announced a $620 million loan last year to a small North Carolina startup Vulcan Elements. Of the dozens of companies the Pentagon was considering funding at the time, Vulcan’s was the only deal initiated by a top aide to the president, remember Peter Navarro?- yep him. Okay weird howcumzit Navarro was able to fasttrack funding to this particular startup we-eelll about three months before the Pentagon announced plans to lend money to Vulcan Elements, Donald Trump Jr.’s venture capital firm took an undisclosed stake in the company. The $620m loan was a massive financial commitment from the Pentagon in its effort to fund companies that could help the U.S. reduce dependence on China’s critical mineral supply chains. The deal was a dramatic win for Vulcan, a North Carolina rare-earth magnet company launched just two years earlier. Estimates of its valuation grew tenfold after the deal was announced. Don Jr had visited Navarro in prison while he served time for defying a subpoena from lawmakers investigating the Jan. 6, 2021, Capitol riot. Trump Jr. was one of the small group of people Navarro dedicated his latest book to for having “my back when it was against the wall.” And a week before the Vulcan deal was announced, Trump Jr. hosted Navarro — now the president’s senior counselor for trade and manufacturing — on his streaming show, encouraging his nearly 2 million subscribers to buy Navarro’s book. “No company receives preferential treatment,” a Pentagon spokesperson said. “Outside affiliations, investors, or political connections play absolutely no role in the Department’s funding decisions.” The Pentagon’s response did not address how Vulcan was selected, explaining only how the department addresses conflicts that arise from its employees’ financial holdings, not those of the president’s family. The Office of Strategic Capital is expected to deploy billions more in loans in the coming months to critical mineral and military technology companies. Among the companies under review was Unusual Machines, a Florida drone parts maker, a Defense official said. Trump Jr. sits on the company’s advisory board and holds millions of dollars worth of shares. Brodie Sutherland, CEO of Nevada-based tungsten mining company Patriot Critical Minerals, said “It’s like any industry: A lot of what it is, is who you know.” Defense Department records reviewed recently by ProPublica show Sutherland’s company had already been considered for a loan but was rejected. Yep yep yep.
1:14:02 Jim: Let’s check in on the beautiful, unsoiled ecosystem of American campaign finance, which has recently birthed a shiny new Super PAC called “Lead Left.” According to its official mission statement, Lead Left exists to “stand against MAGA extremists who will infect our country with Donald Trump’s agenda.” It sounds ideal, basically a progressive grassroots collective operating out of a yurt. But if you look at their actual spending, Lead Left has a very specific, almost avant-garde strategy: they are dropping millions of dollars into Democratic primaries to back candidates who are completely insane. Take Texas’s 35th District, where Lead Left dumped nearly a million dollars supporting a primary candidate named Maureen Galindo. Galindo is a progressive housing advocate, a sex therapist, and a casual enjoyer of vibrant antisemitic conspiracy theories. In a series of totally normal Instagram posts, she promised that if elected to Congress, she would introduce legislation to convert a local ICE detention center into a literal internment camp for “American Zionists” that would also double as a “castration processing center for pedophiles which will probably be most of the Zionists.”
1:15:09 Mark: Yeah, that well-known overlapping Venn diagram.
1:15:13 Jim: Naturally, mainstream Democrats aggressively backed her sane opponent, Johnny Garcia, who thankfully won the runoff last week. Lead Left has pulled the same stunt in swing House districts in Nebraska and Pennsylvania, backing supposedly progressive candidates with massive political liabilities, or running bizarre TV ads smearing moderate Democrats as secret Trump lovers. It’s almost as if Lead Left isn’t actually run by progressive activists at all. When the investigative journalists at Popular Information started looking into it, they found two Republicans in a trenchcoat instead, For starters, Lead Left structured its filings so it wouldn’t legally have to disclose its real donors until late June—handily after most of these primaries are already over. The PAC registered its official headquarters at a mailbox inside a Staples store in Tallahassee, Florida, and of the 48,000 political committees registered with the FEC over the last decade, only two others have ever used that exact same Tallahassee Staples mailbox. Both of them are directly run by the Crosby Ottenhoff Group, a prominent Republican compliance firm. Furthermore, a quick peek into the metadata of Lead Left’s original website revealed code directly linking it to WinRed, the official fundraising platform for the Republican Party. The man sitting at the top of this entire apparatus is Caleb Crosby, a top-tier Republican operative who concurrently serves as the treasurer for the Congressional Leadership Fund – the primary Super PAC dedicated to electing House Republicans. Yes, the chief fundraising arm of the GOP is secretly laundering millions through shell companies, painting themselves blue, and using a Staples mailbox to fund antisemitic sex therapists and sabotage competitive Democratic primaries from the inside. It’s the kind of cartoonish, multi-layered ratfucking that would make Dick Cheney shed a single, proud tear. wow, it's.
1:17:02 Mark: It's almost kind of batman And supervillain cartoonish stuff, isn't it? You're right, yeah. Since Trump bought between $15,000 and $50,000 worth of shares of stock in TKO, the parent company of UFC, this week, he wants to make sure the TKO event on his front lawn looks good on TV, What better way than to fill out the bleachers with fine examples of strapping young manhood, and where better to go than the military for that following Pete Hogsbreath’s edict told to that room of fat generals and beardos. a memo circulated within the Air Force, eligibility is contingent on meeting “CURRENT WAIST-HEIGHT RATIO and current physical fitness standard.” Another internal message stated that the Department of Defense was looking for junior personnel and officers, specifically. Great okay it’s bit of a jolly, a day out at the White House representing the nation’s prowess, does it really matter that it’s a bit Hitler-youthy in its optics? Except the caveat is that the co-opted aryan specimens have to pay their own way to get there and probably buy their own snacks, though I expect they’re not allowed to be seen holding a coke and a burger – they’d all be on Trumps TV-dinner tray anyway. This despite the fact that the junior troops are the lowest paid in the military. Well I guess AVClub is right in summarising it as there’s no better way to ring in America’s 250th birthday than by humiliating its military while watching some guy have his orbital bone obliterated all in the service of Trump’s share portfolio. Welcome to the American Utopia!
1:18:38 Jim: As we know, if there’s one thing Republicans hate, it’s the weaponization of the Federal government against the President’s enemies. So it must have been a really tough decision for Todd Blanche to launch a criminal perjury investigation into E. Jean Carroll the 82-year-old woman who already beat the deep-fried, spray-tanned stroke hazard in chief twice in civil court and walked away with an $88 million judgment after he was found civilly liable for sexual assault and defamation. The prosecutors’ theory hinges on a 2022 deposition statement by Carroll, that she received no outside funding for her lawsuit, though it was later revealed that billionaire Reid Hoffman had paid some legal fees and expenses. Blanche, the current head of the DOJ, had to recuse himself because he was literally Trump’s personal defense attorney during the Carroll trials. So instead, the DOJ packed up this vindictive little file and shipped it off to prosecutors in Chicago. The moment the story leaked, the Trump-appointed U.S. Attorney in Chicago, Andrew Boutros, sprinted to Twitter to declare that his office “has never opened” an investigation into Carroll and that the rumors were categorically false. Naturally, within minutes, investigative reporters confirmed that the investigation is ongoing, but Boutros says he’s not investigating Carroll, he’s only investigating Hoffman’s nonprofit, American Future Republic. It’s based in Chicago, so there’s the illusion of justification. But that doesn’t make literally any sense. What has American Future Republic done wrong? It’s allowed to donate money to a legal defense fund. I’m not sure Mr. Boutros is telling the truth. Unsurprisingly, this petty act of presidential score-settling is throwing Senate Republicans into an absolute tailspin, because Democrats are already planning to force endless floor votes explicitly condemning the DOJ’s weaponization against an elderly sexual assault survivor, meaning vulnerable Republicans will have to publicly vote to defend this pathetic stunt right on the Senate floor. But hey, that’s the modern American justice system for you. If you’re a private citizen who gets a legal line-item wrong while suing a corrupt administration, they’ll threaten you with a federal cell. If you’re the guy in the Oval Office executing unsolicited multi-million dollar insider trading deals on government supercomputers, they slap your wrist with a devastating $200 fine. Everything is fine, the system works, and the rule of law is totally intact.
1:20:46 Mark: Nothing to see here.
1:20:48 [Unclear]: Move on.
1:20:50 Mark: Rather than, say, admit that the self-begun war on Iran is leading to a global economic crisis that’s impacting the American voter’s cost of living and work out a way to call it all over, admit defeat and graciously accept the error and the impact, Trump’s worked out a way to save money at the grocery store; reduce legislation restricting the use of hydro-flourocarbons in refrigerators. Similar to his concerns about showers not working and wind farms noise giving people cancer, Trump’s reversal of Biden-era rules as a way to ease the economic strictures is another way to kill off any and all green policies. Of course it’ll have no such impact as industry groups said it could even raise prices because manufacturers have already redesigned products, retooled factories and trained workers to build and service next-generation refrigerant equipment. But that’s not the point the point is to create another distraction by creating an enemy out of pro-carbon reducing eco-centred net-zero type legislations in order to say that it’s that’ that’s causing the problem and not the large gas-emitting orange bloat himself with an ego that requires so much power it’s dimming the national grid every time he opens his mouth. Inflation in the United States increased to 3.8% annually in April, amid price spikes caused by the Iran war and Trump’s sweeping tariffs. Inflation is now outpacing wage gains as the war has kept oil and gasoline prices high. David Doniger, a senior strategist at the Natural Resources Defense Council, called Trump’s action “a lose-lose for the environment and the economy. It will harm consumers and the climate and reduce American competitiveness in the global markets emerging for environmentally safer refrigerants.” though Kevin McDaniel, whose company operates 14 Piggly Wiggly stores in Florida, Alabama and Georgia (- hmm noticeably Red States I see), said the Biden-era rule would have forced many independent grocers out of business. “It was thrown together too fast,’’ he said. “The technology is not there yet. It’s just way too fast. That’s the problem. Good idea, but it’s terrible.” Oh for a minute there I thought that last bit was a reaction to the notion of making the greediest stupidest failingest reality TV-host President of the United States.
1:23:01 Jim: Well, it looks like Donald Trump’s highly anticipated $1.8 billion right-wing piggy bank has entered hospice care after a brief, magnificent lifecycle of about two weeks. In a stunning display of Trump Always Chickening Out, the White House has officially informed congressional leaders that they are pulling the plug on the “Anti-Weaponization Fund”, the taxpayer-funded vault originally designed to dole out cash rewards to the president’s political cronies and January 6th rioters, thanks to a Republican mutiny and some deeply annoyed federal judges. In case you weren’t paying attention to us in episode 193, the trouble started when Trump decided to file a completely bogus $10 billion lawsuit against the IRS because a contractor leaked his tax returns years ago. But instead of pursuing actual legal damages, Trump’s private lawyers huddled in a room with acting Attorney General and Trump’s previous personal defense lawyer Todd Blanche, and hashed out a “settlement.” The terms? Trump would drop the suit, the IRS would magically waive all ongoing tax audits against him and his sons, and the government would deposit $1.776 billion into a shiny new fund to compensate “victims of lawfare.” Basically, Trump sued his own administration so he could agree to settle with himself, give his family a lifetime tax-evasion pass, and build a massive bribery fund for MAGA loyalists. Somehow, this crossed the line even for Senate Republicans. Mitch McConnell publicly called the fund “utterly stupid” and “morally wrong,” asking why the nation’s top law enforcement official was asking for a slush fund to pay people who assault cops. Senate Majority Leader John Thune told the White House that if they didn’t kill the fund themselves, the Senate would do it for them. Meanwhile, the judicial system decided it wasn’t particularly fond of being used as a prop for administrative money laundering. On Friday, a federal judge in Virginia slapped a temporary restraining order on the fund to freeze any payouts. Simultaneously, Miami federal judge Kathleen Williams, prodded by a bipartisan group of 35 former federal judges, reopened Trump’s original IRS case and demanded answers. The former judges explicitly filed a brief stating that the court had been “deceived” by a collusive, feigned, and fraudulent lawsuit designed entirely to provide a fake veneer of legality to an illegal payout scheme. Faced with a full-blown Senate revolt and two federal judges actively breathing down his neck, Trump did what he always does when a grift goes sideways: he folded. The Justice Department sheepishly released a statement on Monday announcing they would “abide by the court’s ruling” and halt all progress on the fund. So OK, everything’s not fine exactly, and the system’s still broken, but maybe the rule of law has a temporary pulse.
1:25:31 Mark: In another week eclipsed by the announcement that tickets are soon to be on sale to see the visiting cloth narrative from Bayeux, Westminster weaves its own tapestry of hasty tone-deaf non-decision-making and self-important mini-me Machiavellian mis-steps, basically a room full of people having things jabbed directly in their eye and yet they can’t see for looking. Wes Streeting who resigned expecting people to beg him not to, has yet to announce his leadership campaign and has endorsed Andy Burnham as Labour’s Best Chance of Winning as he walks behind Andy’s human shield body into the slaughter that will be the Brexit leave and Reform UK council-voting Makerfield by-election. “Yeah Andy you go ahead I’m not going for the top job” uttered between breaths polishing the tape measure at the crown-makers. It’s going to be expensive; Wes has a huge sticky thumb for a head, just warning you Garrard and Co. If Andy does become leader Jeremy Corbyn said he would not rejoin Labour, I’m surprised anyone asked him really given how shittily he was dealt with under member-of-Keir’s-cabinet-admitted “unpopular” Starmer. A bit like inviting advice from Tony Blair on how to deal with the US President notwithstanding the debacle of the Iraq war – oh no wait that happened. Angela Rayner, recent returnee to the Labour party suggested ministers take action on the upcoming report from the consultation on a social media ban for under-16 year olds, which in some ways whiffs of umbrage that TikTok has successfully raised an entire generation when government has not. Nigel Farage thinks his gift of £5m was not subject to declaring among the declaration of gifts over £300 in the 12 months prior to being elected cos apparently it wasn’t a gift given to him two weeks after he stood for election in Clacton, it was a reward for all the good work he had done on Brexit, and all the good work he’s doing to promote crypto since crypto zillionaire Christopher Harborne gave him the bung. But it’s personal and non-political so that’s alright we shouldn’t even be asking questions about it cos Nige gets upset, even though it’s more than all of his constituents in Clacton could earn in all their lifetimes put together, “yeah but ‘e’s one of us in’ee eeza proper geezer” – will we never learn!
1:27:53 Jim: So that's all the bad arguments and faulty reasoning we have time for this week. You'll find the show notes at Fallacious Trump .com and if you hear Trump say something and stupid and want to ask if it's a fallacy, our contact details are on the contact page.
1:28:04 Mark: If you think we've used the fallacy ourselves, let us know. And if you've had a good time, please give us a review on apple podcast or wherever you get your podcast, or simply tell one other person in person about how much they like our podcast, and you can support the show at Patreon .com slash f Trump, just like our strawman level patrons chris ward, Mike Smyth, eltee Richard thunder, hopkins, Mark Reiche and amber r buchanan, who told us when we met her at Qed we could just Just call it Amber. And at QED in 24, I met the listener recogniser at QED the year before because we keep using a full name all the time. And last year, we stood outside a restaurant called Sexy Fitch whilst contemplating the interconnectedness of all things. And our true Scotsman-level patrons, Renee Zed, Chuck Gray, Janet Yuetter, and our top patron, Kaz Toohey. Thank you so much for your continued support, everybody. It's very, very much appreciated. Thank you.
1:28:52 Jim: You can connect with those awesome people, as well as us and other listeners, in the Facebook group at Facebook .com slash groups, slash Fallacious Trump or in the Discord at Fallacious Trump .com slash Discord.
1:29:01 Mark: All music was by the outbursts and was used for permission, so until next time I'll Fallacious Trump. We'll leave the last word to the Donald.
1:29:08 [Unclear]: That's right, go home to mommy. Bye.
