Show Notes
Conspiracy theorists often create unfalsifiable arguments, using a combination of goalpost moving, arguments from ignorance and circular logic.
Trump
We started out with Trump talking about the rigged election:
We followed that with this Trump tweet:
How amazing, the State Health Director who verified copies of Obama’s “birth certificate” died in plane crash today. All others lived
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) December 12, 2013
Then we looked at these mutually exclusive arguments about Kavanaugh:
And finally we heard from Trump on paid protestors in these tweets:
The very rude elevator screamers are paid professionals only looking to make Senators look bad. Don’t fall for it! Also, look at all of the professionally made identical signs. Paid for by Soros and others. These are not signs made in the basement from love! #Troublemakers
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) October 5, 2018
The paid D.C. protesters are now ready to REALLY protest because they haven’t gotten their checks – in other words, they weren’t paid! Screamers in Congress, and outside, were far too obvious – less professional than anticipated by those paying (or not paying) the bills!
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) October 9, 2018
Mark’s British Politics Corner
Mark talked about this collection of clips that triggered conspiracies around Brexit:
Fallacy in the Wild (Sting: Crazy Horses by The Osmonds)
In the Fallacy in the Wild we looked at this clip from Monty Python’s Life of Brian:
Fake News
Here are the statements from this week’s Fake News game:
- I think somebody else had a lot to do with that book. I think he wrote the second book, which was certainly not a masterpiece. I’m very good at books, and it certainly wasn’t a masterpiece.
- 20, 30 years ago, you never saw this. We used to have beautiful blue skies. We never saw clouds like these. A lot of people think there’s something going on and it’s not good.
- They go in, they get this monster shot. You ever see the size of it? It’s like they’re pumping in, you know, it’s terrible the amount. And they pump this into this little body.
Click below for the answer
Spoiler
Statement 2 is Fake News. Mark chose number 3Mark got it wrong this week, and is currently on 20%
DNA is not a logical fallacy
We talked about Elizabeth Warren’s DNA
The stories we really didn’t have time to talk about:
- After a week of helping to cover up a journalist’s murder in order to preserve an arms deal, Donald Trump praised the combat technique of journalist-body-slamming-Republican Congressman Greg Gianforte. Trump isn’t actively calling for violence against reporters, but he’s also not not doing that. All I’m saying is you can see why the Saudis would assume he’d be cool with them torturing and murdering a Washington Post reporter.
- And Trump keeps changing his story about how many jobs he’s protecting by refusing to condemn the Saudi government. Whatever the real number is, he’s also ignoring the fact that Saudi officials insist 50% of the spending – and 50% of the jobs, will be in Saudi Arabia. So it’ll only cost an arm and a leg instead of er… two arms and… two legs – hmm too soon?
- Seemingly out of desperation, Trump is also completely inventing ‘unknown middle easterners’ in the Central American migrant caravan currently heading for the US, fabricating imaginary riots in California over sanctuary cities, and totally making up a new tax cut for the middle class which he says is happening in the next couple of weeks, despite Congress not being in session. Honestly, we’re about a week away from him promising everyone a pony if they vote Republican in the midterms.
- And speaking of ponies, Trump called Stormy Daniels ‘horseface’ on Twitter this week and seemed super proud of coming up with such a brilliant insult. In fact, according to the Daily Beast he ‘workshopped’ the nickname with friends and staffers before deciding to ignore the senior aides who told him to let it go, and tweet it out anyway. Because what kind of pussy doesn’t rage-tweet a playground insult at the porn-star they paid off? Losers.
- Melania Trump claimed in an interview with ABC to be one of the most bullied people in the world. *COUGH*Christine Blasey Ford*COUGH* But to be fair, she knew what a bully Donald was when she married him.. Also last week, Melania said she wished people would pay more attention to what she does instead of what she wears. The fact that she said this while cos-playing as Belloq from Raiders of the Lost Ark did NOT help.
- Artificial sun-worshipping idiot stares directly at the real solar eclipse – using just his eyes – declaring “I have a natural instinct for science”. And cos he’s the president he therefore literally Trumps 97% of all professional, skilled, experienced, well-read, researched and objectively peer-reviewed actual scientists and their view that climate change is man-made. Like he said to Lesley Stahl on 60 minutes as justification of everything “I’m the president and you’re not” – is it seemly for a grown man to still be saying nyer nyer nyer nyer nyer?
- A Southwest Airlines passenger has been arrested for repeatedly groping another passenger’s breast during the flight. In his defence, the President has said that grabbing women by the private parts is OK. That’s not a joke. The man literally said that in his defence. We are living in the darkest timeline.
- Speaking of which: this headline from Rolling Stone – A Deceased Brothel Owner Is Still Likely to Win a Nevada Midterm – Dennis Hof’s candidacy does not automatically end despite the fact that he is no longer living. Nye County Commission Chairman John Koenig agrees. “I think the Republicans in this town will still vote for him because they want a Republican in the chair. But I wouldn’t bet money either way.”
If you wanted to buy a T-shirt featuring this fallacy, you could click here. No pressure
And if you have some money left over after that, Jim’s book, 2000 Mules and One Big Lie: A Stubborn Conspiracy Theory is available now.
That’s almost all for this week, but here’s our AI-aided transcript, which is quite accurate, but not totally:
Conspiracy Theory – FT#11 Transcript
Read the full transcript
00:23 Jim: Hello and welcome to Fallacious Trump, the podcast where we use the insane ramblings of a conspiracy theorist to explain logical fallacies. I'm your host, Jim.
00:31 Mark: And I'm your other host, Mark. A logical fallacy is an error in reasoning that results in bad or invalid arguments, and the logical fallacy we're looking at this week is the conspiracy theory fallacy.
00:42 Jim: Now, you might think it's a bit weird to have conspiracy theory in a list of logical fallacies, and it's true that, actually, conspiracy theorists tend to use quite a lot of different fallacies in their their argumentation. They use things, including stuff that we haven't talked about yet, like special pleading and cherry picking, but one thing that they do that is fairly consistent among conspiracy theory is creating arguments which are unfalsifiable. So, right to explain why it's important to have a falsifiable argument. I want to do a quick experiment now. I'm kind of springing this on Mark. I haven't talked to him about it, but no, I'm going to give you a, a set of three numbers, and those numbers follow a rule that I have in my head. Now, right, you have to try and figure out what the rule is, and the way you do it is to give me another set of three numbers and I will tell you if it follows the rule or not.
01:40 Mark: The same rule, right?
01:41 Jim: Yeah, yeah, yeah, so, and you can do it as many times as you need to until you can get figure out the rule. Okay, so the numbers are: yeah, two, four and eight.
01:55 Mark: two, four and eight.
01:57 Jim: Okay, uh, two,
02:01 Mark: three and six. That follows the rule.
02:04 Jim: Ha ha, yep,
02:07 Mark: so the The rule, and so all right.
02:11 Jim: You can guess or you can keep going.
02:13 Mark: 3, 5, and 15.
02:16 Jim: That follows the rule.
02:18 Mark: There you go. So the first two numbers are multiplied together to give you the third number.
02:21 Jim: That's not the rule. A? Keep going.
02:28 Mark: So 2, 3, and 5, but 3 and 5 multiplied together is 15. Yeah, it follows the rule,
02:36 Jim: but that's not the rule I have in my head. Oh, okay, uh, right, okay.
02:42 Mark: So what about 3, 7 and 21?
02:47 Jim: That follows the rule.
02:48 Mark: That follows the rule, okay, so, uh, right, so so the, the, the third number, is divisible by both the first and the second. A number that's not the rule.
03:03 Jim: What, uh, okay, uh, so, uh okay.
03:09 Mark: One, three and three. That does not follow the rule. Oh, okay, so one, three and three doesn't follow the rule. Um, okay, the third number has just got to be bigger than the other, the first two.
03:25 Jim: That's not the rule.
03:30 Mark: let's try another example. Example: five, five and twenty five. That does not follow the rule.
03:35 Jim: Ah, okay, uh, okay,
03:41 Mark: um, I, I, yeah, I'll give up. Okay, can't, can't see how it won't, because what the one, three and three, yeah – is?
03:53 Jim: Yeah, any, any three positive numbers in ascending order. Ah, okay, yeah. What Mark did there was what we all do all of the time, every day in our lives. He came up with a theory that explained what he saw. He came up with basically a set of beliefs and then looked for confirming evidence. He looked for other evidence that showed what he already thought was true was true. So when he thought it might be that you multiply the numbers together to get the third number, he suggested numbers that did that, just did that. Yeah, and that's what we all do all the time. We have beliefs and we look for evidence that confirms our beliefs. That's not what scientists do. What scientists do is they create a hypothesis, they come up with a set of beliefs that explains blames, what they're looking at, and then they look for ways to prove it wrong, yeah, yeah. And once they've thought of all of the things that they can to prove it wrong and they haven't been able to prove their theory wrong, that's when they start to say, okay, this is a good theory.
05:06 Jim: So that's why you need to have falsifiability in your theories, in your ideas, because if you can't to make it a stronger theory, yeah, if there's not going to be any evidence that proves it wrong, wrong, if you're not looking for ways to prove it wrong, then all you're doing is continuing to find um evidence for what you already think.
05:24 Mark: So you're not looking for any kind of thing that might actually make you change your mind, or you're trying to find something that will show that your theory is very strong indeed. Yeah, um, takes you back to where we talked about the straw man thing. What you want to do is make the most convincing argument, uh, in order for that to be knocked down, and if somebody can't knock that down, then that's a very strong argument. If they can knock it down, then you just go. Oh, okay, I need to go back and rethink my theory rather than just ignore the evidence.
06:05 Jim: Yeah, and also, you, you need to try and figure out ways that it can be knocked down, and that's that's the point. Yes, there have to be ways for it to fail. Yeah, conspiracy theorists: basically, they construct arguments that can't fail, they can't be proved wrong, and there's various ways of doing this. Yeah, one way is to suggest a theory that doesn't necessarily actually predict – predict something. Whatever happens, it could be proof that what you said is true. In 2016, in the months leading directly up to the election, Trump started, it seems, to think actually he might not win. Even though everyone had been telling him the entire time he wasn't going to win. It looked like maybe he wasn't going to win. The evidence was building up that Hillary was was going to win. And he started saying things like this.
07:02 Clip: Trump on the rigged election
— I'm afraid the election is going to be rigged. I have to be honest. People are going to walk in. They're going to vote 10 times. Maybe who knows? I'm telling you, November 8th, we better be careful because that election is going to be rigged.
07:11 Jim: So by saying the election was going to be rigged, he was setting up the idea that if he didn't win, he could say it was not his fault. It was because Hillary had rigged it. As it turned turned out, he did win, but that wasn't taken as evidence that Hillary hadn't been trying to rig the election. No, in fact, what he did was he seized upon the fact that he didn't win the popular vote – yeah – and then said that he would have won the popular vote if it hadn't been for all the voter fraud and the three million, three to five million illegals who had voted, of course, with no evidence at all that that happened.
07:49 Mark: No, and even when they did look for the evidence, they found that there was none. Yeah, and it was purely coincidentally that there were many people the same name and same birthday,
07:59 Jim: and even then I mean the actual evidence of of people showing up more in more than one place to vote or using a fake name or something like that. They found, I think, something like 37 cases in about a billion, uh, voting instances. So yeah, yeah, Yeah. So basically, that's that's. One way of creating an unfalsifiable argument is to is to predict something that actually doesn't necessarily lead to a particular outcome. It could be explained by a number of different outcomes. It's what people do, when religious people, when they say they're praying for something to happen, or you know someone, this person is, something bad is going to happen to them if we don't pray for them. And then if something bad does happen, they can say: see, I told you we didn't pray hard enough, and if it doesn't, yeah, they can say: yeah, yay, we prayed hard enough and it stopped.
08:54 Mark: It's part of the unforcifiable thing is that you can't prove it – yeah, exactly either.
08:59 [Unclear]: Well, you can, yeah,
09:01 Jim: I mean they're not. Then they're very rarely looking to be able to prove it. They're very, very commonly conspiracy theorists. Very commonly suggest something or make vague claims, um, and just say: well, you know, I don't, I don't know what the reality is, but it's definitely not what you're being told. You know the story the official story is is clearly wrong, but they're not necessarily. Sometimes they do, and the more specific claims they make, the easier it is for them to be disproved. But they don't necessarily accept that evidence as as:
09:37 Mark: yeah, yeah, and that was a bit like the birth certificate stuff, exactly.
09:42 Jim: The next way of creating a falsifiable argument is simply to move the goal posts. So, even if you have a specific claim and you're looking for specific evidence, just like, uh, Trump did with Obama's birth certificate, when Obama produced his birth certificate, Trump claimed: well, it's not authentic, so that means that there isn't really any evidence that you would accept. Yeah, one of the things when we're being good critical thinkers is to examine your own beliefs and think, okay, well, whatever. Is there evidence that I could see that would make me think? Actually I'm wrong. When we're talking about conspiracy theorists, they don't tend to say: well, we, We recognize that. This goes against a lot of other evidence. They tend to dismiss all that evidence based on the single anomaly they have found. And when they are doing this anomaly, hunting, this cherry -picking of evidence out of a large amount of evidence that sometimes points in the other direction. They see patterns everywhere. We're very good at finding patterns as humans. And they tend to dismiss coincidences. They tend to dismiss the idea that they can be coincidences. All coincidences tend to have meaning to a conspiracy theorist. For example, still on the Bertha conspiracy,
11:05 [Unclear]: in 2013, Trump tweeted, How amazing.
11:12 Jim: The state health director who verified copies of Obama's birth certificate died in plane crash today. All others lived. So that did happen. The person that the state, hawaii state director, died in a plane crash – um, it was a small, small plane and the other passengers survived. Um, the he's, without actually stating it directly. He's saying this is part of the conspiracy. He's saying: you know how amazing it is, yeah, that the person who verified Obama's birth certificate has died in a – you know – inverted commas – plane crash. Yeah, as if it's yeah, yeah, for so there's some reason for killing her, without stating yeah, yeah, without going into details, without saying you know that all of the other things that would have had to have happened for this conspiracy to be true, um, he's, he's kind of making that, that leap.
12:07 [Unclear]: And where, where, where does the?
12:13 Mark: Where does that come from? The the need for? Well, I can see that you know, he, he, he is holding on to his theory that Obama isn't, you know, isn't – a native of America. Uh, isn't American born? Rather, um, because it suits him to say that, because he's perpetrating this idea that Obama has pulled off the, the greatest um heist in political history, by being the president when he shouldn't have been and thereby dismissing his entire terms in office. So he's flying in the face of this evidence just because of that, and what is it that makes it so? There is, however, something attractive about that tweet in particular, such that we can draw the inference from it we, we know exactly what he means and we're kind of we're pulled in. Is it? Is it because we are, um, we can make stories out of everything? We can make meaning from things? It kind of plays directly into that, I think. So, yeah, I think if you give people a set of random events, we will try and join them together to some extent.
13:29 Jim: Um, it's about, uh, the, the comfort that people get from the idea that actually everything is under control and being arranged by someone or something.
13:40 Mark: Um, right, strange abuse, use of the word comfort. There it's, it's, isn't? It's always slightly alarming, isn't that? The? The appeal to motion, but I think actually,
13:54 Jim: people are afraid that everything is just happening randomly, it's just empty. I mean, there is incidents and there isn't. Yeah, it's just a random set of. So the fact that, yeah, things just happen is actually a little bit more scary for a lot of the people than than yeah,
14:10 Mark: and someone, if it was all right,
14:12 Jim: but someone is actually running things and I think, in a way that looking for those seeing that pattern in in life, seeing that when something weird happens, actually there must be a reason for it. And people – you know people do use that as a as a way of comfort and a way of invoking God and stuff. You know, everything happens for a reason.
14:32 [Unclear]: People say yeah, yeah, yeah.
14:35 Jim: Some would say that's not true. Sometimes things just happen without a reason.
14:41 Mark: They just happen and yeah, and. And that you're right. That is a terrifying prospect, that actually nobody is in control of this stuff. It just it's all just a bunch of random stuff.
14:52 Jim: And the other thing about a tweet like that is that, again, because he's not directly stating it, he can, he can kind of back off and has plausible deniability and says: look, I'm just asking questions, I'm just saying: isn't it interesting that this has happened? I'm not saying it's a conspiracy, I'm just saying yeah, yeah, yeah. And. And someone who did that hugely was, uh, glenn beck, who is no longer. He no longer has his own tv show, but when he did he he constantly was talking about. You know how there's these, these links between all the people in government and the Illuminati and all kinds of crazy stuff, um, to the extent that actually a parody website was set up about him that was called: uh, did glenn beck rape and murder a young girl in 1990? .com?
15:41 [Unclear]: And it said the.
15:43 Jim: The website basically said: uh, we don't think he did, but we think it's important to ask the question because that's the kind of question he used to ask about people. Um right, And it used his rhetoric and he tried to get it shut down and the court said actually, no, you can't because it's free speech and it's not saying you did anything, it's just asking a question.
16:13 Mark: Which is an official thumbing of the nose back at him.
16:19 Jim: So the vague claims that conspiracy theorists make that tend to be asserted without evidence and ignore all the evidence that are in the other direction. Those kinds of things have been coming up now most recently. Actually, I'd like to say most recently, but there's been stuff happening in the meantime. But with the Kavanaugh confirmation and Christine Duffy Ford. Now, at first, Trump said this about Ford's testimony.
16:48 Clip: Mutually exclusive arguments about Kavanaugh
— I thought her testimony was very compelling and she looks like a very fine woman to me. Very fine woman. But certainly she was a very credible witness.
16:58 Jim: Then Kavanaugh spoke and a few more days passed. Then he mocked her in a rally and pretended that she couldn't remember some of the stuff that she actually could remember. And then, a few days later, when Kavanaugh was actually confirmed, Trump apologized to brett Kavanaugh on behalf of America for what he'd had to go through and said this:
17:22 Clip: Mutually exclusive arguments about Kavanaugh
— now they're thinking about impeaching a brilliant jurist, a man that did nothing wrong, a man that was caught up in a hoax that was set up by the Democrats using the Democrats lawyers, and now they want to impeach him. It was all made up, it was fabricated and it's a disgrace.
17:42 Mark: On what evidence did he say?
17:45 Jim: No evidence whatsoever. No, did he say that this is following following the fbi investigation – and I use investigation lightly there because, um, there were, there were over 40 witnesses the fbi didn't in uh interview, including Kavanaugh and Ford, and at the confirmation ceremony, Trump actually claimed that Kavanaugh had been proven innocent, which, even if it had been a trial and he'd been acquitted, wouldn't have happened. Even then, it's only proven not guilty or not not been able to prove be proven guilty. But um, yeah, he to claim that he had been proven innocent and then say that it was all made up, it's all fabricated, it's conspiracy by the Democrats, basically saying a hoax, a hoax set up by the Democrats. Is is totally feeding into this idea that that actually they're out to get you and none of this is happening by chance. It's all. It's all being set up by some kind of nefarious outside force and and his, His supporters totally bought into it, even during the confirmation process. They were talked to outside a rally, and one lady said this.
18:49 Clip: Mutually exclusive arguments about Kavanaugh
— I believe that Dr Ford's getting paid by the Democratic Party, or by the media, either or.
— Eh, doesn't matter.
18:58 Jim: Yeah, I have got no evidence for either one, so they're both as likely as each other, basically.
19:02 Mark: And yeah, his supporters lap it up. He might as well have said it's the Illuminati, or whoever, or it's the Klingons.
19:09 Jim: Well, let me tell you some of the other conspiracies that his supporters came up with over the course of the hearings included that Christine Ford was a CIA asset. She was hypnotized into believing that Kavanaugh assaulted her. People claimed that she had accused Neil Gorsuch during his confirmation hearings as well, but that hadn't come out. They claimed that she was linked to peter struck, the fbi agent who was fired following emails that came out that vaguely showed that he wasn't in favor of Trump. Um, yeah, they claimed that Ford's lawyer was linked to Hillary clinton. They claimed that her other lawyer was linked to george soros. They claimed that she mistook Kavanaugh for someone else, that the? Um, the scrubbing of her, Her social media account, had been so extreme that it must have been done by someone at Google. They claimed that Kavanaugh's mother, who was also a judge, oversaw a foreclosure case against her parents when they were younger, which did happen. That actually did happen, but she ruled in their favour. So that doesn't really give her a motive to attack Kavanaugh 30 years later. But all of these things were said during the confirmation hearings, and that's just a few. There's more. More. Wow, these were all seen, I presume, by these people to be more credible than the fact that someone did this at a party, did you know? Held someone down on the bed and tried to take their clothes off while drunk. That that's much less likely than all of these other things.
20:44 Mark: Yeah, and all the other ones, including the bit I like the. That strikes me as being a a familiar thing. That conspiracy theorists say is this: this happened, but they, uh, they edited it out, or they, um hid that, or, and you again, it's another. It's an unfalsifiable thing. You can't prove that they hidden it because it's not there, so they must have.
21:10 Jim: Yeah, and that's the last section actually of of creating an. An unfalsifiable argument is to claim that any evidence against your theory is created by, as part of the conspiracy. It's further proof of the conspiracy. In fact, one of Ford's friends, keith kogler, sent the fbi information that, uh, he had had email exchanges with Christine Ford, um, during the period following kennedy's retirement from the supreme court, but before Kavanaugh was a, a nominee, and Ford was telling him she had told him previously that she had been assaulted by someone who became a federal judge and she told him in these emails that that person was cavanaugh. The fbi didn't interview this guy. It was evidence that she had not been making it up to try and stop him from from having the confirmation. But, uh, one of the replies to this, this story that went out, was: well, this is proof that Ford was poisoning the well before cavanaugh was even nominated. Yeah, so some people can – people who are determined to see this as a conspiracy, see – think that the evidence that she had mentioned cavanaugh as her assaulter before he was a nominee is proof that she was just planning it.
22:29 [Unclear]: Well, wow, yeah, yeah,
22:32 Jim: and that's that's the thing. For this to be real, to this, for this to be true, it's there's such a lot that you have to ignore, you have to pretend, you have to assume that that not only is Ford lying, but that her husband is lying, that her therapist is lying, that they are prepared to um, put themselves out there and and basically, they're not able even yet to go back to their house. Their family has had death threats against them. They um, and and that this would be the choice that they would make, just so that a supreme court nominee didn't get confirmed. And, yeah, that if it was actually the Democrats that were doing this, that they had found this woman who either, depending on what you believe was a sexual assault survivor, but it wasn't Kavanaugh, and they convinced her to say say it was Kavanaugh, or they just convinced her to make up the whole thing. Presumably they didn't ask any of the other 65 women that Kavanaugh knew in high school, because surely one of them would have said: well, I was approached by the Clintons to see if I would do this and I said no. So they just got it right first time. They picked exactly the right person to choose. Also, they made up a story that is really hard to provide evidence for when they didn't need to. So all of the things that people say this is a bad story, that she can't remember how she got home, or the person that she says was in the room with them is a friend of Kavanagh's. That's unnecessary bits of a story. If you were going to make up a story, I would say, OK, Ford and Kavanaugh were a party. There were various other people at the party. Kavanaugh pushed her into a bedroom, managed to remove some of her clothes, managed to kind of take his trousers off. And then a friend of Christine Ford's came in the room and said, what the hell are you doing? Pulled him off and she got away. And then that friend could give evidence and say, yes, I was there. I saw this. This happened. Happened. That's a much harder story to argue against, but, but the the reason they didn't come up with that story is because that's not what happened. So she said what happened most likely, rather than a much better version of what happened.
24:47 [Unclear]: Yeah, yeah, which,
24:50 Mark: if you were making up a story,
24:51 Jim: yeah, you would do that. It's not hard. It's not hard to come up with a better story or make up how she got home exactly. Just say: I walked home. She says she can't remember. Because she can't remember.
25:03 Mark: Yeah, yeah, because that's the problem, that the truth sometimes is quite inconveniently mundane and, you know, filled with gaps. But the conspiracy theorists, they storm straight in those holes and go: ah, you see, that's because dot, dot, dot. Yeah, it's exasperating, because there is is nothing you can say, um, that you would normally apply in, you know, normal critical thinking or scientific method or just plain old logic. It's impossible to falsify, because the goalposts,
25:45 Jim: they just don't accept any evidence on the other side,
25:48 Mark: yeah, and, and will invent their own evidence to counter the evidence.
25:53 Jim: Yeah, and, interestingly, there was a study published in the British journal of social psychology in april of 2011 that said that conspiracy theories are more likely to be believed by people who are themselves willing to take part in a conspiracy. So right, all right, we'll leave you to wow, make your own conclusions about what that says about Trump.
26:20 [Sting: Mark’s British Politics Corner] And now is the time, I think, for Mark’s British Politics Corner.
26:20 Mark: So this week I'm looking, yes, again at brexit. It's the ripe breeding ground for conspiracy theories. In order to make sense of a vote that didn't go the way we expected it, to this apparent anomaly – and the example that I've got is on the day David Cameron announced his resignation, which was the day following the referendum, there was an Article in the Guardian newspaper which, because it was quite astonishing News – not totally unexpected – that David Cameron, the Prime Minister at the time, who went to the country for the referendum when the referendum result went against the way he thought it would go, he just resigned, washed his hands of it in a very Pontius Pilate kind of way, hummed a little tune as he went back into the, into number 10, and at the bottom of that News coverage there was this comment by a commentator called tebes and he put forward this explanation of what had gone on. So it starts with: if Boris johnson looked downbeat yesterday, that's because he realizes that he has lost. Perhaps many brexiters do not realize it yet, but they have actually lost, and it's all down to one man, David Cameron. So there's the bit of hope in this conspiracy theory. He's about to expound why Cameron did what he did. But in there, it's his spin on the whole thing is that, well, it means that the Brexiteers, the leavers, have lost. Because he says, in one fell swoop yesterday at 9: .15am, Cameron effectively annulled the referendum result and simultaneously destroyed the political careers of Boris Johnson, Michael Gove, leading Brexiteers who cost him so much anguish, not to mention his premiership. So he's fundamentally saying that Cameron's in control of this whole thing and he knew exactly what he was doing and he's annulled the referendum result. So if we play in the first clip, this is where Cameron was saying yes, if the referendum says says we must leave, then we will trigger Article 50, which is basically the process of leaving the European Union immediately.
28:40 Clip: The clips that triggered Brexit conspiracy theories
— You would activate Article 50, it would take two years, we'd still be in the EU, we'd have some time to negotiate.
— You activate Article 50. You're going to activate that immediately? You're going to activate that immediately? That is what, if British people vote to leave, that's what we should do. On the 28th of June, you will activate it at the European Council.
— Absolutely, that's what we have to do.
28:53 Mark: What would happen next? You have two years to negotiate. So that's our friend Faisal Islam, who's interviewing David Cameron on Sky News. Um, and Cameron is saying so, this is June 2nd. Uh, when the the kind of the campaign for leave and remain is going on, he's saying so I will trigger Article 50. So immediately. And then on the 24th, June, immediately after the referendum, this is what he said.
29:19 Clip: The clips that triggered Brexit conspiracy theories
— But I do believe it's in the national interest to have a period of stability and then the new leadership required. There is no need for a precise timetable today, but in my view we should. It aimed to have a new prime minister in place by the start of the Conservative Party conference in October. A negotiation with the European Union will need to begin under a new prime minister. And I think it's right that this new prime minister takes the decision about when to trigger Article 50 and start the formal and legal process of leaving the EU.
29:53 Mark: So what he's saying basically is: I'm not going to trigger Article 50 because then I will be the, the prime minister that pulled us out of the EU, and he's kind of putting all sorts of flummery around. Didn't fancy that. He wanted to be remembered for all the wonderful things that he did do. Let me just number those. Yeah, that's about it. This guy who's writing this conspiracy theory is saying he knows full well that Article 50 isn't going to be triggered. And even Boris Johnson is now – to use that British phrase again – he's now snookered because part of the conspiracy theory is: we're going to have this referendum, we will lose, we won't pull out of the EU. I will completely fuck it up for Boris Johnson, who is trying to become the next leader, and I will walk away scot -free and leave the poison chalice to whoever's going to be in next. This is Boris George Johnson's speech the day after the referendum, when he ostensibly has won, because he was the poster boy for the Leave campaign. That was the bandwagon that he jumped on in order to guarantee his bid for the leadership.
31:07 Clip: The clips that triggered Brexit conspiracy theories
— In voting to leave the EU, it is vital to stress that there is now no need for haste. And indeed, as the Prime Minister has just said, nothing will change over over the short term, except that work will have to begin on how to give effect to the will of the people and to extricate this country from the supranational system. And as the Prime Minister has rightly said, there is no need to invoke Article 50. And to those who may be anxious, whether at home or abroad. This does not mean that the the united kingdom will be in any way less united, nor indeed does it mean that it will be any less European.
31:52 Mark: So so this is the leader of the leave campaign saying: okay, we've won the referendum, went, that we should leave. But what he's saying is: yeah, but rest assured, nothing's going to change. We will be no less united and no less European. We won't need to trigger the Article and you. You can almost hear the fear in his voice. So fundamentally – that feeds into this guy's conspiracy theory – that the Brexit leaders have now got a result that they can't use because the leadership is now in a disarray. They're not going to do the thing which actually starts the process of getting out of the EU. And there's another theory that hooks onto. That is by a guy who's actually a chief executive of an organization called panaceaadvisor .com, derek bradley, and he's saying, behind closed doors, the elites that control so -called Democratic Uk set in train a series of actions to ensure that that outcome. We voted to leave, the elites don't want us to leave and, behind closed doors, they're going to put in a series of actions to ensure that we don't leave, and it will take a year or two, but hey ho, is that?
33:10 Jim: Um, if, as looks like it's happening at the moment, everything's gone all tits up and they and there's got no plan at all, and it's no, they can't negotiate a deal. If at some point they actually have another referendum and we say, yeah, you know what bad idea, let's stay, let's stay, that would be taken as evidence that see, the elites wanted us to stay, so they made it exactly exactly that.
33:36 [Unclear]: Yes, yeah, um, so,
33:39 Mark: and he cites: there will be. You know, there are court cases, more court cases. So that there he's: both tebes and and uh, derrick bradley are making sense of what are just a random series of events and a random series of attempts, attempts by ill -informed, politically motivated people to do things to serve their own interests. In the middle of this mess, the only thing they can rely on is right. Well, I need to sort myself out so that at least I've got a future, which is why leading conservative politicians like Nigel Lawson, who was the Chancellor of the Exchequer under Margaret Thatcher, is seeking French – French citizenship. And Jacob Rees-Mogg, who is a staunch Brexiteer, is moving some of his businesses to the Republic of Ireland to remain in the EU. The only kind of thing that you can grasp hold of in this mess is these people looking out for themselves. And again, that's evidence, evidence. It's a conspiracy of elites.
34:51 [Sting: Fallacy in the Wild (Crazy Horses – The Osmonds)]
35:10 Mark: There we go, our favourite residents of Utah, the osmonds, yeah, yeah, there we go, it's good.
35:18 Jim: It's not as good as wild thing, though I prefer that.
35:20 Mark: I know, I don't know, so I'm I'm bright. No, I know we'll have to keep coming back to that. I'll keep trying, but I didn't see, I've moved slightly from wild to crazy. Yeah, you see, yeah,
35:33 Jim: yeah, okay, so in In The Fallacy in the Wild, we like to talk about the fallacy of the week from a non -political point of view. And the example we've got. Actually it's not a conspiracy, but it's demonstrating the kind of thinking of the conspiracy theory fallacy that we're talking about, which is creating an unfalsifiable theory. And it's something that does happen, as we've mentioned, in religion. And this film explored religion very carefully and solemnly. And here's the example.
36:04 [Unclear]: I say: you are lord and I should know I followed a few.
36:36 Jim: So they – his followers, brian's followers there – have created a situation where there's nothing he can say that will convince them he's not the messiah, even when he absolutely says: honestly, listen to me, I'm telling the truth, I'm not the messiah. They take that as proof that he is the, the messiah.
36:57 Mark: Yes, because, yeah, only
37:00 Jim: the messiah would deny his divinity.
37:02 [Unclear]: Yeah, yeah, I like the.
37:05 Mark: I like the setup right at the beginning, which kind of where John please says: yeah, you are a messiah, I know, I should know, I followed a few, yeah. So they're kind of you know, even at the outset they're saying that, yeah, you're, you are a messiah, which by, by definition, means that there's only one. One isn't there. And then he said: I followed a few, yeah, and you're certainly one as I do. You've got all the attributes of a messiah, yeah, so we're gonna.
37:39 [Sting: Fake News] We're gonna play fake News. Folks. I love the game. It's a great game. I understand the game as well as anybody. As well as anybody.
37:46 Jim: Yes, it's time for fake News. The game where I read out three Trump quotes, two of which are real and one I made up, and Mark has to figure out which one is fake News. So, uh, sticking with the theme of conspiracy theories, okay, the the three quotes this week are based on even more conspiracy theories that Trump promotes or defends, or yes, uh, so the first one number one is, uh, his theory on on who wrote Obama's first book.
38:17 [Unclear]: He says, I
38:19 Jim: think somebody else had a lot to do with that book. I think he wrote the second book, which was certainly not a masterpiece. I'm very good at books, and it certainly wasn't a masterpiece.
38:30 [Unclear]: Number two is
38:32 Jim: Trump's opinion on chemtrails. Now, that is the white lines that come out of commercial airliners, which some people say They are chemicals that are being used to change the weather or subdue the populace. He says, 20, 30 years ago, you never saw this. We used to have beautiful blue skies. We never saw clouds like these. A lot of people think there's something going on and it's not good. And number three is his opinion on vaccines causing autism. And he says it's because of the amount of vaccine that they give children. He says, they go in, they get this monster shot. You ever see the size of it? It's like they're pumping in. You know it's terrible the amount and they pump this into this little body, okay.
39:21 Mark: The second one is quite interesting because, knowing his grasp of history, 20 or 30 years ago isn't that long ago and I'm sure there were chemtrails then. In fact, I know that in 1937, when ansel adams was photographing yosemite national park, he would have to wait for the um – what he called Sky worms – to dissipate before he did um. So that okay. And the Obama one is second book, which was a masterpiece. I don't want to help with the first, but, okay, great big, great big thing pumped into a little body, yeah, I think, I think his grasp of history convinces me that number two is real. And the Obama one, that sounds like a proper Trump dig. But he would say great big thing pumped into a little body. Okay, having said that, despite that, I think number three, you made up.
40:41 Clip: Trump, played during Fake News
— Okay.
40:42 Jim: So you think number one is real, yeah, and number one is, yeah, real.
40:49 Clip: Trump, played during Fake News
— I think somebody else had a lot to do with that book. I think he wrote the second book, which was certainly not a masterpiece – I'm very good at books – and it certainly wasn't a masterpiece.
40:58 Jim: I'm very good at books,
40:59 Mark: I'm very good at books and I can tell you can identify a book from a hole in the ground. That's as far as it goes.
41:09 Jim: So basically, what he's saying is: Obama's first book was too good.
41:13 Mark: It was too to be Obama. The second must have got help.
41:18 Jim: The second book was rubbish. He could have written that, but the first one was just too good. A biography too good. So so here's the second one you believe is real, and the second one is fake News.
41:32 [Unclear]: Oh, wow, as
41:35 Jim: far as we know, that's very good. He does not believe in chemtrails.
41:39 Mark: Wow, that's excellent. Well, look at that. Even with the convincing misgrasp of history, that's superb, very good. Oh, I can't wait for him to say that,
41:52 Jim: yeah, yeah, oh, what? There was a, a, um, a fake tweet that was sent round, supposedly from Trump, that said that when he got elected, when he got into office, the first thing he would do would be to, um, stop chemtrails, would be to stop the kind of – uh, manipulation of the weather and and suppression of the populace. Um, yeah, but that was nonsense, it wasn't real. So, okay, that means that number three properly good convincing conspiracy theory. You know, number three, israel is a believer that vaccines, vaccines cause autism, and he did say this.
42:35 Clip: Trump, played during Fake News
— They go in, they get this monster shot. You ever see the size of it? It's like they're pumping in. You know it's, it's terrible the amount, and they pump this into this little body.
42:44 Jim: So, wow, yeah, Trump thinks that they have this because of the number of things that they vaccinate against. He thinks it's a huge needle. He thinks it's like a massive amount of liquid that that gets pumped into a baby, because, you know he's never seen a child vaccinated. You know he's never had anything to do with any of his children ever visiting a doctor. So, so he doesn't know anything about this at all,
43:13 Mark: no, which is why he's an expert, yeah, on it. That's why he can talk with great authority, yes, about it, because he's completely, he's, unencumbered by any facts getting in the way.
43:28 Jim: So I'm afraid that means that you are my running my winning streak of two, you're at 20
43:37 [Unclear]: of successful um.
43:39 Mark: That does. That does sound better. Yeah, we should go with that. Yeah, is there some sort of exponential um calculation? We can make it sound even bigger. Uh, no, yeah, okay, no, it's out of a thousand. They're gonna say I've got 200.
43:57 Jim: So, podcast listeners, I need your help to full Mark. If you think you can make up a convincing fake Trump quote, then share this episode on Twitter. Include your quote and the hashtag fallacious Trump. I'll pick the best one and you'll be podcast famous. So it's time for the part of the show that, this week at least, is called DNA is not a logical fallacy, because this week we are going to talk about Elizabeth Warren's DNA test. Trump has been calling Elizabeth Warren Pocahontas for quite a while now. She claims that that she has been told by her family that her great, great great grandmother was Cherokee and based on that she was listed in a couple of law directories as a minority. All of the people who have ever interviewed her or given her a job have said that that it never came up at all. It was never a factor in hiring her. She's a brilliant law professor and they, they, she instantly impressed them whenever they, they met her and that's why she got jobs. She never, ever, got a job because she was listed as a, a native American or as a minority of any kind. She doesn't claim, despite having been told as a that, that she has a, a distant relative who was cherokee. She doesn't claim tribal identity. She recognizes that. That's much more complicated than that. It's much more more cultural than biological. Tribes don't even have unique dna, so the dna couldn't show a particular tribe. It couldn't show what, what tribal nations she would belong to if, if, it could. But a lot of the reporting on this has been not real, not true. It's been fake News. But. But part of what they have kept up with is Trump's reaction to it.
45:51 Clip: Trump on Elizabeth Warren
— Yeah, because, um, originally,
45:54 Jim: uh, long before this, this happened to, uh, he, he said this about Elizabeth Warren:
46:01 Clip: Trump on Elizabeth Warren
— I've got more indian blood in me than Pocahontas and I have none now.
46:08 Jim: It's good to see that in front of his base, he can just call native Americans indians. Nobody cares, that's fine, doesn't need to be politically correct. In fact, that would probably be a weakness of some kind. So that's fine, yeah, he. He also, however, said this:
46:22 Clip: Trump on Elizabeth Warren
— I will, We'll give you a million dollars to your favourite charity, paid for by Trump, if you take the test and it shows you're an Indian.
46:30 Jim: So, that's interesting. Because she did take the test. And it did show, and it was tested by someone who didn't know it was her who was being tested. It was blind tested. And they did find that she had some Native American DNA in her makeup up in her ancestry. Now, initially it was reported that this was somewhere because the. They said that it was probably between six to ten generations ago and that actually, if the, if it's six, that matches up with her family history, the fact that she was. She had a great, great great grandmother who was Cherokee. That's that six generations ago. So, yeah, that that matches up. They said, however, over that, because it could be as much as 10 generations ago. They did the maths and figured out how many ancestors we all have, 10 generations back right said: okay, so she's possibly as little as one over 1024 right of American. So so one in 1000 approximately. Yeah, and and Trump seized on this immediately, having previously said he's got more native American blood than she does. He said, well, that doesn't count, that's nothing. He first of all he couldn't. He didn't say it, he didn't say that he was going to pay her a million dollars.
47:55 Clip: Trump on Elizabeth Warren
— He said this: you better read it again.
48:01 Jim: And then he was asked about it.
48:04 Mark: We just heard it.
48:05 Jim: Yeah, he was asked about it later and he said this: what's the percentage?
48:09 Clip: Trump on Elizabeth Warren
— One, one thousand.
— I don't have the, the exact number. Tell me when you have the percentage, tell me what. What about the money that you told her you would?
— I mean, if she gets the nomination in a debate where I was going to have her tested, I'll only do it if I can test her personally.
48:23 Jim: So he's still saying he'll go for the because he
48:25 Mark: is a genetic society. Absolutely, it's a geneticist. Yeah, so he's
48:30 Jim: kind of moving the goal on her.
48:32 [Unclear]: Yep, um, but.
48:35 Jim: But here's the thing: a lot of newspapers, a lot of the reports have been about how she is between uh, one in 1024, uh, up to one in 64 or something like that, right, um, but but most have said she's probably, you know, towards the lower end of that. But actually that's a misreading of what the results are and what they actually have said. First of all, we don't get the same amount of genetic material from each of our ancestors. If we go back 10 generations, each of those 1024 people didn't give us the same amount of of stuff. Basically, the mother will have um half the genetic material. Half of her genetic material will be from her mother and her and half will be from her father, but the right stuff that she passes down to her child it could be. All of that is from the grandmother. Okay, it's unloaded – actually, statistically it's not half, but it doesn't pass down half of the grandfather, half half of the grandmother's dna. Um, it will vary dramatically into between individuals, and so what actually ends up happening is you get some ancestors who didn't give you very much genetic material at all and some who gave you quite a lot.
49:54 Mark: So it would increase the odds actually, wouldn't it? On that, if you're not getting the same from everybody over 10 generations, then you're. And when you're getting genetic material from fewer people.
50:08 Jim: Yes, basically the genetic material that you end up with actually comes from a lot less ancestors than you have biologically.
50:17 Jim: And what they said was that the person who did this DNA test said that Warren's DNA is consistent with a single, unmixed Native American ancestor, um, in the range of 10 of six generations ago, or if it's from ancestors as far back as 10 generations ago, potentially from dozens of individuals. Right, yeah, so not one individual 10 generations ago? Yeah, yeah, but but multiple individuals 10 generations ago, or one one, six, Six generations ago.
50:58 Jim: So that's quite different. That's quite significantly more than in the thousands.
51:04 Mark: Yeah, it's a bit of a willful misreading of the stats in order to not have to pay the million dollars, do you think? Well, I don't think so.
51:14 Jim: I mean, I don't by any means think that Trump understands this and is deliberately misreading it. The newspapers that have done it don't understand it. The Washington Post, they fact-checked their own story and the Boston Globe story and various others and said, actually, we got it wrong. We looked at it again and we've talked to the people who do this for a living. You know actual experts, and they've explained it to us and this is what it actually is. And a lot of what I've said today is from the Washington Post fact -check, and they've given themselves three Pinocchios on their four -Pinocchio scale for initially getting it wrong. I don't think that Trump is deliberately misunderstanding this. Or I think he genuinely misunderstands it. Um, and it's convenient, if you are offered a range between 164th and 1 1000th, to go towards the 1 1000th range, but that's not what the evidence suggests. In fact, she she does have the roughly the amount of native American heritage that she has claimed that she has. And
52:23 Mark: finally, some things we really don't have time to talk about.
52:26 Jim: After a week of helping to cover up a journalist’s murder in order to preserve an arms deal, Donald Trump praised the combat technique of journalist-body-slamming-Republican Congressman Greg Gianforte. Trump isn’t actively calling for violence against reporters, but he’s also not not doing that. All I’m saying is you can see why the Saudis would assume he’d be cool with them torturing and murdering a Washington Post reporter.
52:49 Mark: And Trump keeps changing his story about how many jobs he’s protecting by refusing to condemn the Saudi government.
52:56 Clip: Trump
— We're talking about over over 40,000 jobs. It's 450,000 jobs. It's 500,000 jobs. 600,000 jobs, maybe more than that. Talking about over a million jobs.
53:10 Mark: Whatever the real number is, he’s also ignoring the fact that Saudi officials insist 50% of the spending – and 50% of the jobs, will be in Saudi Arabia. So it’ll only cost an arm and a leg instead of er… two arms and… two legs – hmm too soon?
53:29 Jim: Seemingly out of desperation, Trump is also completely inventing ‘unknown middle easterners’ in the Central American migrant caravan currently heading for the US, fabricating imaginary riots in California over sanctuary cities, and totally making up a new tax cut for the middle class which he says is happening in the next couple of weeks, despite Congress not being in session. Honestly, we’re about a week away from him promising everyone a pony if they vote Republican in the midterms.
53:57 Mark: And speaking of ponies, Trump called Stormy Daniels ‘horseface’ on Twitter this week and seemed super proud of coming up with such a brilliant insult. In fact, according to the Daily Beast he ‘workshopped’ the nickname with friends and staffers before deciding to ignore the senior aides who told him to let it go, and tweet it out anyway. Because what kind of pussy doesn’t rage-tweet a playground insult at the porn-star they paid off? Losers.
54:24 Jim: Melania Trump claimed in an interview with ABC to be one of the most bullied people in the world. *COUGH*Christine Blasey Ford*COUGH* But to be fair, she knew what a bully Donald was when she married him.. Also last week, Melania said she wished people would pay more attention to what she does instead of what she wears. The fact that she said this while cos-playing as Belloq from Raiders of the Lost Ark did NOT help.
54:53 Mark: And, in other News, an artificial sun -worshipping idiot stared directly at the real solar eclipse using just his eyes, declaring I have a natural instinct for science. And because he's the the president. He therefore literally trumps 97 of all professional, skilled, experienced, well -read research and objectively peer -reviewed actual scientists and their view that the climate change is man -made. Like he said to Leslie Stahl on 60 Minutes as justification of everything, I'm the president and you're not. Is it seemly for a grown man to still be saying?
55:34 Jim: A Southwest Airlines passenger has been arrested for repeatedly groping another passenger's breast during the flight. In his defence, the president has said that grabbing women by the private parts is okay. That's not a joke. The man literally said that in his defence. We're living in the darkest timeline.
55:51 Mark: Speaking of which, this headline from Rolling Stone. A deceased brothel owner is still likely to win a Nevada midterm. Dennis Hoff's candidacy does not automatically end despite the fact that he is no longer living. Nye County Commission Chairman John Koenig agrees. I think the Republicans in this town will still vote for him because they want a Republican in the chair. But I wouldn't bet money either way. We do not need to say anything else.
56:21 Jim: So that's all the bad arguments and faulty reasoning we have time for this episode. If you think we've used a fallacy ourselves, let us know.
56:36 Mark: And if you've had a good time, please give us a review on iTunes, Stitcher or wherever you get your podcasts. You can support the show on our Patreon page at patreon.com slash ftrump, just like our newest patron, Gary Jungling. I'm saying Jungling because it's German, but it could be Gary Jungling. It could be. Thanks, Gary. That's brilliant. Thank you very much.
56:58 Jim: That's superb. We also have a brand new Facebook group at Facebook .com slash groups, slash fallacious Trump, where we'll Post some links to some of the stuff we've talked about and some of the pictures we've laughed about in this episode. There's also to try and encourage you guys to all join the Facebook group so that we can interact with you and say, hi, there is a competition that we're running. Now this competition is to win a few things, including digital copy of, uh, the book that this podcast is based on, on either kindle or epub. A copy of the um album by mark's band yep,
57:35 Mark: the outbursts who provide the theme tune.
57:37 Jim: A couple of copies of other books that I've written, an audio book of a detective novel that I wrote, a shout out from Mark and me on the show. A discount account code for t -shirts or other merch from our t -public store – you didn't know we had a t -public store, did you? We did. And also, most importantly, the right to choose which logical fallacy we talk about next now the. The competition ends on the 10th of November and you can only enter it by joining our Facebook group. That's the only place you can go and enter it. It's very easy. You don't have to kind of answer any questions or give us your email address or anything like that, just kind of come up with a conspiracy theory. You don't have to do that. You just have have to go join the Facebook group and then we can all chat about stuff and we can tell you what, what kinds of things, we're going to be talking about next week and give you links to the things we talked about this week and it will be fun. So do that.
58:30 Mark: All the music is by the outbursts and was used with permission, so until next time on fellatio Trump,
58:35 [Outro] we'll leave the last word to the. That's right. Go home to mommy, bye, bye.
