16 Nov Ad Fidentia – FT#204
Show Notes
The Ad Fidentia fallacy occurs when someone attacks their opponent’s self-confidence instead of their argument, and take any doubt expressed as evidence in their favor.
Trump
We started out by discussing this clip of Trump mocking a reporter for believing government statistics about immigrant crime:
Then we talked about this clip of Trump mocking another reporter for believing other government’s statistics about Covid deaths:
Mark’s British Politics Corner
Mark talked about these clips from Question Time of Jeremy Corbyn being berated for his unwillingness to launch nuclear weapons:
Fallacy in the Wild (Sting: Bob Dylan – One More Cup of Coffee)
In the Fallacy in the Wild, we looked at this clip from Tangled:
Then we discussed this clip from Friends:
And finally, we talked about this clip from Grey’s Anatomy:
Fake News
Here are the statements from this week’s Fake News game:

Mark got it wrong this week and is still on 48%!
The midterms were not a logical fallacy
We talked about the midterms with our very special guest Cecil from Cognitive Dissonance, The Know Rogan Experience, and Citation Needed.

The stories we really didn’t have time to talk about
- We’ve talked about the midterms already, but there are some results so delicious they’re worth dwelling on for a bit. Congresswoman Lauren Boebert, who got thrown out of a Denver theatre during Beetlejuice for giving her date a helping hand, is in a toss-up race in Colorado’s 4th District. CNN has called it for her opponent Eileen Laubacher, but as of this recording the AP still hasn’t called the race, and Boebert is refusing to let it go. She’ll hold on for as long as she can, but eventually it will slip through her fingers and there’ll be a happy ending. Meanwhile, in Maine, Susan Collins has finally lost her Senate seat to Democrat Troy Jackson. Rumor has it she tried to concede by text message, but her phone kept auto-correcting it to “concerned”. In South Carolina, Lindsey Graham’s sister, Darline Graham, who’d been holding his Senate seat since the glorious day he died, lost to pediatrician Annie Andrews, who is now officially the first woman South Carolina has ever elected to the Senate. It was a midterms defined by firsts, in fact, almost as much as by the bluenami. Ohio got its first woman governor when Amy Acton beat Vivek Ramaswamy, Chris Pappas in New Hampshire is the first openly gay man elected to the Senate, and Abdul El-Sayed in Michigan is the first Muslim. He’s very pleased that JD Vance will be forced to swear him in. Georgia has had 83 governors, every one of them a white man, and they just elected Keisha Lance Bottoms, the first Black woman elected governor in the history of the United States. Deb Haaland in New Mexico is the first Native American woman elected governor, and Peggy Flanagan in Minnesota is the first Native American woman elected to the Senate. Scott Colom in Mississippi has now beaten Cindy Hyde-Smith to become the state’s first Black senator since Reconstruction, and Juliana Stratton gives Illinois the first state with two women senators of color. The governors’ mansions are breaking records too. The USA had only ever elected three Black governors in 250 years. Five will now serve at the same time, and even if one of them is Byron Donalds, that’s pretty cool. Trans candidates have won local elections in Michigan, Wisconsin and Washington, as well as Georgia, Alabama, and Florida! Melat Kiros, a 29-year-old Colorado lawyer, will be the first Gen Z woman in a House of Representatives with a record breaking number of Congresswomen. 136 at last count, but there are still 11 races left to call. 136 women out of 435 is still way too low, by the way, but it’s worth pointing out that 117 of those are Democrats, which is 46% of all the blue seats, so at least we’re moving in the right direction.
- Michigan’s Democratic Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed, as well as addressing the camera full on on CNN and telling Hegseth you’re no good at your job just quit, also admonished the Democrats who wasted their first opportunity after such a resounding victory in the mid-terms and failed to turn up for the vote to impeach the said Hogsbreath. A motion to impeach Hegseth for “high crimes and misdemeanors” over waging the war in Iran and bombing alleged drug boats in the Caribbean without congressional approval failed Tuesday night. The House voted 211–204 to refer eight articles of impeachment filed against Hegseth to the GOP-led Judiciary Committee, where it will languish until Democrats take control of Congress in January 2027. There were 11 Democrats among 18 lawmakers who did not vote, if the 11 absent Democrats had voted to send the articles of impeachment to the House floor, they would have had the numbers. Some who missed the vote were on their way back from an Elect Democratic Women event about 1.5 miles away when they got stuck in a major traffic jam. Elected Democrat Woman Marilyn Strickland of Washington was called out for missing the vote after she previously posted that “an impeachment vote cannot come soon enough.” Strickland’s followers replied to her X post, “Why didn’t you show up to impeach him then?” Jonathan L. Jackson of Illinois said the vote closed before he and other members could get there. One replied to the congressman “Traffic isn’t a valid excuse for working Americans to clock into work late Why should it be valid for you?” “This sounds like your “dog ate” your homework fam. Either do your job or pass the controller,” another said. Exactly! Look I know that the US is like the home of the automobile and no-one goes anywhere if you can’t ride in a congressional limo but come on guys – why sit in a traffic jam when you coulda got out and walked!! Or are you so unused to going anywhere without being driven that you’d get lost going to the end of the block without a chauffeur. But traffic wasn’t the only problem, missing Democrats included Haley Stevens of Michigan, who was reported to be “hiding” in a Republican cloakroom Monday during another House vote after endorsing GOP candidate Mike Rogers in the midterm elections over Michigan Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed. When asked by reporters about the lack of attendance, House Minority Leader and wannabe House Speaker Democrat Hakeem Jeffries said, “I haven’t had a conversation with anyone on the floor team about what may or may not have happened in terms of the Hegseth resolution, but this is not the end of it. It’s just the beginning,” Except it is the end cos the Republican-controlled Judiciary Committee is of course not expected to take any further action, effectively ending the impeachment attempt. After laying into Hegseth newly-elected Adbul El-Sayed was asked by CNN’s Kaitlan Collins what he would say to the absent Democrats. “You should show up and do your job.” Ooh we do like Abdul!
- Last week Trump announced on Truth Social that he’d found a new press secretary. “I am pleased to announce that the Great Dana White, a violent Fighter and Warrior, has been offered the job of Press Secretary of the United States.” Because of course “violent” is the first adjective that springs to mind when hiring White House staff. He added that “we need these people to defend us against the Lunatic Left,” and said White should bring along a team of UFC stars as assistants and shared a cartoon video of White at the briefing room podium, flanked by UFC fighters beating up reporters. Within minutes of the announcement, the internet came up with a theory. You see, there’s another Dana White, a Black woman, who was the Pentagon’s chief spokesperson in Trump’s first term, so might actually be qualified for the job. Online sleuths claimed she was on a shortlist, that someone said we should get “Dana White,” and Trump assumed they meant the large white man who runs a company where people hit each other, rather than the Black woman who spent two years briefing the Pentagon press corps. Whether it’s true or not, it’s an amazing story, made infinitely amazingier by the fact this all happened on my favorite holiday, Four Seasons Total Landscaping Day. Yes, six years to the day after Rudy Giuliani did objectively the funniest thing that’s ever happened, and held a press conference in the parking lot of a Philadelphia gardening business wedged between a crematorium and an adult bookstore because the Trump campaign mixed it up with the Four Seasons hotel. I’m starting to understand why Trump is so convinced Alaska voters won’t be capable of voting for the right Dan Sullivan. On Sunday, Trump claimed it had all been a joke, and on Monday the UFC Dana White joined Trump at a press briefing at the White House, and officially turned the joke offer down. Dana W. White, incidentally, has also announced that she’s not interested, just in case. So, was Trump just kidding, or is he just that stupid, or both. Hard to say, but I’ve learned my lesson about giving this administration the benefit of the doubt. Speaking of Katie Zacharia, according to the New York Post, she’s not quite ready to give up on the job she was fired from after a single press briefing. Three unnamed sources close to Trump told the paper that several high-profile advisers believe she’s angling for a second chance at the podium, and that she’s been working to charm Trump and his new chief of staff, Stephen Miller, into giving it to her. Her method, according to one source, was helping anchor election-night coverage on Right Side Broadcasting Network, hoping Trump would see her and decide she’s right for the job after all. To be fair, watching right-wing media is how Trump gets a lot of his staffing ideas. Another source says she turned up at Mar-a-Lago over the weekend, in the middle of the staffing shake-up, and was seen “staring at” Trump, trying to get his attention, like a dog that sits at your feet while you’re eating and does the sad eyes thing. Zacharia herself says the story is “utterly fake.” We may never know the truth. We know she has had trouble in the past with passing bars, but if she does want it, the bar for this job has never been lower.
- You know when Trump got in again this time and launched all those literally Trumped-up investigations into all the people – and their daughters – that he felt had been out to get him, and that was all fine and legitimate in Trumpland i.e. illegal and completely made up in the actual land of the law and stuff? Well, White House counsel Will Scharf said in a letter to Robert Garcia, who is poised to become Democrat chairman of the powerful Oversight Committee starting in January, that The Trump administration is “monitoring” Democrats’ “abusive and capricious threats” to launch congressional probes. Of course when Joe Biden occupied the White House, and Republicans took control of Congress, Democrats cried foul that Trump’s allies were only interested in launching partisan probes that damaged their political enemies. But those high-profile investigations continued unimpeded including James Comer launching probes into the business dealings of Biden’s son Hunter and brother James. The White House pointed to Supreme Court rulings that have held that congressional investigations must be tied to a legitimate legislative purpose and must not be used to punish political opponents. At which point I stand open mouthed and head scratched wondering whether Trump’s administration has ever heard of ‘methinks she doth protest too much’ or the psychological phenomenon of doing all the things you accuse others of doing! Like Trump’s Republicans doing it to James Comey, Letitia James, Adam Schiff, Mark Kelly etc etc etc. Scharf’s letter accuses Democrats of seeking “to abuse the legislative process to intimidate and to interfere with the lawful functioning of government,” adding that “threats to executive branch officials designed to deter them from public service, or process designed merely to abuse or instill fear in the recipient may cross the line into blatant criminality.” See what I mean? complete lack of self-awareness! In responding to Sharf’s letter Garcia said “The American people voted overwhelmingly for us to pass laws to root out corruption and abuse. The Trump Administration continues to weaponize the government with threats of unconstitutional attacks on Congress. We are a co-equal branch of government and will not be deterred by baseless threats from a weaponized DOJ or from the President’s lawyers.” Yay! say we, Yay!
- Pretty much immediately after the happy happy joy joy midterms, Republicans started turning on each other and, especially, on Trump. Ron DeSantis called the result “a rebuke of the president and the Congress.” JD Vance bravely came out against the war he’d spent the past eight months supporting, Right wing group The Taxpayer Protection Alliance called the tariffs “a self-inflicted political wound,” and Susan B. Anthony Pro-Life America said Republican consultants “got the campaign they wanted, and the defeat they earned”. Ted Cruz, who’s backed nearly everything Trump has done since Trump called Ted’s wife ugly, called it “a Watergate-level repudiation” and blamed the tariffs and an Iran war that “dragged on too long.” On November 5th, the White House Office of Public Liaison, the department that deals with outside groups, sent a memo to more than 3,000 conservative organizations. Most of it was a list of Trump’s made up accomplishments and a pledge to stop incoming Democrats from undoing them, but the last sentence was highlighted in yellow: “As always, we are monitoring statements, press releases, and media engagements from your organizations.” The White House’s answer to someone saying “Watergate” is to start spying on its critics. Who says the right doesn’t do irony? A White House spokeswoman rather unconvincingly told the Wall Street Journal that the memo wasn’t a threat, and that the office has sent messages with similar language before. They told the Daily Caller that these are “routine emails” sent every week. The Journal looked at the earlier emails, which just asked groups to share their pro-Trump messaging. One, from October, asked them to “flag any statements of support.” None said anything about monitoring. “Please send us the nice things you’ve said about us” and “we’re watching you” aren’t what I call similar language. The memo doesn’t say what happens to a group that says the wrong thing about Trump, whether it’s lost access, lost invitations or something worse. If it did, it would be a policy. Leaving it blank is what makes it a threat.
- Despite the historic beating Republicans took during the midterms our glorious President Donald J has kept his focus on what truly matters…. to him: overlaying the nation’s capital with his lovely ornate aesthetic. To that end, Trump signed a proclamation Friday naming the Oval Office a national monument. With it, he seeks to forbid future presidents from following him as project-manager-in-chief. Trump’s executive order proclamation acknowledges that the White House and its grounds are already recognized as a National Historic Landmark but gives the Oval Office — and Cabinet Room — a special carveout. The National Park Service will now require “documentation, review, and consideration of alternatives before any action that would substantially alter or demolish the monument or its essential architectural elements.” i.e. those gaudy tacky stick-on plastic Amazon-bought gold bits that led Obama to describe it as “like Saddam Hussein opened a Cheesecake Factory.” The proclamation doesn’t mention Congress but relies on the Antiquities Act of 1906, which allows a president to create a national monument on federal land by proclamation without congressional input. But Trump’s DOJ, when the Trump administration was looking to undo monuments created by President Joe Biden, argued tersely that the Antiquities Act that gives presidents the “power to declare, carries with it the power to revoke.” Thus graciously, the proclamation acknowledges that future presidents can restyle the Oval Office with no consequences: “Nothing in this proclamation shall be construed to restrict the President’s authority to redecorate the monument, select furnishings, or make ordinary operational and security modifications that do not substantially impair the monument’s historic structure or architectural character.” In other words, if whomever is sworn in January 2029 wants to get rid of the tacky wall sconces and swap out the gold curtains, then they can. The White House staff are basically placating a toddler on the verge of a tantrum. The document has no real impact on anything, but if it makes Trump feel better to sign a piece of paper, make a proclamation, look like he’s important, then hand one to him. Consider that a staffer took the time to write this proclamation, newly installed White House chief of staff Stephen Miller likely reviewed it, a communications aide drafted a fact sheet and a staff secretary scheduled a signing. An incredible use of resources on exactly the kind of nonsense that has left the GOP rudderless but provided Trump a degree of escapism when he’s supposed to be working for the people.
- Jensen Huang, the centi-billionaire leather-jacketed co-founder of Nvidia, the company whose chips power the entire AI boom, admitted in an email to staff that he’d been unfaithful to his wife, which is a weird route to take if you ask me. The woman he was involved with is Alice Huang, no relation, an executive at Megaspeed, a Singapore data center company that also happens to be an Nvidia customer. Jensen’s overenthusiastic customer service is mostly newsworthy because US intelligence suspects Alice was recruited by China’s Ministry of State Security to get close to him and maybe nudge him towards selling chips to China. Nvidia’s board has launched an internal investigation into whether any national security or Nvidia secrets were compromised. Meanwhile, Jensen got the kind of character witness who can only possibly make things worse. On Sunday, Trump called him “a fine person,” adding “you never know what is going on,” which is probably the most accurate thing he’s said all year. I’m shocked, shocked I tell you, that Trump is on the side of the philanderer who donated $25 million to his ballroom. On Monday, Trump told reporters “He said he had absolutely no idea that the person in question was a spy.” That… that’s just how spying works. That’s not a defense. If anything, that’s worse, because if he did know she was a spy, that would probably be because she told him, which is either a bold double bluff or an indication that he wasn’t her target. CNN reported that Marco Rubio briefed Trump about all this aboard Air Force One on the way to China in May, and Trump insisted Jensen come along anyway, and gave him the National Medal of Science in October. Trump says he found out “not too long ago.” On Wednesday, the New York Times reported a second affair, this one with an Nvidia executive who reported to him. The board met that night, and by Thursday Jensen was out “effective immediately.” The board put up with the spy issue for four days, but a relationship with a direct report took one. National security and possible corporate espionage are one thing, but they take HR violations very seriously at Nvidia. Jensen’s wife of more than 40 years, Lori, hasn’t said anything publicly. If she does divorce him, and there’s been no announcement, here’s a suggestion. Jeff Bezos’s ex-wife, MacKenzie Scott, and Bill Gates’s ex-wife, Melinda French Gates, both took their share and became two of the most generous philanthropists in the world. Jensen is worth about $150 billion, California is a community property state, and they almost certainly don’t have a prenup. Take that $75 billion, Lori, and give it away at MacKenzie speed. Maybe Jensen has finally done something that will benefit people who need it.
- During another fortnight in British Politics in which Westminster has mistaken the management of political survival for the management of a country; Andy Burnham has floated the prospect of Britain rejoining the EU during his lifetime, prompting Labour figures, including Chris Ward, to suggest the party’s Brexit red lines should eventually be retired. Michel Barnier former French Prime Minister and Brexit negotiator has said it could happen in 4 years but don’t bank on the £5bn rebate that Thatcher negotiated in the 80’s to be available again. Remain voters (are we still called that?) are thus hoping in a macabre fashion that Burnham has thus received a diagnosis of a terminal illness and has thus barely weeks to live, otherwise the opportunity to use the mahoosive majority he has in the Commons to force through an EU rejoin is about to be wasted nest-ce pas?. Farage, naturally, regards this as an assault on democracy – especially since closer alignment on food standards in a bid to cut costs for British companies trading with Europe may mean that Smoky Bacon flavoured crisps could be affected by an EU decision in 2024 to phase out a number of artificial smoke flavourings. YouGov puts Labour on 27%, Conservatives on 21%, Reform on 20%, Lib Dems on 12% and Greens on 10%. Everybody is close enough to feel optimistic and nervous enough to be unbearable. Whilst they are all arguing about the electoral prospects offered in 2028 by Europe, tax, pensions, energy and national identity, the voting public who aren’t the ones being told that the problems are all down to immigrants, would probably settle for a government that can make the trains run, the bills fall and the social care system work – without blaming immigrants for those problems.
You can now buy Jim’s book, 2000 Mules and One Big Lie: A Stubborn Conspiracy Theory, and you can buy all our t-shirts, mugs, hats and more at our TeePublic Store, including this week’s fallacy:
