Show Notes
The If By Whiskey Fallacy is committed when someone either takes such a non-committal stance on an issue that they could be supporting either side, or redefines the terms of the question to answer in the way they want to answer.
Trump
We started out by discussing the Trump admin redefining sex/gender, and banning words
Then we talked about this tweet from Don Jr:
If by “us” you mean career politicians who’ve spent a half-century in government, then yeah, he didn’t worry too much about you and your kind. https://t.co/8Ca5MlBbED
— Donald Trump Jr. (@DonaldJTrumpJr) September 22, 2020
Mark’s British Politics Corner
Mark talked about Boris Johnson explaining that he’s not a nationalist if you mean bad things when you say that:
Followed by Johnson, in the Q&A following the speech, claiming he didn’t say certain things about Turkey and the EU:
Fallacy in the Wild (Sting: You Know What I Mean – Oasis)
In the Fallacy in the Wild we looked at this clip from The Simpsons:
Then we discussed this clip from Pulp Fiction:
And we finished with this clip from Frasier:
Fake News
Here are the statements from this week’s Fake News game:
-
- The first time I heard about Diamond and Silk was from our great First Lady. Very popular First Lady, I have to say. She was on the cover of so many magazines until she met me. Then they said “Keep her off covers”. She was a great, great, beautiful woman, she was on so many magazines and then she meets Trump and they say “Let’s keep her off”, even though their sales – what they don’t figure out, Mike, is that their sales would have doubled, tripled, quadrupled.
- Now Arnold Schwarzenegger’s a big movie star, right? And he… I mean I said that sounds like a great idea, he should be able to do well, I wanted to see it do well. Although I’m not that sure about that. You know, I had a choice. You understand this Mike? If he did really well, really well, they’d say “What the hell do we need Trump for?” If he did really poorly, maybe I won’t make any money if that happens, but if he did really poorly I can say “see, I’m the only one that can do it”. Well he did really poorly, he got no ratings.
- She was a beacon of light and a great source of wisdom and common sense. That’s what we need more of, isn’t it? Common sense. What do you think Mike? If there was a bit more common sense maybe we wouldn’t have left $85 billion of the most beautiful military equipment in Afghanistan for the Taliban to use, including three brand new Black Hawk helicopters, and hundreds of thousands of guns and binoculars and other military things. But your sister, Diamond, was taken from us too soon.
Spoiler
Statement 3 is Fake News. Mark chose number 1Mark got it wrong again this week, and is on 48%
The Fair Tax Act is not a logical fallacy
We talked about the mad tax policy the maddest GOP members of Congress support, which McCarthy will probably have to bring up for a vote because he sold his soul to win the leadership.
The stories we really didn’t have time to talk about
- In what must be one of the most frequently reused headlines since we started this show, it’s been a bad couple of weeks in court for Trump. To be honest I can’t remember the last time Trump had a good week in court, but even he doesn’t usually end up owing almost a million dollars for having such bad lawyers. Judge Donald Middlebrooks, who last September threw out Trump’s lawsuit against Hillary Clinton accusing her of rigging the 2016 election – yes, the one Trump won – ordered Trump and his attorney Alina Habba to pay $938,000 in a scathing ruling that included lines like “This case should never have been brought. Its inadequacy as a legal claim was evident from the start. No reasonable lawyer would have filed it”. Meanwhile, in a separate case, New York Attorney General Letitia James has asked another judge to impose sanctions on Trump’s legal team after showing that Trump, several of his children and his lawyers lied multiple times in depositions and in written responses to questions posed in the fraud case currently underway. Which is particularly impressive, since Trump pleaded the fifth more than 400 times during his depositions in the case. The judge questioned the Trump team’s initial response, saying “In my 35 years practicing law, I have never, never… seen a pleading with such excess verbiage as the 300-page-or-so answers of the 15-or-so answers to the complaint” and has actually asked Trump’s lawyers to have another go. Perhaps this time they won’t take the unusual step of claiming there’s no such thing as the Trump Organisation like they did the first time despite Alina Habba announcing herself in court, during this case, as representing Donald Trump and the Trump Organisation.
- Okay so in the saga of Car-a-lago Lynne Patton’s term – she’s a right-wing what? commentator? Journalist? Nah the equivalent, along with Lara Trump and Erin Elmore on RightView’s ex-president’s daughter-in-law’s podcast, of the UK’s Loose Women; washed up z-listers employed to up the gender balance when it comes to whinging ignorantly about Huffpost hot topics. Through a pointless expenditure of energy and creativity (just think with brains like that they could be addressing world poverty and peace) These three maintain that no-one would store classified documents in a private garage next to their corvette – a dozen or so you remember, rather than the proper way to do it – 10s of thousands in a publicly accessible golf club. No one would do this so its obviously cos the Dems planted them there – Obama did it – in order to get rid of Biden now he’s served his purpose of winning the election maintaining the Senate and holding the House to a tiny majority. We’re reminded of foresight attributed to Trump in the good ol days of Q posts – who incidentally has gone silent since June last year after a two year hiatus prior to that – and the QAnoners who’d be able to see that Trump foresaw the election results fifteen years before Hilary was born etc etc. Look if the Dems had actually revealed that they’d win in 2020, hold the senate and reduce the GOP to a hamstrung whiny infighting majority in the house that took 15 goes to elect a leader, and with a septuagenarian older than Trump yet, they’d have been laughed at in the face. So yeah okay it was all planned and hidden and everything, but hey if it works is it such a bad idea?
- Another guy who’s had a bad week recently, legally speaking, is Richard “Bigo” Barnett, who was convicted on eight counts, including four felonies, for his part in the insurrection and now faces up to 20 years in prison. You’ll remember Bigo as the guy who was photographed with his feet up on Nancy Pelosi’s desk. His lawyers tried various tactics throughout the trial including suggesting he couldn’t get a fair trial in DC because a jury made up of mostly Democrats wouldn’t be a jury of his peers, then claiming he was just caught up in the surge into the Capitol and was looking for a bathroom when he stumbled, all innocent-like into Nancy’s office. The fact that, while there, he left a note on her desk saying “Nancy, Bigo was here bi-otch” and then tried to copyright the phrase after he was arrested didn’t really help their case, nor did Bigo’s understanding of the Bill of Rights when he claimed he was just a patriot. The prosecutor asked him “You love the Constitution?” “Love it!” Bigo said. “First Amendment?” the prosecutor asked. “Yes,” he said. “Second Amendment?” “Yes” “Love the Third Amendment?” “Yes,” and then the prosecutor asked “What’s the Third Amendment?” and Bigo paused and said, “I don’t know.”
- What you’d get if you typed “A photo of an angry overweight embittered wannabe politician made of pillows, with a large outdated moustache” into an AI image generator: Mike Lindell,
apparently didn’t foresee that one day he wouldn’t be the leader of the RNC. “The pillow guy? That’s kind of a joke.” said by one of the voting RNC members must have been music to Lindell’s second-pluck duck-stuffed ears, after all it didn’t seem to phase the GOP when Trump ran for nomination by the party, so “Well, why wouldn’t I win? I am more qualified”. You gotta admire Lindell’s determination, his sheer manifestation would surely be enough but dammit if reality didn’t intervene at the party’s winter meeting in Dana Point, California where he garnered only 4 of the 168 votes; Ronna McDaniel won the election with 111 votes. Still he outdid Kevin Phillips Bong (Silly Party) who as you’ll recall polled no votes at all, not a sausage, bugger all. Despite his crushing defeat Lindell remains plumped up and fluffy, “Do you even know how this works?” he responded to the criticism that he’d whipped very few votes. “Wake up!” Which is rich coming from a dreamer who sells sleep materials! Still could be worse we could have got Ronna McDaniel… oh no wait… - In an impressive unbroken run of freaking out about made up stuff, Fox ‘News’ is outraged at XBox for their latest update, which according to one host, shows that “They’re trying to recruit your kids into climate politics at an earlier age – make them climate conscious now”, to which his co-idiot then replied “You’re right – they’re going after the children!” So, what news led to this I’m sure entirely justified panic about children knowing about stuff? Surely an insidious new game that indoctrinates young minds under cover of entertainment and forces them to offset carbon emissions to unlock achievements and win premium downloadable content? Not quite. You see, the XBox power settings include a power saving shutdown mode that draws less power than the standard standby mode. The new update will make that more energy efficient version the default, thereby saving their users a little bit on their electric bills and saving a substantial amount of energy when you add all the XBoxes together. Evil bastards.
- “Can you not vet the ads on Truth?” asked one user in a post on Trump’s own Truth Social social media platform directly to Trump. “I’ve been scammed more than once.” Well two things – what did you expect, and what do you think they’d do? oh three – why did you do it the second time? Apparently advertisers, real advertisers of real verifiable products and reputations aren’t that enamoured of advertising on Truth Social. It’s difficult for them to get all the information they need about how well the adverts are doing cos the monitoring systems are a bit antiquated, that and whilst its important for advertisers to be associated with leading politicians, Bob Hoffman, an advertising industry veteran and the author of The Ad Contrarian, a newsletter critical of the industry says “It’s not in their best interest to get involved in that quagmire.” Truth is burning through about $1.7 million each month and they only raised about 37 million to start with so advertising revenue is sorely needed especially as two federal investigations have also put about $1.3 billion of much-needed funding in jeopardy. Whilst the demographic is somewhat narrow, older, right-wing, dare we say self-confessed conspiracy-theoristy and hyperpartisan soccer-momish? So consequently not much of a draw for the big advertising guns especially since Truth Social’s first avowed intent voiced by Devin Nunes (remember him?) was to “displace the Big Tech platforms”. However if you want to buy the chance to win a solid gold 1,000-dollar bill given away free by Trump and aren’t bothered by the snake-oil salesmen who are running the competition with its not gold, not free, not given by Trump, non-1,000 dollar bill, then the platform could use all the gullible help and cash you can give it.
- I’m thinking of moving to the US and becoming a political consultant, since it seems like the easiest job in the entire world, largely because the politicians themselves are so fundamentally lacking in self awareness that they are prepared to pay huge amounts for obvious answers they just can’t figure out for themselves. Take, for example, the Pennsylvania GOP, who have hired DC based firm Public Opinion Strategies to solve the mystery of why they did so poorly in the 2022 midterms. The quest for a solution to this conundrum is expected to set them back a cool 100 grand, and involve focus groups, voter interviews and other research. It’s worth it, of course, because currently the brightest minds in the Pennsylvania Republican party are completely stumped about why they shat the bed in the midterms and wisdom so esoteric can only be gained through great effort and financial sacrifice. If, at the end of this odyssey, the consultants don’t come back with “You ran Dr Oz and Doug Mastriano and your party just set women’s rights back 50 years” then they might have overpaid, and I would have told them for half the price, is all I’m saying.
- In Britain Rishi Sunak continues to insist he is upholding “integrity, professionalism and accountability at every level” after sacking Nadim Zahawi as Tory Party Chairman for breaking the ministerial code. Not because former chancellor Zahawi had to pay a 3 million pounds-odd fine to the taxman for things he didn’t declare whilst he was Chancellor, nor for the fact that he untruthfully called the Independent newspaper’s investigations into the fact that he had not declared various receipts of monies that would require the payment of millions of pounds worth of tax as a “smear”, but cos he had not declared that he was under investigation by the revenue when he was given the job of chancellor. Of course Zahawi maintains that oh if by “under investigation” you mean they were asking questions and looking into my past business dealings then sure, but I wasn’t “under investigation”. It’s a kind of reverse Al Capone trap – he was tried for tax evasion in lieu of being able to pin any actual moiders on him and Zahawi was found guilty of breaking the ministerial code about be untruthful in lieu of being able to do him down for undeclared earnings from offshore accounts. That of course is at the heart of the Tory’s soul, “no offshore tax loopholes closed under EU law in our country we’ve taken back control” cos why else do you think they fought so hard to get out of Europe! Sunak of course said he acted as soon as he knew, which I suspect contains an oh if by knew you meant had any inkling of in an official breaks-the-promise-of-integrity-and-accountability kind of way then I didn’t “know” cos I didn’t have the job of Prime Minister at the time. Worryingly on the face of it, on the other side of the house Labour’s Starmer gave a speech using such phrases as “Labour is not the party of protest but of public service” on the eve of an act banning strikes for public service workers being presented to parliament and the largest and most widespread strike by public service workers; you know, the very people for whom the Labour party was founded to represent. I fear that Tory-light Starmer is pandering to the worlds of media barons and business to show that Labour is an electable proposition despite the people’s actual propositions for electing Labour, decent pay, supporting the strikers rights, taxing the rich, curbing the obscene profits of energy companies, and voting for Jeremy Corbyn as leader. Let’s face it with these media barons you can be sure the revolution will not be televised – unless there’s money in it.
That’s all for this week, thanks for listening!
If you wanted to buy a T-shirt featuring this fallacy, you could click here. No pressure
And if you have some money left over after that, Jim’s book, 2000 Mules and One Big Lie: A Stubborn Conspiracy Theory is available now.
That’s almost all for this week, but here’s our AI-aided transcript, which is quite accurate, but not totally:
If By Whiskey – FT#117 Transcript
Read the full transcript
00:23 Jim: Hello and welcome to Fallacious Trump, the podcast where we use the insane ramblings of a hoof-wanking bungle-cunt to explain logical fallacies. I'm your host, Jim.
00:31 Mark: And I'm your other host, Mark. A logical fallacy is an error in reasoning that results in bad or invalid arguments. And the logical fallacy we're looking at this week is if by whiskey. And did you get that description of Trump from Susie Dent? No, no, this is one
00:50 Jim: that I didn't get from Susie Dent. No, hoof-wanking bungle-cunt is a British term for a rich idiot, basically. Oh, OK.
01:01 Mark: I've not heard all the words separately.
01:04 Jim: I've not heard them matched together in that. That's extremely common. Yeah, no, actually there was a linguist like Susie Dent who put something on Twitter a few months ago saying something about the kind of most pleasing rhythm for swear words.
01:19 Jim: And hoof-wanking bungle clunk doesn't fit it. Oh, OK. So I replied with: OK, well, how come hoof -wanking, bungle clunk worked so well? Then, yeah, and they and other people went: oh yeah, no, that one is brilliant.
01:33 Mark: Well, it's almost an iambic pentameter is dum -di -dum, -di -dum? Absolutely, yeah, oh yeah, no, fair enough.
01:42 Jim: Yeah, the exception that proves the rule, yes, quite so, if by whiskey. This one comes – comes from one specific speech that was given by a Mississippi lawmaker called Noah Sweat, who went by the nickname Soggy. Soggy Sweat.
02:02 Mark: Not no, not no sweat. Yeah, Soggy Sweat.
02:05 Jim: Who was a Mississippi lawmaker who, in the 50s, while Mississippi was still a dry state, the prohibition had not been repealed there?
02:13 Mark: Because it's a progressive, forward-thinking state.
02:15 Jim: He was asked about what he thought of whiskey. And so he gave this speech, which I'm gonna read in in toto, because it does kind of set the scene for what this whole thing is. Yeah, so he's gonna
02:28 Mark: read it like forrest gump, I'm not.
02:30 Jim: I'm gonna do it in my voice because I can't sustain an accent for that long. My Friends, I had not intended to discuss this controversial subject at this particular time. However, I want you to know that I do not shun controversy. On the contrary, I will take a stand on any issue at any time, regardless of how fraught with controversy it might be. You've asked me how I feel about whiskey. All right, here is how I feel about whiskey. If, when you say whiskey, you mean the devil's brew, the poison scourge, the bloody monster that defiles innocence, dethrones reason, destroys the home, creates misery and poverty – yay, literally takes the bread from the mouths of little children. If you mean the evil drink that topples the christian man and woman from the pinnacles of righteous, gracious living into the bottomless pit of degradation and despair, bear and shame and helplessness and hopelessness, then certainly I am against it. But if, when you say whiskey, you mean the oil of conversation, the philosophic wine, the ale that is consumed when good fellows get together that puts a song in their hearts and laughter on their lips and the warm glow of contentment in their eyes. If you mean Christmas cheer. If you mean the stimulating drink that puts the spring in the old gentleman's step on a frosty, crispy morning. If you mean the drink which enables a man to magnify his joy and his happiness and to forget, if only for a little while, life's great tragedies and heartaches and sorrows. If you mean that drink, the sale of which pours into our treasuries untold Millions of dollars which are used to provide tender care for our little crippled children, our blind, our deaf, our dumb, our pitiful, aged and infirm, to build highways and hospitals and schools, then certainly I am for it. This is my stand. I will not retreat from it. I will not compromise.
04:09 Mark: Excellent, well read, yes. If when you say that you mean this, yeah, yeah, so as a fallacy,
04:17 Jim: it can be used to mean basically taking both sides of a topic and giving an answer so vague or supposed to please everybody that you don't really take a stance, yeah, obviously. In this instance, what he was doing was actually not really a fallacy. It was just a rhetorical device to point out that there are good arguments on both sides, yeah, and that it is a nuanced issue and not as simple as as kind of black and white thinking might lead you to believe. He said later, when I finished the first half of the speech, there was a tremendous burst of applause. The second half of the speech, after the close of which the wets all applauded – the dries were as unhappy with the second part of the speech as the wets were with the first half – excellent,
05:01 Mark: I love the way he says: this is my, I stand, I will not retreat, I will not compromise. It's got the it's, it's filled with that, that kind of the 50s beauty of a Frank sinatra record. It's just, it's beautifully written, yeah, and perfectly delivered and and is a gag at both camps expense. Really, yeah, yeah, absolutely it is.
05:27 Jim: Yeah, so it can can be used to be taking such a vague view or a both -sides view of an issue that you don't really take a stand on it and thereby avoiding the question. Really. I'm also going to stretch it a little bit in this, in a, if someone less charitable might call a Mark-like way, to… I was going to say,
05:49 Mark: yes, you're stealing my thunder.
05:52 Jim: To also cover kind of redefining words, words of of what. If someone asks a question, yeah, yeah, yeah, well, if you meet – if by that you mean this, and then taking the question in a completely different way,
06:05 Mark: and it also allows you to to well, as he's done brilliantly – there is to duck criticism from either side and you can kind of slippery eel your way out of um, coming down on one side or another. Yeah, and so I would. I would gladly, you know, being the being the inventor of stretching it beyond this, beyond recognition.
06:30 Jim: Yeah, so yeah, for our first Trump example, it unsurprisingly, Trump has never actually been as clever in his rhetoric as this speech at all. So he, he doesn't really both sides stuff, he, he doesn't care about anyone other than his base, so he only says things they want to hear. So the, the kind of definition I'm using here in a very if by whiskey kind of way, is when the Trump administration redefined words, specifically, the department of health and human services under the Trump administration sought to redefine the word sex and right by implication in their memo that they did also gender, because they were basically flattening them and pushing them together as one thing. Right, yeah, yeah, and this was talking about title nine, protections for gender identity, for protecting specific classes of people. So the memo that they proposed, the hhs, said that sex means a person's status as a female or a male based on immutable biological traits identifiable by or before birth, and that the sex listed on a person's birth certificate, as originally issued, can shall constitute definitive proof of a person's sex unless rebutted by reliable genetic evidence. Okay, so, basically they, they went: ah, sex. Well, if by sex you mean this specific definition – which is not about not a scientific definition or a social definition that we use as in society, of sex, then we are going to do this in a way that basically excludes trans people from protection.
08:17 Mark: Exactly, yeah, and they called it grounded in science. You know, into far as we've used some scientific words.
08:24 Jim: I mean grounded in as much as they ground the science up into into tiny bits,
08:29 Mark: which didn't ground it into the dirt.
08:32 Jim: Yeah, yeah, yeah, just any scientist in this area whatsoever would immediately say, yeah, this is, this is grounded in a kind of third, Third grade understanding of science. This is… It's the stuff that we teach you beyond,
08:47 Mark: you know, primary school.
08:49 Jim: It's nonsense and it was just a transparent attempt to redefine it in a way that allowed them to be bigots, essentially.
08:59 Mark: Yeah, as if no one would notice apart from the entire scientific community. You know, not just biologists, physicists and chemists as well. Who just went, I went, no, it's, do you know what? It's a lot more complicated than that.
09:16 Jim: And in the same essential method of just taking words and either redefining them or ignoring their existence. Essentially, the CDC came out in 2017 with or. Analysts at the CDC said that they had been forbidden from using certain words and believed that other parts of the Department of Health and Human Services, which the CDC falls under, probably had the same rules. And words that they were forbidden from using in budgetary documents, in policy documents, were vulnerable, entitlement, diversity, transgender, fetus, evidence-based and science-based.
10:01 Mark: So not only have they gone. If by sex you mean something, something, something that's based, that's ground in science, yeah, and then, then, then. The next bouncing caveat is: if by science you mean something that isn't so, they're there because their alternative phrase was: uh, recommendations based on science, in consideration with community standards and wishes. Yeah, that's not science. Science is utterly objective and strives to be completely objective and separate from whatever the community standards and wishes are. Can you, can you imagine? Well, that's, isn't that what galileo
10:42 [Unclear]: suffered at the hands of? Yeah, yeah, so, yeah, they've, they've gone.
10:47 Jim: Basically, if by science you mean what we reckon – yeah,
10:51 Mark: what we determine, because these are our community standards and our wishes – that the earth is flat and the universe rotates around the earth, um, then that's, then, that's that science stuff that disproves that is heresy, and you'll – you'll be burned at the stake for it. Sorry, flat earthers, yeah, yeah, yeah.
11:15 Jim: So our second example is a a tweet from Donald Trump jr. Uh, which was actually a reply to a tweet from joe Biden, and joe Biden, in september of 2020, pre -his election – said Donald Trump ran for office saying he would represent the forgotten men and women of this country, and as soon as he got in office, he forgot about us, and don jr replied to that saying: if by us you mean career politicians who've spent a half century in government, then yeah, he didn't worry too much about you and your kind,
11:47 Mark: and in and in the process, he allies himself with us, jr, in the same way that he did when he got a selfie with some people when he, when he rode in coach on the plane. But he, but he, and they said, yeah, he's just like us, yes, if by us you mean this, then he didn't worry about you, he, but he was more concerned with people like us. He's, he's implying, and that he is like he's one of the forgotten men. One of the forgotten men.
12:24 Jim: Yeah, well, to be fair,
12:25 Mark: yeah, yeah, we've tried our hardest to forget him.
12:30 Jim: So, yeah, I mean also by his dad. He's probably regularly forgotten, yeah, so that, not quite as much as eric,
12:38 [Unclear]: admittedly, yeah, yeah, so,
12:40 Jim: uh, our third, third example actually comes from a Trump supporter, or I'm making a slight assumption that he's a Trump supporter,
12:45 Mark: based based on what he's based,
12:48 Jim: based on based on what he says: yeah, I'm reasonably confident that he's a Trump supporter. This is on an article that was on floridapolitics .com. So brilliant, I'm sure.
13:00 Mark: Yeah, that's a oxymoron.
13:03 Jim: Yeah, actually the this, This particular page of Florida Politics, was pretty much just printing a press release that was from Associated Press. Oh, a real gem. And it was about Biden blaming Trump for the unrest and riots in the summer of 2020, which is completely reasonable. And a commenter said, nothing new here. The Trumpster just repeats himself over and over again. Congratulations on supporting the most corrupt, divisive, racist, lying administration in US history. Nothing new here, just lies and more lies – like Trump – and the person who I'm assuming is a Trump supporter replied to that, saying: if by divisive you mean he's pro -america and if you want to burn down and destroy America and turn it into a socialist, marxist shithole, then you're right, he is a hundred percent divisive. Now, if you mean create a race war and war between classes, then you're talking about the obama administration and the mainstream media.
14:04 Mark: Okay, I thought you're gonna say: and then you're right, he is 100 % divisive.
14:09 Jim: Wow, so if you, if you define divisive as he loves America and you hate America,
14:18 Mark: But if you mean the other thing, yeah, if you mean what you actually mean, then obama, actually nothing to do. That's Obama, Obama, Obama, mainstream media.
14:31 [Sting: Mark's British Politics Corner] And now is the time, I think, for Mark's British Politics Corner.
14:33 Mark: If by someone who very carefully engineers his responses to abdicate any responsibility whatsoever – you mean Boris Johnson, then yes, well, here he is, as is the culture of slippery, constant blame -dodging redefinition that he engendered, whilst in what we are calling the position of utmost responsibility. If you want my position about my responsibility, the prime minister. This is a speech that he gave to businesses at the jcb's Uk headquarters regarding the his brexit -based bid for the Tory leadership on january 18 2019, and he said this about controlling immigration.
15:15 Clip: Boris Johnson explaining he's not a nationalist
— I'm not a nationalist if by that you mean I'm a xenophobe or someone who deprecates other countries and And cultures – absolutely not, far from it. I'm called Boris, if I'm anything else. My ancestors come from all over the place. Like, I don't know, all this, anyway. Couldn't think of a place. No, no.
15:41 Mark: Hold on, hold on. Anyway, yeah. And he goes on to. So basically, he's saying: if by a nationalist, you mean I'm a complete and utter fucking racist who deprecates other countries and cultures, then well, I'm called Boris for one thing. Well, you're also called alexander defy for Boris. Yeah, and yes, sure enough it doesn't. Yeah, but it's kind of. That's using the. I'm not a racist. Some of our best Friends are black argument and what he does he does go on to say: if, however you mean by being a national, it is possible to be a nationalist who supports and defends immigration and the Rights of others but, at the same time, advocates being able to control one's own national borders. And this is because a tenet of the leave campaign that he was the champion of was that, whilst belonging to the eu meant free movement of our citizens into europe, which they agreed was a good thing. It also meant the free movement of people into the Uk, and that is termed unchecked immigration, because it's a bad thing insofar as that's the kind of thing that would hemorrhage votes to the right -wing parties like UKIP if the Tories didn't embrace it as a bad thing. And thinking about it, it should have been done a lot earlier, and the likes of Boris's Turkish ancestors would thus not have been able to come here and permit subsequent generations to eventually begat Boris. And, of course, ironically, if by nationalist you do mean out -and -out races. There are many examples of just such as detailed by the Daily Mirror's mikey smith in who went who in the daily mirror at when this speech came out, he said: well, yeah, you'd say that. If you mean xenophobe, he says right. In august 2018, Boris compared muslims who wear face veils to letter boxes and bank robbers. Is that a little bit deprecating? In 2013, he appeared alongside the malaysian prime minister at the world islamic economic forum and suggested that that more and more women were going to university in Malaysia because they've got to find men to marry. And in 2006 he wrote in The Telegraph. For 10 years, we in the Tory party have become used to Papua New Guinea -style orgies of cannibalism and chief killing. And in 2002 he described black people as flag -waving pickaninnies with watermelon smiles in a column for The Daily Telegraph, talking about why the Queen loves going to the Commonwealth.
18:16 Jim: It's kind of amazing and, yeah, at the same time, not surprising in the slightest.
18:20 Mark: Yeah, so he's using the. If by this you mean that, then I'm certainly not that. And if but if by this you mean I want to control immigration, and whilst it's a good thing, I think we should be able to, he goes on to try and say: actually, it's about the control that we don't have under the, none of which was was true, because when the eu directive came in about free movement, which was late 80s, early 90s, and subsequently, theresa may, under david cameron, was foreign minister and she didn't enact the national rules that you were unable to enact to limit immigration under that european diktat. So the the rules are there. The europeans say, well, we're not going to enforce people to have a quota voter of immigrants. Of course we're not. We're not going to do that. Here are some rules that you can use to control that. They didn't use them. So, and of course it's the. All you've got to do is shout immigration, because, as the next journalist goes on to say, you will say anything to get votes. Boris is the master of saying exactly what his voters need to hear. In the same speech. Channel four news is. Michael crick asked a question about the leave campaigns message that, unless we vote leave, 80 ,000 Turkish migrants will be coming to England.
19:42 Clip: Boris Johnson claiming he didn't say things about Turkey and the EU
— 2016 the referendum, you and your chum Dominic Cummings, in the vote leave campaign suggested 80 million Turks would come to this country.
— Well, I actually, um, I didn't say anything about, about Turkey in the in the I didn't say anything about. I didn't since I made no remarks. I can't, I can't,
— I didn't make any remarks about Turkey you make,
— I, I'm, you
— were the leader of the vote leave campaign. Well, you do me,
— you do do me too much honor. I was, I was, I was, I was happy to support leave and and I and I do, and I and I did. So.
20:17 Mark: I think in there I've spotted several hidden if by whiskies which, for me, typify boris's use of the micro plausible deniabilities that uses the splitting hairs of meaning that allow him and his chums to claim they were taken out of context, so that when he says I didn't say that thing about turkey, I think in the hidden in there is is if by saying you mean actually saying it out loud, then possibly he didn't. However, one post have featured a British passport depicted as an open door with the trailer footprints going through it alongside the slogan turkey – population 76 million is joining the eu. Vote leave, take back control. And in 2018, this and many other vote leave ads were submitted to the department of cultural media support committee by Facebook as part of the committee's inquiry into fake news. And then he says: well, I didn't make those comments, mate. And the the hidden one is: if by comments you mean I commented on something, then I didn't. But except he did, because in april 2016, he was quoted by the daily express and the Sunday times and the spectator as saying: I'm very pro -turkish, but what I certainly can't imagine is a situation in which 77 million of my fellow turks and those of turkish origin can come here without any checks at all. Strictly speaking, it's probably not a comment. If he's in an interview, it's an answer. So yeah. And then then he said: well, ah, you do me too much honor, bah, I wasn't the leader of the the leave campaign, because he's he's implying. Well, if by leader you mean I was elected, the leave certainly wasn't that. But um, the vote leave campaign director. His chum, dominic cummings, wrote after the referendum: if Boris gove and gisella had not supported us and picked up the baseball bat. Mark: turkey slash, nhs slash 30 350 million pounds with five weeks to go, then 650 000 votes might have been lost. So, whilst you know, if by leader you mean someone who's elected to run the campaign to be the head, then he wasn't elected. If by elected you mean there was a membership that had a vote on who was going to be the leader then, and if by membership you meant, I think, if it was raining, Boris could walk from his House to number 10 without getting wet. He's that practiced at that, dodging between the infinitesimally small variations of meaning.
24:03 [Unclear]: I was just
24:40 Mark: there, of course, with, you know what I mean.
24:43 Jim: So in the Fallacy in the Wild, we like to talk about the fallacy of the week from a non-political perspective. And our first example this week comes from The Simpsons.
24:49 [Unclear]: Yay!
24:49 Jim: And this is immediately following on, actually, from a previous example that we've used. And I think the complex question, Alassie, they're being interviewed about why they hate America, basically, by an obnoxious talk show host.
25:04 Clip: The Simpsons
— Well, America's not perfect. So America isn't perfect.
— Is that why you and your son hate us? If by us you mean loudmouth talk show hosts, which everyone seems to be in this country, then yes, I do hate Americans.
25:19 Mark: Quite a prescient thing, isn't it? Everyone's now a loudmouth talk show host. Yeah, yeah, we, we know lots of them and we've looked at lots of their outputs.
25:31 Jim: So marge goes completely the other way. She doesn't avoid a question. She makes it much worse for herself, yeah, by interpreting his question in the worst possible way.
25:41 [Unclear]: Yeah, yeah, yeah, and she doesn't even.
25:46 Mark: There isn't even another one, no, but if you mean us, yes, you know. Loving flag, yeah, patriotic Americans,
25:54 Jim: yes, yeah, no, she just does the. If you mean people like you, then yes, yes, yeah. So our second example is from pulp fiction, and this is when, uh, marcellus wallace, thing rames, is telling butch bruce willis, yeah, why it's probably time he gives up boxing.
26:14 Clip: Pulp Fiction
— See, this business is filled to the brim with unrealistic motherfuckers, motherfuckers who thought their ass would age like wine. If you mean it turns a vinegar, it does. If you mean it gets better with age, it don't.
26:37 Mark: Yeah, yeah, you shouldn't unseal a old bottle of wine, because inevitably it would have having did that. When my mum died, she had a bottle of champagne that was probably 70 years old and it had never been opened because nothing was ever important enough to open it through her entire life, marriages, births, deaths, so, and actually the only thing important enough to open the bottle of champagne. For was the opening of the bottle of champagne? We made the mistake of not selling it, you know, auctioning it, whatever to a collector and using the money to buy, buy a perfectly nice drinkable bottle of champagne. But we opened it turned, it was like it was not good, it was like vinegary syrup, I mean.
27:23 Jim: I think I don't think it's probably fair to ever open an old bottle of wine, because there's some supposedly that get better with age. And that is what marcellus is kind of saying here is that you know, people think well, they don't. He's saying they don't. People think that they – you know,
27:40 Mark: boxers, for example – will get better with age. Like the ones that people who spend lots and lots of money on pretend it tastes good.
27:51 Jim: So our third example comes from Frasier. This is an episode where Daphne, who is a bit psychic, she thinks she's a bit psychic anyway. Niles is sceptical and they agree to get a scientific approach to this. and invite a scientist who tests these kind of things to come and give her a test. And he's played by Fisher Stevens, who was the offensive Indian stereotype in Short Circuit. Oh, God, yeah! And also played a psychiatrist in an episode of Friends.
28:25 Clip: Frasier
— Believe me, nothing would make me happier than discovering a legitimate psychic. Oh, so you've never found one? Well, if by psychic you mean people with above-normal prescience, then a few. You. If you mean somebody who can beat the House in vegas,
28:38 Jim: then no, well, nobody means someone with above normal prescience when they say psychic. No, that's not what a psychic means. No, that's just someone who's good at figuring stuff out,
28:51 Mark: yeah, or uses a vast quantity of lifetime experience to go. Well, yeah, I'm not gonna just sell my shares yet.
28:57 Jim: Yeah, yeah, yeah, people's level of intuition in specific topics, often things they're very familiar with – varies. That's not psychic, no, and and so, yeah, only by redefining the word can he claim to have found any psychic.
29:14 Mark: Yeah, yeah, and I think I was expecting james randy to burst into the scene and go: if, by prescience, you made, yeah, stuff that normal people have, then yeah, that's not a psychic. because ultimately, ultimately, you're right. See up, yes, I, I, I take it back that you've stretched the whole redefining the word. It's not. You didn't, um, charitably or otherwise. Yeah, it is. Ultimately. Well, I keep wanting to go to straw man, or or the goalposts moving. It's that kind of taking their argument and turning it into something else and then denying it based on the something else that that you've turned it into. Yeah, I guess there's a part
29:58 Jim: of that in there. Yeah, there's, yeah, yeah.
30:01 Mark: So I came up with an example. It's occurred to me that, because we work in the realms that we do, there's a guarantee that opinions will be held strongly in the worlds of film and music, both with and without the if -by -dot, dot, -dot -you -mean caveat. And this example I found on a Worst Song in the World poll from 2013, against the entry for seasons in the sun. So I was looking up who sang seasons in the sun and um, and this came up: he just voted worst song in the world in 2013. And someone replied: if you mean the version by terry jacks, I concur. I recommend the version recorded some decade or so earlier by the kingston trio. And another reply to that proposes: yeah, but if you mean jack brells version, his incomparable artistry was casually but mortally wounded by anything that came after. So there's that kind of: if you mean this, then yes, but if you mean that, then I would disagree. But if you mean and so, despite all that, I think the original proposal is still right. It is a bad song, but if you're going to talk about versions of june, if you mean yeah, then we will. We could argue for hours about that. If you mean the david lee truck, yeah.
31:19 Jim: If the top of the worst song in the world poll of 2013 wasn't life by des ray, then it's not a valid poll in my opinion. Yeah, and and the – I should say the top of every worst song ever: yeah, it's just. It's the. It's just objectively, the worst song that's ever been released, right, it's just the worst. It's not even even the worst song, it's the worst thing thing.
31:45 Mark: Yeah, it's just the worst thing, right?
31:49 [Unclear]: Yeah, so
31:53 Mark: of all, I mean, there are some things – yeah, I'm not, I can think of,
31:57 Jim: I'm not putting it, no, I'm not, I'm not putting it in a specific category – no, worse than all the other things.
32:03 Mark: Yeah, yeah, in 2013, or or no, no, no, no, no, I mean, it probably wasn't.
32:10 Jim: It was way, it was before 2013, but it existed at that point and therefore, from the point at which it existed, moving forward any time, I mean ideally, any polls that were taken before that as well, they should have anticipated how bad it would be and added it there. Yeah, yeah, I mean, it's just. You know, I, I don't want to see a ghost. It's the The site that I fear most. I'd rather have a piece of toast. Those are the fucking lyrics to a commercially released song for grown-ups.
32:41 [Unclear]: It's unacceptable.
32:44 Mark: I think what happened there is they put a placeholder in and just went, yeah, yeah, we'll come back and find something there. Just finish the song, get the words down. We'll know we've got to go back and fix that.
32:56 [Sting: Fake News] So we're going to play… Fake news, folks. I love the game. It's a great game. Yes,
33:04 Jim: it's time for Fake News. The game where I read out three Trump quotes, two of which are real and one I made up, and Mark has to figure out which one is fake news.
33:10 Mark: You see, if by figure out you mean identify the one I'd most like to hear Trump say, despite that, it might be fake, then I'm not so sure. However, if you mean positively understand the way that you write these things in order to humiliate me and, I dare say, all some, several, maybe none of our listeners, then I'm quite uncertain. And that's my stance, and I'm not going to deviate from it.
33:40 Jim: We have heard from listeners who say they also find this difficult. So you're not alone.
33:45 Mark: Yeah, but that doesn't mean that they get it wrong. We all find it difficult.
33:49 [Unclear]: No, that's true. They probably find it difficult.
33:51 Jim: Yeah, I'm thinking they're being quite charitable.
33:52 Mark: They're going in a kind of patronising way. I think they are just trying to be nice to you. Yeah, they're just going, yeah, poor fella. We all find it a bit difficult. Yeah, but all the way up until getting the right answer.
34:07 Jim: So, last time we talked about Trump kind of invagling his way into things he says about dead people. Oh, yeah, the life of dead people. And in a weirdly prescient way, but not psychic. Psychic. This, yeah, also follows that same theme because, yeah, are you aware of Diamond and Silk? No, a double Act of black women who, uh, were very pro -trump and oh okay, that's probably why I haven't heard of them. Yeah, online commenters, um, who, who rose up in in fame for how pro -trump they were and ultimately became kind of Fox news contributors, yeah, and then got chucked off Off Fox News for COVID misinformation.
34:51 Mark: Off Fox News? Right, OK.
34:54 Jim: Their sisters, Diamond, largely would yell and rant and occasionally swear. And Silk would mostly just go, mm-hmm. And…
35:05 Mark: And a kind of sarcastic affirmation.
35:10 Jim: So, unfortunately, very sadly, Diamond died a couple of weeks ago. Oh, dear. But Trump was such a big fan of theirs and they of him that he attended the memorial service, which was televised on Right Side Broadcasting Network, that big, famous channel. And he spoke for a while, actually.
35:34 Mark: They were keen to get on with the ceremony and he was held up by this jerk talking about himself, mainly.
35:42 Jim: To be honest, quite a lot of the people who spoke spoke about him and the fact he was there and how much she thought he was great and right. He talked for 43 minutes, oh my God, of which 13 minutes were about Diamond, yeah, and the rest were about him. The other 30 minutes were about him and how, and his kind of campaign and how terrible America is now that biden's in charge, and all that kind of stuff. Just random things. So here are some things.
36:13 Mark: He's never been one to read the room, has he?
36:16 Jim: So here are some quotes from his eulogy of one of his biggest fans. OK. Statement number one. The first time I heard about Diamond and Silk was from our great First Lady. Very popular First Lady, I have to say. She was on the cover of so many magazines until she met me. Then they said, keep her off covers. She was a great, great, beautiful woman. She was on so many magazines. And then she meets Trump and they say, let's keep her off. Even though their sales, what they don't figure out, Mike, Mike, is that their sales would have doubled, tripled, quadrupled. So Mike there, by the way, is Mike Lindell, who was also one of the speakers at this memorial service. And for some reason, Trump kept talking to Mike during his eulogy. He was like sat on the stage.
37:02 Jim: And he would just keep shouting out to Mike.
37:06 [Unclear]: It's weird.
37:08 Mark: That's because he's used to having a mic standing behind him. Passively listening to his drivel whilst flies land on his head.
37:17 Jim: So statement number two: this is talking about his time on The Apprentice. Obviously, as you would when you're talking, when you're giving a eulogy, somebody's recently died and how when he, after he left The Apprentice to run for president, NBC was very sad, tried to get him to stay, but instead they went for Arnold Schwarzenegger. And uh, because he had to go and be president and and so he said: now Arnold Schwarzenegger is a big movie star, right, and he, I mean, I said that sounds like a great idea. He should be able to do well. I wanted to see it do well, although I'm not sure about that. You know, I had a choice. You understand this, Mike. If he did really well, really well, they'd say: what the hell do we need Trump for? If he did really poorly, maybe I won't make any money if that happens, but if he did really poorly I can say: see, I'm the only one that can do it. Well, he did really poorly. He got no ratings.
38:17 Mark: If by ratings you mean. OK.
38:20 [Unclear]: OK.
38:21 Jim: And number three, she was a beacon of light and a great source of wisdom and common sense. That's what we need more of, isn't it? Common sense. What do you think, Mike? If there was a bit more common sense, maybe we wouldn't have left $85 billion of the most beautiful military equipment in afghanistan for the taliban to use, including three brand new black hawk helicopters and hundreds of thousands of guns and binoculars and other military things. But your sister Diamond was taken from us too soon.
38:53 Mark: Oh, what see, I'm going so before if I figured out I. I want to hear the one, hear him say that then. Oh there, it is right there.
39:03 [Unclear]: Oh God what.
39:06 Mark: Okay, so well that you see that the number three has got the, the, the inkling of reality, because it's got got kind of eulogiac kind of things at the beginning and end,
39:28 [Unclear]: with a massive detour in the middle.
39:32 Mark: Just like they took military equipment away, she was taken from. But then the Schwarzenegger.
39:45 Mark: I mean, that's nothing but diversion, is it? Which makes you think that that's probably real. Okay, so, and yet the one about magazines – subtly convincing. So I wonder whether the two really outrageous ones are actually real. And the subtle one that looks convincingly real is the, the one you made up. Okay, yeah, I'm gonna go with that, I'm gonna go for number one is the one that you made up, okay.
40:29 Jim: So the other two which you more convinced by?
40:31 Mark: Uh, number three, the black hawk helicopters, yeah, yeah.
40:39 Jim: And number three, yeah is yeah,
40:43 [Unclear]: fake news, oh
40:45 Mark: man, oh, what? Yeah, should have gone with the first instincts. It's overthinking.
40:54 Jim: He didn't bring up, as far as I can remember, because I did listen to the entire 43 minutes, he didn't. He didn't bring up the withdrawal from Afghanistan, right, surprisingly. And he brought up lots of other Schwarzenegger, yeah, lots of other stuff you wouldn't expect in a eulogy. Well, exactly, why not? Yeah, Yeah, but he did do a lot of that bit where it's like I'm going to because he had prepared remarks. Someone had written him a, he proudly said, someone's, you know, script writer's written this for me, basically. So, you know, none of the stuff I'm saying about Diamond is from the heart at all. He basically said, I have these written remarks. And so, yeah, he would say like half a sentence from the thing that had been written for him and it would trigger a thought in his head and he would go off like the dog from Up on a chasing squirrel. Squirrel! And then at some point would run out of steam and then come back to the remarks.
42:06 [Unclear]: Oh, man.
42:08 Mark: Like he always does. But that's yeah. And you, just how disheartening must it have been at a funeral for a, you know, a cherished right winger – albeit right winger – that the things that are most heartfelt are his stories about his disappointment at Schwarzenegger getting the gig.
42:32 Jim: Yeah, so that, that one was indeed true.
42:37 Clip: Trump, played during Fake News
— Now, Arnold Schwarzenegger is a big movie star, right? And he, I mean, I said, that sounds like a great idea. He should be able to do well. I wanted to see it do well, although I'm not that sure about that. You know, I had a choice. Do you understand this, Mike? If he did really well, really well, they'd say, what the hell do we need Trump for, Trump? If he did really poorly, maybe I won't make any money if that happens. But if we did really poorly, I can say, see, I'm the only one that can do it. Well, he did really poorly. He got no ratings. So Silk in the
43:11 Mark: background going, mm-hmm.
43:13 Jim: That's all she does.
43:19 Mark: Oh, my God. So it's kind of what she would have wanted.
43:24 Jim: She was loving it.
43:27 Jim: He went on an extended rant about Pocahontas, about Elizabeth Warren. And she thought it was hilarious, she was having a great time.
43:38 Mark: Oh dear, yeah, it's the, it's the, it's the desperate, saddest people laugh at funerals. It's a release. Yeah, built up, it was a celebration. Emotion of Trump. Oh yeah, let's just stick her in the ground and get Trump on again.
43:54 Jim: At one point – I didn't include this because it was – it was over quite quickly, but so it wasn't. You know, it wasn't as long as some of the other things I wanted to include, but, um, at one point he was basically complaining about how long it had been happening. For because it was – it was, to be fair, a reason. It was a long. It was like a almost four hour service, three and a half hour memorial service, um, and he said,
44:22 Mark: well, he contributed a lot,
44:23 Jim: yeah, yeah, yeah, but what? Pretty much. When he got up to speak, he said: oh, you know, I, I was asked if I would do this, and I, and and they said: you know, can you just give us a bit of time? And I said how much? And he said they said, oh, you'll be in in 15, 15 to 20 minutes in and out, and it's been a lot more than 15 minutes, isn't it? And it's like what the fuck? This is not how you start your eulogy. Jesus Christ, I've been sitting there a long time listening to all the hymns and prayers and things. Yeah, I've got places by the.
44:54 Mark: Yeah, I've got other people to see off the kingdom come, so, uh also.
45:04 Jim: Number one was was real, where he talked about malaria.
45:08 Clip: Trump, played during Fake News
— The first time I heard about Diamond and Silk was from our great first Lady, very popular first Lady, I have to say. She's uh, she was on the cover of so, so many magazines until she met me and they said: keep her off covers. She was a great, great beautiful woman. She was on so many magazines. And then she meets Trump and they say let's keep her off, even though their sales – what they don't figure it, Mike, is that their sales would have a double, triple, quadruple. She was a great, great girl. She was on so many magazines.
45:47 Mark: Jesus. Oh, King Christ. He's like a kind of a fictional, fat stand-up comic played by Robert De Niro. Up against the beauty of that Mississippi lawmaker in the 50s. Saying those wonderful things. And then he's going, you know, take my wife, somebody, please.
46:10 Jim: Yeah, honestly. I mean, you know, for this podcast, I've watched a lot of Trump stuff. It's part of the cross I bear for the podcast.
46:22 [Unclear]: Gladly the cross I bear.
46:23 Jim: But he hasn't. Although he did a couple of speeches in small places to kind of kick off his campaign last week, he hasn't done rallies for a while. He hasn't been doing long talks. So I haven't kind of had to sit through much for a while.
46:40 Mark: Yeah, you're kind of like enjoying the rest.
46:43 Jim: Yeah, but watching this because of all of the weird sharp left turns away from eulogising this woman into oh – and that reminds me of a funny story about how Joe Biden's an arsehole was. I out loud said oh, for fuck's sake, Trump. Several times when watching this, which I haven't done for a while. While, like I, I couldn't believe what he was saying.
47:16 Mark: And you've got a big screen. I can imagine standing up getting his ass breaking and standing up pointing at straight at the screen.
47:30 Jim: if he just stayed on script, it would have been. It would have been 15 minutes and it would have been nice stuff that he said about her. Everyone would have been happy and
47:40 Mark: it would have been dignified. Yeah, it would have had some semblance of occasion and he would have got nothing out of the experience at all. No, no, that's the thing, isn't it? That's why he, he can't stand waiting, because he's got to get up there, he's got to generate the adulation of the crowd and basically whine about things that he thinks have gone wrong and and stuff that you, you know. Pity me, pity me, poor me, pity me. Have some concern for me. I've gone through all of this terrible, terrible stuff and you're here for somebody else that's died? How dare you?
48:25 Jim: One of the big things that's gone round about this speech, because I actually had some trouble tracking down the whole thing, because there's a couple of Twitter users who. Thankfully, people have been queuing around,
48:38 Mark: taking it down.
48:40 Jim: Well, no, there's a couple of Twitter users who watch most of his stuff and will kind of clip little bits. And all of the commentary that has happened about this speech has been about those clips that appeared on Twitter. And it's kind of four short sections. So it was tough to track down the whole version of it. But I did it for you guys. Um, but uh, but one of the things that has gone around, because one of those, those uh clips that was clipped was of him saying, of the two sisters, I thought I knew you both, I knew Diamond, but but I've just found out, I've just learned about Silk. I've just kind of, you know, I've just discovered Silk – and you're great too – which everyone has taken to mean. He's first of all insane because, because they are never apart. They are absolutely a package deal. And then there's some other… There's no way you'd possibly know one of them and not the other. Pepsi and Shirley. Yeah, Bert and Ernie there. Laurel and Hardy. You know, it's just, it's not possible. But I'm going to defend Trump, because this was after Silk had been on stage for an hour talking about her sister. Well, slightly talking about her sister, mostly blaming the covid vaccination, which her sister didn't take, for her death.
50:08 [Unclear]: yeah, yeah, they're they're,
50:11 Jim: they're such strong anti -vaxxers. It somehow still killed her, the vaccine, yeah,
50:16 Mark: just because it's in the world.
50:18 Jim: Yeah, yeah, that's basically it, because other people have had it and they somehow got her sick from it.
50:25 [Unclear]: So, anyway, yeah, um,
50:27 Jim: what did she? What did she die? Heart attack. But because she's a big fat woman and she had high blood pressure, right. So, not, like, there's underlying thing,
50:36 Mark: even if she did have covid or the vaccine, there would have been underlying conditions. Yeah, in this case, the underlying conditions were the overarching conditions. Yeah, the thing that killed her.
50:47 Jim: Yeah, yeah, anyway, okay, um, so, having listened what he was saying, I think – and maybe I'm giving him too much credit, but I don't think that's ever happened than before, so it seems unlikely – yeah, um, I think he was saying: I have learned a lot more about you by listening to you talk now, because, apart from the else she previously, he's probably only ever heard her go. Yeah, and and yeah, so, yeah, he's, he learned a lot more about her. So I think that's what he meant when he was saying: you know, I knew Diamond. Now I know Silk too. You know, now, I've met met you.
51:22 Mark: Now I know, if he had a better grasp of humanity and grace and the English language, he might well have been able to sculpt those words into something that, momentarily, wasn't about him. Yeah, I've learned much more about you, but no, I think visual. Yes, I think, yeah,
51:44 Jim: I think people have been unfair to Trump in this particular instance. So so there you go,
51:49 Mark: that's my, I think you. I think it's time, nurse, it's time to check the medication levels.
51:54 [Unclear]: The gym: yes,
51:56 Jim: that's all the defending of Trump. I'll be doing this decade.
52:00 Mark: Okay, for another 117 episodes? Yeah, yeah, so I expect to hear something at 234, where you go. Well, I've been thinking, actually, maybe we should be, yeah, not being so harsh on him.
52:13 Jim: Yeah, so unfortunately, that means that you did not get this one right. Oh, I fooled, fooled you again.
52:19 [Unclear]: Yeah, I don't. Yeah, yeah, if by fooled you mean
52:23 Jim: to look like a fool,
52:25 Mark: yeah, yeah, and not just me. One, some several, maybe none whatsoever, who you know find it quite difficult to, yeah, up until you get the right answer.
52:38 [Unclear]: Actually send us a tweet,
52:41 Jim: put a message in the Facebook, Facebook group or on Patreon to say how frequently you, when I am wrong, are you right?
52:49 Mark: Yeah, yeah, well, you know. Yeah, what's your percentage? Yeah, yeah, because mine's now 53 out of 107, uh -huh, which is slightly less than two prime numbers right there,
53:00 [Unclear]: coincidence, I don't think so. So
53:10 Jim: it's time for the part of the show that, this week at least, is called the fair tax Act is not not a logical fallacy, and don't go away just because it's about taxes and that's really boring. It's not really about tax, not really. It's not really it's about.
53:24 Mark: It's about arm wrestling, isn't it? It's kind of, kind of, yeah, it's about whilst, at the same time, laughing behind your hand.
53:32 Jim: Yeah, it's about how bad a job Kevin Mccarthy is doing, yeah, and how, and also how much he,
53:40 Mark: like he gave, Yeah, how many concessions he gave away. Basically.
53:43 Jim: Because he was not going to get elected as Speaker unless he kowtowed to the worst of the worst.
53:54 Mark: People like Marjorie Taylor Greene.
53:58 Jim: Yeah, she could still bring your firearm into Congress. He got her onside pretty early on, but people like Lauren Boebert and Matt Gaetz and Paul Gosar and various others.
54:09 Mark: All the people that said: it's about you, it's just an ego trip.
54:14 Jim: So, yeah, they, they're terrible people. And to get their votes to make him Speaker, he had to give up lots of things, including various kind of committee memberships.
54:28 Mark: Grip on reality. Yeah, the ability for,
54:31 Jim: like any member of the House – and I don't know why they made this so broad, not just Republicans, but any member of the House – yeah, can, can trigger a vote to vacate the Speaker, to basically get him out. I'm surprised he's lasted this long.
54:48 Mark: Well, it because he's, because this thing has come up and the Democrats are loving it, so they're playing it to the hilt. They're playing along with the game, aren't they? They're going well, if you've said that, then surely this is what it must, And they know that it's got the air. This is the equivalent of the fiscal grip that the the conservatives always say they have and maintain over the economy. They are, first and foremost, the people that are in charge of the economy, even when one of their leaders that was in for 20 minutes tanks the entire economy. I mean, every one of their leaders.
55:31 Jim: If you look at the kind of economy, the GDP, the national debt, everything, basically the debt goes up when Republicans are in and goes down when the Democrats are in.
55:44 Mark: And yeah, exactly like the right wing over here, the right -hand side of the House will say: oh, we are the ones that are strong and stable when it comes to finances. They are just tax and spend, tax and spend, rather than tax and provide tax cuts for our rich mates. I'd much rather do the spend thing. That's fine. Spend it on good stuff. Give it to British Petroleum.
56:09 Jim: So yeah, one of the things that McCarthy agreed to was a vote on a thing called the Fair Tax Act, and also that it would actually get a proper debate through committee and that kind of stuff. And the Fair Tax Act is a thing that's been kicking around for 20 years, 30 years? Oh, yeah, easily. Yeah, since the early 90s.
56:33 Mark: Well, because I can remember Frank Zappa talking. People got interested in talking to Frank zapper. Of all people, um, I think it was even, I think it was reagan's administration, right, yeah, well, yeah, because Frank with Frank zapper was was saying, yeah, let's just do away with income tax and put it. Put a sales tax on everything. Yeah, so it is then controlled by what you buy.
56:58 Jim: Yeah, so that's the idea: you get rid of income tax, tax, corporate tax, death taxes, payroll taxes, gift taxes completely. Just wipe them out. Get rid of the irs essentially, yeah, and replace them all with a 30 tax on pretty much everything you buy. Yes, a federal sales tax, with the idea that that that money will then replace all of the other the taxes. And the concept that it's fair is based on the fact that then you're, it's a consumption tax, you're you're paying tax on if you buy stuff. So the more the you know rich people buy more stuff, yeah, yeah, so they'll pay more expensive stuff. Yeah, uh, obviously it's incredibly regressive in that that means that, um, people who currently don't pay no income because they don't earn earn enough to pay income tax, they are still paying that 30 on everything, yeah, which is a lot of money. So they they came up with a solution to that problem, uh, which is called a pre -bait, where they initially the idea was to mail out a check to – is it low -income houses, I think it's low -income houses – at the beginning of every month so that they had enough, basically, that that would would cover to pay for, yeah, what they're allowed to spend essentially on food and shelter, and you know the essentials.
58:27 Mark: Wouldn't it be easier just to have a kind of low income declaration certificate, well, something a bit like a voucher, where you just go I don't have to pay the tax, I mean get it discounted off the price, because the sales tax, vat and all that kind of stuff for the people that make the product are still going to get their value -added tax, it's just that they wouldn't pay the federal tax.
58:56 Jim: Yeah, I mean, the problem is you start to come up against things like the issues with snap, the supplemental nutrition assistance program which low -income people have access to, and it's essentially food stamps – used to be called food stamps – one thing that some, Some places are now doing – I can't remember which state it is, but one state – it might be like Indiana or somewhere like that – has tried to specify quite narrowly what you're allowed to buy with that stuff, to the extent that you're not allowed to buy any fresh meat.
59:29 [Unclear]: What?
59:31 Jim: Or you can get canned tuna. That's kind of the most protein.
59:36 Mark: That's got to be lobbying on behalf of Tim's Goods Firms.
59:42 Jim: Yeah, but yeah, there's such a lot. They're like they're so prescriptive about what kinds of things you're allowed to have that it's kind of quicker to list the things you're allowed than the things you're not allowed. Really, it's so patrician saying that essentially, you know, if you just give poor people the ability to buy food, you can't trust them to buy the right food. Yeah, yeah, yeah, you have to tell them what food they're allowed to buy,
1:00:05 Mark: deserving, poor, and absolutely it's. It's the same as the right wing thing that the poor people are poor because it's their own fault and we need to educate them how to do it better. Whereas the left wing say people are poor because of the fucking government policies.
1:00:21 Jim: So if you start to have some kind of exemption system where you know it's like I am low income, I don't have to pay the sales tax. Yeah, first of all, that's incredibly dehumanizing in terms of having to show that as as snap is, but also, inevitably, some local governments, some state governments are going to say: okay, you can, here are things you are allowed to use your exemption to buy and here are things you are not allowed to buy with it. That means that people on low incomes don't have access to that stuff because it becomes 30 percent more expensive than it was previously. Yeah, and – and I think it's reasonable to say, people should have the choice of how to spend their money, yeah, what food they want to buy, what they want to buy for their kids, etc.
1:01:09 Mark: Yeah, there's a movement in international development that recognizes that in the global south, the global north, who go in and provide The? U .S? does it. The U.S. aid goes in and provides monetary support through governments and local nonprofit organizations to distribute the aid that they get in community settings. Things. But then there's a but. There's a recognition that who are we, as the global north westerners, to dictate what this stuff can be spent on? And there's a movement to say: just give them cash, absolutely. Yeah, like you know, don't. Don't give it to a charity. Who, a local charity, who will then Then distribute yet more blankets and yet more solar -powered lights? Just give them the money in their hands. Let them do what they want with it. You know, they might want to buy bicycles. They will buy what they want. They might want batteries. They might want a new well. They might want to buy booze. Why not? If you're having a party, fucking buy booze. You know, you should be allowed to. And that's an increasingly popular and, well, not amongst the international development organisations.
1:02:35 Jim: I think to some extent it's becoming more recognised to some extent, even among those organisations to say that actually.
1:02:42 Mark: Yeah, but it's quite alarming to discover that those international development organisations really feel old fashioned. It feels, you know, like that it predates Live Aid and the 1980s. They're still saying, we know what you need, what's best for you. And that phrase never worked ever anywhere. You know, we know what's best. You think you know what's best for you, but you don't.
1:03:13 Jim: There's definitely been a shift towards investment in local communities, rather than, you know, driving up with trucks full of grain and saying: here's your grain, have this now be happy.
1:03:27 Mark: But it's been a new thing ever since the Aswan Dam, you know, or similar dam projects. When you go in there and say, okay, to solve your water problems, what we're going to do, and your energy problems, we're going to dam this river off and that will provide you free electricity. And everyone downstream says, ah yeah, we kind of like the water, thanks, we kind of drink that and we use it to water our crops. No, no, we don't need that now, because we'll heat the greenhouses. So it was called local technology. Forget about dams. Let's just let people make Archimedean screws, screws that they could just get their own water. It doesn't matter if they're made out of wood, it works. Let them do it so. And that I learned about that in the 70s, so it's kind of a new concept since then. But yeah, so it's gaining some traction. Takes a long time in international. It takes a long time to chip away at that notion that we know best and you can't possibly know what you're doing because you're driving a motorbike in some mud and you've got. You Live in the stone age, yeah, yeah.
1:04:46 Jim: So the pre -bait idea essentially is supposed to give low -income families enough to raise them up to the kind of poverty level, the level of where they're not having to, they're not having to, kind of use, uh, to just buy basic food and shelter and things like that, the essentials, obviously. That is, then, a an administrative issue, because they've got rid of the irs by this point, so that money is going to be sent out either by the federal government or by the state government or what, yeah, and the sales tax is then going to be collected by all of the different state governments, so 51 agencies essentially around the U .s,
1:05:27 Mark: which would pay for the pre -bate and there,
1:05:29 Jim: and those would then go to the treasury directly. There is significant question of whether this would then actually pay for itself, and certainly whether it kind of replace all of the taxes that are currently in existence. What it would do, according to the kind of tax experts that have looked at it, is it would give the wealthiest people significant tax cuts, like the biggest tax cuts.
1:05:54 Mark: Yeah, because, yeah, yeah,
1:05:56 Jim: because the people, People who earn or inherit – because it wipes out death tax as well – Millions or billions of dollars, aren't spending all that money on stuff. They are investing that money. And there's no tax on investing. That's fine. There's no tax on inheriting or earning or anything like that. So they're spending. There's only a certain amount of money you can spend. If you've seen Brewster's Millions, you should be well aware that literally there is a hard limit on how much money you can spend.
1:06:33 Mark: Ah, yeah, but that was in a pre-online world, was it?
1:06:36 Jim: Yeah, but realistically, billionaires – as a percentage of their income or wealth or inheritance, are spending significantly less than people who are on the poverty line or just above the poverty line. Middle class incomes. This tax would add to the cost of cars, uh, gasoline, houses, like everything basically that you buy. Yeah, would make would be much more expensive. Though there's some people say 23 because they're being disingenuous. But it's, but it's, that's. This is not how you work out tax. It's a 30 tax, and the reason they say 23 is because if something costs ten dollars, then under this new system it would cost $13, because that's 30 % tax, right. But that $3 of tax, that's only 23% of the new price. So of the $13 that you're paying for this thing, only 23% of it is tax because $3 is 23% of $13. So. But that's not how tax works. When you add tax to something, the percentage of tax that you add is based on you know how much it started at and how much you end up having to pay.
1:08:00 Mark: Yeah well, it's a bit like buying anything in America. You buy a cup of coffee in starbucks and it says on the wall two dollars 40 and you get to the deal and you pay sales tax. In the Uk it says two pounds 40. That's what you pay.
1:08:17 Jim: We are still paying sales tax, but it's included in the price. That's included in the price.
1:08:21 Mark: It's a bit. If only ticket sales for events got that when they just go: yeah, it's two pounds, it's 215 pounds. And then when you go to check out, he said: yeah well, there's an administration fee. What administration is going on? It's on a fucking computer. How many times are we paying this programmer for having put that program on?
1:08:42 Jim: That's not how it works in America. There's all kinds of extra things. I saw a tweet today where someone was posting a medical bill for having a baby. And there was a $40 charge on there for post-birth skin-to-skin contact. So they charge you $40 for holding your baby. What the fuck is that? How does that cost the hospital anything?
1:09:10 Mark: To pick up your own baby and well, perhaps it had to be supervised because it was your first they checked. Is this your first one? When I had my second child? Well, I didn't. I was present at a distance because I got bitten during the first one, and yeah, not by the child but by the mother, and so I thought I'd go up the other end. And because, Because we had to get home, which was admittedly only a five -minute walk from the hospital, we had to get home because the first child was coming back from school, from nursery school, so we had to get home. So I performed all of the postnatal checks. It's like there's a kind of – That saved time?
1:10:00 Jim: It feels like that wouldn't save time. Let the doctors do it, I say.
1:10:03 [Unclear]: Well, yeah, I did it.
1:10:04 Mark: I just kind of went: okay, yeah, chop the thing, tickle the feet, yeah, do the thing like the drop test, all that kind of stuff, you know. That's why I poke me in the eye: everything did, all the tests did, all that got all the right in the machine that goes ping. Yeah, we still had to wait for the doctor to arrive and I said, okay, I did this, this, this is brilliant, off you go. And so it didn't save any time at all.
1:10:27 Jim: I mean, this was, this was a while ago, go, but it doesn't feel like that should be allowed. Yeah, no, I don't.
1:10:37 [Unclear]: I think I'm.
1:10:38 Mark: I think it was in left, left wing socialist era, I think.
1:10:42 Jim: If the doctor comes in and you go, oh yeah, don't worry, I've already done all the tests, that no they should say: I think we'll just double check.
1:10:50 [Unclear]: You know, someone with a
1:10:53 Jim: little bit of medical training should have a look.
1:10:55 Mark: I had, I had the appropriate medical training because it's appropriate for that moment, because I had one child. It's not hard. It's kind of like: okay, I need you to change the tire on your bike, this is how you do it. You're then able to do it on a bike.
1:11:12 Jim: It's having a child. They're different things. I don't think you can compare them to
1:11:17 Mark: fundamentally made of rubber and air. They're exactly the same And they go round and they you know, and you've got to take them. They are very bouncy. They are. The other thing I thought about with the tax system is that this would in the milieu of international development non -profits. There's no incentive for rich billionaires to give money to NGO concerns because there's no tax deductible. If they'd got no tax to pay, that would, Jesus Christ, that would entirely dry up as well.
1:11:59 [Unclear]: Yeah. I mean, they just
1:12:00 Mark: wouldn't want what, you know, it's kind of forced altruism. That's the incentive. Dear Mr. Gates, give us a lot of money to eradicate this stuff in, you know, polio. Polio. And and put in some wells and allow people to drink and, you know, survive and go to school and not die in childbirth. Please can we have some money? And in return, any donations we will give you, we will give you the equivalent tax deductible. You can give this away and that will come off your tax bill.
1:12:41 Jim: Now, there's there's many issues with it. Quite a big issue which I don't think has been addressed at all really, is that this removes all state income tax, state state tax, essentially. So essentially all the states would get all their money from the federal government, which is not what happens at the moment,
1:12:58 Mark: and the Republicans are against big government. They want to shove everything out to local administrations. Yes, I think the issue is not discussing the viability of the, the sales tax, because it's never going to the. The real point is that the Democrats are really enjoying the fact that they're coming up with all of these little nuances and going, oh yeah, well, that's going to be difficult, absolutely because, because he gave this up, yeah, as a thing, to get some votes in, yeah, yeah, he doesn't agree,
1:13:32 Jim: he doesn't support it. I mean, he's come out and said I don't support this, even though he's going to kind of encourage a vote on it.
1:13:39 Mark: And well, it's a bit like, um, david cameron and, uh, nick clegg. Nick clegg said: okay, I will go into coalition government with you if you give me a vote on proportional representation. So, rather than the first, that we have the first pass the post -election system here, um, what he wanted to do was bring in proportional representation and david cameron went, yeah, all right, he didn't, he's, he wasn't in favor of it and he said: I'm not in favor of this, but I'll let you do it. And of course, nick clegg fell for it and when he came, nobody was interested. There was a public referendum on it and everyone went, yeah, whatever. So it didn't get passed and that was the one thing and clegg squandered it. It's like playing your joker on the field rouge in hits a knockout. We've just lost 70 percent of the audience, but they, but they. And then failing to score any points and not doubling anything. And he did: yeah, great, I'm gonna do it.
1:14:39 Jim: 70 percent of the audience is very conservative there, because I think 70 percent of the audience is well, 90 percent of the audience is non -uk. So okay, and then of the Uk listeners, you've got the number of people who were alive when it's a knockout was on tv. Yeah, it's all on youtube.
1:14:59 Mark: Just go and watch it. The royal, it's a knockout. Go watch that. Just find it and watch it, then you'll understand.
1:15:06 Jim: It was briefly revived by channel five for like two seasons. So, yeah, yeah, yeah.
1:15:11 Mark: Was that when we were there? It was: yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Well, I'll bet you got some calls about that.
1:15:19 Jim: So the The point really is that none of this is going to happen because it doesn't have the votes in the House. It has less support, this idea, than really it's had since it was proposed. In 2016, it had 75 supporters in the House. This year, so far, there's about 24 co-sponsors of HR25. That's in the House. Even if they could get the votes in the House for it, which they definitely won't – it would then go to the senate, where it's never had more than eight supporters in the senate, and so it won't obviously get through. And even if somehow they managed to do some kind of weird deal where they said: all right, tell you what, we'll agree on: a path to citizenship and like free medicare for everyone and all of that stuff, if you'll let us have this, yeah, joe Biden would veto it. So there's – there's absolutely no possible chance that this is going to get passed. But But Kevin McCarthy agreed with idiots to have a hearing on it.
1:16:24 Mark: So is it ultimately just to embarrass Kevin McCarthy? I mean, from the Democrats' point of view, this is perfect, isn't it? Because they will just say, well, he gave away the entire story in order to get into office. It was just a…
1:16:42 Jim: Yeah, I mean from, yeah, from Democrats point of view. It's just, the Republicans are just wasting time doing stuff like this. Yes, and let them waste their time. You know when, when your enemy is making a mistake, don't interrupt them
1:16:53 Mark: exactly, just carry on. Just keep watching the screens. And they are: yeah, you carry on. Here's another thing I would suggest. Maybe you know this is how you might collect it: blah, blah, blah. Oh yeah, so you stoke the fire. Yeah, that's what you do,
1:17:09 Jim: but the problem is is that it is it's the thin end of the wedge of things that he gave up, which gives the worst people more power, and and it's why people like Marjorie Taylor green, Lauren boba and Paul Gosar are all on the oversight committee, which is a powerful committee which will actually it won't achieve anything, but it'll do a lot of stuff that that will make noise, and they have already prevent a lot of things, started to do bad things, like they used to have a committee, a subcommittee, on civil Rights and civil liberties as part of the oversight committee, which seems like a reasonable thing for for there to be oversight on, and they've disbanded that committee because they don't give a shit about your civil Rights or civil liberties.
1:17:57 Mark: They want to curb them as much as possible.
1:17:59 Jim: Yeah, james coma, who was a fucking arsehole Republican, uh, congressman from kentucky.
1:18:04 Mark: He was a who who? Frankie bunker cunt.
1:18:07 Jim: Uh, yeah, he has said that it doesn't matter that they're disbanding this, this subcommittee. He's also on the oversight committee. Um, in fact, he's the chairman of the oversight committee. He's. He's the one who has been saying how very, very, very important it is to investigate the Biden documents issue and hunter Biden and all of that kind of stuff. Yeah, because there might be some kind of foreign interference or something, or Biden might have have given documents to people and then, when asked, okay, well, what about Trump? It was like, oh, there's no evidence that Trump did anything.
1:18:40 Jim: So, yeah, that arsehole, he said, let me be very clear, any topic that's not mentioned in the subcommittee jurisdiction is reserved for full committee. We can have a committee hearing in this committee on basically anything we want. So he's saying: you know, it doesn't matter that there's not a subcommittee, we can still look at civil Rights and things in the main committee. Which is basically saying sub committees are meaningless, we don't need any for anything and and that. But that isn't all of that. That isn't the route they've taken. They've just disbanded this one. Yeah, they've just gone, not anything else. Let's not care about civil Rights so much as some of the other things we have sub committees for.
1:19:17 Mark: Yeah, because we can take care of that in a yeah, like that, like right, like they will.
1:19:22 Jim: Theoretically, it could come up in main committee. Yeah, but yeah, so. So the arseholes in the House are doing bad stuff and will continue to do bad stuff, because Kevin McCarthy, who is supposedly the leader of the House, cannot do anything about it, because he's given ground to these people and is serving at their whim, because one of the other things he gave them was the ability to get rid of him very easily.
1:19:54 Mark: Yeah, vote me in, because what I'm going to do is allow you to vote me out, not just, not just. You know I don't need a majority vote or anything but, or, but. Anyone could bring that up at any point and we can have a vote on it and you can get me out. Let's do it on that basis. That's open and transparent and full of integrity, but it's also weak and stupid. And yeah, well, you know, when you got, when you've had 14 votes, you're gonna give. What else must I give away in order to get? Why would you want to be in office when there's no power or substance to your office? Because you've had to give it all away in order to get into that office. As groucho marx once said, I wouldn't want to join a club that would have me as a member. And finally, some things we really don't have time to talk about
1:20:53 Jim: In what must be one of the most frequently reused headlines since we started this show, it’s been a bad couple of weeks in court for Trump. To be honest I can’t remember the last time Trump had a good week in court, but even he doesn’t usually end up owing almost a million dollars for having such bad lawyers. Judge Donald Middlebrooks, who last September threw out Trump’s lawsuit against Hillary Clinton accusing her of rigging the 2016 election – yes, the one Trump won – ordered Trump and his attorney Alina Habba to pay $938,000 in a scathing ruling that included lines like “This case should never have been brought. Its inadequacy as a legal claim was evident from the start. No reasonable lawyer would have filed it”. Meanwhile, in a separate case, New York Attorney General Letitia James has asked another judge to impose sanctions on Trump’s legal team after showing that Trump, several of his children and his lawyers lied multiple times in depositions and in written responses to questions posed in the fraud case currently underway. Which is particularly impressive, since Trump pleaded the fifth more than 400 times during his depositions in the case. The judge questioned the Trump team’s initial response, saying “In my 35 years practicing law, I have never, never… seen a pleading with such excess verbiage as the 300-page-or-so answers of the 15-or-so answers to the complaint” and has actually asked Trump’s lawyers to have another go. Perhaps this time they won’t take the unusual step of claiming there’s no such thing as the Trump Organisation like they did the first time despite Alina Habba announcing herself in court, during this case, as representing Donald Trump and the Trump Organisation. organization.
1:22:32 Mark: Okay so in the saga of Car-a-lago Lynne Patton’s term – she’s a right-wing what? commentator? Journalist? Nah the equivalent, along with Lara Trump and Erin Elmore on RightView’s ex-president’s daughter-in-law’s podcast, of the UK’s Loose Women; washed up z-listers employed to up the gender balance when it comes to whinging ignorantly about Huffpost hot topics. Through a pointless expenditure of energy and creativity (just think with brains like that they could be addressing world poverty and peace) These three maintain that no-one would store classified documents in a private garage next to their corvette – a dozen or so you remember, rather than the proper way to do it – 10s of thousands in a publicly accessible golf club. No one would do this so its obviously cos the Dems planted them there – Obama did it – in order to get rid of Biden now he’s served his purpose of winning the election maintaining the Senate and holding the House to a tiny majority. We’re reminded of foresight attributed to Trump in the good ol days of Q posts – who incidentally has gone silent since June last year after a two year hiatus prior to that – and the QAnoners who’d be able to see that Trump foresaw the election results fifteen years before Hilary was born etc etc. Look if the Dems had actually revealed that they’d win in 2020, hold the senate and reduce the GOP to a hamstrung whiny infighting majority in the house that took 15 goes to elect a leader, and with a septuagenarian older than Trump yet, they’d have been laughed at in the face. So yeah okay it was all planned and hidden and everything, but hey if it works is it such a bad idea?
1:24:27 Jim: Another guy who’s had a bad week recently, legally speaking, is Richard “Bigo” Barnett, who was convicted on eight counts, including four felonies, for his part in the insurrection and now faces up to 20 years in prison. You’ll remember Bigo as the guy who was photographed with his feet up on Nancy Pelosi’s desk. His lawyers tried various tactics throughout the trial including suggesting he couldn’t get a fair trial in DC because a jury made up of mostly Democrats wouldn’t be a jury of his peers, then claiming he was just caught up in the surge into the Capitol and was looking for a bathroom when he stumbled, all innocent-like into Nancy’s office. The fact that, while there, he left a note on her desk saying “Nancy, Bigo was here bi-otch” and then tried to copyright the phrase after he was arrested didn’t really help their case, nor did Bigo’s understanding of the Bill of Rights when he claimed he was just a patriot. The prosecutor asked him “You love the Constitution?” “Love it!” Bigo said. “First Amendment?” the prosecutor asked. “Yes,” he said. “Second Amendment?” “Yes” “Love the Third Amendment?” “Yes,” and then the prosecutor asked “What’s the Third Amendment?” and Bigo paused and said, “I don’t know.”
1:25:38 [Unclear]: I'm
1:25:45 Mark: surprised, it just didn't please the fifth, each and every time. What you’d get if you typed “A photo of an angry overweight embittered wannabe politician made of pillows, with a large outdated moustache” into an AI image generator: Mike Lindell, apparently didn’t foresee that one day he wouldn’t be the leader of the RNC. “The pillow guy? That’s kind of a joke.” said by one of the voting RNC members must have been music to Lindell’s second-pluck duck-stuffed ears, after all it didn’t seem to phase the GOP when Trump ran for nomination by the party, so “Well, why wouldn’t I win? I am more qualified”. You gotta admire Lindell’s determination, his sheer manifestation would surely be enough but dammit if reality didn’t intervene at the party’s winter meeting in Dana Point, California where he garnered only 4 of the 168 votes; Ronna McDaniel won the election with 111 votes. Still he outdid Kevin Phillips Bong (Silly Party) who as you’ll recall polled no votes at all, not a sausage, bugger all. Despite his crushing defeat Lindell remains plumped up and fluffy, “Do you even know how this works?” he responded to the criticism that he’d whipped very few votes. “Wake up!” Which is rich coming from a dreamer who sells sleep materials! Still could be worse we could have got Ronna McDaniel… oh no wait…
1:27:13 Jim: In an impressive unbroken run of freaking out about made up stuff, Fox ‘News’ is outraged at XBox for their latest update, which according to one host, shows that “They’re trying to recruit your kids into climate politics at an earlier age – make them climate conscious now”, to which his co-idiot then replied “You’re right – they’re going after the children!” So, what news led to this I’m sure entirely justified panic about children knowing about stuff? Surely an insidious new game that indoctrinates young minds under cover of entertainment and forces them to offset carbon emissions to unlock achievements and win premium downloadable content? Not quite. You see, the XBox power settings include a power saving shutdown mode that draws less power than the standard standby mode. The new update will make that more energy efficient version the default, thereby saving their users a little bit on their electric bills and saving a substantial amount of energy when you add all the XBoxes together. Evil bastards.
1:28:14 [Unclear]: What the fuck?
1:28:16 Mark: And quite right, FoxU, to point that stuff out.
1:28:20 Jim: Won't somebody think of the children?
1:28:23 [Unclear]: Children.
1:28:24 Mark: But somebody? Think of all the angry subscribers. We've got to keep paying us money to make them angry and justify their expense. What the fuck? That's brilliant. “Can you not vet the ads on Truth?” asked one user in a post on Trump’s own Truth Social social media platform directly to Trump. “I’ve been scammed more than once.” Well two things – what did you expect, and what do you think they’d do? oh three – why did you do it the second time? Apparently advertisers, real advertisers of real verifiable products and reputations aren’t that enamoured of advertising on Truth Social. It’s difficult for them to get all the information they need about how well the adverts are doing cos the monitoring systems are a bit antiquated, that and whilst its important for advertisers to be associated with leading politicians, Bob Hoffman, an advertising industry veteran and the author of The Ad Contrarian, a newsletter critical of the industry says “It’s not in their best interest to get involved in that quagmire.” Truth is burning through about $1.7 million each month and they only raised about 37 million to start with so advertising revenue is sorely needed especially as two federal investigations have also put about $1.3 billion of much-needed funding in jeopardy. Whilst the demographic is somewhat narrow, older, right-wing, dare we say self-confessed conspiracy-theoristy and hyperpartisan soccer-momish? So consequently not much of a draw for the big advertising guns especially since Truth Social’s first avowed intent voiced by Devin Nunes (remember him?) was to “displace the Big Tech platforms”. However if you want to buy the chance to win a solid gold 1,000-dollar bill given away free by Trump and aren’t bothered by the snake-oil salesmen who are running the competition with its not gold, not free, not given by Trump, non-1,000 dollar bill, then the platform could use all the gullible help and cash you can give it.
1:30:33 Jim: I’m thinking of moving to the US and becoming a political consultant, since it seems like the easiest job in the entire world, largely because the politicians themselves are so fundamentally lacking in self awareness that they are prepared to pay huge amounts for obvious answers they just can’t figure out for themselves. Take, for example, the Pennsylvania GOP, who have hired DC based firm Public Opinion Strategies to solve the mystery of why they did so poorly in the 2022 midterms. The quest for a solution to this conundrum is expected to set them back a cool 100 grand, and involve focus groups, voter interviews and other research. It’s worth it, of course, because currently the brightest minds in the Pennsylvania Republican party are completely stumped about why they shat the bed in the midterms and wisdom so esoteric can only be gained through great effort and financial sacrifice. If, at the end of this odyssey, the consultants don’t come back with “You ran Dr Oz and Doug Mastriano and your party just set women’s rights back 50 years” then they might have overpaid, and I would have told them for half the price, is all I’m saying.
1:31:39 Mark: I was gonna say you can undercut them by 50 percent and still retire. In Britain Rishi Sunak continues to insist he is upholding “integrity, professionalism and accountability at every level” after sacking Nadim Zahawi as Tory Party Chairman for breaking the ministerial code. Not because former chancellor Zahawi had to pay a 3 million pounds-odd fine to the taxman for things he didn’t declare whilst he was Chancellor, nor for the fact that he untruthfully called the Independent newspaper’s investigations into the fact that he had not declared various receipts of monies that would require the payment of millions of pounds worth of tax as a “smear”, but cos he had not declared that he was under investigation by the revenue when he was given the job of chancellor. Of course Zahawi maintains that oh if by “under investigation” you mean they were asking questions and looking into my past business dealings then sure, but I wasn’t “under investigation”. It’s a kind of reverse Al Capone trap – he was tried for tax evasion in lieu of being able to pin any actual moiders on him and Zahawi was found guilty of breaking the ministerial code about be untruthful in lieu of being able to do him down for undeclared earnings from offshore accounts. That of course is at the heart of the Tory’s soul, “no offshore tax loopholes closed under EU law in our country we’ve taken back control” cos why else do you think they fought so hard to get out of Europe! Sunak of course said he acted as soon as he knew, which I suspect contains an oh if by knew you meant had any inkling of in an official breaks-the-promise-of-integrity-and-accountability kind of way then I didn’t “know” cos I didn’t have the job of Prime Minister at the time. Worryingly on the face of it, on the other side of the house Labour’s Starmer gave a speech using such phrases as “Labour is not the party of protest but of public service” on the eve of an act banning strikes for public service workers being presented to parliament and the largest and most widespread strike by public service workers; you know, the very people for whom the Labour party was founded to represent. I fear that Tory-light Starmer is pandering to the worlds of media barons and business to show that Labour is an electable proposition despite the people’s actual propositions for electing Labour, decent pay, supporting the strikers rights, taxing the rich, curbing the obscene profits of energy companies, and voting for Jeremy Corbyn as leader. Let’s face it with these media barons you can be sure the revolution will not be televised – unless there’s money in it.
1:34:31 Jim: So that's all the bad arguments and faulty reasoning we have time for this week. You'll find the show notes at fallacioustrump .com, and if you hear Trump say something stupid and want to ask if it's a fallacy, our contact details are on the contact page.
1:34:41 Mark: If you think we use fallacy ourselves, let us know. And if you've had a good time, please give us a review on Apple Podcasts, Stitcher or wherever you get podcasts, or simply tell one other person in person about how much they like our podcast. And you can support the show at Patreon .com slash ftrump, just like our Strawman -level patrons Don Toovey, Rene, Zed, Schmutz, Mark Reikian, Amber R. Buchanan, who told us when we met her at QED we can just call her Amber – and our true Scotsman -level patrons Stephen Bickle, Janet Yuetter, Kaz Toohey, Andrew Houck, Max Beaver and our top patron, Lauren. Thank you so much for your continued support. It really is very much appreciated.
1:35:20 Jim: You can connect with those awesome people, as well as us and other listeners, in the Facebook group at Facebook .com. Slash groups, slash Fallacious Trump.
1:35:27 Mark: All music is by the outbursts and was used with permission. So until next time on Fallacious Trump, we'll leave the last word to the Donald.
1:35:35 [Outro] That's right. Go home to mommy. Bye. Bye.
1:35:39 Jim: So that's all the bad arguments and faulty reasoning we have time for this week. I just ran out of breath. I don't know why I started with so little breath. It's not even a long sentence.
