Hasty Generalization FT#14

ShareBlueskyThreadsFacebookRedditEmail

Show Notes

The fallacy of Hasty Generalization is committed when an assumption is made based on too little information. It may, for example, be that a small sample of a large group has been observed, and the properties of this sample are assumed to be present in the larger group.

This is fallacious because we don’t know how representative the sample is of the larger group. Statistics based on small sample sizes aren’t reliable, and can be misleading, so they shouldn’t be relied upon when making generalizations.

Trump

We started out with Trump talking about Mexicans:

 

Mark’s British Politics Corner

Mark talked about this Vote Leave TV ad:

Then, bizarrely, we looked at this clip from The Grand Tour, because Mark couldn’t wait until the Fallacy in the Wild section:

 

Fallacy in the Wild (Sting: Wild Wild Life by Talking Heads)

In the Fallacy in the Wild we looked at this clip from Batman:

Then we talked about this clip from Friends:

 

 

Fake News

Here are the statements from this week’s Fake News game:

  1. I think the press was very, very tough on Rick Perry. But certainly, I would think he would be the first to admit it wasn’t his finest hour, or, as the expression goes, two hours.
  2. Hopefully China is going to be happy. I think we will be happy. And as the expression goes, when you’re losing $500 billion a year on trade, you can’t lose the trade war; you’ve already lost it.
  3. I don’t need advisors to tell me about tariffs. Some people do – Hillary would – but I advise myself. Nobody knows more about trade than me and, as the expression goes, I have a very good brain.

Click below for the answer

SpoilerStatement 3 is Fake News. Mark chose number 1

Mark got it wrong this week, and is currently on 23%

 

A perjury trap is not a logical fallacy

We talked about Cohen pleading guilty and Manafort getting his plea deal revoked

 

The stories we really didn’t have time to talk about:

  • The votes are finally in, and the Democrats picked up a total of 40 House seats, and won with the largest midterm vote margin in history. And that’s actual history, not Trump’s version, where nobody’s ever done as much winning as him.
  • Speaking of winning, General Motors is laying off 15% off it’s workers and closing 5 factories in the US and Canada, partly due to the $1 billion they’ve lost due to the steel tariffs.  Canada’s PM Justin Trudeau tweeted “we’ll do everything we can to help the families affected by this news get back on their feet” while Trump tweeted “We are now looking at cutting all GM subsidies, including for electric cars”, because revenge is way more fun than helping people.
  • According to Donald, Ivanka and just about every Republican spokesperson, Ivanka’s use of a private email account to conduct official government business, is absolutely nothing like Hillary’s use of a private email account to conduct official government business, and anyone who says they’re the same is just crazy. Just because she sent hundreds of emails to cabinet officials, White House aides and her assistant, does not mean you should chant ‘lock her up’ next time you see her.
  • Trump is still working his way through his copy of “Dictatorship for Dummies” and it looks like he’s reached the chapter on Propaganda, because during one of his daily twitter attacks on CNN this week, he proposed starting a state run TV network to tell the world how great he is.  Which will probably put Fox News’ nose out of joint cos they thought they were definitely a shoe-in for the job. 
  • The confirmation of Trump judicial nominee Thomas Farr to the Eastern District of North Carolina is not going so smoothly.  With Senator Jeff Flake refusing to confirm any nominees until the government agrees to protect the Mueller investigation, and all Democrats voting against, it would be a tie vote, but for the fact that Senator Tim Scott has announced he will vote to oppose.  Nobody knows why, exactly, but it could have something to do with the fact that Senator Scott is the only African American Senator in the GOP, and Thomas Farr is a white supremacist who fights against civil rights.
  • According to psychologists, men who are worried they might have small dicks are more likely to have voted for Trump. A pair of NYU psychologists studied the regional levels of google searches for terms such as ‘penis enlargement’; ‘penis size’; ‘erectile dysfunction’; and ‘how to get girls’, compared the results to the regional voting trends in 2016 and 2018 and found a strong correlation.  If you listened to the last episode, you’ll know not to assume a causative link, but it would explain a few things.
  • The government chose Black Friday to quietly release a federally mandated report on climate change which began “Earth’s climate is now changing faster than at any point in the history of modern civilization, primarily as a result of human activities.” But nobody panic, because Trump says it’s fine.  He told the Washington Post “One of the problems that a lot of people like myself — we have very high levels of intelligence, but we’re not necessarily such believers.” So, you just have to choose who to believe – the scientists of the 13 federal agencies that make up the US Global Change Research Program, with their ‘facts’ and ‘evidence’, or people like Donald Trump, with their ‘very high levels of intelligence’.
  • After Trump claimed that the President Niinistö of Finland had told him that they rake the forest floors to prevent forest fires, everyone in Finland made fun of Trump on twitter, posting photos of themselves sweeping, raking and vaccuuming the forest, with hashtags such as #RakeNews and #RakeAmericaGreatAgain. It must feel great for Trump to be respected again all over the world.

 

If you wanted to buy a T-shirt featuring this fallacy, you could click here. No pressure

And if you have some money left over after that, Jim’s book, 2000 Mules and One Big Lie: A Stubborn Conspiracy Theory is available now.

That’s almost all for this week, but here’s our AI-aided transcript, which is quite accurate, but not totally:

Hasty Generalization – FT#14 Transcript

Read the full transcript

00:53 Jim: Hello and welcome to Fallacious Trump, the podcast where we use the insane ramblings of a petulant toddler to explain logical fallacies. I'm your host, Jim.

01:00 Mark: And I'm your other host, Mark. And there's a bit of a special episode this time because we're actually in the same room together. I can see Jim's face from where I am. Normally we record this via the wonders of the internet, about 50 miles apart, something like that. So there might be a slightly different audio quality to it this time. It's actually been quite fun seeing each other's smiling faces – faces across the table where we are at Fallacious studios right now. A logical fallacy is an error in reasoning that results in bad or invalid arguments, and the logical fallacy we're looking at this week across the table in each other's faces, is the hasty generalization, also known as an argument from small numbers leaping to conclusions and converse accident fallacy.

01:49 Jim: So hasty generalization is when you use a small sample size or the first example that you find of something and then assume that all things that share one aspect of that share all of the traits of it. So if you just test one part of a sample of a large group of people and you find one trait that that small sample has in common, you assume all the people in that group share that trait. And it's basically where stereotyping comes from. It's the quick method of knowing something about a group of people you've never met before. It's the beginnings of prejudice, basically okay, yeah, so, given trump's predilection for prejudice for that and stereotypes, uh, obviously it does come up in his speeches and actually the most notable one and the one that tends to get pulled out as an example of hasty generalization from from Trump, is right from when he first announced his candidacy.

02:51 Clip: Trump talking about Mexicans

— When Mexico sends its people, they're not sending their best. They're not sending you. They're not sending you. They're sending people that have lots of problems, and they're bringing those problems with us. They're bringing drugs. They're bringing crime. They're rapists. And some, I assume, are good people.

03:13 Jim: On Trump is is obviously here saying a general thing about mexicans as a whole, about immigrants really, but specifically in this case about mexicans and – and he can probably cite, and has cited in the past, specific instances, specific cases of particular illegal immigrants who have committed crimes. And in fact, in the kind of the closing moments of the race towards the midterms, the Trump campaign released a video, an advert for the Republican Party, basically saying: vote for us, which focused on one particular illegal immigrant who had killed some policemen.

03:53 Mark: Right, yeah, and was saying:

03:55 Jim: look, the Democrats let this person in, which wasn't true. And and who else are they going to let in? It's kind of as the beginning of a slippery slope. But it was also saying that this is what immigrants are like. You don't want more of them. So by doing that he is. He is saying that, generalizing that that thing that you can sometimes say about one person in a group is true of all the people in the group,

04:17 Mark: even though he says at the end: but I assume there's some good ones amongst that.

04:23 Jim: Yeah, he's allowing for the odd exception, yeah, but, but.

04:26 Mark: But. So, given the numbers game that he's playing, it's just as true for him to say, actually, so there are one or two good people, so the rest of them are good. He can, he ought to be doing that's that he's. He's choosing to focus on the bad guys because that serves his purposes, but he's kind of you're in the interest balance, saying, well, I must be one or two good ones. No, there are only one or two bad ones.

04:57 Jim: Yeah, yeah, if you have a, a small sample size of anything. Basically, if you, if you don't put enough effort into finding out about a group, yeah, of whatever it is – people or anything – then you don't, you can't necessarily make a conclusion based on what you found if it's just a small sample size. It's why Why, when people do randomised controlled trials, they need to have a large number of people involved, a large number of people they're studying, to be robust, to make sure that it is a valid thing that they are concluding. Andrew Wakefield, who caused the whole vaccine scare from autism, he based his conclusions on nine individual cases. Oh, that was what the study that was published in the lancet that that he concluded that these particular people who had had problems following following vaccine there was also issues that he was um being paid by a um a company who made an alternative vaccine. Okay, that that complicated things as well. Yeah, the actual study, peer -reviewed as it was, had had such a small n number um that that it was really worthless to generalise from that to everyone.

06:06 Mark: So it's illegitimate to scale up, to say this therefore applies to absolutely everybody.

06:12 Jim: It ignores the fact that there are exceptions in groups. And even if you can say something that is broadly true of the group, there are going to be people in that group who aren't like that. And if the people that you happen to be looking at are those exceptions, then you're making a very bad decision.

06:29 Mark: So it's a bit cherry-picking.

06:32 Jim: It can be cherry-picking if you're doing it deliberately.

06:36 Jim: So, which arguably Trump is in this case, but he's not. When you look at a group and you choose particular individuals and you say, look, this is true of these individuals, you're cherry -picking because you're not giving the information that those are exceptions.

06:51 Jim: In this case, he's not doing that. He's saying that they're all like that, basically.

06:57 Mark: Well, he's kind of implying that, Isn't he? So they only send the bad ones. But then he gets to the end of the list and in the you know for the uh, in this kind of impartiality thing, he goes: oh yeah, well, they'll send us some good ones as well, because he's talking about the negative, um, the you know the people that are uh, bad guys, drug, drugs, they got drugs and they're murderers, some of them rapists. Um, you kind of, uh, buy into that, because that's that plays into the whole thing about fear, and you think, oh yeah, no, that's really which is very good at. That's the thing to concentrate on. You latch on to that rather than think, than thinking. What they're sending are surgeons, judges, um, you know, experts in social cohesion, all that kind of stuff. Even.

07:48 Jim: It doesn't even have to be that. It can just be people who are law abiding, yeah, prepared to do jobs that Americans aren't prepared to do, yeah, and pay taxes. Net positive, yeah, for America, yeah, yeah, um, yeah, so it doesn't. They don't need to be, you know, the the best of society, they just need to be not the worst. Yeah, yeah, um. And in fact, what you see when you look at the figures is because there is this danger of if you attract attention from law enforcement, you're going to get deported. The The immigrant community typically has a much lower crime rate than the general population. So the Public Policy Institute of California. They looked at the statistics for men aged 18 to 40, which is the most commonly incarcerated age group and demographic. And in California, where obviously there's going to be more immigration from Mexico, 17 – .2 % of the non -incarcerated population are Mexican -born non -U .S. citizens, which is pretty high. That's almost one in five of the entire population of that age. Who aren't in general. Males 18 to 40 who are just, yeah, out in the general population are non-U.S. citizens from Mexico. In prison. Only 2, .9 percent of that age group are mexican -born immigrants. So unless they're just not being caught in the same numbers, which seems unlikely, they're not committing crimes at the same level as as American citizens are. Yeah, and that makes sense. Just to. To clarify on hasty generalization, there is, there is a similar fallacy, which is, um, the fallacy of composition, right, which, which is where you look at one aspect of something and assume that the whole that is made up of those things shares that trait. So, for example, if you had a car where the tyres were made in Germany, then if you assumed the entire car was made in Germany because of that, that's a fallacy of composition, because you're looking at a whole thing that's made up of lots of parts and you assume that the traits of one of the parts means that's the traits of the whole, whereas with hasty generalization, in that instance you would be assuming that because the tires were made in germany, all of the other parts of the car were also made in germany,

10:09 [Unclear]: right as opposed to the car as a whole,

10:12 Jim: which, yeah, together somewhere else from parts made in germany.

10:15 Mark: And so, and if you didn't particularly like the way that the germans made tires – because they're not pirellis, for instance – you could denigrate the whole of the structure of the car based on the fact, hastily generalizing, that the – uh, the german, particularly german, make tires actually meant that the whole car was rubbish, yeah, whereas actually it's just the tires.

10:40 Jim: Or you could assume, for example, that because the italians make good tires, they must make good cars,

10:45 Mark: really good cars, yeah, which, as alfa romeo owners will attest, is not the case,

10:52 Jim: whereas ferrari owners, yeah, yeah. Sometimes you just can't generalize,

10:57 [Sting: Mark's British Politics Corner] And now is the time, I think, for Mark's British Politics Corner.

11:01 Mark: The nice thing about doing this podcast is that you can go through the pain and awfulness of current British politics with a slightly detached ear and, rather than rant and rail about the how awful it all is, you just go. Is that an example of a? An exact example of that? And actually the the? Now that Boris is out of mainstream politics, he just kind of comes in every time. He thinks there's an opening for him to bid for the next leadership position that most of the British politicians are very good at not doing hasty generalizations. So I did look at Philip Hammond, who is the Chancellor of the Exchequer, and he was tasked with reporting on the findings that the Bank of England had published, which were how we would be off economically in Britain as a result of the deal that Theresa May has brokered with the EU. Versus no deal at all, versus staying in the EU. Basically, we're going to be worse off with every single deal or a no deal than if we stayed in the Eu. But nobody is doing any kind of big spinning um and hasty generalizing. You know, I was listening to philip hammond's report, listening to Mark carney, the uh control of the bank of England report, even jacob's reese mug – God help me um his rejoinder – to philip hammer's report, and none of them do the hasty generalization thing, um. So I had to go back to good old michael cove who, uh who part of his leave campaign video did this.

12:55 Clip: Vote Leave TV ad

— David cameron now claims Turkey won't join the EU, but that's not what he said before.

— This is something I feel very strongly, very passionately about. Together, I want us to pave the road from Ankara to Brussels.

— We are giving two billion pounds to Macedonia, Serbia, Albania, Montenegro and Turkey to join the EU. You can't trust David

13:23 Mark: So there's the hasty generalisation. This is also almost a non sequitur, because they are, incidentally the noises of kind of chaos and furore.

13:35 Clip: Vote Leave TV ad (continued)

— In the background is the Turkish parliament.

13:40 Mark: And they're using that as an example of how chaotic the whole. But if you listen to prime minister's questions it's not dissimilar. Um, the videos it's great to watch. It's a bit like watching berlusconi's italian parliament, because people are leaping across the tables and throwing things at each other, and so what the leave campaign is trying to draw the conclusion from and to is that David cameron is saying, having said, after this thing that he's just said, which is we want to pave the way for Ankara to join the EU. Basically, the Turkish and all the states around that part of Europe were all being wooed to join the EU. Cameron subsequently said they're not going to join the EU. It's a mistake to even think that they are and to use that as part of any kind of campaigning to say that we ought to get out of the EU. Even Boris famously said, do you want Turkey to join the EU? You and he said: yes, but only if we've left part of the. The thing is we're so we're paying two billion. So the the thing about it seems to me, about hasty generalization, is that you pick on a figure and then that leads you to a conclusion, but they're completely unsubstantiated and there's no other evidence other than this figure. They're saying we're paying two billion. Well, in what way? Where does it come from? Why? So for all of these states around Turkey to join the Eu? And then it says: if you want to save the nhs, vote leave.

15:13 [Unclear]: So the the non -sequitur bit,

15:16 Mark: the un, the, the implied bit is we could be spending that two billion on the nhs. If we spend it to get Turkey to join, then we it won't be available for the nhs. So I think there's the hasty generalization is it's dangerous for them to join, vote leave. So is the.

15:35 Jim: Is the generalization the fact that you can't trust him on the other things he said, so therefore you can't trust him on.

15:42 Mark: Well, I think there's a whole. Where's the generalization? I think the generalization is that, whatever happens, that if we get Turkey in, that would be bad for the nhs, and also that the generalization is that you should vote leave. But I don't see.

16:02 Jim: I don't see where the generalization is. I see the non -sequitur, yeah, right, yeah, but the generalization needs to have something which is an example of something, a sample or a small, yeah, part of it, yeah, which which then is assumed that all things that are like that share that set of traits. Right, so I can see how, if, um, if you're saying that because the person on the on the advert said: you know you couldn't trust him on Macedonia and all of these things. Therefore, essentially, the implied thing is you can't trust him overall at all, because, because you can't trust them on one thing. That's kind of a generalisation.

16:38 Mark: So you're choosing one example of a thing, and you're generalising that any other occurrence of this thing will be equally as bad.

16:47 Jim: They're going to share the negative thing that you've attributed to it.

16:50 Mark: Well, maybe this is a good time to play the other clip from those politically aware presenters of the Grand Tour. So Jeremy Clarkson… So we're not going to do that in Fallacy in the Wild. No, let's do it now. Because we've got other examples for Fallacy in the Wild. But these are, so I would maintain that Jeremy Clarkson is the most successful right-wing comic in television. I agree.

17:22 Jim: I can't believe we're doing Top Gear in the British politics.

17:28 Mark: Well, okay. But he is a big supporter of the right-wing politics. However, he did come out as a Remain, purely on the basis that it would be much more difficult for them to get travel visas if we left. So his example is not very political, but it is taking one example of something and then generalising that, as it turns out, to the World.

17:59 Clip: The Grand Tour

— The thing is, though, OK, even though a Jaguar is an international get-out-of-jail-free card, very few people actually ever buy one. I mean, who here's got a Jag? One, two… Only three people in Britain try Jaguars.

18:14 Mark: So he cuts out, he even cuts out the middle bit. He cuts out the, there are three people in the audience. Therefore there's a very small percentage of the entire British Isles who own a Jag. He just goes from three people in Britain to all the people that own them are in my audience.

18:33 Jim: I mean, obviously it's for comic effect, but that is exactly what he's doing. Is he's taking this sample, which is the studio audience, and extrapolating that, generalizing that across the entire UK population? This audience not only represents the UK population, the three people in the audience who have Jaguars are the only ones in the UK. OK, so, yeah, but obviously for comic effect, so we can let him get away with that.

19:06 [Sting: Fallacy in the Wild (Wild Wild Life – Talking Heads)]

19:24 Mark: There we go. There's David Byrne and Talking Heads.

19:30 Jim: OK.

19:31 Mark: Doing wild, wild life.

19:34 Jim: So in the Fallacy in the Wild, we like to talk about the fallacy of the week from a non -political perspective, using a bit of pop culture. Um, I'm not sure you could describe this, this one, as pop culture. It's going back a bit. Um, this is um it was,

19:47 Mark: it was pop culture in the 60s, exactly, yeah, yeah, but where else is it? Yeah, sure, just yeah.

19:53 Jim: So this is, uh, an episode of batman, yeah, from, uh, from the original series with adam west, and what happens just before this clip is that cat woman scrapes her nails across something which appears to be some kind of poison and then um touches batman and robin with her with her long nails. So, uh, yes, it is a. It is a hasty generalization for robin to say that you, You can never trust a woman.

20:52 Mark: Yeah, just because this particular one, who is a foe and happens to be female, utilised her cat-like nails, claws probably, to poison them. Yeah, it's a bit of a hasty gesture.

21:10 Jim: It is, in this situation, entirely apropos.

21:16 [Unclear]: Hasty or not. Yeah, yeah, yeah.

21:19 Jim: So absolutely small sample size. You're just basing, basing your decision on one person and assuming that's true of all women. Yeah, uh, yes, not. Not logically valid. So moving on to our next example is an episode of friends and chandler has been to visit joey's taylor.

21:38 Clip: Friends

— Joey's Taylor took advantage of me. What? No way. I've been going to the guy for 12 years. Oh, come on. He said he was going to do my inseam. Then he ran his hand up my leg and then there was definite

— what?

— Cupping.

— That's how they do pants. First, they go up one side, they move it over. Then they go up the other side, they move it back and then they do the rear. Ross, will you tell him? Isn't Isn't that how a tailor measures pants? Yes, yes, it is. In prison!

22:21 Jim: So, Joey has limited experience of going to the tailor. He has only one example of tailors. He's been going to the same tailor for 12 years, so since he was probably like 12-ish, I guess. And he is assuming that all tailors do the same thing. He's generalizing to that's how they do pants. That's how tailors measure you. Because that's his only experience. Yeah, um, and he's using a small sample to make that generalization.

22:52 Mark: Well, it's not a hasty generalization if he's been doing it for 12 years.

22:55 Jim: It's hasty in the sense that you need more information. You need to gather more information before you can make that assumption that that is how everyone does measure. Yeah, yeah, we, we all kind of have this, this cognitive bias, where we assume that other people's experience is the same as ours and when we do have a very limited experience of a thing, it is natural to assume that everyone sees it in the same way. For example, if you have a bad experience with an insurance company, if you, if you try and make a claim and they don't pay out, then it's, it's understandable. If you think, well, just all it's your, all insurance companies are just trying to to avoid making a pay. Yeah, yeah, yeah, because it goes along with not only your own personal experience but kind of things you hear from other people when they've had problems. But obviously it's likely that the people who have problems are the ones who are. We're going to talk about it.

23:44 Mark: Yeah, yeah, yeah, um, and that's the whole basis of of, uh, trust pilot.

23:49 Jim: So, yeah, it's, it's completely normal for us as humans to to assume that our experience is universal. Yeah, but actually you need to remember when you're going through life that that actually you can't necessarily generalize your own experience out to everyone. Or indeed, if, if you haven't got a lot of experience in a particular area, that the the little experience you have is is representative of everything.

24:13 Mark: Well, that's kind of the the thing that powers the advertising, for if you swap um insurance policy brokers, you will save 483 pounds a year. And then it says: you know, based on a survey of four people, yeah, yeah. So that is absolutely the thing.

24:33 Jim: It depends how many people you survey. If you have a set of of. In the Uk, for example, our population is about about 68, 69 million, something like that. Um, when, if they do a phone survey, yeah, to find out who's going to vote a particular way, or or to find out who likes particular kind of product, and they survey 100 people, that's not going to give you a very good example, even if they try and make that survey demographically relevant to to the Uk. The the larger that sample becomes, the more you can can rely on it to say: this is a true thing about this population. Yeah, um, but at small sample sizes, which is which is why this – an alternative title for this – is an argument from small numbers, um, at small sample sizes, you can't make an assumption that what you have found is the rule rather than the exception.

25:25 Mark: Yeah, you need to question the, the, the source, the, the, the polling number. Yeah, So in order to counter something like Trump's? You know they're only sending the bad Mexicans. You think, well, yeah, okay, how many bad Mexicans have you counted and how many Mexicans have come across the border? So in order to counter it, you'd need to say, okay, how many are you sampling from the large number and why are you drawing? So. So you can't legitimately draw the conclusion that you're drawing from those tiny numbers.

26:08 Jim: And and the other thing is, it's not only the size of the sample, but how you collect that sample as well. If you wanted to, for example, find out how often people go to the cinema, and what you did was stand outside a cinema and ask people coming out how often they go, yeah, what what you're getting is a biased sample, yeah, you're finding – of people who come to the cinema. Yeah, yeah, how, how often do they get? Yeah, if you, if you ask people generally, you might find it's a lower, a lower number. Yeah, because there's some people who don't go to cinema much at all. So, yeah, it is. It's really important how you take the sample, who you're sampling. If you, if you either get a very small sample or a biased sample, then you're not able to effectively generalize that out to a whole book.

26:53 Mark: There used to be that uh advert for cat food which was: eight out of ten cats prefer whiskers, prefer whiskers. And you think, well, they have to modify that to eight out of ten cats whose owners expressed a preference. Yeah, which is the equivalent of standing outside the cinema. How many people go to the cinema. Of a survey taken outside the cinema, yeah, versus of a survey taken outside an opera house.

27:17 Jim: So one of the other names for the hasty generalization is the converse accident fallacy, and the reason for that is that there's another fallacy called the accident fallacy, which is the opposite of nothing to do with falling over in your high top training shoes, it's not, no. So the accident fallacy is where you assume that a thing that is generally true is also true of every specific case within the collection. So, for example, lying is wrong, wrong. Therefore, there's no possibility, there's no option. Where lying is right, there aren't any possibilities. There are, you know, each individual case. Lying is always wrong. Yeah, and that's a Fantasy, because sometimes there are exceptions to rules. So so the accident Fantasy assumes there are no exceptions.

28:06 Mark: So you're going from a general, you're going from general down to specifics, which means that, okay, so when politicians say I can't possibly comment on a specific example, example when being asked about what's the general trend, what they're doing is is countering the accident fallacy.

28:27 Jim: Sometimes that might be the case. So if, if they are, if they know something about the, the general population, yeah, um, and then they're being asked to comment on a specific case. They don't actually know about that case. Yeah, they might. They might actually be be using that out validly. Yeah, yeah, I don't know about the specific incidents. So, yeah, that's the accident Fantasy, and so the converse accident Fantasy is going to go the other way.

28:50 Mark: Yeah, go specific to general ramping it up. Well, that's interesting, Isn't it? Because that the never thought about that, that that is actually a fallacy when you think you hold that, where something is held to be generally true, therefore, you ought not to look at any specific case. Yeah, I, Because it's going to be true. You know, the same circumstances are going to pertain for an individual case.

29:21 Jim: You might say, for example, that men like sport. That's generally held to be true. That is a stereotype of men. I'm a man, not that into sport. Really couldn't give a shit about sport. Unless England are involved and it's the World Cup. No, even then, I don't care. All right. If you're looking at me and see that I'm a man and therefore assume I'm into sport, yeah, which people do, because you know, if you meet another bloke and and start up a conversation, one of the things that comes up is what, yeah, yeah, yeah, um, yeah, and – and at which point I say I don't really follow.

29:58 Mark: I used to support chelsea in the 1970s. Yeah, yeah, so yeah. All the other example is: cannabis use is generally a bad thing. It's frowned. You know, cannabis is used by drug addicts. But then there was that specific case of the kid who had epileptic seizures and the only thing that could treat him was cannabis oil. And because of the general thing in the Uk that, because cannabis is only used by drug abusers, it is therefore the use is banned. Yeah, they banned him from using it, which which actually there was a petition to allow him to get it on prescription and the, the home secretary in Britain allowed that to happen, which kind of opened the doors for, you know, cannabis oil being used for therapeutic stuff. So we will probably talk more about the accident

30:55 Jim: fallacy on a future episode, but, um, yeah, that that's the basis of it.

31:00 [Sting: Fake News] So we're gonna, we're gonna – play fake news folks, I love the game. It's a great game. I understand the game as well as anybody. As well as anybody.

31:08 Jim: Yes, it's time for fake news. The game where I read out three Trump quotes, two of which are real and one I made up, and Mark has to figure out which one is fake news and,

31:17 Mark: going on last week's experience, to do it successfully, yeah, which I'm very buoyed by the whole experience.

31:25 Jim: Well, you are currently at 25%. And you have an opportunity this week to go up to 31%. Oh, my God, that's great. So would you be approaching chance at that point?

31:40 Mark: We should try and make a hasty generalisation. So if I get up to,

31:45 Jim: what is it, 31%? 31%, yeah. If you get this one and the next one right, then you'll be above chance.

31:52 Mark: Okay, yeah, excellent. So, and what is the hasty generalization? The hasty generalization is: I'm really very good at this.

32:00 Jim: Based on last week, yeah, yeah, absolutely yeah, yeah.

32:04 [Unclear]: So,

32:07 Jim: based on last week, it's likely that you'll get them all right.

32:10 Mark: Yeah, yeah, there's no, there's no way I can fail.

32:13 Jim: So the uh, the theme this week, okay, is that Trump doesn't seem to know what a saying is, what an expression is right, what's a popular thing to say yeah, so he just kind of yeah, he doesn't say um, well, let's just, it'll become clear, okay. So, uh, did he say number one? Yeah, I think the press was very, very tough on rick perry, but certainly I would think he would be the first to admit that it wasn't his finest hour, or, as the expression goes, two hours. It doesn't.

32:47 [Unclear]: Or?

32:48 Jim: Did he say number two? Hopefully, china is going to be very happy. I think we will be happy. And, as the expression goes, when you're losing 500 billion dollars a year on trade, you can't lose the trade war, you've already lost it.

33:01 Mark: That's that goes trippingly off the tongue, doesn't it? Or yeah, did

33:05 Jim: he say number three? Yeah, I don't need advisors to tell me about tariffs. Some people do, hillary would, but I advise myself. Nobody knows more about trade than me. And, as the expression goes, I have a very good brain.

33:16 Mark: I've only said that today. Actually, I have a very good brain. As the expression, what?

33:23 Jim: As the expression goes, these things are expressions,

33:26 [Unclear]: no, and that it's that.

33:28 Mark: It's that whole thing that he does, where he just kind of runs up to something absurd by saying, as we all know, or many people tell me, or as the expression goes, and then and he says something, and you're left with this, instead of just going, that Isn't the expression you're left with. Why don't I know that expression and that I had more examples of this that I could have used,

33:50 Jim: so we might have a part two.

33:52 [Unclear]: Okay, yeah, okay, okay, right, so it's very,

34:00 Mark: very, very, very tough. As the expression goes, two hours, it wasn't his finest hour, or, as the expression goes, as we all know, we found ourselves self -saying only this morning to uh, well, that, yeah, that's how I think. The well, yeah, given his is thinking that he's the best guy that to do a deal ever in his transactional politics, which I think is very kind of the commentators. Hopefully China's going to be happy. I think we'll be happy. As the expression goes, when you're losing 500 billion a year on trade you got perhaps, Perhaps that's a Confucian thing – literally translated from the Chinese, that we've just, you know, we've not come across. You've already lost it. I don't know. I think number three is true because I have a very good brain is very Trump. I know all the best words. I have a very good brain. I think press is a very tough word. I think you made up, though I do want him to say number two. God damn it. I think you made up, I think number one is the one you made up.

35:13 Jim: So you think that number two is real?

35:16 Clip: Trump, played during Fake News

— Yeah.

35:18 Mark: Mainly because I just wanted to have said it.

35:21 Jim: And number two is real.

35:25 Clip: Trump, played during Fake News

— Hopefully China's going to be happy. I think we will be happy. And, as the expression goes, when you're losing $500 billion a year on trade, you can't lose the trade war. You've already lost it.

35:41 Mark: What expression is that? What expression goes? It's more. It's like, you know, put a cat amongst pigeons, or as the expression goes.

35:56 [Unclear]: So, yes, that's good.

35:59 Mark: I'm very glad you said that right.

36:03 Jim: And do you think number three is real? I do, and number three is is fake news. Oh man, I'm afraid he didn't say that.

36:14 Mark: Oh, that's very convincing,

36:16 Jim: which means he did say number one. Number one is real.

36:22 Clip: Trump, played during Fake News

— I think the press was very, very tough on rick perry, but certainly I would think he would be the first to admit it wasn't his finest hour, or, as the expression goes, those two hours. It's

36:35 Jim: really not clear what he was going for.

36:39 Mark: No, no, it was that kind of thing of saying, well, as I always say, you know, but it doesn't lend it any more legitimacy. It's just made it up, that's oh, yeah, no, well, you see, I see what you did there with the other very good brain. You've hoodwinked me into think, because that's a very Trump thing today. I think he probably has said that.

37:02 Jim: He said things about his brain,

37:04 [Unclear]: definitely, yeah, yeah, the

37:08 Mark: fact that he can't locate it. So some people do. Hillary, would I advise myself? Yeah, and he, uh, well, actually that's a very, that's almost a um God, who was that? That was tony blair, wasn't it?

37:20 Jim: Did he say he advised himself?

37:21 Mark: Yeah, he said I, you know, I asked myself about the um, the, the, the wisdom of going into the iraq war with the Americans, and and then you go, oh well, that's all right then, tony, as long as you've checked with yourself, that's fine. Yeah, and as the expression goes, you can't lose the iraq war. You've already lost it.

37:43 Jim: Yeah, so I'm afraid that you're down to 23 percent.

37:49 Mark: no, oh, I've only slipped two percent.

37:51 Jim: Yeah, yeah, it's not too bad. Yeah, so you still, you still can get, yeah, over time back up to somewhere near random chance claw that,

38:00 Mark: yeah, it's only two percent, or, as the expression goes, you know, it's one percent between people.

38:07 Jim: So, podcast listeners, as the expression goes, I need your help to full Mark. Uh, if you think you can make up a convincing fake Trump quote, then share this episode on twitter, include your quote and the hashtag Fallacious Trump and I'll pick the best one and you'll be podcast famous. So it's time for the the part of the show that, this week at least, is called a perjury trap is not a logical fallacy, because this is the part of the show where we want to talk about all the crazy stuff that's happening around Trump. Uh, but we have to pick one subject, particularly crazy thing, and this week we are talking about the, the latest movements of the of the Muller investigation – yeah, particularly manifort and cohen in court and and the things that have come out of that. Because cohen this week has pleaded guilty. He's pleaded guilty previously to other things that were unrelated to the russia investigation, but this time he's actually pleaded guilty to something that is specifically part of the russia investigation and therefore he becomes the 33rd person charged as part of the investigation, part of the witch hunt and, um, he has pleaded guilty to lying to congress, basically right.

39:26 Mark: So he's basically saying: it's true, I made it up.

39:29 Jim: Yeah, he's he's. Well, Trump is saying that he's lying now, now that he lied.

39:34 [Unclear]: He didn't lie before, but now he's lying. He's lying about having lied.

39:38 Jim: Yeah, he's lying now to to get a. Isn't that too wrong? To make it right.

39:44 Jim: So the story is basically that when he spoke to Congress in 2017, he claimed that a Russian real estate deal that Trump had been trying to put together in 2016 or 2015 to 2016 finished in January 2016.

40:07 Mark: Before the…

40:08 Jim: Before he became the Republican nominee for president, before all the primaries, and it was all put to bed. It didn't, you know. It never went any further and it stopped in january 2016. He has now said that that deal, which is being reported as as building a Trump tower in moscow – but actually it's not quite that – it's actually that a a building was being built anyway and the the deal deal that was going to be done was that they would put trump's name on it. Essentially, it would be a Trump building, right, and they were going to pay him a hundred million dollars to have his name on it, essentially in moscow. That's a lot per letter, Isn't it, Isn't it? Yeah, that was the going to be the deal. Cohen initially said to congress that it had stopped in january 2016. No further discussion had been had about it. He'd only spoken to Trump about it three times and and not to anyone else in the Trump organization, and it was. It was just not a thing. It hadn't really happened. Actually, now he's saying that negotiations were still going on as late as june 2016, by which time Trump was the Republican nominee for president, and that he had spoken to Trump more times than three times and he had spoken to other members of the Trump family. I .e, ivanka, don, probably eric as well. Yeah, and this was during a time when Trump said he had no dealings in russia and they were trying to kind of soften the Republican party's stance against russia and it all becomes very um, collusiony about, about kind of the – if not collusion itself.

41:51 Mark: So it's kind of collusion -like.

41:54 Jim: And there's also reports that they were going to give Putin the $50 million penthouse at the top of this 100-story building.

42:03 Mark: Yeah, because Isn't there a bit where he kind of had got through to Putin's personal secretary in order to get a kind of endorsement, to give the green light for the deal or something?

42:13 Jim: Yeah, yeah, there's no doubt that this deal would have required interaction with the Russian government and with um, with, with a great deal of, uh, Russian input. Obviously, it being in russia, yeah, um, but also Trump would have been involved, with loans from Russian banks and and things like this, yeah, so it kind of puts don jr in the firing line a little bit and it, um, it directly links, uh, the people who were involved in the Trump campaign to russians during the campaign, during, like after, the point where he'd said that they'd stopped and been and stopped talking about this kind of thing. Interestingly, it also shows that cohen has been working with Muller because he has, he has got a deal. He's pleaded guilty because he's got some kind of plea deal and previously it looked like he wasn't dealing with Muller there. There had been no deal on the table before because the deals that the pleas that he had made had been non -muller related. They'd been referred to the the southern District court of new york.

43:20 Mark: So that's interesting, but but Trump is framing it as he's lying in order to get a deal.

43:28 Jim: Yeah, well, Trump is is doing his old thing of saying: I didn't do it and even if I had done it, it wouldn't be a crime.

43:37 Mark: I didn't do it. Yeah, if I did which I didn't, yeah, then it would because I didn't do it. But even if I did, yeah he's saying, he has,

43:45 Jim: has said that it's he was just a businessman doing business, perfectly happy doing business, no problem, just being business, and he's perfectly allowed to do business while he was campaigning and it was fine and everyone knew about it anyway, and he didn't do it.

43:58 Mark: I didn't cover it up and uh, yeah, yeah, because it was all. I was patently completely blatant about the whole thing.

44:06 Jim: And giuliani, brilliantly, has claimed that neither of the two versions of michael cohen's story creates a problem with what the president has testified happened in because because last week the president gave written answers to questions from, yeah, Muller, which seems to be probably the only testimony he's going to give in this case. He says he's not going to testify in person,

44:30 [Unclear]: he's all written out, yeah, he's, so he's,

44:32 Jim: he's had questions from muller's team and he's given written answers and and so in, as part of that testimony. Giuliani claims that neither either the version of michael cohen's story where the Trump tower in the moscow Trump tower deal stopped in january – yeah, or the one where it was continuing in june 2016 contradicts anything. The drum set, okay,

44:56 Mark: well, so that's the equivalent of saying, yeah, he didn't do anything wrong and even if he did, it wasn't wrong. Yeah, yeah, kind of so. So the one, so yeah, so it's this one or that one, it doesn't matter, because neither will apply. What the hell that's?

45:15 Jim: The other interesting thing that has happened this week with miller is that they have voided manifort's plea deal because manifort previously had he? He pled guilty to various crimes. He accepted the 10 counts that that the jury had had hung on previously and and not been able to reach a verdict on. He. He essentially pled guilty to those in exchange for a lighter sentence. Yeah, yeah, and there was asset forfeiture as well, which, which more than funded the entire investigation, and this week, Muller has essentially announced that Manafort has been lying to the special counsel's team and therefore his plea deal is is void. So he, the guilty pleas still stand. Yeah, but they don't have to give him a reduced sentence now,

46:10 [Unclear]: right, and he's no longer working with them.

46:13 Jim: Yeah, but the interesting thing about this is that Manafort's lawyer has been reporting back to Trump's legal team. Yeah, if you want to call it that, Giuliani at least. Yeah, which is interesting because they have – they had a joint defense defense agreement, yeah, uh, which means that the lawyers get to interact with each other and get to talk about the strategy and things like that. But that kind of thing usually stops when one of the parties decides to work with the prosecution. Yeah, yeah, yeah, that doesn't usually continue, right, but apparently Manafort's lawyer has been reporting back to Giuliani and to Trump's team. So what are the implications of that? Well, the interesting implications of that are that it it has meant that the Trump team have thought they knew what was going on with the Mueller investigation. There's no, this is speculation. I think that Mueller realized fairly early on working with Manafort that Manafort was lying to him.

47:16 Jim: I think he realized that Manafort's lawyer was probably going to go back and talk to Trump because fairly early on, Giuliani started saying things about out what was going on in the investigation that he could have only known from getting inside information. And there are no leaks coming out of Miller's team. Yeah, this is – this is kind of only coming from Manafort's lawyer, and it's interesting that this has happened, that this plea deal has been revoked and that Cohen has pled guilty just after the written statements have come from Trump to go to Miller. So here's what I think has happened right. I think that Manafort has been been going back to Trump and saying: this is what I've told them and Trump has based his written answers on what Manafort has said. Ah, okay, but Muller knows manafort's lying, yeah, and he's just been waiting for Trump to write that stuff down.

48:12 Mark: Yeah, yeah, yeah, oh, nice. So now that he's

48:15 Jim: got the written answers, he can say: we know you've been lying, yeah, you're out, yeah, and it's the perjury trap that people have been talking about where – which is a bizarre thing, because people – you know giuliani has been saying this thing – as if it's a – uh, you know, a thing that anyone can fall into. You can only get caught in the perfect trap if you lie to a, to a federal agent, a prosecutor. So, yeah, I I think they've been waiting for Trump to actually testify and he's now testified in writing. Yeah, based, I think, on what information he has had from what manifold's been saying. Yeah, so as far as he's concerned, when he testified, when he wrote those things down, he's saying the same things as Manafort. So they're going to be fine. But Muller has evidence that contradicts those things. That's what I think I'm very much speculating. All we know at the moment is – and it kind of post -Tocco, it's about the timings. We know that the testimony went in, uh, beginning of the week and then manafort's plea deal was revoked and cohen pled guilty and this stuff has come out. So, yeah, it's possible that's coincidence, it's possible that the timing is just weird and that's just happened like that, but it wouldn't surprise me if Muller has had a plan. Is that?

49:41 Mark: Is there a um? Are there odds being offered by any kind of bookkeepers on on that? Because I just wonder whether you can do the hasty generalization from the small numbers. You know if the numbers are getting smaller and smaller. It's like it's the gap is. You know where it's gone: from 15 to 1, that Trump has lied down to 2 to 1.

50:03 Jim: I mean, I don't think there was ever any doubt that Trump was going to lie. That's why he hasn't been able to sit down with Muller face to face, because because basically his legal team right before gianni was complaining that he, he couldn't even tell a single lie that you know that would be leapt on. And, and yeah, because yeah, that's the point. You're not supposed to lie.

50:24 Mark: You can't even do one. No, you're not allowed to even one, you know, even one, the job that you're in, there's no such thing as a little white lie. No, you can't just can't do that. It comes with the territory, you know, whereas all the business thing that you've done before, you can lie through your teeth and everyone.

50:42 Jim: And they did practice work with him to try and see what it would be like if he sat down with Muller. And he couldn't get through it without telling a lie. So they knew that it wasn't going to work. And they went to Muller and said, look, we're not going to have him sit down with you. And so that's why he's written them down. And he claimed on TV last week that he'd written all of the answers himself. They were very easy answers. He didn't need legal advice. Because he knows all the best words. Yeah, yeah, of course. So, yeah, we shall find out. And the interesting thing is, Muller will get to write a memorandum about what lies he thinks Manafort has told. Okay, during this period. Yeah, that will be public record. So, while the new attorney general, matthew whittaker, possibly might be able to seal or suppress the manifold, the Muller report when it comes out, we don't know yet. Yeah, this won't be be sealable. This will be stuff that that is is,

51:39 Mark: and then, if there's any correlation between that and what Trump has said, it will become apparent that Trump has been, yeah, lying. It will be fairly obvious,

51:48 Jim: and and and Muller has a – uh, an interesting way of writing his, his summaries of what's going on, yeah, and including details that don't necessarily need to be in there. So in the plea deal that has come out about Cohen, for example, they have laid out a timeline of meetings that Cohen had planned to have in Russia about this real estate deal. And he was apparently talking to another individual, Felix Sater, who is a Russian emigre into the US who has a bit of a mobster. He's informed for the FBI against the Russian mob and and was apparently helping to set up this, this Russian real estate deal. He was trying to get cohen to to visit russia and talk to the major players about this deal and, ideally, hoping to get Trump to come after the uh primaries to to talk to them. Cohen was fully planning to go and on the day that it was first publicly mentioned that russia had been hacking the dnc's emails, cohen met sata in the lobby of Trump tower and said, uh, I'm not, I'm not actually going to go to russia now. Yeah, yeah, we're not gonna, we're not going to be doing this anymore. Yeah, that that timeline was in muller's report about that doesn't need to be in there. No, it's in there so that we can see the connections that he's making. Yeah, between um cohen and the russians and Trump and the russians and this whole system. So there might be some interesting information that comes out from that memorandum. Yeah, uh, about what manifold has been saying and what Trump has been saying and,

53:35 Mark: finally, some things we really don't have time to talk about.

53:37 Jim: The votes are finally in, and the Democrats picked up a total of 40 House seats, and won with the largest midterm vote margin in history. And that’s actual history, not Trump’s version, where nobody’s ever done as much winning as him.

53:53 Mark: Speaking of winning, General Motors is laying off 15% off it’s workers and closing 5 factories in the US and Canada, partly due to the $1 billion they’ve lost due to the steel tariffs. Canada’s PM Justin Trudeau tweeted “we’ll do everything we can to help the families affected by this news get back on their feet” while Trump tweeted “We are now looking at cutting all GM subsidies, including for electric cars”, because revenge is way more fun than helping people.

54:24 Jim: According to Donald, Ivanka and just about every Republican spokesperson, Ivanka’s use of a private email account to conduct official government business, is absolutely nothing like Hillary’s use of a private email account to conduct official government business, and anyone who says they’re the same is just crazy. Just because she sent hundreds of emails to cabinet officials, White House aides and her assistant, does not mean you should chant ‘lock her up’ next time you see her.

54:49 Mark: No, don't do that. We don't encourage you to do that at all. Trump is still working his way through his copy of “Dictatorship for Dummies” and it looks like he’s reached the chapter on Propaganda, because during one of his daily twitter attacks on CNN this week, he proposed starting a state run TV network to tell the world how great he is. Which will probably put Fox News’ nose out of joint cos they thought they were definitely a shoe-in for the job.

55:18 Jim: The confirmation of Trump judicial nominee Thomas Farr to the Eastern District of North Carolina is not going so smoothly. With Senator Jeff Flake refusing to confirm any nominees until the government agrees to protect the Mueller investigation, and all Democrats voting against, it would be a tie vote, but for the fact that Senator Tim Scott has announced he will vote to oppose. Nobody knows why, exactly, but it could have something to do with the fact that Senator Scott is the only African American Senator in the GOP, and Thomas Farr is a white supremacist who fights against civil rights.

55:49 Mark: According to psychologists, men who are worried they might have small dicks are more likely to have voted for Trump. A pair of NYU psychologists studied the regional levels of google searches for terms such as ‘penis enlargement’; ‘penis size’; ‘erectile dysfunction’; and ‘how to get girls’, compared the results to the regional voting trends in 2016 and 2018 and found a strong correlation. If you listened to the last episode, you’ll know not to assume a causative link, but it would explain a few things.

56:22 Jim: The government chose Black Friday to quietly release a federally mandated report on climate change which began “Earth’s climate is now changing faster than at any point in the history of modern civilization, primarily as a result of human activities.” But nobody panic, because Trump says it’s fine. He told the Washington Post “One of the problems that a lot of people like myself — we have very high levels of intelligence, but we’re not necessarily such believers.” So, you just have to choose who to believe – the scientists of the 13 federal agencies that make up the US Global Change Research Program, with their ‘facts’ and ‘evidence’, or people like Donald Trump, with their ‘very high levels of intelligence’.

57:02 Mark: So a great cartoon of the Titanic sinking. Sinking and there are people at the far end. Um, as the end is going up and they're going. I don't know what all this talk about sinking is. We seem to be going higher. After Trump claimed that the President Niinistö of Finland had told him that they rake the forest floors to prevent forest fires, everyone in Finland made fun of Trump on twitter, posting photos of themselves sweeping, raking and vaccuuming the forest, with hashtags such as #RakeNews and #RakeAmericaGreatAgain. It must feel great for Trump to be respected again all over the world.

57:40 Jim: So that's all the bad arguments and faulty reasoning. We have time for this episode. If you hear Trump say something stupid and wonder if it's a Fantasy, find us on twitter at Fallacious Trump, or email us on pod at Fallacious Trump .com.

57:52 Mark: If you think we've used a fallacy ourselves, let us know. And if you've had had a good time, please give us a review on itunes stitcher or wherever you get your podcasts, and you can support the show on our Patreon page at Patreon .com. Slash f Trump like our newest patron, neil curlogue. Yay, thanks, neil. That's fantastic. Thanks for finding us and for sponsoring us and patronizing us.

58:12 Jim: That's great, and you can connect with us and other listeners in our Facebook group at Facebook .com. Slash groups – slash Fallacious Trump, where we'll post some links to some of of the stuff we talked about.

58:22 Mark: Oh, music is by the outbursts and was used with permission. So until next time on Fallacious Trump, we'll leave the last word to the Donald.

58:30 [Outro] That's right, go home to mommy, bye, bye.

58:33 Mark: After Trump claimed that the president, wow, nini sto, or nista, or ni ni nisto anyway. After Trump claimed that that president nini sto.

58:46 [Unclear]: I have to admit

58:48 Jim: I did put in the president of to fill in his name, just to see how you would pronounce it. Well, it's gotten up now,

58:56 [Unclear]: so it needs to be an earth. It's probably, it's um. Nianista, oh yeah, oh,

59:02 Mark: okay, that's her nia.

59:04 [Unclear]: Yeah, of course, nianista,

59:05 Jim: um, and – and this, incidentally, is how Trump pronounced it – okay,

59:10 [Unclear]: it is my great honor to welcome president ninucho to the white house

59:19 Jim: and if you watch that video, it is absolutely brilliant, because he steps up to the podium, yeah, and there's this look on his face like, oh crap, I have to, I have to pronounce this guy's name now,

59:31 Mark: and then he thinks that everybody that's got n's and I's in the name must be japanese. Yeah, it's gonna be an e in there.

Featuring: Friends Michael Gove
Share this episodeBlueskyThreadsFacebookRedditEmail

Never miss a fallacy

New episodes every couple of weeks. Subscribe free wherever you listen, or support us on Patreon.

Also on Pocket Casts, Android and RSS.