Show Notes
The Argument by Vehemence is committed when someone gets loud, angry or indignant in place of making an actual argument.
Trump
We started out with this clip of Trump failing to answer a question about COVID:
We followed that with this clip of Trump shouting over Biden in their first debate:
Mark’s British Politics Corner
Mark talked about this clip of Boris Johnson shouting at Kier Starmer:
Fallacy in the Wild (Sting: Shout – Tears for Fears)
In the Fallacy in the Wild we looked at this clip from Matilda:
Then we looked at this clip from The West Wing:
And we finished with this clip from Citizen Kane:
Fake News
Here are the statements from this week’s Fake News game:
- I made a hole-in-one. It took place at Trump International Golf Club in West Palm Beach, Florida, on the 7th hole, which was playing 181-yards into a slight wind. I hit a 5-iron, which sailed magnificently into a rather strong wind.
- As soon as I hit it, Ernie Els, great golfer, winner of four majors, turned to me and said “That’s a hell of a drive, Sir.” The we all watched it bounce on the green and roll into the hole. Everyone got very excited and started cheering.
- The match was Ernie and me (with no strokes) against Gene, Mike, and Ken. I won’t tell you who won because I am a very modest individual, and you will then say I was bragging — and I don’t like people who brag!
Click below for the answer
Spoiler
Statement 2 is Fake News. Mark chose number 2Mark got it right this week, but is still on 49%
Confirmation hearings are not a logical fallacy
We talked about the racist shit-show that constitutes today’s Republican Party and their behavior at Judge Ketanji Brown Jackson’s confirmation hearing.
The stories we really didn’t have time to talk about
- There’s been no shortage over the past six years of people with actual legal expertise pointing out that Trump has committed actual crimes that any normal person would be prosecuted for. These claims have generally fallen into two categories. Those which are true but won’t make any difference for some fucking reason, and the significantly rarer category of those which are true and might actually turn into something. In category one this week, we have Manhattan prosecutor Mark Pomerantz who resigned from the Manhattan DAs office last month when it became clear new DA Alvin Bragg was reluctant to prosecute what Pomerantz described in his resignation letter as “numerous felony violations” that Trump committed. In the much more exciting and colorful category two is the ruling from Judge David Carter in the case we talked about last episode where attorney John Eastman was trying to avoid giving the January 6 Committee a number of documents. Judge Carter ruled that 101 of the 111 documents were not privileged, one of which was specifically because “Based on the evidence, the court finds it more likely than not that President Trump corruptly attempted to obstruct the Joint Session of Congress on January 6th, 2021”. That, by the way, is a federal crime, and the document that quote specifically refers to also seems to implicate Rudy Giuliani directly in the criminal conspiracy. Mind you, if we just waited a bit Rudy would inevitably butt-dial a reporter and confess to it anyway.
- Just occurred to me that phrases about the truth are sometimes related to clothing – “a lie is halfway round the world before the truth has got its pants on” and “liar liar pants on fire”. Something about dressing up to appear better than others perhaps? It’s what Republican Madison Cawthorn seems to striving to do, apart from recently still calling the 2020 election fraudulent, rigged and stolen, he’s having a go at his own party now, saying in a podcast this week that he saw some of his own party members doing cocaine in a car park and was invited by fellow republicans to an orgy! Both of which he later admitted to lying about when taken to task by House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy. Impetuous youthfulness aside – he’s the youngest Republican representative – is he attempting to make himself appear better by being above the allegedly debauched behavior of his colleagues having been accused of sexual misconduct himself? Or does he think this is what you just do to please Trump in Trump’s GOP, after Trump endorsed candidate Lynda Bennett instead in 2020? Y’know – lie about being turned down for Naval Academy after injuries sustained in a car crash, nope he was just turned down, and lie about being pronounced dead in said crash – nope officially pronounced incapacitated. When you tell lies to clean the swamp – you are the swamp – did Donnie teach you nothin’?
- Now I know that during my last headline you were all shouting at your cell-phones and smart speakers “But Jim, doesn’t 18 USC 1512 C2, attempting to obstruct an official proceeding require criminal intent? How will they prove Trump had corrupt intent Jim?” and I would expect nothing less. Frankly, if you weren’t shouting that then you’re not the listeners I know and love. But you’re also forgetting that Trump is a fucking idiot, and commits all his crimes out in the open like a naked man robbing a bank because a witch sold him an invisibility potion and he doesn’t think you can see him. Of course the Judge had plenty of evidence that Trump acted corruptly, but it’s always nice to have more, like, say, someone deliberately concealing or tampering with evidence. In unrelated news, the Washington Post reported this week that the White House Presidential phone log which was provided to the Jan 6 Committee is curiously absent of any phone calls between 11.17am and 6.54pm on January 6th. We know from the extensive reporting of that day that during that period Trump spoke on the phone to Senator Mike Lee, House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy and Mike Pence and it would be a bit surprising if he didn’t speak to anyone else, since it was a bit of a busy day, what with fomenting an insurrection and everything. So did he borrow someone else’s phone for some reason? Did he use a burner phone? Of course, Trump claims he not only didn’t use a burner phone, but he doesn’t even know what that term means, despite using it three times in his lawsuit against his niece Mary.
- Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton has issues – I suspect it’s because he is furious that he’s one letter away from sounding like General Patton. He recently fired a letter off to the Austin Independent School District saying “By hosting ‘Pride Week,’ your district has, at best, undertaken a week-long instructional effort in human sexuality without parental consent. Or, worse, your district is cynically pushing a week-long indoctrination of your students that not only fails to obtain parental consent, but subtly cuts parents out of the loop. Either way, you are breaking state law.” Of course those aren’t the only choices – other choices include what the school district’s superintendent Dr Stephanie Elizalde fired back. “I want all our LGBTQIA+ students to know that we are proud of them and that we will protect them against political attacks,” and that Pride Week is “a time to highlight the district’s commitment to creating a safe, supportive and inclusive environment” for LGBTQ students. As a dangerously rich well-fed cis white male you’d think Paxton wouldn’t have to be blowing the dog-whistle so damn hard to continue to be voted in by similarly bigotted Texans. But hey, as we’ve learned this week, if you can’t be right be STUPIDLY FUCKIN’ VEHEMENT OR ELSE PEOPLE WILL FIND OUT!
- Trump claims to be the best at a lot of things, and in almost every case, he’s either delusional or… end of sentence. However, one thing he truly seems to be better than pretty much everyone else at is losing in court. To be fair, he gets a lot of practice. He’s having another swing at it now, having recently sued Hillary Clinton, The DNC and 26 other people and entities for conspiring to undermine his 2016 campaign by making up lies about him and Russia. I’m not sure exactly what damages he’s claiming he suffered, since – I don’t know if you remember this, but – he won the 2016 election, but I guess it gives him something to do between poorly attended rallies. On hearing about the lawsuit CNN reached out to some of the defendants for a comment and FBI agent Peter Strzok’s lawyer said “We haven’t had a chance to read the complaint, but knowing the former President there’s probably very little in there that’s true.” which is extremely judgemental and probably highly accurate. One person who did get the chance to read it is First Amendment lawyer Ken White, who described it as “freakishly unprofessional and legally bumptious. Rather than a serious effort by serious lawyers, it’s a performative caper by injudiciously barred clowns.” Of course, when I hear the phrase injudiciously barred clowns, I think of Rudy Giuliani and Sidney Powell but they’re too busy being investigated for being terrible lawyers, so this lawsuit was filed by Trump’s old military academy classmate Peter Ticktin, a Florida lawyer who’s been suspended twice for conflict of interest violations and who writes fucking awful poetry that he proudly displays on his law firm’s website. He was also apparently responsible for getting Trump the award of ‘Ladies Man’ in the military academy yearbook. Trump has previously claimed it was because of his ‘great feeling’ for women, but Ticktin says “Somebody else got ‘Most Popular,’ and we wanted to give him something, so we made him ‘Ladies’ Man,’ which to us was kind of an inside joke because there really were no ladies,” I don’t think he’s going to last long as Trump’s lawyer if he keeps revealing stuff like that.
- Right the whole Stop the Steal, overturn the election, bring down Biden thing was all to do with horned shamen and proud boys and working-class Americans stirred up by billionaire care-nothings on Jan 6th yeah? Except, no, well, you know Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas? You know he’s married? Texts sent by his wife Ginni to Trumps Chief of Staff Mark Meadows have been obtained by the Jan 6th committee The Washington Post notes that the committee is in possession of 21 such texts sent by Thomas to Meadows in the wake of the Nov. 2020 election. “Help This Great President stand firm, Mark!!!…You are the leader, with him, who is standing for America’s constitutional governance at the precipice,” one sent on Nov. 10 reads. “The majority knows Biden and the Left is attempting the greatest Heist of our History.” and on Nov 5th – “Biden crime family & ballot fraud co-conspirators (elected officials, bureaucrats, social media censorship mongers, fake stream media reporters, etc) are being arrested & detained for ballot fraud right now & over coming days, & will be living in barges off GITMO to face military tribunals for sedition.” But of course she’s a private citizen, completely mad mind you, but is entitled to say such stuff surely; not that she uses her husbands clout to influence any decisions nooo of course not – it’s not like she invoked her husband in an effort to woo Florida Governor Ron DeSantis into participating in an event hosted by a conservative group or anything in emails saying that the governor should be familiar with her because, in addition to seeing him at a state dinner at the White House and having interviewed him for the Daily Caller, her “husband has been in contact with him too on various things of late.” Well good to know that the supreme court is beyond the reach of the likes of Lady Macbeth.
- If there’s one thing Republicans are sure of, it’s that your children are constantly in imminent danger of being kidnapped by pedophiles. If there’s a second thing they’re sure of it’s that being a Republican instantly absolves you from any accusations that you might be involved in anything inappropriate around children. Just look at Matt Gaetz. Or Roy Moore. Or Mark Foley. Or Jim Jordan. Or Dennis Hastert. Or George Nader. Or Lauren Boebert’s husband. Or… there’s a lot, is what I’m saying. In unrelated news, former Washington State representative Matt Shea, who is a Republican, by the way, who was suspended by the House Republican caucus and urged to resign after a House commissioned report found that he had planned and participated in domestic terrorism against the United States THREE TIMES between 2014 and 2016, showed up in a small town in Poland this week with over 60 Ukranian children. Weronika Ziarnika, an aide to the mayor of the town was contacted by local people who were concerned about the situation. She asked to speak to whoever was legally in charge of the children and Shea told her he’d spoken to the mayor and everything was fine. Ziarnika says she knew that wasn’t true, because it was the mayor who asked her to speak with him. Shea got really angry, refused to tell her his last name, and asked to see her ID. She asked him “What are you going to do with these children” and he said “None of your business”, which, of all possible answers to that question, is not one that fills you with confidence. Speaking on a right-wing religious Polish TV show later, Shea claimed that he was there on behalf of a Texas group called either Loving Families and Homes for Orphans, or Loving Homes and Families for Orphans depending on which part of the interview you listen to. He claimed that the group has been facilitating adoptions for years and while a group by that name is registered with the Texas Secretary of State, they are not registered as an adoption agency or affiliated with international adoption organizations and the group’s website is just a parked domain. But sure, it’s probably fine, because we only need to protect children from Democrats.
- Britpol this week in numbers – Rishi Sunak promises a tax cut in ooh… look 2024 election year having announced tax rises worth 2% of GDP in just two years – the same as Tony Blair and Gordon Brown did in ten. Oh and reinstated car parking fees for NHS staff! Nazanin Zaghari-Ratcliffe is freed from Iran and Fox News wannabes GB News accuse her of being ungrateful when she said “what took them so long” – after all the UK just paid £400 million to get you out – nope it was Iran’s money from a tank order unfilled in 1979. Homes for Ukraine gets 28,000 applications, only 2,700 visas are issued. COVID lateral flow tests will no longer cost nothing despite new cases topping 74,000 after the end of restrictions. P&O ferries knowingly break the law by laying off 800 staff at short notice and the government, familiar with knowingly breaking the law, is issued with 20 fines for COVID law breeches but Boris still maintains rules were followed. Commons Liaison Committee member calls PM “pretty much toast” if he had been issued one surely, Boris replies: “I think you’re just going to have to hold your horses and wait until the conclusion of the investigation when there will be a lot more clarity.” Spoiler alert, and let me be perfectly clear – there will be no clarity, only bread-like opacity. Would that we could afford enough energy to actually make toast with!
That’s all for this week, thanks for listening!
If you wanted to buy a T-shirt featuring this fallacy, you could click here. No pressure
And if you have some money left over after that, Jim’s book, 2000 Mules and One Big Lie: A Stubborn Conspiracy Theory is available now.
That’s almost all for this week, but here’s our AI-aided transcript, which is quite accurate, but not totally:
Argument by Vehemence – FT#97 Transcript
Read the full transcript
00:23 Jim: Hello and welcome to Fallacious Trump, the podcast where we use the insane ramblings of Unhappy Gilmore to explain logical fallacies. I'm your host, Jim.
00:23 Mark: And I'm your other host, Mark. A logical fallacy is an error in reasoning that results in bad or invalid arguments, and the logical fallacy we're looking at this week is the argument by vehemence.
00:41 Jim: Yeah, so the argument by vehemence is basically when you don't really have an argument. So instead you substitute it for just getting loud about stuff, getting loud and cross and talking over other people, because that That might get them to stop arguing with you, in a way. Or at least not give them the chance to make their point. Or concede the point. So it's kind of the last resort of the desperate man, in a way. And so Trump is a regular user. And obviously I mean I could have just used the entire four days of the Katerngy -Brown -Jackson confirmation hearings, basically, and everything the Republicans said, which is basically this, because they didn't have a single argument against her.
01:26 Mark: If you just, yeah, if you just look at the decibel meter, you could kind of go: oh yeah, you've not really got an argument, have you? You're not really, yeah, putting any kind of intelligent thing across you, just being insistent and loud for the sake of it.
01:43 Jim: Yeah, so our first example from Trump comes from when he was asked a completely reasonable question by peter alexander about covid.
01:52 Clip: Trump failing to answer a question about COVID
— What do, What do you say to Americans who are scared though? I guess nearly 200 dead, 14,000 who are sick, millions, as you witnessed, who are scared right now. What do you say to Americans who are watching you right now who are scared?
— I say that you're a terrible reporter. That's what I say. Go ahead. I think it's a very nasty question, and I think it's a very bad signal that you're putting out to the American people. The American people are looking for answers, and they're looking for hope. And you're doing sensationalism, and the same with NBC and Comcast. I don't call it Comcast, I call it Comcast. Let me just, for whom you work, let me just tell you something. That's really bad reporting. And you ought to get back to reporting instead of sensationalism. Let's see if it works. It might and it might not. I happen to feel good about it, but who knows? I've been right a lot. Let's see what happens. John? Can I get back to the science and the logistics? You're going to be ashamed of yourself.
02:47 Jim: You had to get that, you had to. You ought to be ashamed of yourself. But and at the end there, so yeah, he's just, he's just, he's just attacking peter alexander, really not not saying, not answering anything. He was being. He was initially. He was talking about hydroxychloroquine at that point and and peter alexander was saying, yeah, but you know, do you have a message for the, the hundreds of thousands of Americans who are, you know, a bit worried,
03:12 [Unclear]: a bit concerned about this?
03:14 Mark: Because all you'd need is, yeah, we're doing everything that we can. We really feel for you. I mean, it's hollow and pointless and doesn't mean actually anything. But at least it wouldn't be. That's a horrible question. Well, it isn't. We're following the science. That's all he needed to say.
03:32 Jim: It'll just go away. It'll go away on its own.
03:36 Mark: And I've been right. I've been right. I've been right about a lot of things. And then forcing in the gag about concast. Yeah, I call it concord, just as if the room would just go: oh, that is so well observed. Thank you so much for being our president.
03:53 Jim: Yeah, it's weird. Even while he's on an angry rant, he can't avoid doing that. That's so weird that he just couldn't stop himself from playing to that.
04:03 Mark: The invisible oh. And who's he doing it for? Who's it for? So, yeah, and it's just that kind of let's prick the bubble of of intelligent people. That's, that's kind of what he does. He's constantly aware. Either he's constantly aware of appealing to his voter base or he's just constantly stupid. I think probably both.
04:28 [Unclear]: Yeah, yeah, why not both yeah, yeah, yeah.
04:31 Jim: So our second example from Trump comes from the first debate he had with Joe Biden, which, again, is pretty much just the whole thing, is an example of this. Here is here's one of the bits where it got worse.
04:47 Clip: Trump shouting over Biden in their first debate
— We have a higher deficit with china now than we did before. We have the highest deficit – trade deficit – with mexico. China – ate your lunch,
— Joe, and no wonder your son goes in and he takes out what he takes out billions of dollars, takes out billions of dollars to manage. He makes millions of dollars. And also, while we're at it, why is it just out of curiosity, the mayor of Moscow's wife gave your son $3, .5 million. That's not true. What did he do to deserve it? What did he do with Barista to deserve $183,000?
— None of that is true. You've asked your question, not an answer. None of that is true. Oh, really? He didn't get $3.5 million? Mr.
— President, please.
— Totally discredited. Totally discredited. And by the way. Well, wait. He didn't get $3.5 million, Joe?
— Mr. Vice President. He got $3.5 million.
— That is not true. Oh, really? Mr.
— President, it's an open discussion. Please. It's a fact. Well, you have raised an issue. Let the Vice President answer.
— It's been totally discredited.
— Did Burisma pay him $183,000 a month with no experience and energy? Mr.
— President, my son did nothing wrong at Burisma. I think he did. Mr. President. The only guy that did something.
05:59 Jim: Poor, poor Chris Wallace.
06:03 Mark: And then he's kind of like working out, okay, which one's the vice president? Just Trump, shut the fuck up for a minute. And that kind of, it's a needling thing. What he is, is he's not the school bully. He's the one that stands behind the school bully with his hand in the middle of the school bully's back, needling the other guy to go, and then he will push, he will duck behind, kind of push the bully forward, who will get thumped in the face, and he'll go, yeah, and I think what about what about that? Yeah, what about that?
06:37 [Unclear]: Yeah, but don't, don't let him answer no,
06:41 Jim: no, so, yeah, it's just he's just talking over him the entire time. He's just kind of trying to derail the conversations. Just, I mean also completely making stuff up. Obviously, the – yeah, the three and a half half million dollars that the mayor of moscow's wife supposedly gave Hunter Biden – not what happened at all. Um, there was a, there was an account that was connected to a company that was connected to a company that was co -founded by Biden, that got money from the mayor of moscow's wife, and it's several degrees of separation, and and at one point he said that he was getting 183 000 a month from Burisma, which, right the, the real number was up to 50 ,000 a month, which is still quite a lot of money for for what he was doing, for basically being on the board and having a famous person's name. That's how kind of
07:36 Mark: boards work is it really?
07:38 Jim: But Trump has has variously claimed it was 50 ,000 a month, 83 ,000 a month and now 183 ,000 a month based on nothing whatsoever.
07:46 Mark: No, and also he says There's, yeah, he's on there. He's got no prior experience in energy. They think, well, many members of your cabinet had no prior experience in any of that. And yeah, and up till that point, Trump had no experience in politics.
08:06 Jim: He also claimed later on that Hunter never had a job until Biden became vice president, which was completely not true either. And yeah, it's just. He was just shouting for the sake of being the one saying something and not giving Joe the opportunity to say something.
08:22 Mark: To say anything factual or refuting what he was saying. I went to a fundraising gig in London for the Ukraine and Dara O 'Brien was talking about when he encounters people who come at him with various opinions in a shouty way. When somebody comes at you bulldozing with a thing, you just say: can I just stop you right there and then say nothing and then and then wait for the moment when the gap into which you would then speak gets too long and then the other person starts to talk again, at which point you then walk off. So it's just like, can I just stop you there and that so that for me would be the perfect reputation for this, the vehement thing you just you don't take, take any of it on, because Joe kind of fell into the trap of trying to answer rather than seeing that it was pointless answering because he's just being vehement for vehement's sake and he's just making a point. So you would, you could justifiably just say, okay, can I just stop you right there? As if you were going to give the answer that they are hectic for and then not do anything.
09:46 Jim: Part of the benefit of doing this – one part of what comes out of it at least – is it kind of makes it seem like your opponent can't answer your question because you're not giving them the opportunity to answer, because you're just keeping on battering them with stuff. So, yeah, it kind of makes it seem like they are not able to formulate a good answer because they're basically under attack the whole time.
10:14 Mark: Yeah, there's no space to put anything together. And when you do, it's never enough. The answer that they give could be based – in fact, could be based – on the fact that they're putting something intelligently together to counter what you're accusing them of, but you're not having any of that.
10:31 Jim: Yeah, and at the very least, it probably won't be as loud as what you're saying.
10:34 Mark: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yes, exactly. I did get bought a coaster when I went to visit boston and it said on it: I may not know what I'm talking about, but I'm loud enough to be convincing,
10:49 [Sting: Mark's British Politics Corner] And now is the time, I think, for Mark's British Politics Corner.
10:54 Mark: I actually kind of think that the other thing that vehemence is used for is to sneak by a whole bunch of absolute lies. If you do them as loud as you possibly can, which we saw Trump doing – um, it allows you, under the cloak of volume, to put in some lies, many lies, and also also, in being loud, you've kind of got to justify your loudness, this by being angry, and then that therefore kind of adds some weight to that. You're being righteous in your anger. So, and – and Boris does this a lot – um, so the first example is from the 21st of april 2021, in Prime minister's questions. The other thing, the other thing about this: when we decided to do this particular one, I knew I would have to go back and watch Prime minister's questions on. So damn you for that. I've managed to avoid it for a couple of episodes, because it is the most soul -destroying thing in the world. Um, so anyway, Prime minister's questions in 21st of april 2021, in a very empty house of commons because I think we were still under lockdown measures. So much of the parliament.
12:15 Jim: Just the odd, the odd work event was going on. But other than that,
12:19 Mark: Yeah, yeah, they didn't, didn't worry them, you know they. Just they turned up for work rather than work events. Yeah, um, kia starmer asks about is asking about the culture of preferentially granted contracts to friends of the Tories. Basically, things like the, the ppe and the creation of the track and trace system, all that kind of stuff were under under scrutiny because, basically, they are their mates.
12:46 Jim: Anything connected slightly to Matt hancock?
12:49 Mark: Yeah, yeah, so, yeah, so there you go. So, um – and this is keir's question, which I suspect he's – he knows what he's doing when he's triggering Boris – what do we get from this Prime Minister and this conservative government?
13:04 Clip: Boris Johnson and Keir Starmer at Prime Minister's Questions
— Dodgy contracts, jobs for their mates and cash for access. And who's at the heart of it? The Prime Minister – major
13:12 Mark: sleaze – sitting there.
13:14 Clip: Boris Johnson and Keir Starmer at Prime Minister's Questions
— Don't the British people deserve a Prime Minister they can trust and a government that isn't mired in sleaze, cronyism and scandal?
13:22 Mark: The major sleaze thing is there is his riposte to boris's oft said um Captain Hindsight, which he accuses keir starmer of of coming up with policies on in Hindsight, which is kind of the opposite. So he, yeah, he, he's suggesting that starmer, uh, follows where the crowd is going and and then calls from the back: yeah, yeah, I knew this would happen. Whereas Boris, as we all know, sees which way the crowd's going, runs to the front and says, follow me. So that's why that was there. So lacking the usual baying mob behind him. So if you look at the footage of this, there's Boris, and then there's three empty rows, and then four or five people behind him. Normally what happens behind him is there is a wall of noise, in a full spectre kind of way. It's exactly that. That approval, yeah, which is just. It's just kind of so, because that's lacking. Boris has had to up the vehemence in his reply. It's the equivalent, it occurred to me. It's the equivalent of the guitarist having to do more because there's no bassist. So the last gig that my band played, we nearly didn't because the bass player got covid um, and then so we were talking about, well, what will we do? Should we do it without him? And the guitarist was saying, well, yeah, I can do a lot of a lot of that, except when we come to the lead bits, I'm relying on the bass player to fill out the bottom end because I'm no longer playing. You know, I'm not strumming and filling out the the soundscape, so that's so. That's what Boris is doing. So when we play this clip, listen to how the distortion crackles as Boris is shouting and he's also pointing – which you can't hear on radio – with both hands, interchangeably, and he's using his finger, not that odd thumb point thing where they don't point fingers, I think it's. It's viewed upon as being really rather rude. Yeah, so they kind of do it. They sort of point, but with their, with the thumb on top of the fist, but he's not, he's pointing with both hands.
15:40 Clip: Boris Johnson and Keir Starmer at Prime Minister's Questions
— Mr speaker, last night, our friends in in the european union voted to approve our brexit deal, which he which he opposed – which enables us not just to take back control of our borders, Mr speaker, but to deliver freedom, which it does, which he fervently opposed. Taking back control of our country has allowed us to deliver the fastest vaccine rollout in europe, as he well knows, Mr speaker, which would not have have been possible it which would not have been possible if we'd stayed in the european medicines agency, which he voted for.
16:10 Mark: So, as the meme goes, I'll counter your intelligence with my confidence. And even though they're forcefully made, lies are still lies. He didn't oppose the brexit deal. On 24th december 2020, keith sarma announced he will whip the Labour Mps to support the brexit deal when it comes to parliament in december. Nor did membership of the european medicine medicines agency preclude rolling out the vaccines. On the 3rd of feb 2021, uk's channel 4 television's fact check reported again. An Eu provision passed into Uk law in 2012 meant that the government had legal powers to act alone in temporarily authorizing the use of new vaccine, without waiting for the European Medicines Agency to sign it off. 20 years, 10 years prior. This was confirmed in statements by the government and the UK's independent regulator, the Medicines and Healthcare Products Regulatory Agency, who said this law was used to approve the Pfizer COVID vaccine unilaterally in December last year, when Britain was still in the Brexit provision period. So Britain was still subject to the processes of the EMA when when the first vaccine was approved. But EU law gave the UK regulatory emergency powers to act alone. And whilst it's true that Starmer didn't vote to stay in the EMA, he did say in 2017: why would we want to be outside the European Medicines Agency, which ensures that all medicines in the UK market are safe and effective? We ask that consideration be given to finding ways to ensure that, where we can stay within those agencies for the obvious benefits, benefits that they bring. The Ema, among other things, assesses medicines before they're authorized within the european union, which is quite a good thing, I'd have thought. But I think the, the getting out of the Ema is, actually means that the Uk can have dodgy untested medicines quicker than perhaps india somewhere like that.
18:18 Jim: So it's, I mean, they're still under the purview of the mhra, aren't they? So yes, there is that yeah, aspect, but the, the rules are slightly different. I don't know if they're more lenient under the mhra than they are under the Ema, but I think you would think that the,
18:33 Mark: the european, being in the, meant that you would get bulk discount kind of thing you know, on getting stuff through and you would actually, there, you could enforce, force, strict rules on medicine providers because you are a large block. You're not having to renegotiate that, all of that stuff, which is, you know, when you continually ask take, when you continually say take back control, one should ask who's taking back the control? Yes, all right. So example two: um, to compare with this week's full house of parliament and Prime minister's questions, Johnson uses the vehemence trick to whip up more baying, whereas so the thing is. To kind of contrast and compare – we've got Boris Johnson, Keir Starmer and the Scottish National Party leader, Ian Blackford – how they deal with the noise that they that is generated either in opposition to what they're saying or in support of what they're saying. When it's in opposition to what they're saying, they react differently. Johnson shouts over the top. He doesn't say anything. He just shouts over the top of it in order to shout it down. For every six pounds they're taking in tax rises,
19:53 Clip: Boris Johnson and Keir Starmer at Prime Minister's Questions
— they're only handing one pound back. Prime Minister, is that cutting taxes or is that raising taxes?
— The Prime Minister – I do not know where he has been for the last two years, but even by the standards of— Yes, he has. Even by the standards of Captain Hindsight— There we have it. They are the party of excess excess oil and gas profits.
— We are the party of working people.
20:36 Clip: Boris Johnson and Keir Starmer at Prime Minister's Questions
— Talking of parties, Prime Minister.
— The Prime Minister At the very same time, Tory MPs were gathering across the street for a champagne bash in the Park Plaza. Has a party during lockdown and now they're can shout and scream when we're raising the Tory cost of living crisis. Mr speaker, so
21:13 Mark: the this is a contrast. There's johnson, who just I don't even know what he was going to say or what he was, because he just goes – yes, he did – in the middle of all that stuff. So he's shouting that down by trying to be insisting upon trotting out Captain in Hindsight again. And but starmer just kind of waits whilst they all go when they say we're the party of the bar because he's just called them out perfectly. And then ian blackford, he doesn't even bother to kind of speak over the end of it, he just sits down. They're doing all that stuff. They sit down, then he stands up and just calls out what it is that the, the baying crowd is just being vehement. They're just screaming and shouting in order to try and shut him up and it's uh yeah. So my only worry is is that starmer's tactic of remaining calm and triggering Boris to rant is actually not cutting through to the voters, because I suspect that shouting and vehemence appeals to the voters, who feel a bit intimidated by intelligence, and they applaud boris's shouting, And Boris knows that that appeals more than any nuance to the vast majority of Brexity type voters. So there is that. I think he's kind of like the people's champion in that regard. I mean, he's a, he's a vastly intelligent man on paper, but he's, whereas Starmer it uses the kind of the scalpel approach of pairing away the layers and saying: you know, are you a tax collector? Or not, whereas Boris will just bulldoze through facts and noise – um, he doesn't, he doesn't, he doesn't. Bulldoze the facts through, he bulldozes through any existing facts and makes noise in order to get to the sound bites which are: we are better at managing the economy, whereas, you know, Even the Financial Services Commission has said no, there is no tax cut. This is all a tax rise. And yet it will transpire that people will just go, oh, yeah, they're good with the economy. By what measure of means other than Boris constantly shouting, we are better at the economy than them? Yeah, just label your tax rise a tax cut. Yeah, just so everyone will go, wow, yeah, it doesn't look like it on paper. But they've said it is, and, you know, he seems to talk a lot of sense. Seems really convinced by it.
24:08 [Sting: Fallacy in the Wild (Shout – Tears for Fears)]
24:49 Mark: for fear, of course, with shout.
24:51 Jim: What else could we have in the Fallacy in the Wild? We'd like to talk about the fallacy of the week from a non -political perspective, and our first example this week comes from the tim minchin musical matilda. Yeah, this is from a song called loud.
25:04 Clip: Matilda
— People don't like smarty -pants what go round Claiming that they know stuff we don't know. Now here's a tip: What you know matters less Than the volume with which what you don't know's expressed. Content has never been less important. Important. So you have got to be.
25:41 Mark: That's brilliant. Normally, when we do this podcast, what I normally do is kind of go, okay, yeah, so that's that. And then I get some clue as to you know the extent to which I've got to be scholarly about it by listening to the Fallacy in the Wild examples. Examples. But I didn't do that this time. I did all that, all the stuff about starmer and Boris, because he just kind of went, oh yeah, well, that must be, and then went to matilda and then she, she just sings exactly what I've just discovered. So, yeah, it's brilliant, it is absolutely.
26:18 Jim: I love to mention and that is: yeah, it's content has never been less important.
26:24 Mark: Yeah, does it doesn't matter what you're saying, it's just the volume at which you're expressing the stuff that you think you know. Yeah, yeah, or don't, or know that you don't know. Yeah, yes, yeah, it's,
26:39 Jim: it's kind of style over substance, but it's volume over substance.
26:43 Mark: Really, yeah, yeah, yeah, yes.
26:46 Jim: The second example comes from the West wing, and this is kind of representative of a legal adage.
26:52 Clip: The West Wing
— You know, I had a civil procedure professor who said: once take a beat, there you go. He said: when the law is on your side, argue the law, and when the facts are on your side but it's not in cement, you don't have the law on your side and you don't have the facts on your side, bang your fist on the defense table as loud as you can.
27:12 Jim: It's from a speech that jeb bartlett is giving and and we kind of keep cutting away to the other room where they're listening to the speech and the kind of behind behind the scenes and stuff. So that's why the the volume keeps coming in. Yeah, yeah, because it's on
27:25 Mark: the tv screen.
27:26 Jim: Yeah, he's. He's saying that. A, a law professor of his, used to say that when the facts are on your side, argue the facts. When the law is on your side, argue the law. And when you don't have the facts or the law, pound your fist on the defense table as as hard as you can. Yeah, and this is a legal kind of strategy that has been attributed to lots and lots of different people. It's been attributed to alan dershowitz when he was a harvard law school professor. Before that it was a columbia professor named jerome michael oliver wendell holmes. It was attributed to him. There's a site called quote investigator who kind of looks for the origins of these kind of commonly misattributed quotes or quotes that are attributed to different people. They follow it back to the earliest citation they can find, from 1911, where it is written by Byron K. Elliott and William F. Elliott. And they word it slightly differently. It says: if you have a case where the law is clearly on your side but the facts and justice seem to be against you, said an old lawyer to his son who was about to begin the practice of law, urge upon the jury the vast importance of sustaining the law. On the other hand, if the law is against you or doubtful in and the facts of your case is founded in justice. Insist that justice be done, though the heavens fall. But, said the young man, how shall I manage a case where both the law and the facts are dead against me? In that case, replied the old lawyer, talk around it. And the worse it is, the harder you pound the table. There you go. So it's become, over 110 years, much more kind of pithy. And, yeah, if neither the facts nor the law are on your side, pound the table.
29:10 Mark: That's interesting because it would be that might be another way of surviving. Watching Prime minister's questions is to act. Just to see as well as how often he ruffles his hair is how often Boris bashes the dispatch box or points at it on thumps on the thing when he's – and you just know the more he does that, the less truth is actually employing. Yeah, there it's all sound and fury,
29:37 Jim: signifying nothing, absolutely, yeah, yeah. Our final example in this section this week comes from citizen kane. Oh, wow, and this is where kane has just taken over the new york inquirer and is advising his underling. Now his, his kind of the editor – I guess the previous editor of the paper – on how to get a sensational story.
29:59 Clip: Citizen Kane
— I want you to send your Best man to see Mr silverstone in brooklyn. Have him tell Mr silverstone, if he doesn't produce his wife, mrs silverstone, at once, Once the Enquirer will have him arrested. I haven't told Mr. Silverstone he's a detective from the central office. The central office. If Mr. Silverstone gets suspicious and asks to see your man's badge, your man is to get indignant and call Mr. Silverstone an anarchist. Loudly, so the neighbours can hear you.
30:25 Mark: Yeah, that's activist, isn't it? That is the latest kind of byword version of that. Yes, he's activist. You're an activist. So if he asks
30:37 Jim: a reasonable question, if he says, are you really a detective? Show me some proof. Just get indignant and call him an anarchist. And do it loudly.
30:51 Mark: Which is what Trump does. Isn't it? You just say, you're a terrible journalist. Like Trump would know. Yes, well, I'm just holding you to account. That's my job.
31:07 Jim: So before we move on to fake news, there's just time to give you an update on our Oscar pool, because the Oscars happened – don't know if you noticed – and we had some people who joined us in our Oscar pool choosing which films they thought would win the various awards. How did we do? Well, I did very well,
31:23 Mark: oh right, damn damn. You kind of, yeah, yeah, I did kind of go in there, going, going. Should I go with the ones that I know will win?
31:34 Jim: Yeah, you did go out on a limb a bit with a few of yours.
31:38 Mark: Yeah, I know, and it kind of made no sense. I knew I was just going, it was that kind of protest vote. And why did I do that? I don't know why I did that. Because I'm an anarchist.
31:48 Jim: Well, I got 16 correct out of 23 possible Oscars.
31:55 Mark: What were the ones you didn't get right?
31:56 Jim: Uh, well, I, I went out on a limb and chose uh encanto for Best score, on the assumption that the Academy voters would not know what it was. Yeah, yeah, that score doesn't mean songs, I think I did too. Yeah, but uh, and if I'd been right on that, I I would have won a reasonable amount of money because I also put a bit of a bet on that. But yeah, then it was yeah, so, um, but still, I got got 16 out of 23. Uh, the the highest anyone did other than me, as, as the winner was our most recent lovely patron, Colleen Lyerla, who got uh 10 out of 23. Oh, wow, cool. And you were close behind uh, with nine in third place, right and, and, and our other people who joined in didn't do quite as well as you, but well done. Thank you for everyone joining in patronize us.
32:47 Mark: Yeah, we were kind of. It was always about second place.
32:53 [Unclear]: We knew that. We knew that. The other one I got wrong was Best Picture,
32:56 Jim: which I I absolutely thought would be Power of the Dog, but went to coda, which I'm very pleased by. Wow, because it absolutely was a much better Picture in my opinion. Yeah, Power of the Dog.
33:07 Mark: Wow, well, I'm you. You weren't so keen on Koda. No, I wasn't. And I wasn't. What did I vote for? I think I exceeded. I think you went for Dune, actually, in Best Picture. Did I? I thought I acquiesced to your greater ignorance and went Power of the Dog. Yeah, well, I'm surprised by that. I am. All right.
33:29 Jim: Yeah, in fact, Jane Campion, Best Director, was the only Oscar that Power of the Dog got in the end out of the 12 nominations.
33:38 [Unclear]: So, yeah, and?
33:39 Jim: And coda won the Best Picture, despite – and it was the first film ever to win Best Picture without being nominated for either Best editing or Best Director.
33:48 Mark: So well, how about that? Look at that.
33:51 [Sting: Fake News] Wow, so we're gonna, we're gonna – play fake news folks. I love the game. It's a great game. I understand the game as well as anybody. As well as anybody.
34:00 Jim: Yes, it's time for fake news. The game where I read out three Trump quotes, two of which are real and one I made up, and Mark has to figure.
34:05 Mark: So, before we go any further, can I just say it's a complete travesty of justice, this thing, because I have been winning consistently, time after time after time, and it seems to count for nothing. It's just a travesty of gamesmanship.
34:24 [Unclear]: Ship.
34:25 Jim: So our theme this week is one of Trump's statements. Since he lost his twitter, he's been putting out, uh kind of public statements via, mostly via liz harrington, his kind of spokeswoman, because she still has a twitter account. But these are kind of Trump from the desk of Donald j Trump, and this was his official press that he put out because he got a hole in one at golf. Supposedly no one's actually necessarily seen seen that it did happen. There was a video, but the video was of him kind of getting the the ball out of the hole, not of the actual shot.
35:02 Mark: So, having got a hole in one,
35:05 Jim: he he put out a press release because it's obviously very important, so So these are parts of the release. Statement number one. I made a hole-in-one. It took place at Trump International Golf Club in West Palm Beach, Florida, on the seventh hole, which was playing 181 yards into a slight wind. I hit a five iron, which sailed magnificently into a rather strong wind.
35:30 Mark: Well, that's very bland for Trump. Very factual, very factual, even though it's all lies.
35:38 [Unclear]: Statement number two.
35:39 Jim: Yeah, as soon as I hit it, Ernie else great golfer, winner of four majors – turned to me and said: that's a hell of a drive, sir. Then we all watched it bounce on the green and roll into the hole. Everyone got very excited and started cheering.
35:51 Mark: Yeah, yes, I'm immediately suspicious of that, which has put. Put me on my guard,
35:56 Jim: right, yeah, statement number three: the match was Ernie and me, with no strokes against Gene, Mike and Ken. I won't tell you who won because I'm a very modest individual, vigil. And you'll then say I was bragging and I don't like people who brag.
36:09 Mark: Right, okay, you see, you throw you, ha. Ha, you've thrown in a curveball the, the, so, so, which has made me suspicious of the middle one. But then I'm thinking: well, that's probably why you've done it. So now I'm more suspicious of the first one. Made a holy one With me, no strokes. Max was earning with me, with no strokes Against Gene. Okay, Mike and Ken. Well, they're all made up names, aren't they? Because I'm a very modest Individual. No, he does like people who brag. So that in itself is a lie.
36:57 [Unclear]: Okay, Oh no, You see,
37:00 Mark: the red flags are all going. Okay, I know, I'm gonna choose the one that I'm gonna choose and I know that I've been fooled and, oh God, okay. So I think that, oh no, I'm gonna get out of the way, I'm going for it. I think the number two is the one that you made up,
37:36 Jim: okay, so the other two,
37:37 Mark: which are you more convinced by actually the hole in one? I made a hole in one, the first one, number one,
37:44 Jim: and number one, yeah,
37:46 [Unclear]: is yeah, real, despite
37:51 Jim: the fact that he says I was, it was 181 yards into a slight wind and then, one sentence later, it's a rather strong wind.
37:58 Mark: Yeah, I hit a five which sailed, sailed, Nailed magnificently, obviously, way across a different green and got blown back onto the seventh green. Well, yeah. That's a very dull thing to say from Trump, isn't it? Apart from that bit about it was a slight wind, and then, as if he hadn't written that or decided to change it and then forgot to erase the previous sentence.
38:28 [Unclear]: Yeah. Oh, it was very windy.
38:30 Mark: It was so windy. Yeah, it was a slight wind. Oh, no, it doesn't sound very good. 181 is no. No, actually it was. It was a raging wind. I had to practically flown over, I had to lean into it to.
38:45 Jim: Yeah, so you also think number three is real.
38:48 Mark: I do, yeah, number three match was only me.
38:53 [Unclear]: Yeah is real, oh what so?
38:58 Jim: Yeah, so he did
38:59 Mark: say the match, he did say I was bragging and yeah, and I don't like people who brag,
39:04 Jim: well, he does nothing,
39:05 Mark: but do that, yeah,
39:06 Jim: yeah, I kind of that. There has been some speculation online that that that was kind of because obviously he doesn't write these himself. No, he, you know, he has someone who write. He he kind of pretty dictates them, and then someone – one – has to kind of write it up and send it to Liz and she has to post it and you know,
39:22 [Unclear]: yeah, so go
39:24 Mark: down to the mailbox.
39:25 Jim: There's been some speculation that that might have been added by someone as kind of like a a joke about the fact that he is bragging. This entire thing is right.
39:35 Mark: nice, yeah, but I won't tell you who won.
39:38 Jim: Yeah, because it wasn't even necessarily him.
39:46 Mark: because then you'll say: well, no, because if it wasn't him, if he, if he had one, he would definitely have. Yeah, yeah, yeah, you know, if I won't tell you, because I'm modesty, because I don't like losing yourself, yeah, right, that's a. That's there you go. That's definition of humble brag, isn't it?
40:01 Jim: Yeah, yeah, so, uh, yeah, you're correct. Number two was: It was indeed fake news. Yeah, it was the
40:09 Mark: great golfer and the sir.
40:12 Jim: Yeah, the sir was the kind of giveaway because he said he was playing with legendary golfer Ernie Els, winner of four majors. He was also playing with Gene Sowers, Ken Duke and Mike Goodes,
40:27 [Unclear]: who are tour players, basically.
40:31 Mark: Is it possible to let someone get a hole-in-one? Do they employ some kind of reverse tornado,
40:37 Jim: so it would just suck it in. There is quite a lot of luck involved in getting a hole -in -one, but there's also it's it's also a numbers game. Yeah, according to golf digest right, who are the authorities, I think it's fair to say on this kind of thing? A pro – pga tour pro – will get an ace, a hole -in -one, once every 2375 shots, whereas an average golfer will get a hole -in -one every 12 ,000 shots. Good grief. So if you play enough, eventually, you know, you'll probably get a hole-in-one. Especially on par-3 holes, which this was. Hole 7 of the West Palm Beach Trump International. They're a lot rarer on par-4 and 5. But yeah, this is 181 yards, not that far. Trump apparently regularly drives around 200, 230 yards kind of off the tee. So 181, not that big a deal with a five iron rather than a driver knowing the hole is only 181. You'd pick a more pitched club. Yeah, um, yeah. But yeah, looking at, um, kind of how frequently he golfs as president, according to the Trump golf tracker, pretty frequently he attended his own golf courses like 250 days out of his presidency and definitely golfed at least 150 times. Yeah, his handicap, according to the official online measurement, is 2, .8.
42:13 Mark: Right, I thought you're gonna say his handicap is being a Trump,
42:20 Jim: There's no chance that's his real handicap because, like, um, jack nicholas is like four or something like that. So, wow, so, yeah, yeah. And the thing is, if you look, there's this uh online tool that people enter their golf scores into to come up with their handicap and, and if you look at Trump's, that I think – I think it was golf digest – did it in in 2020 and he'd only played, according to this tool, like 20 games since 2009. Right, that had been in input, put into this tool. So, basically, when he has a good round,
42:56 [Unclear]: he puts it in. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
43:00 Jim: And he's only had 20 good rounds since 2009 and so, based on those ones only, his handicap is like 2 – .8,
43:09 Mark: yeah, so, on everything else, it's up there. With his iq, you know it's in the it's in the 30s,
43:15 Jim: so so, based on that, based on the fact that his handicap is actually a bit higher, you're looking at a minimum of 80 shots per game. Basically, right, yeah, used probably most most average golfers to round 90 to 100 shots per uh per round of 18 holes. Um, so if you, if he played 150 times while he was president and shot 80 shots per game, yeah, that's 12 000 shots. There you go. So, just in the the four years he was president, he you'd expect he might have got a hole in one. Based on golf digests numbers, yeah, he's been golfing for years and years and years – 2009, yeah, yeah, yeah, and he's golfed pretty much constantly since he stopped being president and he's finally now got a hole in one. So, yeah, all the people online saying, oh yeah, I don't even believe he's got it now he probably has, just from the law of large numbers, it's eventually it's going to happen – doesn't mean he's a good golfer.
44:19 Mark: No, it's. It's just, even if he just – well, I think that I think what's happened is he's only ever played that seventh hole. That's what goes out there, yeah, and just plays that I mean whacking and whacking away with a massive bucket of balls. He never plays golf, he, He's just kind of he's practising constantly. It's the equivalent of having the thing in the you know in your den, with the screen that you whack the ball into and then you just watch it go. Jack Nicklaus's thing on the Commodore 64, that kind of a thing. But he's doing it in real life because, hey, he's got time on his hands. You know, even during his presidency.
45:00 Jim: But, yeah, I mean, if there was a way for him to cheat it, he definitely would have. There's an entire book written about how, how he cheat, just how Trump cheats at golf.
45:08 Mark: Just oh, I want that, yeah, yeah, so, oh, yeah, brilliant, yeah, yes, well, woohoo, that means I won. It does so you are.
45:21 Jim: You're on your way back to 50. You're not quite there yet,
45:25 Mark: but slow, slow and steady ready. So you know, one out of every 12 000 strokes, you know, eventually is going to go my way.
45:42 Jim: it's time for the part of the show that, this week at least, is called. Confirmation hearings are not a logical fallacy. Oh, my God, this is brilliant because,
45:49 Mark: yeah, you know, kind of a parade of it's not so much about her as about everybody else.
46:00 Jim: Yeah, I mean, the thing is, it's not about her Because the confirmation hearings for Ketanji Brown -Jackson Biden's pick – for the next Supreme Court justice – are essentially a formality. They've got the Democrat votes because she's ridiculously well qualified. That's the thing. She is immensely qualified for this, like more so than half the people who are currently Supreme Court justices.
46:25 Mark: And any of the ones that got appointed under Trump, certainly.
46:29 Jim: And so there's really not any question about it. All they need is the Democrat votes. Susan Collins has come out since this and said that she's going to vote for her as well. So you know, even if Kirsten Sinema wants to have another day where her name's on the Internet by voting no, it won't make any difference.
46:52 Jim: So there was no point to all of the stuff that the Republicans said. Having first of all come out at the very beginning of the process and kind of berated the Democrats for how terribly they treated sex pest beer lover Brett Kavanaugh for what Ted Cruz called his teenage dating habits and other people call raping someone.
47:16 Mark: Yeah, being a bit rapey, yes.
47:19 Jim: The stuff after that where they basically were saying: we are not going to treat this hearing like that, we're going to be respectful, we're going to be sensible with you know, this will not turn into a political circus. And they then immediately put on clown shoes and arrived in a car with offset wheels.
47:37 Mark: Yeah, all the doors fell off. Yes, and in a kind of, in a similar way that the um, the, just the, the routine thing of, of verifying the votes on january the 6th. You know, yeah, it's, it's just a constitutional thing that will just let it pass by without incident. You know, no, yeah it's. You know so. They just. And yet, of course, if the Democrats just kind of point out to them that, uh, well, you said that we did this then and now you're doing it, now they go, no, no, this is another kind, this is completely different kind of circus. They'll get all vehement: absolutely, yeah, yeah.
48:23 Jim: So I mean, basically all they got out of this really is a bit of kind of meat: the for the for the base and and and the odd Fox news interview, because, because, obviously, once lindsey graham has has flounced out of the room a couple of times, that means yeah, that secures him a spot on tucker carlson to talk about, About why he was so flouncy.
48:50 Mark: Well, I half arrived and I went off in it.
48:56 Mark: Just nuts. And Ted Cruz holding up a book. The anti-racist book. So if it was, you know, if you kind of so, we want to list all of the things. You just kind of go okay. Well, there's got to be something about critical race theory. and there's got to be something about transgender rights and anti-religious things. You could just draw up a list and go, okay, yeah. Do you think they did any of those? Yeah, they did all of those. They must have got into the
49:29 Jim: room beforehand and did it. They basically called her a paedophile, racist, communist. Yeah, and anti-Catholic. And also somehow woke.
49:39 Mark: Uh, yeah, in amongst all of that. Yeah, no hell, you could be all of those and woke, yeah, but you can't point that out because they would just shout at you: yeah, yeah, and you just have to go. Well, let me just stop you right there and then leave.
49:58 Jim: So, yeah, so Ted cruz's attack on on Ketanji Brown -Jackson was that she is on the board of a day school in D .C, Georgetown Day School, which is against racism, and this is somehow a negative. Yeah, like that's a bad thing? On their curriculum, which I don't know if it's in their library, basically. Basically, one of the things they have available for children is this book called Anti-Racist Baby by Ibram X. Kendi, who writes about anti-racism. He's written some excellent books about anti-racism. And this is one for kids. Basically, the idea is it's like a board book. There's a paperback. There's a Kindle version that it is designed to encourage parents to talk to their children early on about racism and anti-racism. And, you know, treating everyone with respect and seeing that while people are different, they aren't better or worse than each other. But pretending people aren't different and there aren't differences to how people are treated by society is not reasonable. And it's designed to encourage those kinds of conversations with kids. Ted Cruz claimed that it calls babies racist and asked Judge Jackson if she agrees that babies are racist like it says in this book that is endorsed by this school on which you are a board member of.
51:45 [Unclear]: So many layers. She paused for a while.
51:51 Mark: I kind of go, wait a minute, let me just untangle what you've just asked me.
51:56 Jim: And then she sighed, and then she answered: I don't believe that any child should be made to feel as though they are racist or not valued or less than that. They are victims, oppressors, she said eventually. When Cruz refused to drop the subject, she gave a more direct answer. I've not reviewed any of these books. They don't come up in my work as a judge, which I'm respectfully here to address. So nice, try to get it back on track. As to you know, yeah, maybe ask me law questions. You know how I would address things rather than do I think babies are racist, which is a fucking weird question, and that's not what the book says anyway.
52:37 Mark: No, I was gonna. How do you get to there? It's a kind of it's one of those, um, specious. It's not even a slippery slope, no argument, they just go with it. This is some strange connection to you. Therefore, that allows me to go into the usual rants and accuse you, just because you're not a Republican, of being what the flavour of the month is. It's a bit like saying, well, if you opened the Hungry Caterpillar and said, are you pro-famine? Uh -huh what? Yeah, have you, has your child ever read the Hungry Caterpillar? Yes, what does that mean? That you have taught them to be pro -famine? No, no, it doesn't. There is no link there. And there's no link between your position and this book. And there's no link between me and endorsing this book on the basis that I'm a board member of a school that happens to have it in the library, because it's a kind of important thing to say that nobody is born to be a racist.
53:54 Jim: Yes, the book specifically says babies are not racist or anti -racist. They have to be taught to be one or the other. Yeah, and that's the problem. It's too many babies have been taught to be racist. That's that's the whole fucking issue.
54:10 Mark: Exactly, yes, do they not see that? It just makes them look like fools.
54:15 Jim: It also has to be said once again: propelled anti -racist Baby to the top of the amazon.
54:22 Mark: Yeah, quite didn't. We have another one of those. It's been happening regularly.
54:33 Jim: It happened with mouse. It's basically anything that Republicans say. This is a dangerous, awful thing. Everyone goes, oh, I'm gonna buy that, then I'm gonna go get that.
54:47 [Unclear]: Yeah, yeah, yes, yeah, exactly so.
54:52 Jim: Um, yeah, among other people who, yeah, who use this other favorite, yeah, for their own useless, pointless ends. Uh, was marcia blackburn, senator marcia blackburn, who is basically a ball of hair, who was nominated to the senate? Yeah, she asked judge jackson if she could, um, provide a right in an attempt to get some kind of transphobic soundbite that she could use, or, or, or something that she could then claim. Means that, judge jackson? Well, whatever, I don't know what the fuck she was trying to do. It's really unclear.
55:31 Mark: That's what we're always lost to. Yeah, yeah, and you kind of just want to go. Can I just stop you and say, okay, what is it you're getting at? Just, you know what is it? What is it, cousin it? What are you trying to say to me?
55:46 Jim: So, judge jackson did not rise to the bait of no defining what a woman is in some way. She said: no, I'm not a biologist. That's not something I do. That's not, yeah, something judges are required to do. Yes, um, in their, in their work.
56:03 [Unclear]: Why would, why would
56:05 Mark: I need to? Yeah, have an opinion on that?
56:07 Jim: Yeah, And the entire right wing then got confused about what define means and claimed: this person doesn't know what a woman is, which is not the same thing at all. You can know, for example, what a shark is without biologically defining a shark, in a way of defining it that excludes other fish or you know, know other things that aren't sharks – that that's much harder to. To give a biological definition of something which which separates it out from other things that aren't. It is different from looking at a Picture of a shark and going, yeah, that's a shark,
56:53 [Unclear]: yeah, it's definitely a shark.
56:54 Mark: Yeah, it reminds me of when we played no more jockeys and we got to the point with whether a planet was a place, and then we got to the point where scientists define it as, oh well, scientists. And then we argue about define and then, yes, exactly that, it's just that desperate need to win the point. That's what they're doing, isn't it? They're playing the point scoring game, so they're just going, okay. So she successfully dismissed this stupid question and so, to win the point, the entire right wing have got to move to. Ah well, they've got to miss the point, haven't they? They've got to go. Well, she doesn't know what a woman is. No, that's not the question what was asked? Yeah, it's like: yeah, do you know what a woman is? Yeah, I can point to several in the room. Yeah, there's one, there's one, there's one, but no, could you? And then, well, but I can't define one.
57:56 Jim: Yeah, there's no. Apart from, there's no particular need to define one, because there are different definitions depending on what context you're talking about. Whereas, yeah, whereas just saying oh, yeah, define this thing, is not how the law works at all, not.
58:12 Mark: So you haven't got to have the, the knowledge of the definition of absolutely everything, in order to, to, to prove your generalness or your suitability for an office where that's not called upon, and if it were, you would get an expert in yeah, to do that. It's like kind of: can you define, find space? Well, no, but if I needed to, I would get a nasa expert in. Yeah, you know, because I'm not a trained astronaut. Doesn't mean I can't be a high Court judge, and you know I mean.
58:42 Jim: The thing is, it's just it – it's her response to it – of basically refusing to define a woman – yeah, is just more evidence for Democrats and for people who are trans -affirming or who are kind of sympathetic to people identifying who they are themselves. It is more evidence in favour of those people saying, yes, this person isn't someone who is going to say, yes, this is how I define a woman and that's the right way to do it, and no one else gets to say what what a woman is. Yeah, because that's the right way to go about it. Yeah, it's. There isn't a specific definition that I can give you right here and now, in in, without any context or nuance.
59:32 Mark: No, which would and which would, from here on in, define my viewpoint. And that's what you don't want in a judge. You want, you don't want somebody that goes in with a, with with a completely sorted out definition, because you would then say, hmm, okay, well, actually, that's probably a little bit dangerous, because what happens if, in certain circumstances, that definition doesn't work within the law? So to have somebody that is very strictured in their outlook, because that's what they're asking for, really, isn't it? They're just saying: can you be really blinkered in your outlook, please? And so what we're doing, we're testing how blinkered you are and if, and, and getting outraged that you're not. Yeah, that's when you when, really, ideally, you want somebody that isn't blinkered in their outlook, beyond in the Supreme Court, beyond upholding the law and the rights of people under the law. That's kind of what you want, isn't it? And all of that is completely lost on the Republicans, because they don't think they're particularly. They think everybody else is blinkered and stricted and narrow minded. That's what it is: the narrow mindedness. We want you to be really narrow minded in order for us to vote for you. Well, just as well.
1:01:10 Jim: Yeah, we want you basically to signal that you're going to give us the opportunity to be bigoted legally.
1:01:24 Jim: If there's any, and obviously they knew she wasn't going to do that. There's no question that given her record, who she is.
1:01:33 Mark: She's a trained legal mind.
1:01:37 Jim: Yeah, but you know it worked for, uh, amy coney barrett. So there you go, yeah, um yeah, the probably the worst though of all of the attacks came from josh hawley, backed up by things that tom cotton said, because he's an arsehole as well, but josh hawley, basically, was going queuing on on her and claiming essentially that she is pro -pedophile. He was bringing up her egregious record of lenient sentencing for child porn offences, in which she has consistently given child porn havers under the minimum sentence or the recommended sentence and therefore she's clearly basically a paedophile.
1:02:31 Mark: I'm guess I'm guessing not much of that is true.
1:02:35 Jim: There's quite a lot of nuance that is missed by right by everything he said that he's making out.
1:02:45 [Unclear]: Yeah, okay, yeah, yeah, essentially what?
1:02:49 Jim: What it's good that judges do is not treat every case the the same. That's a good thing. Judges are supposed to look at the specific circumstances of a case or of a defendant or whatever. Yeah, one thing that judges tend to try and do as a whole, but isn't necessarily reflected in the in the sentencing guidelines to the extent that many judges would hope it would be, is to treat people who possess child porn differently to people who create child.
1:03:53 Jim: Most legal experts, including Republican judges, including Trump-appointed judges, compared to how they actually tend to get sentenced. It's not like this is kind of a specialist area for her. She's dealt with, I think, 10 child-born cases in 10 years.
1:04:10 [Unclear]: Right. It's not like she's a regular. No. No.
1:04:13 Jim: And in every single one of those cases she requested countrywide data on the kind of typical sentencing of these kinds of cases to make sure that she was sentencing them within the General guidelines of how other judges. And that's judges in red states, blue states, you know, appointed by Trump, appointed by Reagan in some cases, like literally all over the place. And in every single case her sentencing was in line with those guidelines, essentially right the right,
1:04:49 Mark: so she didn't strike out on her own.
1:04:51 [Unclear]: No, absolutely what
1:04:52 Jim: I'm gonna do again in. In most of those cases, the kind of request from the prosecutors – the people actually trying to put these people away – was for, uh, sentences that were at the low end or a downward departure from, yeah, the minimum sentencing guidelines based on the circumstances of the case. For example, in cases where people took a plea deal, because that's how they get people to take plea deals and plead guilty, rather than going through the process of a trial. So, yeah, she sentenced these people in these cases in line with how judges generally sentence people.
1:05:34 Mark: Which is what you'd want your judges to do. You want them to look at all the precedent and do something that's within the ballpark of that, in order to ensure that future sentencing does the same thing. It reflects the thinking of all of the judges that are prosecuting these kind of cases, because otherwise, yeah. And it's good that she did that with all of them, not just the first one.
1:06:07 Jim: She was on the U.S. Sentencing Commission and was involved in a 2012 report which recommended lowering the mandatory minimums for two types, specific types of child porn offenses. And also on that sentencing Commission. Who also agreed with this report and participated in the report was a judge called Dabney Friedrich, who was a Trump appointee US District Court judge who was given a unanimous vote on his nomination by Senate Republicans. So, so he voted for the same lowering of, yeah, of mandatory minimum sentences for these child porn offenses. Exactly the same as her, on literally the same Commission. Yeah, and all senate Republicans went: oh, yeah, he should definitely be a district Court judge. Yeah, and, and now that this black woman is up for Supreme Court, they're going. Yeah, she's a bit lenient on child porn.
1:07:05 Mark: Yeah, which makes you think: well, actually, perhaps it's to do with party politics rather than performance. Could it be that she's a Democrat?
1:07:14 Jim: Could it be that she's a woman? Could it be that she's black? I mean, who knows? Why not all three? Who knows?
1:07:22 Mark: There you go. These questions should be asked.
1:07:27 Jim: Asked: but yeah, honestly, these things, along with lindsey graham asking her to rank her faith on a scale of one to ten, and things like that, are all, exactly, like you said, what you would expect from Republicans. Yeah, one thing that went slightly outside of what we might expect was senator Mike Braun, from indiana, I think, right, he was talking about – and this wasn't in the confirmation hearings, but it was at the same time and it was – he was talking about state states rights and essentially calling judge jackson a kind of activist judge who was going to, you know, try and change things from the bench, um, and and he was saying that that you know these, these things, um, gay marriage and all that kind of stuff should be left to the states. It shouldn't be be a federal thing at all anyway. Um, and and basically, kind of everything possible should be led left to the states. And he was asked specifically by a reporter in that conversation about loving versus virginia, which is the case that legalized interracial marriage. Right, and they said, like that, for example, do you think that should be a state's rights issue? And and he said, right, yes, absolutely, which would definitely mean some states got to make interracial marriage illegal again.
1:08:50 Mark: Wow, despite the fact that which we'll talk about in the headlines: Supreme Court, justice. Clarence thomas is married to a black man. He's married to a white woman. He's on the. He's on the Supreme Court. He's he. He's a Republican. He's up there. They're doing the job that they're voting – well, they don't even have to vote – to – what the actual?
1:09:19 Jim: – Yeah, but – and later on, once people pointed out you know – What the fuck. Yeah, what the fuck? Once people said what the fuck, Mike Braun basically said that he kind of misheard the question or misunderstood the question.
1:09:34 Mark: When you said: but you can say you can watch it,
1:09:38 Jim: it's on video, yeah, and it and no, it was very clear. They, like like a reporter, when he said it said: yeah, no, hang on, are you sure?
1:09:48 [Unclear]: Anyway, yeah, yeah, wow, wow.
1:09:53 Mark: How far out to the right must you be? Where is he in indiana, today's Republican party? Yeah, not particularly clanny, there, is it, you know? I mean there are all sorts of people living in Indiana. Yeah, wow, Jesus Christ, I mean, how old are these people? Are they born in the 1800s or something?
1:10:20 Jim: He's not one of the older ones, to be honest.
1:10:24 Mark: Whoa, yeah, what he needs to read is anti -racist, Baby, you know? Or have it read, Read to him, obviously.
1:10:33 Jim: Maybe they should make an anti-racist senator book.
1:10:38 Jim: That should be Ibrahim Kendi's next book. Yeah, in really big type.
1:10:44 Mark: You know, it's kind of like a Dr. Seuss kind of thing with only five words on each page and a repeated one. The anti-racist bit repeated on every page. Jesus H.
1:10:56 [Unclear]: Christ. Yeah. Yeah.
1:10:59 Mark: Hmm well, thankfully they have no, uh say in the outcome. Really, no, no, no,
1:11:07 Jim: no, she's, she's getting confirmed. This was all just just noise. A racist shit show.
1:11:13 Mark: Yeah, and there you go. There you have it. That's the Republican party in 2022. A racist shit show, yep. And finally, some things
1:11:27 [Unclear]: we really don't have time to talk about.
1:11:29 Jim: There’s been no shortage over the past six years of people with actual legal expertise pointing out that Trump has committed actual crimes that any normal person would be prosecuted for. These claims have generally fallen into two categories. Those which are true but won’t make any difference for some fucking reason, and the significantly rarer category of those which are true and might actually turn into something. In category one this week, we have Manhattan prosecutor Mark Pomerantz who resigned from the Manhattan DAs office last month when it became clear new DA Alvin Bragg was reluctant to prosecute what Pomerantz described in his resignation letter as “numerous felony violations” that Trump committed. In the much more exciting and colorful category two is the ruling from Judge David Carter in the case we talked about last episode where attorney John Eastman was trying to avoid giving the January 6 Committee a number of documents. Judge Carter ruled that 101 of the 111 documents were not privileged, one of which was specifically because “Based on the evidence, the court finds it more likely than not that President Trump corruptly attempted to obstruct the Joint Session of Congress on January 6th, 2021”. That, by the way, is a federal crime, and the document that quote specifically refers to also seems to implicate Rudy Giuliani directly in the criminal conspiracy. Mind you, if we just waited a bit Rudy would inevitably butt-dial a reporter and confess to it anyway.
1:12:47 Mark: Yeah, outside a garden, garden center somewhere. Yeah, it Just occurred to me that phrases about the truth are sometimes related to clothing – “a lie is halfway round the world before the truth has got its pants on” and “liar liar pants on fire”. Something about dressing up to appear better than others perhaps? It’s what Republican Madison Cawthorn seems to striving to do, apart from recently still calling the 2020 election fraudulent, rigged and stolen, he’s having a go at his own party now, saying in a podcast this week that he saw some of his own party members doing cocaine in a car park and was invited by fellow republicans to an orgy! Both of which he later admitted to lying about when taken to task by House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy. Impetuous youthfulness aside – he’s the youngest Republican representative – is he attempting to make himself appear better by being above the allegedly debauched behavior of his colleagues having been accused of sexual misconduct himself? Or does he think this is what you just do to please Trump in Trump’s GOP, after Trump endorsed candidate Lynda Bennett instead in 2020? Y’know – lie about being turned down for Naval Academy after injuries sustained in a car crash, nope he was just turned down, and lie about being pronounced dead in said crash – nope officially pronounced incapacitated. When you tell lies to clean the swamp – you are the swamp – did Donnie teach you nothin’? nothing?
1:14:18 Jim: Now I know that during my last headline you were all shouting at your cell-phones and smart speakers “But Jim, doesn’t 18 USC 1512 C2, attempting to obstruct an official proceeding require criminal intent? How will they prove Trump had corrupt intent Jim?” and I would expect nothing less. Frankly, if you weren’t shouting that then you’re not the listeners I know and love. But you’re also forgetting that Trump is a fucking idiot, and commits all his crimes out in the open like a naked man robbing a bank because a witch sold him an invisibility potion and he doesn’t think you can see him. Of course the Judge had plenty of evidence that Trump acted corruptly, but it’s always nice to have more, like, say, someone deliberately concealing or tampering with evidence. In unrelated news, the Washington Post reported this week that the White House Presidential phone log which was provided to the Jan 6 Committee is curiously absent of any phone calls between 11.17am and 6.54pm on January 6th. We know from the extensive reporting of that day that during that period Trump spoke on the phone to Senator Mike Lee, House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy and Mike Pence and it would be a bit surprising if he didn’t speak to anyone else, since it was a bit of a busy day, what with fomenting an insurrection and everything. So did he borrow someone else’s phone for some reason? Did he use a burner phone? Of course, Trump claims he not only didn’t use a burner phone, but he doesn’t even know what that term means, despite using it three times in his lawsuit against his niece Mary.
1:15:44 Mark: Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton has issues – I suspect it’s because he is furious that he’s one letter away from sounding like General Patton. He recently fired a letter off to the Austin Independent School District saying “By hosting ‘Pride Week,’ your district has, at best, undertaken a week-long instructional effort in human sexuality without parental consent. Or, worse, your district is cynically pushing a week-long indoctrination of your students that not only fails to obtain parental consent, but subtly cuts parents out of the loop. Either way, you are breaking state law.” Of course those aren’t the only choices – other choices include what the school district’s superintendent Dr Stephanie Elizalde fired back. “I want all our LGBTQIA+ students to know that we are proud of them and that we will protect them against political attacks,” and that Pride Week is “a time to highlight the district’s commitment to creating a safe, supportive and inclusive environment” for LGBTQ students. As a dangerously rich well-fed cis white male you’d think Paxton wouldn’t have to be blowing the dog-whistle so damn hard to continue to be voted in by similarly bigotted Texans. But hey, as we’ve learned this week, if you can’t be right be STUPIDLY FUCKIN’ VEHEMENT OR ELSE PEOPLE WILL FIND OUT!
1:17:10 Jim: Trump claims to be the best at a lot of things, and in almost every case, he’s either delusional or… end of sentence. However, one thing he truly seems to be better than pretty much everyone else at is losing in court. To be fair, he gets a lot of practice. He’s having another swing at it now, having recently sued Hillary Clinton, The DNC and 26 other people and entities for conspiring to undermine his 2016 campaign by making up lies about him and Russia. I’m not sure exactly what damages he’s claiming he suffered, since – I don’t know if you remember this, but – he won the 2016 election, but I guess it gives him something to do between poorly attended rallies. On hearing about the lawsuit CNN reached out to some of the defendants for a comment and FBI agent Peter Strzok’s lawyer said “We haven’t had a chance to read the complaint, but knowing the former President there’s probably very little in there that’s true.” which is extremely judgemental and probably highly accurate. One person who did get the chance to read it is First Amendment lawyer Ken White, who described it as “freakishly unprofessional and legally bumptious. Rather than a serious effort by serious lawyers, it’s a performative caper by injudiciously barred clowns.” Of course, when I hear the phrase injudiciously barred clowns, I think of Rudy Giuliani and Sidney Powell but they’re too busy being investigated for being terrible lawyers, so this lawsuit was filed by Trump’s old military academy classmate Peter Ticktin, a Florida lawyer who’s been suspended twice for conflict of interest violations and who writes fucking awful poetry that he proudly displays on his law firm’s website. He was also apparently responsible for getting Trump the award of ‘Ladies Man’ in the military academy yearbook. Trump has previously claimed it was because of his ‘great feeling’ for women, but Ticktin says “Somebody else got ‘Most Popular,’ and we wanted to give him something, so we made him ‘Ladies’ Man,’ which to us was kind of an inside joke because there really were no ladies,” I don’t think he’s going to last long as Trump’s lawyer if he keeps revealing stuff like that.
1:19:14 Mark: Right the whole Stop the Steal, overturn the election, bring down Biden thing was all to do with horned shamen and proud boys and working-class Americans stirred up by billionaire care-nothings on Jan 6th yeah? Except, no, well, you know Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas? You know he’s married? Texts sent by his wife Ginni to Trumps Chief of Staff Mark Meadows have been obtained by the Jan 6th committee The Washington Post notes that the committee is in possession of 21 such texts sent by Thomas to Meadows in the wake of the Nov. 2020 election. “Help This Great President stand firm, Mark!!!…You are the leader, with him, who is standing for America’s constitutional governance at the precipice,” one sent on Nov. 10 reads. “The majority knows Biden and the Left is attempting the greatest Heist of our History.” and on Nov 5th – “Biden crime family & ballot fraud co-conspirators (elected officials, bureaucrats, social media censorship mongers, fake stream media reporters, etc) are being arrested & detained for ballot fraud right now & over coming days, & will be living in barges off GITMO to face military tribunals for sedition.” But of course she’s a private citizen, completely mad mind you, but is entitled to say such stuff surely; not that she uses her husbands clout to influence any decisions nooo of course not – it’s not like she invoked her husband in an effort to woo Florida Governor Ron DeSantis into participating in an event hosted by a conservative group or anything in emails saying that the governor should be familiar with her because, in addition to seeing him at a state dinner at the White House and having interviewed him for the Daily Caller, her “husband has been in contact with him too on various things of late.” Well good to know that the supreme court is beyond the reach of the likes of Lady Macbeth.
1:21:19 Jim: If there’s one thing Republicans are sure of, it’s that your children are constantly in imminent danger of being kidnapped by pedophiles. If there’s a second thing they’re sure of it’s that being a Republican instantly absolves you from any accusations that you might be involved in anything inappropriate around children. Just look at Matt Gaetz. Or Roy Moore. Or Mark Foley. Or Jim Jordan. Or Dennis Hastert. Or George Nader. Or Lauren Boebert’s husband. Or… there’s a lot, is what I’m saying. In unrelated news, former Washington State representative Matt Shea, who is a Republican, by the way, who was suspended by the House Republican caucus and urged to resign after a House commissioned report found that he had planned and participated in domestic terrorism against the United States THREE TIMES between 2014 and 2016, showed up in a small town in Poland this week with over 60 Ukranian children. Weronika Ziarnika, an aide to the mayor of the town was contacted by local people who were concerned about the situation. She asked to speak to whoever was legally in charge of the children and Shea told her he’d spoken to the mayor and everything was fine. Ziarnika says she knew that wasn’t true, because it was the mayor who asked her to speak with him. Shea got really angry, refused to tell her his last name, and asked to see her ID. She asked him “What are you going to do with these children” and he said “None of your business”, which, of all possible answers to that question, is not one that fills you with confidence. Speaking on a right-wing religious Polish TV show later, Shea claimed that he was there on behalf of a Texas group called either Loving Families and Homes for Orphans, or Loving Homes and Families for Orphans depending on which part of the interview you listen to. He claimed that the group has been facilitating adoptions for years and while a group by that name is registered with the Texas Secretary of State, they are not registered as an adoption agency or affiliated with international adoption organizations and the group’s website is just a parked domain. But sure, it’s probably fine, because we only need to protect children from Democrats.
1:23:13 Mark: Brit poll Britpol this week in numbers – Rishi Sunak promises a tax cut in ooh… look 2024 election year having announced tax rises worth 2% of GDP in just two years – the same as Tony Blair and Gordon Brown did in ten. Oh and reinstated car parking fees for NHS staff! Nazanin Zaghari-Ratcliffe is freed from Iran and Fox News wannabes GB News accuse her of being ungrateful when she said “what took them so long” – after all the UK just paid £400 million to get you out – nope it was Iran’s money from a tank order unfilled in 1979. Homes for Ukraine gets 28,000 applications, only 2,700 visas are issued. COVID lateral flow tests will no longer cost nothing despite new cases topping 74,000 after the end of restrictions. P&O ferries knowingly break the law by laying off 800 staff at short notice and the government, familiar with knowingly breaking the law, is issued with 20 fines for COVID law breeches but Boris still maintains rules were followed. Commons Liaison Committee member calls PM “pretty much toast” if he had been issued one surely, Boris replies: “I think you’re just going to have to hold your horses and wait until the conclusion of the investigation when there will be a lot more clarity.” Spoiler alert, and let me be perfectly clear – there will be no clarity, only bread-like opacity. Would that we could afford enough energy to actually make toast with!
1:24:53 Jim: So that's all the bad arguments and faulty reasoning we have time for this week. You'll find the show notes at fallacioustrump.com. And if you hear Trump say something stupid and want to ask if it's a fallacy, our contact details are on the contact page.
1:25:03 Mark: If you think we've used a fallacy ourselves, let us know. And if you've had a good time, please give us a review on Apple Podcasts, Stitcher or wherever you get your podcasts, or simply tell one other person in person about how much they'd like our podcast. And you can support the show at patreon.com slash ftrump, Just like our Strawman-level patrons Steve Pickle, Schmutz, Mark Reiche and Albert R. Buchanan, and our true Scotsman-level patrons Kaz Toohey, Andrew Houck, Max Beaver, and our top patron, Lauren. Thank you so much, everyone. Your support is really very appreciated.
1:25:36 Jim: You can connect with those awesome people, as well as us and other listeners, in the Facebook group at Facebook .com. Slash groups, slash Fallacious Trump.
1:25:42 Mark: All music is by The Outbursts and was used with permission. So until next time, I'm Felicius Trump. We'll leave the last word to the Donald.
1:25:50 [Outro] That's right. Go home to mommy. Bye. Bye.
