Fallacy Fallacy FT#182

ShareBlueskyThreadsFacebookRedditEmail

Show Notes

The Fallacy Fallacy occurs when you assume a claim is false because a logical fallacy was used during arguments supporting the claim.

Trump

We started out by discussing this clip of Trump invoking accusing the media of Contextomy:

Then we looked at this clip of Chuck Grassley during Kash Patel’s confirmation hearing:

And finally we talked about this clip of Eric Burlison defending DOGE:

Mark’s British Politics Corner

Mark talked about these clips of Lord David Frost attacking the concept of NetZero:

Fallacy in the Wild (Sting: Tragedy -The BeeGees)

In the Fallacy in the Wild we looked at this clip from Better Call Saul:

Then we discussed this clip from God’s Not Dead:

And we finished up with this clip from The Good Life:

 

Fake News

Here are the statements from this week’s Fake News game:

SpoilerStatement 2 is Fake News. Mark chose number 2

Mark got it right this week, and is still on 49%!

 

A Government Shutdown is not a logical fallacy

We talked about the current Government shutdown, and who is to blame.

 

The stories we really didn’t have time to talk about

  • Seven years ago, Trump gave a speech at the UN General Assembly, and when he said his administration had achieved more than all past US presidents, the generally assembled leaders of the entire rest of the world laughed at him. Well, they’re not laughing now. Instead, at this year’s speech, they sat dumbstruck by dumbness. The actual real politicians who know what they’re doing and for the most part don’t actively hate the people who voted for them had to sit there while this sundowning fuckwit told them their countries are all going to hell, that the US is living through a golden age, that climate change is the “greatest con job ever perpetrated on the world”,, that everyone says he should get the Nobel Peace Prize, that the UN building in New York would have been much better and cheaper if he had won the contract to renovate it back in 2001, that Christianity is the “most persecuted religion on the planet”, and most absurdly, that “I am really good at this stuff”. It doesn’t matter what stuff he was talking about at that moment – he isn’t. Of course, he also railed against the fact that the teleprompters didn’t work and that an escalator stopped while he was on the way to make the speech, which was clearly an act of sabotage. Some people online had fun with the fact that this happened on the day of the supposed rapture and Trump couldn’t even ascend one floor, let alone to heaven. Personally, I’m glad that rapture didn’t happen, because I’ve still got two episodes of The Residence to watch on Netflix. Just kidding, I am NOT getting raptured. Anyway, I’d rather stay down here with all you cool heathens. Where was I? Oh yeah, The escalator thing. Predictably, the right’s already overdeveloped culture of victimhood turned a stopped escalator into an international incident. Propaganda Barbie Karoline Leavitt said that “if someone intentionally stopped the escalator as the President and First Lady were stepping on, they need to be fired and investigated immediately”, presumably in that order. Fox News Host Jesse Watters suggested either leaving or bombing the UN, and his Fox colleague Maria Bartiromo claimed “this could’ve been a massive, massive issue. The president being frozen there in one place makes him vulnerable.” Conservative commentator Wilt Chamberlain agreed, saying “this was remarkably dangerous. If someone in the building wanted Trump assassinated this would have been a great way to freeze him.” They talk like Trump is constantly on the move, ducking and dodging and running in zigzags to avoid snipers. He’s a 79 year old man who stands in one place for hours at a time talking about sharks and Hannibal Lecter. The thing is, as Mitch Hedberg once said, “An escalator can never break: it can only become stairs.” If all that’s needed to endanger the President is some temporarily static stairs, you’ve got bigger problems than sabotage. Of course, in the usual course of right wing victimhood, the sabotage was self-inflicted. Apparently a White House videographer accidentally triggered the emergency stop on the escalator, and the malfunctioning teleprompters were also being operated by Trump’s team. Perhaps they were trying to prevent him from saying some of the stupider shit in his speech. Jokes on them though, because Trump can be stupid extemporaneously.
  • I don’t think Trump is modern enough to have watched the movie Elysium where the rich live in a space station orbiting the earth, though I suspect he’d love it – for all the wrong reasons; while it’s a socialist revolutionary movie about rebelling against the whopping class divide between the wealth of the owners of the means of production and the workers providing that wealth, he’d definitely be on the side of the orbiting oligarchs deploying the military police to quell any kind of protest that threatens the exclusivity of the astral Mar-A-Lago. No he’s more a Star Trek Original Series kind of guy, not for the diversity, inclusion and acceptance of working and living alongside all sorts of different species in peace and harmony for the furtherance of boldly going, but rather for the magic beds that Bones has in his medical facility. In an AI-generated video shared on Truth Social the president’s daughter-in-law Lara Trump anchors a fake Fox News segment promoting a new Trump administration healthcare plan she says will result in “MedBed hospitals”. and “national Medbed card[s] for every citizen.” Conspiracy theory believers in the “Medbed” conspiracy have long thought that the U.S. government has technology – the same featured in Elysium – capable of healing wounds, regrowing limbs, curing diseases, and has kept it hidden away from the American public for years, using it only on members of the military and politicians. Needless to say, the beds do not exist, just like they don’t really in Elysium and Star Trek. Yet here’s Trump so convinced by the fake news of it that it got shared on his platform, cos he’s the best president – he’s going to make it available to everyone, and not just the elites. Someone must have reminded him that actually they are not going to renew MediCare insurance subsidies and have been steadily dismantling any semblance of universal free healthcare access cos it’s got Obama’s name on it, in order to fund a tax cut for the top 1% so how, or even why, will they roll out MedBeds to everyone. But he definitely only took the post down on the basis of “now everyone will want one you fool, and then I’ll have nothing that they don’t have, you can’t be King like that! That’s practically communism!” Also it’d use up all the available money, tech and 1.21 gigawatts of power the US generates in order to make one big and powerful enough to house his huge dysfunctional, unhealthy blob of a carcass. Ah, can’t wait til he reposts footage of those zero-gravity humans in Wall-E!
  • At the end of September, former weekend Fox and Friends host Pete Hegseth ordered every senior US general and admiral worldwide to drop whatever they were doing, leave whatever active warzone command post they were running, and join him at Marine Corps Base Quantico in Virginia for an in person meeting. This is not only hugely disruptive and expensive, but also pretty much unprecedented, so he must have had some urgent and vital news or strategy to announce that could only effectively be done in person. Sure enough, when the 800 or so senior military leaders gathered, Hegseth redefined the parameters of a meeting that could have been an email by demanding an end to fat soldiers and beards. The Secretary of War who can’t do a single pull up lectured the career soldiers on the warrior ethos, briefly hawked his own book, and then told them about just some of the ways he plans to actively make the military worse – saying “no more politically correct and overbearing rules of engagement”, referring to the directives that were created after WWII to prevent war crimes. He said no more to “identity months”, “climate change worship”, “dudes in dresses”, and demanded a return to hazing, and drill sergeants being allowed to “put their hands on recruits”. He also feels that military careers are side-tracked by accusations of unacceptable behavior, which is something he knows a little about, as someone who paid $50,000 to a woman who accused him of sexual assault in 2017. Eager to avoid that kind of thing happening to soldiers, Hegseth called for “No more frivolous complaints, no more anonymous complaints, no more repeat complaints, no more smearing reputations,” so presumably, so long as you behave inappropriately on a regular basis, it will be dismissed as a repeat complaint and you’ll be cleared. Fortunately for the generals, they hadn’t totally wasted their time in coming to hear him speak, because after Secretary Pete was done, Trump came on, and immediately complained about the lack of applause from military officers who are not allowed to express partisan views while on duty. He told them if they didn’t like what he said they could leave, and threatened their jobs if they did, and did a tight five on the Gulf of America and Joe Biden’s autopen, and then announced his plan to use American cities as training grounds for the US military, which he said “is going to be a major part for some of the people in this room. That’s a war, too. It’s a war from within.” Totally cool  and normal thing for a President to say.
  • Democrats are accusing House Speaker Mike Johnson of stalling the swearing-in of newly elected Adelita Grijalva, who will represent Arizona’s 7th Congressional District, because she will sign a petition forcing a vote on releasing the Jeffrey Epstein files. Grijalva said in a September 30 statement sent to Newsweek, “Earlier this year, two Republicans in Florida were sworn in during pro forma sessions less than 24 hours after their elections. The fact that Southern Arizona is being treated differently raises serious questions about political motivations – especially since I have pledged to become the 218th signature on the discharge petition to force a vote on the Epstein files.” The petition is missing one signature hers would force a vote on the matter.
    Call me naive but I just don’t understand what the problem is cos surely we’ve been told the files don’t exist/do exist and/or its a Democrat hoax and/or Trump is/isn’t on there and would/would not thus be liable to something or nothing. Oh actually that’s the problem, it’s not nuanced – it’s just wrong!  The sound of the old V8-powered goalposts being driven up and down the White House dragstrip, not heard since the previously turns-out-to-be-true Russian conversation that did/didn’t happen from out of Trump Tower, no it didn’t, we don’t know anything about that, the tapes with the voices saying that on them are obviously a Democrat hoax, oh sorry you mean those beautiful conversations I bragged about? Well no I didn’t. Just when you thought Trump was actually stupid and thus harmless (no-one thinks that) turns out the GOP knows that and knows exactly what it’s doing and having Stupid as their malicious narcissistic front man provides all the smoke screen they need. We all see it, we know it, they know it and yet…and yet! 
  • We’ve talked about the One Big Beautiful Bill a few times, and there are so many things wrong with it that I honestly can’t remember if we mentioned that the Congressional Budget Office estimated it would result in 3 million more Americans being unable to qualify for SNAP benefits. That’s the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, formerly and colloquially still known as food stamps, a federal government program that provides food-purchasing assistance for low- and no-income persons to help them maintain adequate nutrition and health. But fuck those poor people, says the GOP they should have had the good sense not to be poor, like we did. The benefit of the Bigness of the beautiful bill was that it was hard to talk about all the badness in it, and while a good chunk of Republican voters are actively happy that poor people don’t get to buy bread with taxpayer money, it’s not one of those policies that everyone agrees with. Unfortunately for the Trump Administration, for the past thirty years the US Department of Agriculture has released an annual report on Household Food Security in the US, which is seen as the gold standard for understanding the struggle that millions of families face to put food on the table. Fortunately for the Trump Administration, rules aren’t a thing anymore, so this year’s report, which covers 2024, will be the last. After all, we know Trump’s theory on COVID testing, and so obviously if you stop counting the number of hungry people, they stop existing. Actually, there’s a point at which that one kind of comes true. Fuck.
  • Yaaay what’s the next best thing to Jacob Wohl resurfacing? It’s the QAnon Shaman! In a rambling complaint, Jacob Chansley the poster boy of insurrection and buffalo-hat face-paint fashionista is representing himself, naturally, for a suit he filed on Monday in Maricopa County Superior Court. A rambling, 26-page complaint consisting of a single paragraph alleging that his First, Fourth and Second Amendment rights have been violated by a host of parties – Trump, the Federal Reserve, the National Security Agency, the International Monetary Fund, the World Bank, the Bank of International Settlements, the state of Israel, Elon Musk’s X Corp., T-Mobile, the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency and Warner Bros. Studios. The claims in Chansley’s suit include:
    • That the central banking system and the Federal Reserve are unconstitutional
    • That the U.S. government is guilty of treason for prioritizing the interests of foreign financiers at the expense of the American people
    • That the NSA surveilled Chansley daily using the Patriot Act as he was writing a “2nd Declaration of Independence”
    • That “all radio stations and most of their DJ’s are a part of the intelligence community”
    • That a scene in the 2008 Christopher Nolan-directed Batman film “The Dark Knight” and many plot details in 2009’s “Avatar” were cribbed from his writing and are proof that the NSA was spying on him
    • That the NSA catfished him on Facebook by contacting him while pretending to be actress Michele Rodriguez, whom Chansley identifies as “my celebrity crush”
    • That he was then “offered the opportunity to work with the NASA covertly and help them deal with other-worldly matters” that his “shamanic beliefs” made him “a perfect candidate to handle”
    • That he was emailed by Donald Trump on Jan. 8, 2021, from an address of donaldtrump@nsa.gov
    • That the government stole more than $100,000 in cryptocurrency from him
  • Chansley concludes his complaint by declaring himself the first president of the “New Constitutional Republic of the United States.” and that Phoenix will be the capital of this new republic. As his first act, Chansley said he would order the Federal Reserve to mint a one-ounce gold coin and set its value at $40 trillion to pay off America’s debt – which isn’t really how debt or currency works. “I am within all of my own rights and legal authority to do this because all of the information provided in this lawsuit is factual and cannot be argued, if a person were in the loop of what I had written on my computer a few months prior those details would stand out to a sharp mind.” Perhaps if that sharp mind (sic) belonged to Dinesh D’Souza? And in a Dinesh D’Souza-esque “there’s more evidence that we’re not able to bring you right now” kind of way Chansley did include a handwritten URL for a Google Drive folder that he said contains more than 1,000 exhibits that prove his accusations. Phoenix New Times encountered an error attempting to access it.
  • In all the best democracies, the one thing we are guaranteed to see is political opponents being performatively prosecuted at the whim of an authoritarian leader. Sorry, not democracies, banana republics. That’s what I meant. We know this is an uncontroversially good thing because of how happy Republicans were when there was a slight chance that Trump might face a single tiny consequence for all the crimes he absolutely committed. So of course, everyone’s equally happy about the indictment of former FBI director James Comey. To be fair, if you’re going to indict someone and are hoping to please everyone, Comey’s a great shout, as pretty much everyone dislikes him for different reasons – Democrats because of his thumb on the scales that helped Trump’s election, and Republicans because he planned to actually investigate the links between the Trump Campaign and Russian interference in the election. But we’ve got this weird thing on the left where we only think people should be indicted for crimes they actually committed, even if we don’t like that person. Trump disagrees, of course, and that’s why he fired US Attorney Erik Seibert, who foolishly refused to indict Comey on the flimsy basis that he hadn’t committed a crime, and replaced him with Lindsey Halligan, an insurance lawyer with no previous prosecutorial experience. She’s already fucked up in court, presenting the judge with a signed indictment on three counts, only two of which had actually been accepted by the grand jury. Meanwhile, because the entire administration is a shitshow, an FBI agent has been fired for refusing to arrange a perp walk for Comey where he’s arrested and handcuffed in front of news cameras. Perp walks, by the way, are prohibited by DOJ policy, but Trump really wanted one, and that’s what really matters.
  • Well in Britain it’s all going down the Tubes except when the Tube is on strike of course. The Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood is being more Suella or Priti than her previously-seen-protesting-pre-election-about-Palestine-in-July 2024-self. Shabana is bringing in more powers to prevent repeat protests against Israel’s actions in Palestine, despite the fact that the British Government has been the first in Europe to recognise the Palestinian State. Even taking that into account it’s still illegal to protest against the Palestinian genocide in perceived suppport of the proscribed terrorist organisation Palestinian Action, this has led to the recent arrest and leading away of a blind woman who obviously couldn’t even see that she was holding a placard demanding the end to the genocide. The new powers would prevent people gathering in the same place time and time again cos that causes problems for policing and indeed drains the resources of the police force. In danger of employing the false equivalence fallacy surely the same could have been said of the protesters gathering outside the same so-called immigrant hotels week after week, but no extra powers employed there. This comes in the wake of several people being killed in an attack on a synagogue after which the Palestinian support protests were deemed to be in poor taste and should be called off. Zak Polanski the leader of the Green Party, and Jewish himself, pointed out that that was a conflation of two separate things, and reacting to the deaths of three or so people and 10s of thousands of people could both happen at the same time, and saying otherwise would be falling into the Israeli government’s claiming that anti-Zionism and anti-Netanyahu-ism was the equivalent of anti-semitism. Zak thankfully said the thing we often say “ it’s a bit more nuanced than that”. Meanwhile knives are out, obviously, for Corbyn and his new party, I’ve seen the ‘unelectable” word being bandied about again, ignoring the stats that show that Corbyn’s election results in 2017 at 40% of the public vote outweighed Starmer’s 34% in 2024. But with Zak Polanski I guess being the equivalent of Gavin Newsom in terms of speaking against the right-leaning tide, both Starmer and Corbyn need to look out, if only the media would show more of Zak than tweedy gonad Farage, perhaps he wouldn’t be being drumrolled into Number 10 and Reform-fearing Shabana wouldn’t be being such an arse.

You can now buy Jim’s book, 2000 Mules and One Big Lie: A Stubborn Conspiracy Theory, and you can buy all our t-shirts, mugs, hats and more at our TeePublic Store, including this week’s fallacy:

 

That’s almost all for this week, but here’s our AI-aided transcript, which is quite accurate, but not totally:

Fallacy Fallacy – FT#182 Transcript

Read the full transcript

00:24 Jim: Hello and welcome to Fallacious Trump, the podcast where we use the insane ramblings of a Backpfeifengesicht to explain logical fallacies. I'm your host, Jim.

00:32 Mark: And I'm your other host, Mark. A logical fallacy is an error in reasoning that results in bad or invalid arguments. And the logical fallacy we're looking at this week is the fallacy fallacy, also known as the argument by fallacy. Backpfeifengesicht. Sounds like one of those marvellous portmanteau German nouns. It's one of

00:52 Jim: those words that the Germans do so brilliantly. It means a face in need of a punch, basically.

01:04 [Unclear]: Yeah, one of those great words that we don't have a direct

01:08 Jim: single word translation of. Nice. The concept is universal. That's fantastic. So, the fallacy fallacy. Fallacy fallacy, yeah. It's one where someone uses the fact that their opponent has used a fallacy in their argument as a reason for dismissing the claim. The truth of the claim.

01:32 Mark: Oh, yeah, because we've often talked about don't just spot the fallacy being used. That is not the end of the argument. And we've tried to say, and we've fallen into the trap ourselves, just going: oh, I've just spotted that you've cherry -picked me or you've red -herringed me, as if that's enough to just end the argument and dismiss the other person's position or their points, even if their points are perfectly valid.

02:02 Jim: Yeah, because the thing about informal fallacies is that they don't make something definitely not true. They just change the, the probability. So, right, you can defend a valid point within valid logic. Yeah, you can defend the truth badly. Yeah, and if someone does that using logical fallacies, that doesn't make the truth not true, yeah, it just means that their argument's a bad argument for defending it. And yeah, some people will use the fact that their opponent has used a logical fallacy as the as the basis for dismissing their claims that some people include one: Donald j Trump. We're not exactly, because one of the things – and I've been waiting – we're on episode 150 182. I've been waiting for him to do this, but the thing about this fallacy is that in order to do it, you need to have at least a basic understanding of logical fallacies, of what they are, and Trump obviously is a fucking idiot, so he doesn't. So the closest I've got is him accusing people of taking things out of context, which is context to me, which is a fallacy if it is done in an invalid way to back up an argument. So he doesn't invoke the name of the fallacy, but he does make this accusation.

03:22 Clip: Trump accusing the media of contextomy

— But what they use a lot was was: I'll be a dictator.

— Day one, you said, I'll be a dictator for one day.

— But they leave that out. And sometimes when they do add it, they don't say why. And I said jokingly on Sean Hannity, who's a great guy. I said no, Sean, I want to be a dictator for one day, because I'm going to get going with drill, baby drill. And I'm going to strengthen the borders to a level like you've never seen. I only want to be. And after that, I'll never be a dictator." So I said it nicely. And I said, one day, because I want to do the energy and I want to strengthen the border, one day. And it was said with a chuckle. The audience laughed. I laughed. We all laughed. But they take it and they cut it. And then they cut it. And it says, I want to be a dictator. These are very dishonest people that we're dealing with, very dishonest people, bad people.

— So you say that was taken out of context?

— Well, all you have to do is watch it.

04:25 Jim: So I did watch it. Here's how NBC, that night, portrayed this exchange between Trump and Sean Hannity. They played this clip.

04:37 Clip: Trump accusing the media of contextomy (continued)

— You would never abuse power as retribution against anybody. Except for day one.

— Except for what? He's going crazy. Except for day one. Meaning? I want to close the border and I want to drill.

— Drill, drill, drill. That's not retribution.

— I'm going to be, I'm going to be, you know, he keeps, we love this guy. He says, you're not going to be a dictator, are you? I said, no, no, no, other than day one. We're closing the border and we're drilling, drilling, drilling. After that, I'm not a dictator.

05:08 Jim: If you want to say that NBC took that out of context, if they did, that's still a kind of 30 second clip. That's quite a lot, and he says things that you shouldn't say in any context. Really, yeah, yeah, but here's the context. They were talking about something else completely before that. Here is what follows on directly from that clip.

05:30 Clip: Trump accusing the media of contextomy (continued)

— That sounds to me like you're going back to the policies when you're President. All right, take a break. Just getting started, we're in beautiful davenport, iowa, Donald Trump with us for the hour. As Hannity continues. Thank you, so that's it.

05:42 Jim: Hannity normalizes, Kisses it and then throws to a break. That's the context that they took it out of.

05:48 Mark: Him saying you've taken it out of context, they're going, yeah, what you've done is just said that's all fine. And he's saying that people are saying they took it out of context for it not to be fine. But the opening bit, he does say, oh, yeah, we're going to get him. He should go to jail for retribution.

06:06 Jim: Well, Hansi asks if he would ever use presidential power as retribution. And he says only on the first day: yeah, yeah, he hasn't really forgot about that bit, yeah, yeah, as is often the case with these kinds of things, what I'm pointing out here is that he's wrong when he says it was taken out of context. Yeah, but the point is that even if he wasn't wrong, even if they had taken it out of context, there's plenty of other evidence that Trump would love to to be a dictator. Many, many other things he has said, almost everything he's done since the beginning of his second term, points to his desire to be an authoritarian dictator. This is also him saying it out loud when cameras are running and he knows he's being filmed. So right, had there been some context for this which made it less bad? There wasn't, but it had if there had been. The fact that The fact that they also use this clip to bolster their argument doesn't mean the argument is not true. It doesn't mean that their claim that Trump wants to be a dictator isn't.

07:12 Mark: It's entirely invalidated by that taking it out of context.

07:16 Jim: So our second example is from Senator Chuck Grassley in Kash Patel's confirmation hearing for director of the FBI.

07:25 Clip: Chuck Grassley during Kash Patel's confirmation hearing

— Outside of this committee and some people on this committee have accused you of promoting the QAnon movement. My colleagues have already asked your future boss, Mr. Bondi, many questions about this. I think it's easy to see these attacks for what they are, guilt by association. Are you a follower or promoter of QAnon?

— No, Senator. In fact, I have publicly, including in the interviews provided to this committee, rejected outright QAnon baseless conspiracy theories or any other baseless conspiracy theories. That's not true.

08:01 Mark: No, that's kind of. Has he though? Yeah, yeah, that's. It's very specific about the baseless conspiracy theory. Yes, yeah, um.

08:12 Jim: I don't know why Chuck Grassley referred to pan bondi as Mr bondi.

08:16 Mark: Yeah, your future boss, Mr bondi.

08:18 Jim: Yeah, um, yeah, but but yeah, he's claiming that this is just guilt by association. There people are trying to connect Kash patel to q anon to make him look bad, to make him look like he's a conspiracy theorist. He very much openly promoted conspiracy theories on his podcasts that he that he's run and as guests on other people's podcasts. The books that he wrote about how the election was stolen. He signed 10 of them with the q anon phrase where we go on, we go all, and then raffled those specifically as like limited edition copies. He has gone on multiple kind of q anon friendly podcasts and and courted q anon believers. When he was involved in truth social and setting up of that with devin nunes, he promoted, actively promoted – one of the first accounts on truth social, which was just at q, and yeah, he posted things claiming he was hanging out with the person who ran the at q account and saying that people who follow who, who believe in Q's, should follow on Truth Social. And he has promoted and thrown bones to the QAnon community repeatedly over years.

09:31 [Unclear]: That was his route to stardom. Yeah, yeah.

09:34 Jim: Conspiracy theories are his biggest fans.

09:37 Mark: And that's, and he kind of rode on the back of that entire thing in order to get into Trump's orbit.

09:45 Jim: The thing is he is being essentially interviewed for the job of running law enforcement for the us – yeah, for a big part of the doj. So it is valid to question his links to a, an organization that actively believes in usurping some of those laws, because, yeah, they believe that things are happening that aren't happening, that, yes, you know major Democratic leaders are involved in child abduction, those kinds of things. That justifies them doing things that you're not not allowed to do. That cash sales supposed to be working against that.

10:20 Mark: Yes, that's a kind of exactly the question you want to be asking. Well, any government employee really. But you know they're kind of – um, I guess what they're in in dismissing it as guilt by association. Perhaps they're very aware of the mccarthy I? You know communist stuff, you know. Are you ever, oh, have you ever been member of the member of the q anon party in previous circumstances? If you were associated deeply with an organization that spread conspiracy theories to the detriment of law enforcement agencies being able to carry out their jobs, that would disbar you from taking up the Post.

11:10 Jim: Yeah, if that was the kind of thing they were trying to to actually figure out before just rubber stamping, yeah, anyone Trump wanted in these roles, who would do the things he wants, then that would be a great line of inquiry to go down.

11:24 [Unclear]: But yeah, they don't

11:25 Mark: actually give a shit. No, and they're dismissing everybody by going: oh yeah, that's just got my association. Yeah, yeah, yes, that's precisely what we want to employ when we're doing a job interview.

11:35 Jim: Yes, so our final an example in this section is GOP Congressman Eric Burleson in a hearing about Doge.

11:44 Clip: Eric Burlison defending DOGE

— I would hate to be in the Democratic Party right now because you're in a really bad bind. You're having to defend all of this crazy spending, all of this crazy waste. So how do you do it? You do ad hominem attacks. You attack the messenger. Oh, Elon Musk, right? He's rich. He must be evil, right? That's the attacks. Really? You can't do any better than that? I mean, they can do a lot better than that.

12:08 Jim: And literally everything they said was better than that because no one said that at all. Said that, yeah. None of the people, none of the Democrats in this hearing or any other hearing have said Doge's cuts are bad because Elon Musk is rich, therefore he's evil. That isn't an argument that has been made. If that had been an argument that they had made, they would have been doing a bad job defending their position. But that doesn't mean the cuts are good. Right, yes, the cuts that, yes, yes, that Musk was trying to make and badly failing in so many ways, but some of the cuts did get made. You know, the he damaged Usaid damaged lots of other elements that that were, yeah, doing good things for American people and people around the world. Those cuts, the things that he was claiming were waste, were not waste and were actually helping people and he made it bad. And, yeah, whether, in trying to point that out, you attack his character doesn't affect the truth of the, the fact that those cuts are bad. Again, this is a thing that didn't happen. And – and this guy was talking directly after jasmine crockett had been making an excellent point about how many people were being hurt by the direct things that doge were doing, and burleson then just pretends that they haven't been making any good points and have just been saying Elon Musk is evil and,

13:34 Mark: in doing so, straw mans them as well.

13:37 [Sting: Mark's British Politics Corner] And now is the time, I think, for Mark's British Politics Corner.

13:41 Mark: Just the one example this week, but it's it's packed to the gunnels, so and it's kind of it's about climate and uh, zero, uh, not zero sum, and uh, the uh, climate, net, net, zero. There you go, Thank you. And the net zero agenda, and it came from a climate agenda debate in the house of lords which took place last october. Peter Lilly – now Lord Lilly, who served once in margaret thatcher and john major's cabinets – began the debate. The debate basically says: we take note of the impact. This house takes note of the impact of his majesty's government's climate agenda on jobs, growth and prosperity. The lords is a lot more stayed and somewhat laid back than the commons. The commons so it's the equivalent of the senate, that whereas the commons is all kind of people baying at each other, the lords they're very the fact that they use my noble Lord and things like that it's a lot less heated in the actual exchanges. And the way it's set up is that that people may lay out their case and the arguments. I say it's a lot less heated in the exchanges. It opened with Lord Debden, who was John Gummer, who was originally the chairman of the Conservative Party in the 80s and he was Secretary of State for the Environment in the 90s. And he chaired the UK's Independent Climate Change Committee. And he opened the debate by posing these remarks as a question to Lord Lilly and to the gathered lords.

15:15 Clip: Lord David Frost attacking the concept of Net Zero

— Do we really want to be in the hands of this volatility of the gas price? Do we want to be in the hands of some of the nastiest regimes in the world? Or do we want to have our own energy source at a lower price, at a cost we can afford? The figures are all there. So I merely say to him: read the documents again, game, and accept that you are on one side – science, the church and the climate change committee are on the other.

15:47 Mark: So that kind of lays out where, where it's at. So he's saying that there is an acceptance in fact of, uh, the science, the church – bit of an odd one, because he john gummers – I think he was a member of some church representation thing, for that is government. It's a bit odd to put that in. There is a weird one

16:09 Jim: to include in that list.

16:10 Mark: Yeah, yeah, and the climate change committee, or on the other. So you know, here are all the facts. Um, what have you got to say about that kind of stuff? The Conservative Lord frost then takes the stand, and this is where the the fallacy fallacies come in. So this is david frost, not that one. He's the one who was the united kingdom's chief negotiator for for exiting the European Union during the Brexit negotiations in 2019. And from January December 2024, he was trustee of the Climate Sceptical Global Warming Policy Foundation charitable organisation. Of course it's charitable means they avoid paying tax – whose aims are to challenge what it calls extremely damaging and hurtful policies envisaged by governments to mitigate anthropogenic global warming. And in 2025 – january this year, he joined the net zero watch, which it doesn't sound. It's one of those think tanks that sounds like what it isn't. Um, it's basically a glow spun out of the global warming policy foundation and campaigns for less government funding on climate action. So they're watching it to make sure it doesn't happen. So, um, you might get a flavor from his previous jobs – no guilt by association, but yes – of where his standpoint is. So there's a bit of a long clip, so it's four minutes in total, but we're doing two chunks, but it can. It contains him calling on no fewer than six fallacies allegedly being used by the net zero camp in order for him to discredit its position, and I'm sure he nevertheless adds a few of his own. So he starts by setting out your stall and then he details the first three fallacies.

17:56 Clip: Lord David Frost attacking the concept of Net Zero

— In my view, we're not in the climate emergency. Climate change is a challenge we can meet. It isn't one that requires us to upend our entire economy and our way of life. One of the reasons why I'm confident our current approach is harmful is that it requires many normally sensible people to have to believe in a whole series of economic fallacies for their policy to work. First of all, the broken window fallacy. We're supposed to believe that net zero will make us richer, just like repairing a broken window funds the glazier and gets your window back. But your wealth is just the same. And in fact, what we're doing today is creating an actual reduction in wealth. The new asset is actually worse than the old one. The replacement of the current grid with rickety and expensive renewables is not an improvement. Second fallacy, the fallacy of it's all going to be all right on the night. This is a belief that one day we will just solve the problems, we'll solve the storage problem with hydrogen, hydro, batteries, whatever. The view that interconnects will always work well. They'll never export when they're supposed to import. Those to whom we are connected will never think their interests come first. I can tell you I learned from the vaccines saga and France's threats to Jersey that you can't rely even on our closest friends when the chips are down. This policy is making us deeply insecure. Third fallacy, the fallacy of self-deception, most obviously on prices and costs. A child can see. Surely that it isn't cheaper to build a renewables grid plus all the backup than just to build effective backup and forget about the renewables?

19:35 Mark: Some of those fallacies, I'm sure, aren't fallacies. He's just kind of saying they are using fallacies. I'm going to Call them fallacies in order to say that we've got to believe in a whole bunch of Fallacious things in order to swallow this into the entire idea that renewable energy makes economic sense. He's coming from a Conservative background which is entirely climate change skeptic, so that's kind of where he's coming from, and he dismisses any argument made – and you can infer what the arguments are. Because he dismisses them by saying: oh, that's a, that's a broken window fallacy and then replaces it with that one in particular. He says the replacement of the current grid with rickety and expensive renewables. He doesn't make the argument as to why they're rickety.

20:26 Jim: No, no, I would say that he's replacing it with a straw man. Because absolutely yes, why would they be rickety? And I mean this was october last year, but it's it's long before that – that renewables are now cheaper than fossil fuels.

20:39 Mark: Yes, and john gummer has said that early on. He kind of read out the numbers. He said, yeah, you know the. The reason he's saying, do we want to be tied to the gas prices? Is because Because there's massive lobbying, not least on the part of Lord Frost, to tie the energy that you buy off the grid to the gas price. And it's precisely to avoid renewables showing that they are cheaper and providing cheaper energy to people so everyone will move from gas. So this kind of this idea that it goes on later on, david david frost goes on later on to say, oh, yeah, well, the um, you know, there's got to have, there's got to be a backup system for when it doesn't rain or when it's not sunny or when it's not windy, and all that stuff. You think, yeah, but you don't, that exists, that exists already. That's the gas infrastructure.

21:33 Jim: So, yeah, and his, his, his third one, yeah, the fallacy of self -deception, which I don't, I don't think is a fallacy. I think no, yeah, but he is just using the alleged certainty fantasy and common sense fantasy that he's just. He's just saying, you know, everyone can see, everyone knows, like you'd have to be an idiot not to understand that it's not cheaper to build a renewables grid than just to build effective backup to what? Effective backup to the fossil fuel system? Yeah, yeah, yes, exactly why do you don't need that? What is, what is effective backup to a system of running out energy which is expensive and polluting?

22:11 Mark: He says it's not cheaper to build a renewables grid, where you don't need to build a renewables grid and you don't need to build one because it exists.

22:19 Jim: The grid exists that you can tap into with renewables, but no one needs to build a renewables grid. But it is of course cheaper in the long run to tap in to literally renewable energy instead of stuff that is limited. Of course. That is unrenewable. Because by definition Because once it's gone, it's gone. Stuff that isn't renewable. As there is less of it, it gets more expensive.

22:44 Mark: And he pulls the old switcheroo because he says, yeah, it's not cheaper to build a renewables grid plus all the backup than to just build an effective backup and forget about the renewables. Well, why not forget about the backup and just do the renewables? Yeah, and just build a renewable one. Surely that's cheaper. So, yes. Also, the second one contains a Eurosceptic slur because he says, France's threat to Jersey. So this basically, what I've learned from the vaccine saga and France's threat to Jersey, we cannot rely even on our closest friends. So a little bit of xenophobia in there, a bit of Euroscepticism, which is appealing to that certain wing of the Tory party. And he's referring to the oft -touted thing by Johnson that the European Union, if they had been in the European Medical Agency, they would not have got the vaccine as early as they did in Britain, which is untrue. Nor did Europe prevent them from uh getting any more vaccines subsequently. It was because we'd left the European medical agency that, when astrazeneca started having contraindications and they went to pfizer, we had to join the back of the queue. There's nothing to do with Europe. It's all to do with brexit, the brexit deal brought about by Lord frost and the France's threats to Jersey. Um, he's alluding to the row triggered by the changes brought about by brexit to the fishing rights of Uk and eu fishing fleets, and the french minister for maritime affairs said she was revolted by the lack of access given to french boats that had operated for decades in Jersey waters, because it's all about the fish, and boris's Tory government claimed that. But she had claimed that Paris was ready to retaliate, warning that the Channel Islands relied on the transmission of electricity by underwater cables from France. Ignoring the fact that EDF, which is one of the largest energy suppliers in Britain, stands for Energy de France. So we get a lot of electricity in England from France. So yeah, and that that just played delightfully into frost and johnson's anti -eu rhetoric and that they kind of went: oh yeah, well, this is bloody typical. So that's kind of what he's alluding to. It's quite pleasant listening to – well, not to the content, but the way that it's delivered. It's a lot less fraught, um, and it's a lot more kind of gentlemanly in these exchanges, even though he's a complete arse. So, okay, so here it goes. Four to six. Here we go. Fourth fallacy, the fallacy that jobs are a benefit, not a cost.

25:57 Clip: Lord David Frost attacking the concept of Net Zero

— If you believe that, you must think we could make ourselves wealthier by sending everyone back into the fields to work on the land. We want the fewest, the most highly productive jobs possible, like those we already have in the oil and gas industry, but jobs which this government is gradually extinguishing. Fifth fallacy, the fallacy of the infinite availability of resources. In this world, in the net-zero world, there's always lots of capital waiting to be used. We always have enough workers. There are no linkages or timing problems for proper sequencing. Foreigners are always willing to lend to the UK. UK consumers are always happy to save instead of consume. Massive projects such as insulating every home in the UK or doubling the capacity of the energy grid can be undertaken, apparently, without any resource constraints or knock -on effects in the wider economy. And finally, my Lords, there's the industrial policy fallacy: the view that the Government knows best, that it can pick the technologies, the subsidies and the targets to get us to net zero. The ineffective boilers and heat pumps, the expensive EVs, the windmills, the technology that was the last cutting edge in this country under Henry II. I think we can be confident that any project pursued in this way is going to be a drag on the economy. All economic theory tells us so. Now. I believe in the long -standing Conservative principles – economic freedom, decentralised decision -taking, incentives for entrepreneurs, economic experimentation – yet the net zero approach we've chosen is requiring us to junk all this in favour of greater control. Control and restrictions of Soviet -style production targets, policies we believe are wrong in any area, except when it comes to net zero. And I urge my colleagues to reflect. If you're a Conservative and your policy forces you to implement socialism, then just maybe it's a bad policy. The only way out is to unwind, invest in productive energy – gas and nuclear – and lots of it. Stop picking winners. Roll back the subsidies and let the market decide. Side. If they said: this is going to cost you, we've got to do it anyway, then at least it would focus minds and could have a real debate about whether the ends justified the means.

28:13 Mark: Of course it's tempting to dismiss his entire diatribe with, probably, the fallacy. Well, he would say that, wouldn't he? But he's kind of circumstantial. There you go, but it's just argh, it's amazing, amazing.

28:30 Jim: The whole thing is just great, incredible. The first two directly contradict each other. Yeah, because he's saying, first of all – which is an insane thing to say – which is what we? We want the fewest and most highly productive jobs possible. Oh no, is everyone else gonna do? And is your government, david frost, gonna be perfectly okay with the welfare state looking after all those people who don't have jobs? Then yes, but also – and in his second paragraph, yeah, he's – He's ridiculing the idea that we'll always have enough workers. Well, yeah, we'll have shitloads of workers if we have hardly any jobs.

29:09 Mark: How it goes from the poor fallacy is that jobs are a benefit, not a cost. Hang on. Thatcher's entire government. Okay, so later on he says, yeah, let's have oil and gas and nuclear and plenty of it. That is, the entire government in the 70s was able to declare that their the unemployment was down because they signed people onto benefits rather than unemployment and then they paid for the benefits with the profits from north sea oil. So that was a cost, the fact that there were unemployed people because they were shutting down the coal mines and doing all sorts of other stuff and privatising national industries, so there were fewer jobs to be had. Of course. Surely having jobs are a benefit.

29:58 Jim: What government has ever suggested that jobs aren't a benefit? The more jobs there are in society. That's an indication that industries are doing well, because they are able to employ lots of people, and those people are then contributing to society.

30:18 Mark: If you're running on an income tax model, then you've got to have people getting an income from, yes, exactly. But I love the way that he just conflates it with. You know, if you believe that, you must think we can make ourselves wealthier by sending everyone back into the fields to work the land.

30:35 Jim: Because thinking jobs is a good thing means you must think that manual labour is the best kind of job.

30:42 Mark: So I've coined a new phrase, reductio ad stalinarium. And then later on he says Soviet style. So he conflates all of that into Soviet style, which is basically communism, and he has a go at the whole of the Conservative Party saying: if you're adopting these things, that's just communism and we're not all about that. What? The mocking of windmills as well is the

31:08 Jim: technology that was last cutting edge in this country under Henry II. The thing is, I'm not an energy expert, But I will say that I'm not an engineer, but it's my understanding that there isn't a form of energy production that doesn't use turbines. Basically, if you are burning fossil fuels, you're burning them to heat water, to make steam, to turn turbines, to make electricity. That's how that works. So and a turbine is just a windmill or a water mill. Those are the two things. Yes, they are. They are middle ages technology and they are exactly what we have always used to, yeah, produce electricity because dynamos work. Nuclear plants use the heat to boil water, to make steam, to turn turbines. The fact that the windmills do it directly from the wind cuts out the middle man of boiling water. You don't need to create energy to heat a thing you haven't got to dig it, it up and ship it across to the wind. Actually, I say, I say everything. Solar panels don't do that. That's one thing. One kind of energy that doesn't heat water to turn a turbine that uses clever electricity – stuff that I don't understand – in the photovoltaic cells. But all the old stuff, all the stuff that this guy is arguing in favor of, uses middle -aged technology to do all of the modern stuff that we need.

32:33 Mark: And he also dismisses uh, boilers as ineffective, ineffective boilers and heat pumps. Well, actually they're really very effective. And then he talks about the government saying, uh, industrial policy fallacy, the government knows best and they can pick the technologies.

32:49 [Unclear]: Well, I'm not sure that they're doing that or that they're actively not doing that nearly enough.

32:56 Mark: And the industrial policy fallacy? Is there such a fallacy this week we're going to to be looking at the industrial policy fallacy.

33:02 Jim: There's a reason that hasn't come up in the last 182.

33:05 [Unclear]: Yeah, yeah, you think,

33:07 Mark: yeah, yeah, oh, my God. And then he kind of says, yeah, we've got to junk all that in favor greater control and restrictions. There's a soviet product, soviet style production target, not true? No, uh, and if you are a Conservative and your policy forces you to implement socialism, just maybe it's a bad policy. Wow, where did you get that from?

33:28 Jim: If you're a Conservative and your your policy forces you to implement socialism, maybe you're a bad Conservative, but that doesn't make it.

33:35 [Unclear]: Yeah, it does make it a bad policy.

33:36 Mark: Yeah, the thing is, with these very last paragraph, if they said: this is going to cost you, but we have to do it anyway, at least that would focus our minds, that we could have a real debate. Well, well, that's. That is absolutely what everyone

33:50 Jim: on the side of green stuff is saying. Yes, yes, initially there's a cost, it's what needs to happen and in the long run it will be good.

33:58 Mark: Yes, yeah, yeah, it's not going to cost any more than so. All of the things that he set up earlier about that, they, we've got to have a backup grid, and blah blah. How do we store all this stuff? That all exists? Yeah, all you've got to do, oddly, is ask tesla to build fucking great big battery storages, and that, which they've successfully did way before Musk got involved. And uh, and it, it, It works. If you invest in that, if you're clear that we're going to move to a green based renewable policy in order to free us up from having to ally our pricing to whatever the oil suppliers come up with, be it the Saudis or the Americans or the Russians or whoever.

34:44 Jim: Well, ironically, it's the people who are who, everyone, Trump, etc. Are most scared of the chinese who are doing that. They are moving, yeah, all of them. You know they've. They've gone through an industrial revolution in record time. They've polluted a shit ton and now they are moving at incredible pace everything in their major cities onto electrical grids and onto renewable systems, and they're doing it quicker than anyone else is doing it. And they will be the ones who who are exporting renewable energy when everyone else is still trying to get their feet under the table. And that's what we could be doing. We could be investing in it now to the point where we are the ones who have that system set up before other people have it set up and are ahead of the curve, and therefore able then to implement all of the inevitable improvements to that technology that happen as it rolls out on a wider basis, because that, yeah, will happen. It's not, uh, it's not the fact – what does he Call it? The fallacy of it'll be all right on the night or something, yes, the belief that will solve the problems. We're actively solving the problems, those you know. The problems are getting, uh, less and less problematic. The change in battery technology, which has, up until the last five years, been incremental and tiny, has accelerated massively. We, we are solving those problems. That, yeah, you, You can't increase battery storage excessively. Now we are increasing it at a higher pace. The prices have come down. The technology that improves the effectiveness of photovoltaic cells has increased, and it continues to do so, and will continue to do so as long as we keep investing in those technologies.

36:29 Mark: And that's the appalling rolling back of stuff that the Labour Party are doing in order to appease the right wing. If you want to create more jobs, if you want to create more energy independence, you've got to continue to follow the net zero policies that you put in place and not listen to the likes of fuckwit david frost, who's got an entire anti -everything. He even says foreigners, foreigners, investing foreigners – nobody, you're just a right -wing arsehole that you know. No wonder johnson gave you a peerage in a Wild and shaky argument. Hear the line.

37:50 [Sting: Fallacy in the Wild (Tragedy)]

38:58 Mark: Bee Gees there, of course, with Tragedy. And I remember buying the album when it came out in the 80s. And I went to listen. It suddenly occurred to me, why haven't I done Fallacy? And I listened to it, it's ridiculously high, so I didn't attempt it. I did think I'll just record it and then up it a couple of octaves. It was hilarious, but completely unhearable.

39:29 Jim: In the Fallacy in the Wild, we like to talk about the fallacy of the week from a non-political perspective. And our first example this week comes from Better Call Saul. All. Yeah, this is the uh first episode of the second season and jimmy is uh not sure about. In fact, he's decided not to take up the offer of work at a law firm.

39:46 Clip: Better Call Saul

— If you're not going to be a lawyer, then what? Float around and wait for your sandpiper money to roll in? Yeah, that could take years.

— Sandpiper has no bearing on this at all.

— Okay, then, what's the plan? To be open to the universe? Okay, so no plan. Just walk the earth like Jules at the end of Pulp Fiction?

— Look, whatever the universe presents, whatever opportunity arises, I will take it.

— Whatever opportunity? Yeah. Wasn't Davis and Maine an opportunity? It's a great opportunity, and you're walking away from it.

— Look, shouldn't you at least try the job before you say no? And waste everyone's time, including my own? Kim, I appreciate your concern, but it's not for me. I don't want it.

— Do you remember how long you studied for that bar? How hard you worked all that effort? You're gonna toss it away.

— That's the sunk cost fallacy, the what the fallacy of sunk cost. It's what gamblers do? They throw good money after bad thinking. They can turn their luck around. It's like I've already spent this much money or time, whatever, I gotta keep going. No, there's no. No reward at the end of this game. You are making a mistake.

40:59 Jim: So, yeah, Kim does arguably use the sunk cost fallacy there. It's not her only argument. She makes a few different points about why actually the offer he's been given is a good offer and he should kind of at least think about it.

41:13 Mark: Yeah, not least because he said, I will take whatever comes along. Whatever comes along, he goes, well, this is an offer, it's come along.

41:20 Jim: So obviously it's his decision whether he wants to continue to be a lawyer or not. But the arguments that are being made are not unreasonable – the fact that one of them is a fantasy – he was able to identify a fantasy, to attach to it, to dismiss the whole thing, and yeah, yeah, anymore.

41:34 Mark: And also it's a bit worrying that it's his first episode of season two and you're thinking, yeah, if you're turning down the offer of a job, where are we going to go with this season?

41:43 Jim: Yeah, absolutely, yeah, yeah, and I mean a reasonable amount of season one. He was kind of of looking for that legitimacy of being hired by a proper, yeah, proper law firm. So, yeah, yeah, it's not unreasonable to assume that he might still want that or there's a reason why it would be a good thing for him. Our second example is from god's not dead, the terrible kevin sorbo film. Yeah, dean kane shows up in this one as well. Um, and yeah, the conceit of this is that, uh, kevin sorbo is a, basically, he's a straw man. That's what he is. He's an incredibly pretentious philosophy Professor who demands that his students kind of sign a pledge saying that God is dead. Right, uh, the beginning of his class and and one christian student decides that he will debate his, his Professor and right and to prove that God exists.

42:38 Clip: God's Not Dead

— In our last class, I was asked a question that I couldn't answer. As Professor Radisson pointed out, Stephen Hawking is an atheist. He also wrote a book called The Grand Design, in which he says the following. Because there is a law such as gravity, the universe can and will create itself from nothing. And to be honest, I tend not to refute that. I mean, after all, Hawking. Hawking is clearly a genius, but Professor John Lennox, who teaches mathematics and philosophy, has demonstrated that there are not one, even two, but three errors of logic contained in that one simple sentence, and it all boils down to circular reasoning. Hawking is basically saying that the universe exists because the universe needed to exist, and because the universe needed to exist, it therefore created itself. It's like this. If I say to you that I can prove that spam is the best tasting food that's ever existed – because in all of history no food has ever tasted better – you'd probably look at me strange and say I haven't proven anything. And you'd be right. All I've done is restate my original claim. But when Hawking claims that the universe created itself because it needed to create itself, and then offers that as an explanation as to how and why it was created, we don't immediately recognize that he's doing the same thing. But he is.

44:06 Jim: The example that this student gives about spam. If I said that spam is the greatest food because there's never been a greater food, basically is an example of circular reasoning. And I would say that that's a reasonable thing to do. If you are trying to explain a fallacy to someone, if you're trying to explain why their reasoning is bad and you point out that they've used a fallacy, you can name it if you want, if you want to be pretentious. But a good thing to do is to say: if I said this, then you would see that that's a silly argument and that's essentially what you're doing. That's not a bad way to go. You can use an example that they can see is bad reasoning and then equate it to what they've said. However, yeah, Stephen Hawking, even in just that sentence, which has been taken out of context, is in no way saying that the universe created itself because it needed to create itself, doesn't mention needing to create itself at all. No, the thing he said was: because there is a law like gravity, the universe can and will create itself from nothing, not that it needs to or because it needs to. Therefore, it does nothing. He's not saying that. Had he said that, that would be a bad argument, but it wouldn't be proof of God or that God created the universe. In context, here is what he says in the Grand Design. He says: right, because gravity shapes space and time. It allows space -time to be locally stable, but globally unstable on the scale of the entire universe. The positive energy of the matter can be balanced by the negative gravitational energy and so there is no restriction on the creation of whole universes because there is a Lord -like gravity. The universe can and will create itself from nothing in the manner described in chapter six. So there's a whole chapter in his book, yeah, explaining how and why it happens. Well, that would happen, yeah, and this section is just saying gravity is negative energy because it's attractive. It's negative energy that balances out the positive energy of matter and therefore there isn't that paradox of energy or matter being created out of nothing. Those two things balance out. You start with a balanced system of nothing and when you add positive – the positive energy of matter and the negative energy of gravitational force, you still have a balanced system. Yeah, so it is possible for the universe to exist and have to have been created out of nothing because of the existence of the law of gravity. That's what he's saying, which is a brilliant and completely reasonable thing to say, yeah, and is not in any way circular argument about spam.

46:37 [Unclear]: Yeah. So our final

46:39 Jim: example in the Fallacy in the Wild this week comes from the good life – not the good wife, which we've sometimes used in this section, but the good life, which was a 70s British sitcom about a couple who, uh, who, left the rat race and set up their own self -sustainable home and kind of grew all of the food they needed, and basically in the suburban, in the

47:00 Mark: same suburban house, I believe.

47:02 Jim: Yes, yes, in this particular episode, tom, the husband of the couple, basically doesn't understand why his wife, barbara, wants a posh dress. She has given up everything for this life, and including kind of the going out and being able to afford nice things. Basically she wears a lot of dungarees. Yeah, she quite would. She just like a posh dress. And he is like this is ridiculous. Where have you got to go? You know this is. You don't need that. And so jerry, his their next door neighbor, who is, who has not left the rat race, is, is rich and does well for himself, um is pointing out to tom where his failure to understand this is leading.

47:40 Clip: The Good Life

— Barbara gave up a lot of the normal feminine perks for you – silly things maybe some of them, but she gave them up without a second thought and

47:49 Mark: I think the least you can do is respond when she has the odd withdrawal symptom.

47:52 Clip: The Good Life

— I gave things up. I gave things. I want my job, but you hated it. Yeah, but I gave it up. Though here's one: I couldn't afford to play golf. I gave that up. You were thrown out of the club for shooting rabbits on the short 17. I've only got one suit. You know I don't complain. Why should you? You're naturally scruffy, Barbara isn't? I think you ought to make allowances, you changing sex or something? Oh, you know I'm right. You carry on like this, you'll end up editing the woman's page. Yes, you do know I'm right, feminist fop, you know. All right, how do I know you're right? Because you've resorted to abuse. Clever dick. You're doing it again. Shut up, paul edgerton's love is just great, yeah,

48:35 Jim: so I mean? The thing is he's pointing out that tom is using ad hominem attacks because he has nothing else, which is not completely unreasonable. It doesn't mean that he's his position isn't right in this case. Yeah, it happens that tom is being an idiot and barbara is completely entitled to feel, uh, at least temporarily, unhappy that she doesn't have nice things. But the fact that tom is attacking jerry doesn't mean that his argument is wrong, and that's what jerry is saying is: is you, you know I'm right because you've resorted to abuse?

49:12 Mark: And then you're doing it again and he gets to the to just say: shut up, yeah, but he does that giggle as such a oh, my God, I've forgotten how good that series.

49:22 Jim: It's a great show, yeah, yeah, yeah. So before we move on to fake news, I just want to briefly mention Qed, because Qed is coming up and I'm fucking excited because it's october and I'm looking forward to it and it's the best thing. So, yeah, I've basically spent the last few weeks just going: oh, Qed is coming up, how many days the Qed is. So it's fair.

49:44 Mark: I'm just I hope you haven't been saying sleeps, the number of sleeps, how many sleeps? I'm never talking to you again if you do that.

49:52 Jim: Yeah, I mean, I don't know why the kermit hate, but still, the thing about Qed is, apart from it being awesome, uh, it's so awesome, in fact, that it's sold out. The tickets to attend in person sold out almost immediately, basically within days of it being announced this year, but streaming tickets are still available. So if you haven't got tickets to come to manchester to Qed this year, you can can still get streaming tickets on qedcon .org and you can enjoy the full weekend of main stage talks and panels and things like that. And in fact, the podcast room, I think, is on the streaming as well. And even if you can't watch along during that weekend, your streaming ticket does give you access for several weeks after to catch up on the talks. And it is just, it's brilliant. And you should do that because the streaming ticket, it's not as good, obviously. We'll. We'll be having a better time there. We will enjoy ourselves more than you could possibly could by getting a streaming ticket, because we will be not only seeing the things in person, but also enjoying the social aspects of qd, which but the thing about the stream ticket

50:59 Mark: is it gives you access to – I mean, they're even good. Do we get access to the stream, as we did?

51:04 Jim: Yeah, yeah, we still, so I got to watch the things that I couldn't see because I was busy watching something else, which, Which was awesome.

51:10 Mark: Quite, because we get completely absorbed. Not only do we get absorbed in the stuff that we're watching, but we get completely swallowed up by FOMO, because there's so much stuff going on. There's too much good stuff, basically. We need Hermione Granger's cloak of invisibility and the time machine in order to see all the bloody things. So, yeah.

51:33 Jim: Plus. Plus. Plus the first day, the Friday of the QED. Weekend is skeptic camp, which is run by the lovely people at skeptics in the pub. Uh, that's another thing which you can access online, but you don't even need to pay for that, it's absolutely free. You can go to sitp .online and you will see the talks being streamed and they're kind of 10 minute talks from members of the the community, like attendees at Qed, members of the skeptical community. I, as it turns out, I'm uh opening the whole show, the whole thing this year. Yeah, with my talk about the, the logical errors used by contestants on the traitors – fantastic, yeah, that will be stupid o 'clock in the morning, 11 a .m is not too bad. You don't even have to get up. Oh, no, that's true, yeah, no, yeah, weekend on the Friday: uh, sitp .online. Uh, if you don't manage to catch it on that day, they will be releasing the talks gradually on the skeptics in the pub online youtube channel over the subsequent months. Yeah, you can access all of those talks that day and if you get a streaming ticket for QED, you can access all of the other amazing content that happens that weekend.

52:45 [Sting: Fake News] Yeah, can't wait. So we're going to play Fake News folks. I love the game. It's a great game. I understand the game as well as anybody, as well as anybody.

52:53 Jim: Yes, it's time for Fake News, the game where I read out three Trump quotes, two of which are real and one I made up, and Mark has to figure out which one is fake news.

53:00 Mark: You see, there you go strawmanning me with the false equivalence of two real and one false. It's going to be the sharpshooter fallacy. Yet again. I'll identify one, you'll draw the target of wrongness around it and everyone will see just how popularly appealing that is. Plus, if I was going to win, I would have done so already. Clearly, this is just playing politics and you're just as bad as everyone else.

53:23 Jim: Yeah, it doesn't mean I'm wrong, though, even though I constantly employ all those fallacies, it doesn't mean you're wrong.

53:30 Mark: No, I'm not saying that. No, no, far be it from me.

53:34 Jim: So the theme this week is, yeah, that uh Trump gave a press conference alongside uh Rfk Jr and Dr oz and jay batacharia and other people who don't know what they're doing about health, about displayed how

53:53 Mark: much, how little, he knew about health.

53:55 Jim: Again, yeah, because they've been determined to prove that autism is caused by something bad that the pharmaceutical industry are doing, and they, they reckon they found it okay, and so they gave a press conference, and it lasted about an hour – bloody hell, and each of the people got a chance to speak, but obviously Trump took the bulk of the um the speaking opportunities, but he only really had two things to say. That there was some talk of lucavorin, which is a folinate supplement being given to people with autism, which, if it may possibly help with some of the symptoms of autism, it probably won't do for most people. Right, it's a thing which they claim is a new thing, but it's actually been something that has been. Doctors have been able to prescribe off label for a long time. Okay, the main thing, though, was Tylenol. They claim that Tylenol is a cause, possibly the cause, of a lot of autism. Wow, Tylenol, taken by pregnant women during pregnancy or by children as infants – um, that that then leads to autism? Right, there's no evidence for this whatsoever. No, well, we'll talk afterwards about what evidence there is, but it isn't really evidence. But these are some of the things that Trump said, and because he only had a couple of things to say and an hour to say them in, he kept saying them again and again and again, so it got a bit repetitive.

55:15 Mark: I think we've got, we've hit on the core of basically how he functions.

55:20 Jim: So statement number one: yeah, the Mmr, I think should be taken separately. This is based on what I feel. The mumps, measles and and the three should be taken separately. And it seems to be when you mix them there could be a problem. So there's no downside in taking them separately. In fact they think it's better. So let it be separate. The chicken pox is already separate because when that got mixed in I guess they made it four for a while it really was bad. So they make chicken pox individually. They're okay. When you mix them, something maybe happens. So there's no downside in doing it. It's not like: oh, if you do, bad things, no, I

55:58 Mark: love the fact that he doesn't know what r stands for. Yeah, arithmetic. Yeah, if you do. If you do it, bad things. No, bad things, bad things, okay.

56:10 Jim: Statement yeah for Tylenol or a seat for Tylenol. The advice, certainly for me – and I think this is right – is: don't take Tylenol. There's no good reason to take it. So just don't take it. Don't take Tylenol, don't give Tylenol to your beautiful baby and don't take it if you're pregnant. If the doctor says take it, then I guess maybe take it then. But if you want to know, I think, fight him on it and say you don't want to take it. And when you take the baby to have their shots, don't give them Tylenol and space them out. Do it in four visits, maybe five, three if you have to, but I think at least four. There's no downside. So that's what we're doing. And statement number three, when the alternative is that nothing bad can happen, let's do it now. I was just saying to Bobby in the group, let's do it now. Nothing bad can happen. It can only good happen. But with Tylenol, don't take it. Don't take it. And if you can't live, if your fever is so bad that you have to take one because there's no alternative to that, sadly, first question: what can you take instead? It's actually, there's not an alternative to that. And as you know, other of the medicines are absolutely proven bad. I mean, They've been proven bad with the aspirins and the Advils and others, right? And they've been proven bad.

57:23 Mark: Whoa. Oh, my God. And if you can't live, wow. What? I think it's measles, mumps, and arithmetic. There's something in there which is a gym-sized joke. Joke – and Tylenol, and then he's avoided voiding, saying acid to acid. Whatever he failed to say, uh, fight him on it. That not so sure about that, but also not so sure about can't live fever so bad, you have to take one because there's no alternative, sadly. First. First question: what kentucky's dead? Okay on that, on no business talk, apart from the headache coming on. I think I'm going to say that number two is the one that you made up, so you're happy with nothing bad can happen.

58:22 Jim: It can only good happen.

58:23 Mark: Yes, that's fine. I say happy. I said oh, you know, happy it's a strong word, yeah, but so if the other two, then which you have? You just have. You just revealed that you made that one up, fuck um, I think number one, the Mmr, measles, mumps and the two, okay, and number one, despite the fact – yeah is real – the Mmr, I think should be taken separately.

58:47 Clip: Trump, played during Fake News

— This is based on what I feel: the uh, mumps, measles and and or the three should be taken separately and it seems to be that when you mix them there could be a problem. So there's no downside in taking them separately. In fact, they think it's better, so let it be separate. The chicken pox is already separate, because when that got mixed in – I guess they made it for for a while – it really was bad. So they make chicken pox individually. They're okay. When you you mix them, something maybe happens. So there's no downside in doing it. It's not like, oh, if you do it, bad things.

59:31 Mark: No, did they ever put chicken pulse in? So they did well,

59:34 Jim: they did right. They did do Mmr v, varicella right, chicken pop and yes, there was an increase in seizures seven to ten days out from that being given. So they stopped doing it. They separated out again. But that doesn't mean that you have to do it on separate visits or separate occasions, which is what he is suggesting and was suggesting multiple times through this. In fact, they recommend doing Mmr and the varicella vaccines on the same visit and there's no issue with that, right, there's also no issue with Mmr being mixed in in one. Not at all. They don't think it's better to do it separately. They specifically say: don't do it separately. Yes, by doing it on separate occasions they are concerned that you You may miss an appointment, you may not get vaccinated for one of them. But also by delaying it, by spreading it out, because if you don't do them at the same time, you do have to space them out. Like with the varicella, for example, if you don't have it on the same occasion that you have the MMR, you have to leave. I think it's five weeks, four or five weeks in between, and during that period you could get one of those diseases which could be serious. It could give you problems further down the line. So what they don't want you to do is delay getting vaccinations for various things, and the best way to do that is to have them all in your visit when they're all shown to be safe.

1:00:57 Mark: Yes, because the whole MMR thing is long debunked bollocks that RFK Jr. has kind of decided that's a conspiracy. He's revisited it.

1:01:08 Jim: He's revisited all of the conspiracy theories about vaccines.

1:01:12 Mark: If only we could revisit the bear in the parking park.

1:01:16 Jim: So you also think that number three is real?

1:01:20 Mark: Yes, despite nothing bad, it can only good happen.

1:01:24 Clip: Trump, played during Fake News

— Yes, and number

— three: yes, real.

— When the alternative is that nothing bad can happen. Let's do it now. I was just saying to Bobby and the group: let's do it now. Nothing bad can happen, it can only good happen. But with Tylenol, don't take it. Don't take it, and if you can't live, if your fever is so bad, you have to take one, because there's no alternative to that, sadly. First question: what can you take instead? It's actually there's not an alternative to that and, as you know, other, uh other of the medicines are absolutely proven bad. I mean, they've been proven bad with the aspirins and the Advils and others, right, and they've been proven bad.

1:02:09 Mark: So what the? It can only good, it can only good happen. I'm gonna have that as my retone from now on.

1:02:17 Jim: Yeah, wow, I think. I think I'm gonna do a t -shirt. Nothing bad can happen, it can only good, good happen. Yes, please, yes, but it's not true. No bad can happen, it cannot only good happen. Because the reason that people take Tylenol – the reason Tylenol is by far the most common thing that is given to pregnant women who have a fever – is because the other things have been proven bad there. There have been side effects shown with other things that can reduce a fever that could be given to pregnant women. Yeah, and the difficulty with that is that fevers in pregnancy are Are absolutely bad. They have been proven bad. If a pregnant woman has a high fever, that endangers the child. It either puts their life at risk or it leads to side effects that can lead to other illnesses and diseases later on – disorders that might happen. So Tylenol is the go-to thing for that because there really isn't evidence that Tylenol is bad during pregnancy. The evidence that exists, which is what they have based this on, is a single study which showed an increase in autism among people who did take Tylenol when they were pregnant. But that study which was done recently, it was done over the last couple of years – they didn't end that study saying so: don't take Tylenol. They also looked at what happens when you look at the genetics of it, because autism, largely by the medical community, is understood to be a genetic disorder. Order. It's right. There is a at least a significant genetic component, and when you compare, uh, families and how likely you are to have autism if a sibling or a half sibling, or a parent or an uncle or whatever has autism, they show that the closer you are genetically to the other person in your family, the more likely you are to also have autism, and that stands over millions of people. They've looked at this. Yeah, and twins, for example, I think it's 59 likely. If you have a monozygotic twin that has autism, you're 59 also likely to have autism. And for, for siblings, it goes down to like 13 and and as you get further and further away genetically, the number reduces, which is an extremely strong indication that a big part of it is genetics. Yeah, so the people who did that, that Tylenol study, ran those figures that they gathered through the genetic numbers and looked at whether those people who, in their study, had been diagnosed with autism also had siblings with autism or also had other things. That effect went away completely. There was then, when it could be accounted for by genetics, there was no effect on Tylenol being used. The other factor that isn't factored in by Rfk and this analysis that the Trump administration has supposedly done is the fact that people who have taken Tylenol during pregnancy likely had an issue during their pregnancy which caused them to have right pain or fever. Yes, and those kinds of things can lead to birth defects or issues that the child has on birth or growing up, because those are things that impact that development stage when it's extremely volatile. So if you're comparing people who didn't take any Tylenol or any other kind of painkiller or fever reduction aid because they didn't need to versus people who did need to, yeah, you're immediately skewing that data.

1:05:54 Mark: Yes, exactly, and they are shooting the messenger rather than the message. So people are taking Tylenol in order to deal with these symptoms of something else, or the pain related to, or the fever related to, rather than what was the thing that they were taking the Tylenol to alleviate the symptoms of. What was that? Let's look at that.

1:06:20 Jim: The evidence that they are basing this on first of all doesn't make this argument, and other studies that they kind of have suggested that might bolster it are not full studies. They're often pilot studies that are small in number and suggest that there is more research that needs to be done. But haven't that research hasn't been done, but their his argument is that you should do it now, despite the evidence being scant, because there's no downside. But in fact, there is serious downside and this will hurt people. This will cause problems for people. This, this will cause problems for unborn babies and it will be far more damaging than the benefits that they hope to get out of it. What it made me think of was going back to the MMR thing, because when my eldest was born it was 2003 and the Andrew Wakefield Lancet study about MMR had come out in 98, so just a few years before. And most of the media around it in the ensuing years. The bulk of it really was around 2001, 2002 to when when tony blair's kid was born – yeah, right, and a lot of people were asking: you know, are you, is he going to have the Mmr vaccination and all that kind of stuff, and so there was a lot of news around that time of: is it safe? It does it cause autism? Are there issues with it? So when my oldest was born, when we were kind of getting ready for that in 2003, that was in the news and we asked the medical people that we saw the nurses and obstetrician people like that: um, okay, what you, you know, what are the risks and what should we do? Should we get them vaccinated? All of that kind of stuff. My ex has a first class honours degree in biology. She's a biology teacher. I'm not a complete fucking idiot. I enjoy research. And it wasn't straightforward for us at that point to figure out what the right thing to do was. There's a lot of people who are significantly less scientifically literate, who don't know what they need to look up or how to do that, or how to read studies and see what the flaws in them are, or anything like that.

1:08:27 Mark: Two of those include JFK Jr. and Trump.

1:08:30 Jim: But there's a lot of Americans who will be in this situation over the next few years, who will… Are looking for guidance from their political leaders. They will believe what they have heard from the President and the Department of Health because they don't know to look it up. And if they did, they wouldn't necessarily know know how to, um, how to pass that information. So this will hurt people. It because people will believe it and they will not take Tylenol when they have a fever, yeah, and and even if their doctor says they should, they will say: well, I've, I've heard it's bad. Um, yeah, from someone who I insanely believe everything he says.

1:09:06 Mark: What's the impetus behind this? Why, why, what's? Why are they doing it? Why are they naming Tylenol?

1:09:12 Jim: I mean, the reasoning behind it isn't super clear. They have have this strange need to demonise autism. Oh yeah, there is that, yes, of course. It's a disorder which lends itself to conspiracy theories because of the significant increase over the past 50 years. You know, it was diagnosed in 1950. The criteria for it have changed and the diagnosis has increased dramatically over just the last kind of 10 years even, but…

1:09:39 Mark: But that doesn't necessarily mean it's happening more, it just means that people are… Yes, yeah, yeah, um.

1:09:46 Jim: No, what it means is that it's being recognized more, that we have included more things in the diagnosis, because it's we've had the understanding that things that used to be called aspergers, for example, are now considered part of the asd, the autism spectrum disorder, and symptoms that we didn't necessarily know were associated with adult autism. All right, or even just present. The presentation of autism in adults is now being understood more, but it ultimately, I think, just comes down to the fact that it is a disorder that leads, that lends itself, to conspiracy theory thinking, because if you ignore the increase in diagnosis and the broadening of the diagnostic criteria, you can pretend that lots of other factors must be responsible for the increase, but

1:10:31 Mark: there's got to be an impetus for doing that. It feeds the conspiracy theories, but the thing is the lunatics are now in charge of the asylum, so that they've got to put the conspiracy theory somewhere else. They've got to put it at the blade, the lay and land at the blade of the pharmaceutical giants.

1:10:51 Jim: Like a lot of Dr. Oz's stuff and a lot of RFK stuff comes from big pharma are lying to you.

1:10:58 Jim: The medical community is lying to you about stuff. So, and that's how like Dr. Oz sells supplements. He owns shares in companies that sell supplements. And part of the Leucovorin thing, which is a uh vitamin b9 uh supplement. It's a folinic acid. Is that the? It's actually now out of patent and and it's there are generic b9 supplements that you can get, but lucavorin, specifically, which is glaxosmithcline. Um, the fda have um under Trump like, but under Trump's uh request, um, they are relabeling it to say that it could be helpful for autism symptoms, which is not something that is usually done, because there are plenty of drugs that are labeled for a specific um disease, disorder or whatever that are then also prescribed off -label for other things. People understand that, for example, for antidepressant drugs, they can also be useful for other things. Yeah, um, and so doctors are able to prescribe them off -label for those things. It's it's not common for the people who make those drugs to apply for those disorders also to be added to the labelling. And the only reason for doing that is that you can then market it. You can get people to pay money for using your drug to do that thing. And so the push to have FDA relabel Leucovorin to be used for autism, as well as the other things that it's already labelled for. The only real benefit for that is that GSK can now market it as a drug. For that it also means that the Trump administration can claim that they've done something beneficial for autism and argue there must be joining the third side of the triangle.

1:12:51 Mark: There must be a kickback from GSK to Trump.

1:12:54 Jim: Here goes, arguably, the generic folinate supplements. Governments, yeah, such as ones that are made by a company in which Dr oz owns shares, may also see an uptick in sales.

1:13:10 [Unclear]: Yeah, you do the math listeners. Yeah, we have some social contestants.

1:13:17 Jim: Oh yeah, uh -huh. On Facebook, jeremy voss says: these do my head in every single time. One is fake news, but I have yet to get one right. So oh, wow, wow.

1:13:27 [Unclear]: Yeah, jerome says.

1:13:29 Jim: I believe number Number one and number three oozed from his lying pie hole, while number two is just as credibly insane: it's fake news. Also, one should have included the porky pig voice saying, Aceta, Acida, Acida Tylenol. Yeah, he did really struggle to get out acetaminophen. Because he'd never seen that word before and can't read. Anders says on Patreon, this is bleak. Number one, no idea, but maybe he likes the riff about chickenpox. Box. Number three: only true can be. Number two, Jim. Trying to emulate number three: number two: only Jim can be, I guess. Anyway, if someone told you in any other country two of these statements were made by the person in charge of a country, only bad can be nice, yeah, yeah, kaz too. He said this orange blimp is insane, so could easily have said all three: nice one, Jim. I think I've sadly heard number one, but two and three have got me thinking. And there's my mistake. Trump doesn't think so. My, My rational analyst will unplug my brain, channel a magamora and pick the one that makes me shout: USA, USA. So number two is fake.

1:14:34 Mark: Good reasoning.

1:14:35 [Unclear]: Good reasoning. Yeah.

1:14:38 Jim: Richard Thunder Hopkins says, man, this is so fucking dangerous. This simpleton with no medical experience or the cognitive abilities to even conceive how much work and trial goes into these things. It baffles the mind, Jim and Mark. And the fact that the simpleton I refer to could either be the simpleton who is the secretary of health and human services or the simpleton who is President of the united fucking states is scary, I'm scared. Number two is fake, but I really wish their parents were anti -vaxxers, because if they were, these two fuckheads would likely be dead already. And finally, renee z says good luck, Mark. These all sound real. I'm fairly certain. I've heard parts of all three, so this seems to be a wonderful riff by Jim. A weave of various bits of orange mania in number three. Nice, a weave of orange mania. Nothing bad can happen. It can only good happen. That sounds so familiar, but the rest of it doesn't. So I'll choose three as fake news with a bit of real news mixed into it.

1:15:30 Mark: You see, I did feel you leaning on me like I really only could happen.

1:15:37 Jim: So, yeah, so that means you got that right this time.

1:15:40 Mark: Oh, yeah, I forgot about that bit.

1:15:42 Jim: All of my many logical fallacies didn't fool you. Yeah, I think it was the.

1:15:46 Mark: It was the. What was it that tipped me off? I'm not going to tell you because you're just adjusted for next time. Beautiful baby, and yeah, it was the fight him on it and don't say you don't want to take it, but but equally it could have been. I think what clinched it was the only. It can only good happen. You were convinced that was right. Yes, and but the thing that I nearly did it was: if you can't live, if you're so bad, you have to take one. Then, yeah, Yeah, that nearly did it.

1:16:15 Jim: He did say many times that pregnant women with a fever just need to tough it out.

1:16:21 [Unclear]: Oh, fucking hell. Yeah.

1:16:28 Jim: So it's time for the part of the show that, this week at least, is called A Government Shutdown Is Not a Logical Fallacy, because we are currently, as we record this, five days, 19 hours and 35 minutes into a government shutdown. By the time this is released, it'll be six days. And it is the work of the Republicans. Ah, of course they are. Yeah, trying extremely hard to pretend it's the work of the Democrats and

1:16:55 Mark: they've got you know that it's not like they haven't got form on this. Of all of the history of massive shutdowns, most of them have been under Trump.

1:17:05 [Unclear]: Well, certainly, the last three were under Trump.

1:17:07 Jim: Yes, yeah, long ones, yeah, well, the longest of all time, the 35 day one in, uh, december 2018, 18 january 2019, was under Trump. Um, the the previous two before that were were under Trump as well, and each of those times, um, the public were not convinced, despite everything. He said that it was the Democrats fault, right, yeah, and are they convinced this time either? No, no, Federal agencies have been violating the hatch act to pretend that Democrats are at fault. They've been sending emails to employees claiming that it's the radical left and the radical liberals in Congress who are to blame, which is, you know, the Hatch Act limits the political activities of government employees, but this is very clearly a quite partisan thing to do. The Department of Housing and Urban Development had a pop -up on their website, on the landing page of their website, claiming the radical left are going to shut down the government and inflict massive pain on the American people unless they get their 1, .5 trillion dollar wish list of demands.

1:18:10 [Unclear]: Wow, yeah, that's, that's hard.

1:18:14 Jim: I mean, who even goes to the website?

1:18:15 Mark: Yeah, but even so, that is the equivalent of of Trump posting the thing with the mexican hat. Yeah, mustache on that. It's just, you know, when the President is generating, ai generated things and endorsing them, you think what, what that's?

1:18:36 Jim: Ah, yeah, so the main reason that the Democrats have been unwilling to sign the um, the continuing resolution, the spending bill that would take us through to the end of the year, is that, uh, the budget that the the Republicans are trying to push through is: and the stopgap bill essentially doesn't deal with the expiring tax credits under obamacare. Right, yeah, and if those tax credits are allowed to expire by the end of the year, then millions of Americans will elderly and low income and disabled Americans will lose their health care. Yeah, Democrats don't want that to happen. So they've basically said, yeah, no, we're not going to vote to continue to fund the government unless you agree to re -up those tax credits and stop them from expiring. Yeah, Republicans aren't prepared to do that. And And the shutdown started on just after midnight on Wednesday. You could see it as Democrats being to blame for the shutdown because they are not prepared to allow millions of Americans to lose their health care.

1:19:39 Mark: Or you could you could term it as a kind of humanitarian care.

1:19:48 Jim: That would be another way to look at it.

1:19:50 Mark: Given the fact that they shut down USAID, which is all about humanitarian care. Yeah, yeah, you kind of know that the Republicans don't care about humanitarianism. They just want to bring in a massive tax cut for the rich. Yeah, so, so the Republicans stay in power forever?

1:20:08 [Unclear]: Um, because, yeah, even Republican voters

1:20:11 Jim: who don't have a lot of sympathy for poor people might think that, uh, yeah, we've, we're shutting down the government and not paying Federal workers and shutting down various important things because we really want to take away medical care for poor people. Isn't that good an argument? So what they've gone with instead is pretending that Democrats have shut down the government because they want to give Medicare to illegal immigrants.

1:20:37 Mark: They want to give healthcare to undocumented people, they want to pay for that, they want the renewal of the payment of that, because if you're an illegal immigrant, you're not eligible to receive that.

1:20:51 Jim: Yes, you don't get medicaid, you don't get social security. You don't get obama. Yeah, um, it's. I mean, Call me crazy, but I don't think it would be that bad a thing to give people in your country access to health care. Yeah, even if they're not technically supposed to be there. Yeah, I think that wouldn't be the worst thing. In the Uk, you are allowed to apply to join an nhs doctor's surgery to get health care even if you don't have legal immigration status. Yeah, that's the thing you're allowed to do. You're also allowed to get emergency care at an emergency room, or a a and e as we Call them, accident and emergency. Yeah, that's the thing you're allowed to do. If you need non -urgent care, like if you need an elective surgery or something that requires you to stay in hospital for a period of time, but isn't something that's urgent and you're in danger. If you don't get it done, then we would bill you. The British healthcare service would bill people who are not legal immigrants, legally registered immigrants. But urgent care and GP care, general practitioner care is free to everyone regardless of immigration status. That's not true in the US.

1:22:07 Mark: And it's also true across Europe. It used to be called the EHIC, the European Health something card, health insurance card. It's the GHIC. And it's now called the GHIC, which is the global. So, in fact, I think it's widened beyond Europe. Well, either that or just because we're no longer part of the European Union, we need to access it via something else. So there is a kind of reciprocal arrangement that you can access. At the point of access, it's free. I have friends in France. They are californians and uh, kind of quite elderly, but they needed some medical attention. Just got it, yeah, and and the french kind of went. Yeah, we'll sort that out later, that'll be fine.

1:22:52 Jim: Yeah, I have accessed french health care on behalf of my family. Um went on holiday there and and, yeah, I haven't been charged for it because because that's an acceptable way, way to treat a human being, because,

1:23:04 Mark: yes, because humanitarianism, well, as a first world country that's in stupidly rich, what we could do is, uh, grant that. I mean, for all that we disparage the saudis, you know we're not, we could not without good reason, oh, yeah, plenty of good reasons, yeah, but but one of the things that they have done, um, is use their massive wealth to grant everybody free education, free health, and you think, well, if, if, you could, that's what you do with money. They're not doing it to kind of whitewash the fact that they kill journalists, disagree with them, etc. Etc. But you would why? Yeah, we could. That's surely what a civilized um country that's going to afford to do it.

1:23:58 Jim: You could argue that literally every other, yeah, major industrialized western country does exactly that. They provide free health care to their citizens and to visitors and, in almost all cases, people who are not even necessarily legal immigrants to their country, because it's one of the most fundamental things you can do – do for a person is to help them if they are not well.

1:24:22 Mark: Well, it's that kind of Hippocratic Oath thing, isn't it?

1:24:25 Jim: Yeah, they've made these arguments. They claim that Democrats want to give immigrants health care. That's not the case, but it isn't fooling anyone. That's the important bit. The Washington Post did a poll where 47 % of the people they asked blame Trump and the Republicans for the shutdown and 30 % blame Democrats. 23% weren't sure. If you break that down along party lines, Republicans who are asked, 67% of them blame Democrats. Not that surprising. 8% actually blame Republicans and 25% aren't sure. Among Democrats, 2% blame Democrats, 87% blame Republicans. And among independents, 50% blame Republicans and 22% blame Democrats. And that's just the Washington Post poll. There have been lots of polls about this through the course of September, when it looked like it was heading for a shutdown and with the beginning of the shutdown, and every group that has asked people has found that most of them blame Republicans and less people blame Democrats.

1:25:29 Mark: Trance and it's also um gives. Uh, what's his name? I won't say john voight, but it's not him.

1:25:35 Jim: Project 2025 guy.

1:25:40 Mark: Yeah, the chance to just go through and slash him but carry on the doge work that that, whilst the government was running, they weren't able to do it means that he could just go fire loads of people because on the basis that, well, we can't afford to pay you.

1:25:54 Jim: It's certainly, certainly been an argument that Trump has made that this gives him an opportunity to fire lots of people. Whether that will work when the government comes back, I'm not sure. I mean, you know, it'll cause them difficulty already. Just in, I think, is it the government services administration? This week they are hiring back tons of the people that they fired under because they can't run the government with the number of people that have that are left after they got fired. Yeah, so you, You know, yeah, they might be able to temporarily fire some people. Those firings will be challenged in court. Some of them will be overturned. Then when they realise they can't actually run the departments that they're trying to run without the people, then they'll hire them back and it'll all have cost a large amount of money and affected people's lives in negative ways. But that's the goal of the Trump administration.

1:26:45 Jim: It's to make it clear how bad government is.

1:26:50 [Unclear]: Yes. That is what Republicans love the most.

1:26:53 Mark: Yeah, because they could do away with government and say: what we need is just a kind of some sort of monarchy.

1:27:00 Jim: I mean, it does affect various parts of the Federal workforce. Obviously, not everyone can just go home, because some things need doing, like air traffic control, for example. Yes, they still need those people to actually be doing the job. Yeah, but they are currently doing it without pay. Oh, uh, yeah, that's because they're essential workers, so they are required to still come to work, but they don't actually get any money. The the U .s military currently working without pay, but, right, they're still required to do their job. Um, yeah, the irs: yeah, they're still on the job. Uh, I believe they're still being paid, but I'm not sure about that and I don't know how that. Of course they are.

1:27:42 Mark: They're in charge of the rs.

1:27:47 [Unclear]: of course they would.

1:27:49 Jim: Obviously, there's various parts of the health service that are required to keep working because

1:27:53 Mark: insurance companies have got a massive lobby, lobbying, influence on the government.

1:27:59 Jim: Uh, national parks has pretty much shut down. There's no parks people being employed at this point, so they, they aren't going to work.

1:28:07 Mark: Oh, so if you want to go nick a tree, now's your chance.

1:28:10 Jim: One thing that is continuing is the construction of the ridiculous ballroom, of course, because that's that, yeah,

1:28:18 Mark: even though, no, that's all paid for by our public money but it'll be lots of private companies. I suspect it's funneled the money. Yeah, yeah, it is.

1:28:28 Jim: It is supposedly being paid for by Trump and private donations.

1:28:32 Mark: Um, but, yeah, the cut, yeah, the kind of thing actually that caused a massive scandal in the Uk when donors gave Boris johnson money in order to put you know, a tastefully bad wallpaper up in number 10. That was something, think he failed to declare as a gift and got into big trouble about it before the the vaccine really did him in.

1:28:58 Jim: The thing is I, I don't believe, even if every cent that's going into the construction of the ballroom is private money, I don't believe it's possible to build an enormous building on the grounds of the white house without some government employees required to do stuff. There's got to be people there checking construction workers aren't, like, you know, russian spies and shit like that. There's got to be some stuff doing nothing.

1:29:29 Mark: So you know, far be it from us to kind of say: well, what was it circumstantial? Yeah, he would do that, wouldn't he? Yeah, we know Trump's reputation when it comes to ripping off the money out of his building projects, but of course that's carrying on. Of course it's yeah, yeah.

1:29:45 Jim: So the question I guess at the moment is is: how long will it continue? Yeah, which side will will blink? Yeah, we'll break. And what happened in january of 2019, the last time when the was the longest shutdown in history – yeah, was that Trump backed down, having got exactly zero of the demands that he had made. Wow, from nancy pelosi at the time? Yeah, because he is uh, yeah, and so, yeah, uh. The question really is: how long will Trump keep Keep going before he backs down and gives the Democrats what they want?

1:30:21 Mark: Well, Caroline Levitt has got to stop being angry and start coming up with a way to spin his inevitable U-turn. And when that happens, they will do that. So they'll kind of let the Democrats sweat a bit because he's got to start worrying about the public image. If they can't lay this at the feet of the Democrats sufficiently loudly so that it is reflected in the polls they're going to start thinking about? Okay, this is going to nibble away at our reputation. And finally, some things we don't have time to talk about.

1:30:56 Jim: Seven years ago, Trump gave a speech at the UN General Assembly, and when he said his administration had achieved more than all past US presidents, the generally assembled leaders of the entire rest of the world laughed at him. Well, they’re not laughing now. Instead, at this year’s speech, they sat dumbstruck by dumbness. The actual real politicians who know what they’re doing and for the most part don’t actively hate the people who voted for them had to sit there while this sundowning fuckwit told them their countries are all going to hell, that the US is living through a golden age, that climate change is the “greatest con job ever perpetrated on the world”,, that everyone says he should get the Nobel Peace Prize, that the UN building in New York would have been much better and cheaper if he had won the contract to renovate it back in 2001, that Christianity is the “most persecuted religion on the planet”, and most absurdly, that “I am really good at this stuff”. It doesn’t matter what stuff he was talking about at that moment – he isn’t. Of course, he also railed against the fact that the teleprompters didn’t work and that an escalator stopped while he was on the way to make the speech, which was clearly an act of sabotage. Some people online had fun with the fact that this happened on the day of the supposed rapture and Trump couldn’t even ascend one floor, let alone to heaven. Personally, I’m glad that rapture didn’t happen, because I’ve still got two episodes of The Residence to watch on Netflix. Just kidding, I am NOT getting raptured. Anyway, I’d rather stay down here with all you cool heathens. Where was I? Oh yeah, The escalator thing. Predictably, the right’s already overdeveloped culture of victimhood turned a stopped escalator into an international incident. Propaganda Barbie Karoline Leavitt said that “if someone intentionally stopped the escalator as the President and First Lady were stepping on, they need to be fired and investigated immediately”, presumably in that order. Fox News Host Jesse Watters suggested either leaving or bombing the UN, and his Fox colleague Maria Bartiromo claimed “this could’ve been a massive, massive issue. The president being frozen there in one place makes him vulnerable.” Conservative commentator Wilt Chamberlain agreed, saying “this was remarkably dangerous. If someone in the building wanted Trump assassinated this would have been a great way to freeze him.” They talk like Trump is constantly on the move, ducking and dodging and running in zigzags to avoid snipers. He’s a 79 year old man who stands in one place for hours at a time talking about sharks and Hannibal Lecter. The thing is, as Mitch Hedberg once said, “An escalator can never break: it can only become stairs.” If all that’s needed to endanger the President is some temporarily static stairs, you’ve got bigger problems than sabotage. Of course, in the usual course of right wing victimhood, the sabotage was self-inflicted. Apparently a White House videographer accidentally triggered the emergency stop on the escalator, and the malfunctioning teleprompters were also being operated by Trump’s team. Perhaps they were trying to prevent him from saying some of the stupider shit in his speech. Jokes on them though, because Trump can be stupid extemporaneously.

1:33:53 Mark: Because that's the thing about thwarting Trump and daleks: all you need is some stairs. I don’t think Trump is modern enough to have watched the movie Elysium where the rich live in a space station orbiting the earth, though I suspect he’d love it – for all the wrong reasons; while it’s a socialist revolutionary movie about rebelling against the whopping class divide between the wealth of the owners of the means of production and the workers providing that wealth, he’d definitely be on the side of the orbiting oligarchs deploying the military police to quell any kind of protest that threatens the exclusivity of the astral Mar-A-Lago. No he’s more a Star Trek Original Series kind of guy, not for the diversity, inclusion and acceptance of working and living alongside all sorts of different species in peace and harmony for the furtherance of boldly going, but rather for the magic beds that Bones has in his medical facility. In an AI-generated video shared on Truth Social the president’s daughter-in-law Lara Trump anchors a fake Fox News segment promoting a new Trump administration healthcare plan she says will result in “MedBed hospitals”. and “national Medbed card[s] for every citizen.” Conspiracy theory believers in the “Medbed” conspiracy have long thought that the U.S. government has technology – the same featured in Elysium – capable of healing wounds, regrowing limbs, curing diseases, and has kept it hidden away from the American public for years, using it only on members of the military and politicians. Needless to say, the beds do not exist, just like they don’t really in Elysium and Star Trek. Yet here’s Trump so convinced by the fake news of it that it got shared on his platform, cos he’s the best president – he’s going to make it available to everyone, and not just the elites. Someone must have reminded him that actually they are not going to renew MediCare insurance subsidies and have been steadily dismantling any semblance of universal free healthcare access cos it’s got Obama’s name on it, in order to fund a tax cut for the top 1% so how, or even why, will they roll out MedBeds to everyone. But he definitely only took the post down on the basis of “now everyone will want one you fool, and then I’ll have nothing that they don’t have, you can’t be King like that! That’s practically communism!” Also it’d use up all the available money, tech and 1.21 gigawatts of power the US generates in order to make one big and powerful enough to house his huge dysfunctional, unhealthy blob of a carcass. Ah, can’t wait til he reposts footage of those zero-gravity humans in Wall-E! wally.

1:36:37 Jim: At the end of September, former weekend Fox and Friends host Pete Hegseth ordered every senior US general and admiral worldwide to drop whatever they were doing, leave whatever active warzone command post they were running, and join him at Marine Corps Base Quantico in Virginia for an in person meeting. This is not only hugely disruptive and expensive, but also pretty much unprecedented, so he must have had some urgent and vital news or strategy to announce that could only effectively be done in person. Sure enough, when the 800 or so senior military leaders gathered, Hegseth redefined the parameters of a meeting that could have been an email by demanding an end to fat soldiers and beards. The Secretary of War who can’t do a single pull up lectured the career soldiers on the warrior ethos, briefly hawked his own book, and then told them about just some of the ways he plans to actively make the military worse – saying “no more politically correct and overbearing rules of engagement”, referring to the directives that were created after WWII to prevent war crimes. He said no more to “identity months”, “climate change worship”, “dudes in dresses”, and demanded a return to hazing, and drill sergeants being allowed to “put their hands on recruits”. He also feels that military careers are side-tracked by accusations of unacceptable behavior, which is something he knows a little about, as someone who paid $50,000 to a woman who accused him of sexual assault in 2017. Eager to avoid that kind of thing happening to soldiers, Hegseth called for “No more frivolous complaints, no more anonymous complaints, no more repeat complaints, no more smearing reputations,” so presumably, so long as you behave inappropriately on a regular basis, it will be dismissed as a repeat complaint and you’ll be cleared. Fortunately for the generals, they hadn’t totally wasted their time in coming to hear him speak, because after Secretary Pete was done, Trump came on, and immediately complained about the lack of applause from military officers who are not allowed to express partisan views while on duty. He told them if they didn’t like what he said they could leave, and threatened their jobs if they did, and did a tight five on the Gulf of America and Joe Biden’s autopen, and then announced his plan to use American cities as training grounds for the US military, which he said “is going to be a major part for some of the people in this room. That’s a war, too. It’s a war from within.” Totally cool and normal thing for a President to say.

1:38:54 Mark: Democrats are accusing House Speaker Mike Johnson of stalling the swearing-in of newly elected Adelita Grijalva, who will represent Arizona’s 7th Congressional District, because she will sign a petition forcing a vote on releasing the Jeffrey Epstein files. Grijalva said in a September 30 statement sent to Newsweek, “Earlier this year, two Republicans in Florida were sworn in during pro forma sessions less than 24 hours after their elections. The fact that Southern Arizona is being treated differently raises serious questions about political motivations – especially since I have pledged to become the 218th signature on the discharge petition to force a vote on the Epstein files.” The petition is missing one signature hers would force a vote on the matter. Call me naive but I just don’t understand what the problem is cos surely we’ve been told the files don’t exist/do exist and/or its a Democrat hoax and/or Trump is/isn’t on there and would/would not thus be liable to something or nothing. Oh actually that’s the problem, it’s not nuanced – it’s just wrong! The sound of the old V8-powered goalposts being driven up and down the White House dragstrip, not heard since the previously turns-out-to-be-true Russian conversation that did/didn’t happen from out of Trump Tower, no it didn’t, we don’t know anything about that, the tapes with the voices saying that on them are obviously a Democrat hoax, oh sorry you mean those beautiful conversations I bragged about? Well no I didn’t. Just when you thought Trump was actually stupid and thus harmless (no-one thinks that) turns out the GOP knows that and knows exactly what it’s doing and having Stupid as their malicious narcissistic front man provides all the smoke screen they need. We all see it, we know it, they know it and yet…and yet!

1:40:58 Jim: We’ve talked about the One Big Beautiful Bill a few times, and there are so many things wrong with it that I honestly can’t remember if we mentioned that the Congressional Budget Office estimated it would result in 3 million more Americans being unable to qualify for SNAP benefits. That’s the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, formerly and colloquially still known as food stamps, a federal government program that provides food-purchasing assistance for low- and no-income persons to help them maintain adequate nutrition and health. But fuck those poor people, says the GOP they should have had the good sense not to be poor, like we did. The benefit of the Bigness of the beautiful bill was that it was hard to talk about all the badness in it, and while a good chunk of Republican voters are actively happy that poor people don’t get to buy bread with taxpayer money, it’s not one of those policies that everyone agrees with. Unfortunately for the Trump Administration, for the past thirty years the US Department of Agriculture has released an annual report on Household Food Security in the US, which is seen as the gold standard for understanding the struggle that millions of families face to put food on the table. Fortunately for the Trump Administration, rules aren’t a thing anymore, so this year’s report, which covers 2024, will be the last. After all, we know Trump’s theory on COVID testing, and so obviously if you stop counting the number of hungry people, they stop existing. Actually, there’s a point at which that one kind of comes true. Fuck. yay.

1:42:16 Mark: Yaaay what’s the next best thing to Jacob Wohl resurfacing? It’s the QAnon Shaman! In a rambling complaint, Jacob Chansley the poster boy of insurrection and buffalo-hat face-paint fashionista is representing himself, naturally, for a suit he filed on Monday in Maricopa County Superior Court. A rambling, 26-page complaint consisting of a single paragraph alleging that his First, Fourth and Second Amendment rights have been violated by a host of parties – Trump, the Federal Reserve, the National Security Agency, the International Monetary Fund, the World Bank, the Bank of International Settlements, the state of Israel, Elon Musk’s X Corp., T-Mobile, the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency and Warner Bros. Studios. The claims in Chansley’s suit include: That the central banking system and the Federal Reserve are unconstitutional That the U.S. government is guilty of treason for prioritizing the interests of foreign financiers at the expense of the American people That the NSA surveilled Chansley daily using the Patriot Act as he was writing a “2nd Declaration of Independence” That “all radio stations and most of their DJ’s are a part of the intelligence community” That's That a scene in the 2008 Christopher Nolan-directed Batman film “The Dark Knight” and many plot details in 2009’s “Avatar” were cribbed from his writing and are proof that the NSA was spying on him That the NSA catfished him on Facebook by contacting him while pretending to be actress Michele Rodriguez, whom Chansley identifies as “my celebrity crush” That he was then “offered the opportunity to work with the NASA covertly and help them deal with other-worldly matters” that his “shamanic beliefs” made him “a perfect candidate to handle” And That he was emailed by Donald Trump on Jan. 8, 2021, from an address of donaldtrump@nsa.gov donaldtrumpatnsa .gov That the government stole more than $100,000 in cryptocurrency from him Shainsley concludes his complaint by declaring himself the first President of the new Constitutional Republic of the United States, and that Phoenix will be the capital of this new republic. As his first act, Tracy said, he would order the Federal Reserve to mint a one -ounce gold coin and set its value at $40 trillion to pay off America's debt, which isn't really how debt or currency works. I am within all of my own rights and a legal authority to do this, because of all, the information provided in this lawsuit is factual and cannot be argued. If a person were in the loop of what I had written on my computer a few months prior, those details would stand out to a sharp mind, he said. Perhaps if that sharp mind brackets sick, belonged to Dinesh D'Souza and in a Dinesh D'Souza -esque there's more evidence that we're not able to bring you right now, kind of way. Chansley did include a handwritten url for his google drive that he says contains more than a thousand exhibits, exhibits that prove his accusations. Yeah, phoenix new times encountered an error attempting to access it.

1:45:33 Jim: In all the best democracies, the one thing we're guaranteed to see is political opponents being performatively prosecuted at the whim of an authoritarian leader. Sorry, not democracies, banana republics, that's what I meant. We know that this is an uncontroversially good thing because of how happy Republicans were when there was a slight chance that Trump might, might face a single tiny consequence for all the crimes he absolutely committed. So, of course, everyone's equally happy about the indictment of former FBI Director James Comey. To be fair, if you're going to indict someone and are hoping to please everyone, Comey's a great shout, because pretty much everyone dislikes him for different reasons. Democrats because of his thumb on the scales that helped Trump's election, and Republicans because he planned to actually investigate the links between the Trump campaign and Russian interference in the election. But we've got this weird thing on the left where we only think people should be indicted for crimes they actually committed, even if we don't like that person. Trump disagrees, of course, and that's why he fired US attorney Eric Siebert, who foolishly refused to indict Comey on the flimsy basis that he hadn't committed a crime, and replaced him with Lindsay Halligan, an insurance lawyer with no previous prosecutorial experience. She's already fucked up in court, presenting the judge with a signed indictment on three counts, only two of which had actually been accepted by the Grand jury. Meanwhile, because the entire administration is a shitshow, an Fbi agent has been fired for refusing to arrange a perp walk for Comey, where he's arrested and handcuffed in front of news cameras. Perp walks, by the way, are prohibited by doj policy, but Trump really wanted one and that's what really matters.

1:47:00 Mark: And didn't he say that two other people had been on the Republican side, had been shoved in handcuff when they hadn't?

1:47:10 Jim: No well, yeah, roger stone released a uh a still of him being uh, walked out in handcuffs, but it was still from his own security camera at his house, not from the news.

1:47:21 Mark: So, yeah, not public then no, yeah, yeah. Well, in Britain it's all going down the tubes, except when the tube is on strike, of course. The home secretary, Shabana Mahmood, is being more suela or pretty than her previously seen protesting pre -election about Palestine in July 2024. Self. Shabana is bringing in more powers to prevent repeat protests against Israel's actions in Palestine, despite the fact that the British government has been the first in Europe to recognise the Palestinian state. Even taking that into account, it's still illegal to protest against the Palestinian genocide in perceived support of the prescribed terrorist organization, palestinian action. This has led to the recent arrest and leading away of a blind woman who obviously couldn't see that she was holding a placard demanding the end of the genocide. The new powers would prevent people gathering in the same place time and time again, because that causes problems for policing and and indeed drains the resources of the police force in danger of employing the false equivalence fallacy. Surely the same could have been said of the protesters gathering outside the same so -called immigrant hotels week after week, but no extra powers employed there. This comes in the wake of several people being killed in an attack on a synagogue, after which the palestinian support process were deemed to be in poor taste and should be called off. Zach polanski, the leader of the green party and jewish himself, pointed out that that was a conflation of two separate things, and reacting to the deaths of three or so people and tens of thousands of people could both happen at the same time, and saying otherwise would be falling into the Israeli government's claiming that anti -Zionism and anti -Netanyahuism was the equivalent of anti -Semitism. Zak thankfully said the thing we often say it's a bit more nuanced than that. Meanwhile, knives are out, obviously, for Corbyn and his new party. I've seen the unelectable word being bandied about already, ignoring the stats that show that Corbyn's election results in 2017, at 40 of the public vote, outweighed Starmer's 34 in 2024. But with Zach Polanski, I guess, being the equivalent of Gavin Newsom in terms of speaking against the right -leaning tide. Both Starmer and Corbyn need to look out. If only the media would show more of Zach than Tweedy Gonad Farage, perhaps he wouldn't be being drum -rolled into number 10 and reform -fearing Shabana wouldn't be being such an arse.

1:50:04 Jim: So that's all the bad arguments and faulty reasoning we have time for this week. You'll find the show notes at Fallacioustrump .com, and if you hear Trump say something stupid and want to ask if it's a fallacy, our contact details are on the contact page.

1:50:14 Mark: If you think we've used a fallacy ourselves, let us know. And if you've had a good time, please give us a review on Apple Podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts, or simply tell one other person in person about how much they'd like our podcast. And you can support the show at Patreon .com slash ftrump, just like our Strawman -level patrons Chuck Gray, Mike Smyth, eltee Colleen, Laila, Richard, Thunder, Hopkins, Will M Scott, Mark Breike and Amber Arbucan, who told us when we met her at QED we could just Call her Amber. And last year at QED I met the listener I recognised at QED the year before because we keep using her full name all the time. And our true Scotsman-level patrons, Thank you so much for your continued support, everyone. It's very, very much appreciated. Thank you.

1:51:00 Jim: You can connect with those awesome people, as well as us and other listeners, in the Facebook group at Facebook .com slash group slash FallaciousTrump, or in the Discord at Fallacioustrump .com slash Discord.

1:51:09 Mark: All music is by The Outbursts and was used with permission. So until next time on FallaciousTrump, we'll leave the last word to the Donald.

1:51:18 [Unclear]: That's right. Go home to mommy. Bye. Bye.

Share this episodeBlueskyThreadsFacebookRedditEmail

Never miss a fallacy

New episodes every couple of weeks. Subscribe free wherever you listen, or support us on Patreon.

Also on Pocket Casts, Android and RSS.