Show Notes
The Traitorous Critic Fallacy, or Ergo Decedo, is a fallacy where someone dismisses a person with genuine complaints by telling them if they don’t like it, they can leave. It’s a way of avoiding dealing with the complaint itself and branding the complainer as unworthy of being part of ‘our’ group.
Trump
We started out with this clip of the Donald making excuses for his racist tweets:
Mark’s British Politics Corner
In Mark’s British Politics Corner, we talked about this clip from BBC’s Question Time:
Then we talked about this Noel Gallagher telling ‘remoaners’ where to go.
Fallacy in the Wild (Sting: Creep – Radiohead)
In the Fallacy in the Wild, we talked about this clip from The Office episode “Did I Stutter?”:
Then we discussed a clip from American Hustle, just after Jennifer Lawrence blows up a science oven:
Fake News
Here are the statements from this week’s Fake News game:
- I don’t know if you’ve heard, but I just got a great endorsement from Mitch McConnell. Such a lot of people are endorsing me. Mitch is a great guy and a great friend — a better friend now that he’s endorsed me — and he’s done a tremendous job as Senate Majority Leader. I don’t know him that well, but the couple of times I’ve got to meet him we got on very well. I think we’re going to be good friends.
- I just want to say that we just spent quite a bit of time inside with the Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, who has been a friend of mine for a long time, long before my world of politics, early into his world of politics, I think. But we’ve been friends for a long time. We are probably now, despite what we read, we’re probably now — I think, at least as far as I’m concerned — closer than ever before. And the relationship is very good.
- Mitch McConnell is a man that knows less about Russia and Russia’s influence than even Donald Trump. And I know nothing. So I think it’s a horrible thing when a paper — which is really just a paper for the benefit of Amazon — the Washington Post is fake news, just like the New York Times is fake news. It’s put there for the benefit — the Washington Post — of Amazon. That’s my opinion. And I think it’s a disgrace.
Click below for the answer
Spoiler
Statement 1 is fake news. Mark chose number 3.Mark got it wrong this week, but at least he’s on a nice round number – exactly 40%.
The second Democratic Debates are not a logical fallacy
Then we talked about the second Democratic Debates.
The stories we really didn’t have time to talk about
- Last weekend, America suffered two more mass shootings, in El Paso Texas and Dayton, Ohio. Once again Republicans tried to place the blame anywhere but on guns, with Trump reading disingenuous words from a teleprompter that once again blamed video games, included the phrase “Mental illness and hatred pull the trigger, not the gun” and saw Trump ad lib Toledo when the teleprompter said ‘Texas and Ohio’. The White House barred the press pool from attending his subsequent visits to the affected cities, saying it was about the victims, not a photo op. Of course, because it’s Trump, the White House media team took plenty of photos of a grinning Trump giving his signature thumbs up and made a schmaltzy campaign ad out of the visit. Watching the ad, you can’t even tell that all eight of the victims still being treated in El Paso University Medical Centre refused to meet with Trump.
- Ohio Sen. Sherrod Brown and Dayton Mayor Nan Whaley were rather complementary about Trump’s visit to shooting victims at a Dayton Hospital on 7th August. At a press conference after Trump and Melania had left Brown said “He was received well by the patients, as you’d expect. They’re hurting.He was comforting. He did the right things and Melania did the right things. And it’s his job in part to comfort people. I’m glad he did it in those hospital rooms.” But these are Democrats and their weasel words are not to be trusted – by 2:32pm the same day Dan Scavino Jr. tweeted in an uncannily Trump way “Very SAD to see Ohio Senator Brown, & Dayton Mayor Nan Whaley – LYING & completely mischaracterizing what took place w/ the President’s visit to Miami Valley Hospital today. They are disgraceful politicians, doing nothing but politicizing a mass shooting, at every turn they can…” an hour and a quarter later Trump added “Their news conference after I left for El Paso was a fraud. It bore no resemblance to what took place with those incredible people that I was so lucky to meet and spend time with.” er he’s denying the good things they said took place wait what.. How fragile must your ego be to pre-prepare and tweet out a rebuttal even when people are nice about you – oh yeah no wait durr!
- Trump just seems determined to kill US agriculture because he can’t admit that trade wars are neither good, nor easy to win. His latest round of tariffs on Chinese consumer goods has caused China to announce they are halting all purchases of US agricultural products and they’ve allowed their currency to drop to its lowest value in over 10 years, leading the Treasury Department to officially designate them as a currency manipulator. This is very bad. According to many economists such as Art Hogan, chief market strategist at National Securities Corporation, exactly how bad it will get is impossible to tell, but the worse it gets, the faster the US will be plunged into a full on recession. And Trump still somehow thinks he’s punishing the Chinese.
- On that subject I’m not one to normally hold with conspiracy theories but when 99% of the USDA USDept of Agriculture’s funds to help bailout farmers affected as a result of the trade tariffs war with China instigated by, let me check, oh the US government end up going to white farmers – 91% of recipients being MALE white farmers I begin to suspect some higher plan at work. Donald Carr, a senior adviser at the Environmental Working Group, told Bloomberg that when bailout funds “continue to overwhelmingly flow to an elite group of the largest farms, wealthy landowners and city residents with no real connection to the day-to-day operations on the land, it’s clear the program is deeply flawed and not delivering aid to those farmers in desperate need.” The USDA said payments have all been made in accordance with our published regulations and existing procedures,” ah well that’s alright then no need to do anything about it – “we were just following orders” anyone?
- If Trump put a bit more thought into his nominations instead of just blurting them out, maybe his pick for Director of National Intelligence, Congressman John Ratcliffe, would have had time to look at his own website and delete the parts of his resume where he’d made stuff up, like his claim that he’d put terrorists in prison despite in fact never having prosecuted a terrorist. Or the claim that he was the prosecutor on US v Holy Land Foundation, one of the nations largest terrorism financing cases, for which he in fact was not even on the prosecution team. When he decided to withdraw from consideration, Trump admitted he had been hasty… no, of course he didn’t. He tweeted: Our great Republican Congressman John Ratcliffe is being treated very unfairly by the LameStream Media. Rather than going through months of slander and libel, I explained to John how miserable it would be for him and his family to deal with these people….Trump’s right, it’s very unfair of the media to report on what people actually do. Shame on them.
- Trump of course is noted for insisting people serving in public office hold the law in high regard, and so it is with former Illinois Governor Rod Blagojevich who continues to serve the remainder of 18 years jail time not least for being caught on tape trying to sell off the appointment to the vacated Senate seat of newly-elected President Barack Obama to the highest bidder. Ah no what am I saying, Rod’s also been on TV – on Celebrity Apprentice season 9 – Trump’s Apprentice!! Trump fired Rod when he couldn’t verify facts about Harry Potter, how times have changed – good ol’ showbiz buddy Trump thinks Rod’s been hard done by, wants to make it up to him and commute his sentence. Yeah great optics Donny great optics, set free a convicted and jailed corrupt politician now, now of all moments! Donny You’re Fired – idiot!
- Texas Congressman Will Hurd, the only African American Republican in the House of Representatives, has said he will not be running for reelection in 2020. That makes him the eleventh House Republican, and the sixth just in the last two weeks that have announced they are leaving office next year. Giving up their incumbency reduces the GOPs chances of winning those seats in 2020, but then so does being led by a racist reality TV has-been, so who’s to say how much it really matters. Fans of black Republicans in Congress shouldn’t feel too hard done by, because there’s always the Senate, where you can find Tim Scott and… well, that’s it.
- Ben Carson Secretary of Housing and Urban Development set up for a press conference outside church in Baltimore to appear like he was doing something for the neighborhood Church officials kindly told him to go back to where he came from. Ironic really cos he used to come from round there, working in Baltimore – where he says he was afraid to send kids home because of “rats and an unabated lead problem” and thanked god that he was now in charge at HUD and could do something about it, which he hasn’t apart from roll back Obama-era housing legislation and buying a $31,000 dining room set for his office and $8,000 dishwasher in the office kitchen without notifying congress. Whattaguy whattaguy!
If you wanted to buy a T-shirt featuring this fallacy, you could click here. No pressure
And if you have some money left over after that, Jim’s book, 2000 Mules and One Big Lie: A Stubborn Conspiracy Theory is available now.
That’s almost all for this week, but here’s our AI-aided transcript, which is quite accurate, but not totally:
Traitorous Critic Fallacy – FT#31 Transcript
Read the full transcript
00:25 Jim: Hello and welcome to Fallacious Trump, the podcast where we use the insane ramblings of the least racist person in the world to explain logical fallacies. I'm your host, Jim.
00:33 Mark: And I'm your other host, Mark. A logical fallacy is an error in reasoning that results in bad or invalid arguments. And the logical fallacy we're looking at this week is the traitorous critic fallacy, also known as ergo decado.
00:46 Jim: Yeah, ergo decado or decido, I don't know how it's pronounced. I don't remember Latin.
00:51 Mark: Yeah, Latin, I think it's probably hard C.
00:55 Jim: So that means, therefore, leave. And that is basically the concept of this fantasy. It's a very, very simple one. It is saying: if someone doesn't agree with you, instead of engaging with their criticism or their disagreement, you just say: well, if you don't like it, go away. And obviously, this comes from Trump's recent attempt to tell the four congresswomen in the squad to go back where they came from. And, of course, when he did that, when he tweeted that he was clearly using a racist trope and saying racist things to them. But obviously everyone immediately said no, he wasn't being racist at all. And in fact, a couple of episodes ago, I did a bonus episode where I talked about the media's response to that and and the the media that were calling it racist and the media that were using euphemisms for calling it racist, and what I'm talking about this time is actually his kind of excuse after all of the backlash, because he obviously wasn't prepared to accept that he was being racist. He said he doesn't have a racist bone in his body, but he tried to characterize it as a different point he was making and he said this:
02:08 Clip: Trump making excuses for his racist tweets
— if you're not happy here, you can leave, and that's what I say all the time. That's what I said in a tweet which I guess some people think is controversial. A lot of people love it, by the way. A lot of people love it. But if you're not happy in the U .s, if you're complaining all the time, very simply, you can leave. You can leave right now. Come back if you want, don't come back, it's okay too, but if you're not happy, you can leave.
02:36 Jim: Now, of course, that's not what he was saying. He wasn't saying that
02:41 Mark: a bit of an argument from numbers as well. You know a lot of people, a lot of people like it. Yeah, so that's right. A lot of the the wrong kind of people.
02:49 Jim: Yeah, he wasn't saying anyone who isn't happy can leave the us. Obviously, he doesn't have to give people permission. They can leave if they want to. There's no need for that. Yeah, what he was saying was: you particular people who are complaining should go and, and yeah, that was an attempt not to engage with valid things that they were raising, about things that need need to change in the? U .s, and what he tweeted basically was: I'm not going to do the whole thing, but he said about the, the, the progressive Democrat, congresswomen's kind of countries of origin, despite the fact that three of them are from the? U .s. He said that they don't have functioning government governments. Their total catastrophes are the worst, most corrupt places anywhere in the world. He said: why don't they go back and help fix the totally broken and crime infested places from which they came? Then come back and show us how it's done? And in saying, then come back a lot of his um, his supporters and apologists were saying that. You know, all of the Democrats who were saying he told these people to go away are ignoring the fact he told them they could come back. You know that it's totally disingenuous to say that he was telling people to get out of the us because he said that they could come back. But, of course, the thing thing that they're ignoring is the context there is: come back after you've fixed broken crime, infested places that are total catastrophes, which, yeah, which is like saying, you know, once you've solved poverty, then you can come back. Yeah, that's not actually an invitation to come back, is it?
04:32 Mark: No, it's kind of go away and fix the thing you're accusing me of. Yeah, and when you've done that, you know, take the plank out of your own eye and then you can come back and, you know, deal with the. And again, you know, with no trace of irony in his uh proclamation there, because three of them are working in a broken down, you know, crime infested and three of them that for them, that's the? U .s and that's his government, absolutely, and that's
05:05 Jim: the thing is that they, They are. That's their job. They are fixing. That's why they got into government was to fix things that aren't working in their own country.
05:15 Mark: They're working in opposition to the current state of affairs which he happens to be in charge of. And that's the other part of the, you know, the other name for this is about the traitorous critic. So they are critics of his government and he is calling them out as traitors. He's saying, well, you're not allowed to say this kind of thing to me. So not only must you go away, but you're also. You must go away because you belong to the bunch of people who are traitorous, who we don't trust and we're not going to listen to your argument, much less engage with it. You just need to go with all those people that everybody agrees are treacherous, untrustworthy and we don't listen to. All of that is encapsulated in in that fallacy. I would submit your honor.
06:16 Jim: And he's saying basically that if you don't think everything is great, then then that's un -american somehow. If you're, if you're going to say everything is awesome, yeah, um, yeah, and you should, you should not criticize America. You should, should not criticise the president. And obviously, that's unbelievably stupid in so many ways. It's very much against so many things about America, of having the free speech to speak up and complain about things that aren't OK. Also it's what he has spent not just time while he's president doing, but his entire campaign was based on making America great again, which implies it wasn't already great. You're saying yeah during the whole campaign. America doesn't win anymore, it's it's. You know, all the the stuff about all the immigration and making everything terrible and the ms -13 and all of the stuff is all criticisms of of America and how bad it is and how it needs to be fixed.
07:20 Mark: And the government itself is um run by big business and is swampy and corrupt and not answerable to anybody. You know, and it needs changing. And, yeah, so it's okay for him. So it's special pleading as well, isn't it? It's okay for him to do that, but anybody else who disagrees with him can't say that. They're not allowed to. They are literally cast out. You know, ergo decado means, you know, go, get out here. You know, you've transgressed the unwritten law, which is you can't disagree with me.
08:05 [Unclear]: That's fundamentally it, isn't it?
08:07 Jim: In fact, it makes me think of the quote by Theodore Roosevelt, who said: to announce that there must be no criticism of the president or that we are to stand by the president, right or wrong, is not only unpatriotic and servile but is morally treasonable to the American public. And that's that's. He said that when he was president, or actually, yeah, after. Yeah, he was, this is after he was president actually, and he said that. But but the point is that he's saying it's it's even as president. It's not okay to expect everyone to to or to say all good things about you, um, and that there mustn't be any criticism. That's very much against what America is all about.
08:46 Mark: Yeah, because if you're representing the people, then the some of the people are going to disagree with you and and you need to listen. Listen to the p, yes, that's okay and and, in a way, it's your duty to listen to them. And, in fact, that kind of forms the content of one of the clips – really is your duty as a politician, as a representative of the people, to listen to what the people say and possibly change the way you're doing things,
09:20 Jim: to tell them to go away rather than criticize. Is is just avoiding engaging with criticism itself.
09:28 [Sting: Mark's British Politics Corner] And now is the time, I think, for Mark's British Politics Corner.
09:32 Mark: So, yes, we will get to the example we'll just have referred to shortly, but I kind of wanted – I found it very difficult – to find examples where, uh, British politicians were as ready to happy to vociferous with expressing this notion that you can banish the people who are against you out loud, uh, away from your view. You know, get out, get out of my, my side, you know, rather than engage with what they've got to say, and can't find any of them actively calling their critics traitors or dismissing what they say because they belong to a bunch of people that you ought not to trust, much less telling each other or the voters to leave if they don't like it, and I've got a theory about that in a minute. What's involved in this fallacy is dismissing the critic instead of engaging with the argument, as we kind of talk. And also what's implied in engaging with the argument is the possibility that you might have to give in, you might have to give up your position to the weight of facts and evidence that is being presented to you. We seem to be currently living politically here in the UK and in the US – in an era where facts and evidence are just as much open to interpretation. There's no longer an objective truth that people can appeal to independently of our, you know, the two argumenters' positions. Acquisitions. So dismissing all of that? Um, it includes calling people who point out the flaws traitors, ramonas, enemies, Project Fear, uh. So they all get lumped over there in a bunch of people. It then becomes easier to set them up as being able to be told to go away, because you're saying saying, well, all of these people are enemies of the people. They are just Project Fear. They are Ramoners. So we can just go, okay, we're not going to listen to you. So I did find some examples of MPs kind of saying the stuff, but they don't go as far as saying: so you can just leave. Whereas members of the public, which Jim found a couple of examples of, have no compunction about saying that at all. And in fact, here's the first example is from BBC Christian Time way back in October 2016. So just after the referendum had been run in the June of that year. And we all know the result. And so this Orders member, Gary Young, I think his name is, he accuses Angela Rayner, who's a Labour MP. And these days you have to kind of go well, okay and and they remain so. They're labor and remain so which part of labor do they belong to? Again, that we'll come back to that in a minute. Um, so he's accusing her of ignoring the referendum result. She says this in reply.
12:49 Clip: BBC Question Time
— I'm not saying and I'm not suggesting we ignore the vote. The vote is quite clear. But as a member of parliament, I have a responsibility for British jobs, British workers, Sorry,
— you have. Your job is to represent the public. The people who elect you, start doing your job. If you don't like it, clear off.
13:15 Mark: There you go. So that is kind of interesting because he doesn't want to engage with what she's saying because he doesn't agree with it. Um, she is not unreasonably, um, saying: I have a responsibility. Yes, I, I see what the vote was, but what she is, uh, trying to get to grips with is this: runs. This flies in the face of my responsibility to ensure that, you know, not least her constituents – if not all of the voters who vote labor, if not not the entire country – ensure that they've got a job and that they are able to continue to trade with the markets that they've traded with up till now and remain in work and still have the opportunities for putting their kids through education and all those kind of things. You can almost hear him saying, no, you haven't got that responsibility. Responsibility you're. And then he kind of stops himself. He said, no, you're, you never mind all that. Your responsibility is to listen to the will of the people. Yeah, he's.
14:29 Jim: He's saying that her responsibility is to do what the voters have said, but of course, he's trying to get her to ignore the fact that almost half of the voters said they didn't want to leave. But so her responsibility is to do what the 52 percent of voters – and that's not even necessarily in her constituency, constituency, um, you know, maybe, that the people who she is actually supposed to be representing did vote to to remain, and so, in technically, her job would, in that case, would be to to advocate on their behalf. I don't know, yeah,
15:03 Mark: and also is historically, it would have been to advocate on their behalf vis -a -vis housing, jobs, education, you know, um, free market trading,
15:13 [Unclear]: all of those things.
15:14 Jim: It's a representative democracy, isn't it? So we, we elect people to then use their judgment for what they think is best for us. Essentially, it's not that we elect people and then tell them what to do. We, we elect people who we think will do the best job. So if her view is that actually remaining is better for the people in her district or her constituency, then that is what she should advocate for.
15:39 Mark: Yeah, or the, the, the, the previous um votes, if you, if you like, the previous priorities that her constituents and other labor voters voted for, I .e, good jobs, a living wage, good access to health and education – those things may well um outweigh the leaving the eu in her opinion. As a representative, as a, an elected politician who we ask to do this job for us, um, so my uh second example, or jim's second example that you pointed me out, is: um. So this is Noel Gallagher, uh, from oasis, out of oasis, uh, who's speaking on the 15th of June this year, um, and he he's in the long line of rock stars whose opinions people seek rather than just just make some tunes and entertain us, and that is.
16:45 Jim: It's important that we find out what celebrities think about things that they have no expertise in, because they're just better than us. It is, so it's more important.
16:54 Mark: We have referred to this phenomenon before, haven't we? And they do know better than us. They, you know, they wear sunglasses at night and they wear leather jackets in hot television studios. They certainly act and and speak better than us, and their opinions are worth listening to, even if their lyrics aren't. So here's Noel Gallagher. You know, Noel Gallagher, what he has to say about Brexit. On the Manchester Evening News Twitter feed. And weirdly, it involves one of Trump's favourite places.
17:28 Clip: BBC Question Time
— A democratic vote took place. And it went one way, and the other people don't like it. And I said to most people, there's only f***ing one thing worse than a fool who voted for Brexit. That's the rise of f***ing trying to get the vote overtaken. You know, it's like you take part in a democratic process. If you don't like the outcome, go to North Korea.
17:58 Mark: There you go. So the beeping is, with Noel Gallagher, he swears every other word.
18:04 Jim: You're Noel Gallagher if you don't get beeped quite frequently.
18:09 Mark: I think actually he says that. He doesn't actually swear. He just opens his mouth and a beep comes out. That's because it's quicker. It saves time. So, yeah, there he is. I quite liked his – it was almost Oscar Wilde – when he said: you know, there's only one thing worse than a fool who voted for Brexit, and that's the cunt who wants to reverse the vote. And you kind of think if he wasn't for the cunt, that's almost an Oscar Wilde epithet, isn't it? There's only one thing worse than a fool who voted for Brexit and that's a fool who didn't vote for Brexit. That kind of thing, yeah. Yeah, and then, and it's a very specific um, ergo decado there. Very specific: if you don't like it, you can go to North Korea. Here's my thesis on why um politicians are not keen in the Uk on being as as outspoken about um. Just go, just fuck off um as Trump and noah Gallagher are, because he he actually says, in the same interview of Noel Gallagher, that Brexit isn't divided on party lines. So, uh, it's no longer just you're on the left or you're on the right, because there are people that voted, leave and remain on both sides. Um, so mps can't simply dismiss an opposing view by saying: well, if you don't like what I'm doing, then fuck off and go join the other side. Because, for instance, it's very tricky for Boris because he currently has a working majority of one seat in the House of Commons. There's been a resignation a couple of weeks ago, or was it a defection? There are currently MPs threatening to defect from the Tories, which would leave him vulnerable, more vulnerable – in the event of a vote of no confidence in his government. In fact, today, a senior Tory left the party, not an MP, sadly, because of the extremeness of his view, which is basically to blame the EU for not negotiating and not willing to come to the table and talk about a New deal, even though he hasn't spoken to anybody in the EU since he got elected prime minister. Um, so he's go. He's all set for blaming the no deal on the eu and heading for a no deal crash out. Um so members of his own party are disagreeing with his standpoint, but he's not saying to them: well, if you don't like it, you can leave, because if they do, his government will collapse. Within Within the Brexit argument these days, I think, ergo, decado has simply become get over it. In lots of the correspondence that goes on, even with stuff that I put up occasionally on social media and just to taunt my Brexit friends, they rise to the bait and they go. We won, get over it. And I think that's the equivalent, that's the modern translation of ergo decado. That's, you know, there's nowhere to send people, just just go away.
21:33 [Sting: Fallacy in the Wild (Creep – Radiohead)]
22:18 Mark: Radiohead there with Creep. And that was in honor of, well, both Trump and Boris. Actually, yeah, in the Fallacy in the Wild,
22:28 Jim: we like to talk about the fallacy of the week from a non -political perspective, and uh, first example this week comes from the – uh, the us version of the office, which will always be the – uh, the poorer relation of the Uk version. Sorry, sorry guys. Yeah, um, and this is from an episode where stanley has been quite rude to michael scott and michael is having difficulty kind of disciplining him because of the kind of boss he is. And this is a bit that stanley says to camera.
23:00 Clip: The Office
— It's like I used to tell my wife: I do not apologize unless I think I'm wrong and if you don't like it, you can leave. And I say the same thing to my current wife and I'll say it to my next one too.
23:14 Mark: Yeah, so there's the consequences of just adopting this fantasy. Yeah, so that people will call your bluff. Yeah, that's the yeah. And leave, leave. Yeah, let's hope somebody will do that in the Tory party. Oh, yeah, and I love his face, his fatalism, where he just kind of goes: yeah, yeah, and I say that to my wife, happened to my previous wife and it will happen to the next one.
23:42 Jim: Yeah, so he, he refuses to engage if someone is saying that he's done something he needs to apologize for. He refuses to engage with the criticism. He just says: okay, tough, if you don't like it, leave. Which is the simple, the simple thing that um ergo decadent is. Our next example is from American hustle with Christian bale and jennifer lawrence, and this is just after jennifer lawrence has set fire to the microwave that Christian bale brought home and he's not happy.
24:16 Clip: American Hustle
— I told you not to put metal in the science oven. What do you do that for?
— Don't make such a big deal, just get another one.
— I don't want another one, I want the one that carmine gave me.
— Oh, come on with the one that carmine gave me, come on, come on. Why don't you just marry carmine, get a little gold microwave and put it on chain around your neck?
24:35 Jim: So this is a slightly different version of ergo decadent, because what she's saying is basically in the same way as Republicans sometimes say. You know if, if you think that that socialism is so great, go to venezuela. Or if you think that sweden is so great, go and move to sweden. It's the same kind of thing. It's it's supposed to saying: if you don't like what you've got here, go away. She is saying, as his wife, if you, if you like carmine so much, if he's so great, go and marry carmine. Um, yeah, yeah, it is refusing to. I mean, he is justifiably angry with her because he told her not to put metal in the science oven and she did and it blew up. Yeah, so yeah, she's refusing to engage with that and take any responsibility for it. She's just saying, well, I get another one if you don't. If you think carmine's great, go and marry carmine. So, yeah, yeah, yeah,
25:27 Mark: no, not even yes, it's kind of, you can get another one. No, no, we need, I wanted that one. I want you to take responsibility for and just to pull it. Well, I only apologize if I think I'm wrong. I want you to to just see what it is that I'm saying and go. actually, you're right, yeah, should have. Yeah, yeah, you're right, I'm terribly sorry. Is there anything we can do to to fix that? Rather just going out, get another one. Mind you, I do quite like the idea of having a small gold microwave on a chain. I quite like that.
26:03 Jim: So an exception to this rule of saying, um, if you don't like it, leave, is when you are actually the person who has the authority to make the rule. Because then you can say, if you don't want to play by my rules, you can leave. And a real life example of this is, has been in the UK press recently. And it's actually the school that my son goes to. And there's a child that is due to go to his school in September. September. He's just passed his 11 plus. He's done very well and he's achieved the grades that he would need to get to get into this school. But he has very, very long hair. Uh, he's never cut his hair. It's kind of his as far as he's concerned, as far as his parents are concerned, it's part of his personality is his long hair and the school has rules against that. They say that they they want their students to be kind of well groomed and they have rules about how long boy's hair is. Um, in the Uk more schools have kind of uniform rules and rules about grooming and things like that than they do in the us and this is a kind of. It's a, it's a grammar school, so it's not a private school, it's not paid for, but it is a kind of a quality school that that creams off the, the kind of the, the higher achieving students, and they have a kind of reputation and they have of a certain level of expectation of their students of what they're going to look like, because they they feel that it helps, I guess, people to kind of conform to their standards.
27:39 Mark: So and I guess also they're kind of grooming them, if you can use that word these days they're grooming them to think about. Well, when you're applying for university, and the universities we want you to go to, there will be certain expectations, and if you're going into the workplace, there will be certain expectations. So we are getting you to think about, uh, adhering to the rules and uh, adopting the uniform and behaving in a uniform way, because, and also it makes the school easier to manage.
28:17 Jim: Yeah, and that is part of their argument is that is, that they are preparing, preparing people, they're preparing their, their students, for kind of life in um, in the workplace. And many workplaces – not all workplaces – obviously you can, you can dress how you like in some places, but but many have an expectation of how you will appear and so they are kind of trying to to build this into part of what they do for their students. So the parents are unhappy, the boy is unhappy and basically the school have said: well, if you want to come to the school, these are our rules and And because, as a school, they are allowed to have rules and they are allowed to exclude people who don't follow the rules because they are in that position of authority. That isn't a fallacy. They're not engaging with this criticism. They have explained their position on it and they have the ability to enforce that position, because that's the control that they have as the authority. Trump in trying to say: go away to people who criticize, doesn't have that authority to say: I'm going to deport people who criticize me. Um, he would like, I'm sure, to have that authority, but, um, but he doesn't. So, yeah, it doesn't work in the same way. And the other thing is that this isn't like the school that he's been allocated in in. In some cases, uh, schools are allocated on the basis of how close you live to the school. This, in this case, it's. This is a, a kind of school where you have to, um, pass a test to get in, and and so. So this is, yeah, he's choosing specifically to go to this school. He's picked this school and his parents have he's. Apparently he wants to do like quantum physics or something like that. So, so, this is, it's a good school, he's. He's probably going to get good grades if he goes there, and and you know, that's why he's chosen this. But there are are plenty of other schools that he could go to that may have different rules. Um, yeah, and and. So by choosing this school, yeah, by choosing this school, he's getting a benefit, and and to get that benefit, he may have to concede, uh, on the thing that he doesn't want.
30:23 Mark: You've got, yeah, you kind of got to view it as the entrance fee, haven't you? You can think you know how long are you going to live? How long are you going to be at this school? Six years, seven years? You know you can grow your hair when you leave that. You know it'll grow again. It's not like it won't? Um, and he's only had it for 11 years. You're likely to live another 11 beyond the end of the school. Yeah, um, mind you, if he kind of behaves like that, he's not going to live to see a 12th birthday, that's.
30:52 Jim: I'm not going to take that as a threat. I think that's so.
30:58 [Sting: Fake News] We're gonna. We're gonna play fake news folks. I, I love the game. It's a great game. I understand the game as well as anybody. As well as anybody.
31:07 Jim: Yes, it's time for Fake News. The game where I read out three Trump quotes, two of which are real and one I made up, and Mark has to figure out which one is fake news.
31:15 Mark: Yeah, and if you don't like the way that I've been playing this, you can just leave.
31:24 Mark: Well, I'm just practically in the bag, already ready, and I'm, what is it?
31:30 Jim: 12 out of 12 out of 29 at the moment? Yeah, after a run of success. Uh, last week, you, yeah, went back to tradition, um and um, yeah,
31:41 Mark: I was appealing to tradition, and this this time, um, yeah, I'm joining the band of people over there, the traitors, who are: yeah, I might actually pick two wrong ones this week.
31:53 Jim: Yeah, no, you have to play by the rules.
31:55 Mark: I'm gonna disagree with the rules, okay, yeah, exactly, if you don't like that, you can just go and listen to something else, right?
32:04 Jim: So, okay, our theme this week is: uh, is Mitch Mcconnell?
32:08 [Unclear]: Because he is.
32:10 Jim: He's recently been accused of uh being a kind of another puppet of putin and and trended on Twitter and in social media in general as Moscow Mitch, which he had a problem with. He didn't like lovely, he didn't mind when someone cocaine Mitch a couple of years ago, but he really did not like being called Moscow Mitch.
32:30 Mark: So, and there's, that's really nice, isn't it? It's kind of it conjures up, um, like a small mouse that produced by pixar, voiced by robin williams. Moscow Mitch has all sorts of all sorts of adventures, and then, yeah, people started calling
32:53 Jim: Lindsey Graham Leningrad Lindsey as well, which is quite amusing anyway. So these are things that that Trump has said about Mitch McConnell. This is from pre the election. I think this is May 2016. He said: I don't know if you've heard, but I just got a great endorsement from Mitch McConnell. Such a lot of people are endorsing me. Mitch is a great guy and a great friend – a better friend now that he's endorsed me and he's done a tremendous job as the senate majority leader. I don't know him that well, but the couple of times I got to meet him, we got on very well. I think we're going to be good friends. Statement number two: this is from um 2017, after the election. He said: I just want to say that we spent quite a bit of time inside with the senate majority leader, Mitch Mcconnell, who has been a friend of mine for a long time, long before my world of politics, early into his world of politics, I think, but we've been friends for a long time. We're probably now, despite what we read, we're probably now, I think, at least as far as I'm concerned, closer than ever before and the relationship is very good. Okay, um. And statement number three is is bang up today. It's. It's in response to the people calling him Moscow Mitch. Um, he says Mitch Mcconnell is a man that knows less about Russia and russia's influence than even Donald Trump, and I know nothing. So I think it's a horrible thing when a paper which is really just the paper for the benefit of Amazon, the Washington Post, is fake news, just like the New New York times is fake news. It's put there for the benefit the Washington Post of Amazon. That's my opinion and I think it's a disgrace.
34:29 Mark: um, he's very concerned about how friendly he is with Mitch, and that seems always to be the kiss of death, really, doesn't it? Because anyway, now I hope I've got him in the um the fire swamp. He's going to get fired, doesn't he? Um, okay, Okay. Great endorsements. A lot of people endorsed me. He's a great guy, great friend, better friend now, he's endorsed me. Yeah, that's very Trump. I don't know him now, he's a great friend. I don't know him, but I think we're going to be good friends. Yeah, that's early Trump tropes, isn't it? That's a long time, probably now, probably now. At least that's a lovely extended Trump sentence. And then he manages to get in a whole list of fake news, people. Oh, God. See, it's deserted me, my nose. I think for the sake of that elongated sentence. Oh, no, no, no, no. I'm going to plop for three. I think number three is the one you made up.
35:51 Jim: So of the other two, which one do you think you're more confident about?
35:58 Mark: Okay, I think the second one, actually, with the elongated sentence in the middle, I'm more confident about.
36:05 Clip: Trump, played during Fake News
— So number two is real.
— I just want to say that we just spent quite a bit of time inside side with the Senate majority leader, Mitch McConnell, who has been a friend of mine for a long time, long before my world of politics, early into his world of politics, I think. But we've been friends for a long time. We are probably now, despite what we read, we're probably now, I think, at least as far as I'm concerned, closer than ever before. And the relationship is very good.
36:42 Mark: That runs completely contrary to the previous one, doesn't it?
36:47 [Unclear]: What it's just weird thing is that
36:50 Jim: mcconnell's been in politics for since the 70s, basically, yeah, so Trump's suggesting that they've been friends since, since.
37:00 [Unclear]: Since that time, as
37:01 Jim: far as I could find, he never mentioned Mitch Mcconnell or was mentioned alongside Mitch Mcconnell until 2016, till, yeah, when he was in. They don't seem to be the same kind of person, which I don't think is a kind of, you know, New York party guy in the same kind of jeffrey epstein way as as Trump. Yes, I, I find it very difficult to believe that they've been friends at all or are friends for that matter.
37:32 Mark: Yeah, but exactly yeah, but, or, you know, because there's a thing about being friends that the other person has to acknowledge the friendship you know. So we're probably now, despite what we read, that what and who is this we? I just want to say that we just spent a quite bit of time. Is that the other Trump inside his head? We've been friends a long time. We're probably now. It's probably we're probably now, I think, at least as far as I'm concerned, because it's kind of like: yeah, you're gonna work with me, work for me, everything,
38:06 Jim: I want you to be my friend. Everything is based on how much other people like him, basically, and so So if you can say that he's been friends with this guy for a long time, then that means that he must like him, Mitch must like him, because they've been friends for such a long time.
38:19 Mark: Yeah, because he can't possibly, other people can't possibly be using Trump.
38:24 [Unclear]: No. Because that's what he does. It's not that Trump is just a useful idiot. He does that. No. Yeah. So with that in mind, Yeah.
38:32 Jim: Is number one, where he says that he's barely met him, he's just met him a couple of times, also real?
38:39 [Unclear]: Yeah, is that true?
38:40 Jim: Number one is is: yeah, yeah, fake news.
38:45 Mark: Oh wow, whoa bloody hell. That's very good great guy. Yeah, yeah, well, that was the the little aside. A better friend now than he's endorsed me. Really good gag actually now. Now I know that it's not real. That's really nicely done,
39:07 Clip: Trump, played during Fake News
— but yeah, wow, Wow. Oh, that is rich. Which means that number three,
39:11 Jim: where he says, I know nothing. Is. Oh, my God.
39:16 Clip: Trump, played during Fake News
— Mitch McConnell is a man that knows less about Russia and Russian influence than even Donald Trump. And I know nothing. So I think it's a horrible thing when a paper, which is really just a paper for the benefit of Amazon. The Washington Post is fake news, just like the New York Times is fake news. It's put there for the benefit of the Washington Post, of Amazon. That's my opinion, and I think it's a disgrace.
39:45 Jim: He never finishes that sentence. It's like, I think it's a horrible thing when a paper and then just gets sucked into a fake news accusation.
39:55 Mark: To the whole fake news world, yeah. I think it's a horrible thing when a paper is a disgrace. What, his opinion is a disgrace? Well, it is, yeah, we know that. That. But wow, I love that when he goes there's the, we look, and because he says he knows less about it than even Donald Trump and I know nothing. So he's just kind of looks across, goes: oh, that's me, isn't it? Yeah, oh, that's wow. Oh well, we're blind me. Well, there's no, yeah, so, and that's really
40:27 [Unclear]: up to date. And he's still this week, yeah, maintaining last week. He knows nothing. Yeah, I know nothing, nothing about Russia. Whoa, yeah, nothing.
40:37 Jim: He doesn't specify, he knows nothing about Russia, he just says I know nothing. So I think it's probably one of the more accurate things he said. So, uh, what that means is that you are now on 12 out of 30, which is 40 percent, um, so still, that's a nice rounded number.
40:53 [Unclear]: Yes, yeah, yeah, that's good. Yeah, and uh, yeah,
40:57 Jim: yeah, and and still, yeah, still some way to go um to to. So your heady heights, I think, are 44 % or 45 %. You had at one point. So you can still get there.
41:08 Mark: Either that or you've kicked back into gear with the brilliance of your writing. That's what it is. You've been re-inspired by Moscow Mitch. That's what dismiss my upper surgeon skill level. It says, no, it wasn't you winning, it was me failing.
41:38 Jim: So it's time for the part of the episode that, this week at least, is called The Second. Democratic Debates Are Not a Logical Fallacy, because just after we recorded our last episode, we had two more democratic debates, two more nights of one debate, in a way. So since we talked about the first lot, I thought we should probably talk about the second lot as well. And it was actually, I think, a lot less um impactful on on most of the candidates. I don't think that it really kind of moved moved the needle for most people from what I can see. Certainly, um, after the first one, I declared that kamala harris was the next president and she didn't.
42:22 Mark: How are you feeling about that now?
42:24 Jim: On the second night she did. I thought she did actually pretty well, but a lot of people came after her and a lot of people um came after Biden as well, who was who was on the same night as her. So night one um, the kind of standout people there really were bernie sanders and elizabeth warren, and the weird thing about the Cnn format that that was different from the previous debates in June – was they started off with this big kind of like fight night style introduction to all of the people involved. That went on for quite a long time and and then they introduced them all individually on the stage and everyone got their own round of applause and obviously they started off with the big players – sanders and warren and and by the time it got down to like tim ryan, people were not really clapping much.
43:14 Mark: No, um, well, because they didn't know who, couldn't remember who he was and they were a little bit tired then, so that was a bit mean. Yeah, they should have done it in reverse order really. Yeah, should have built up to the stars, yeah.
43:29 Jim: And also CNN really tried to seemed to be trying to kind of put the cat among the pigeons a bit and trying to kind of play candidates off against each other and push for having a bit of a fight and kind of the Jake Tapper particularly, he asked at one point. One of his questions was: um, I think he asked damien klobuchar, who on the stage is just making promises to get elected, which I mean, what's the point of that other than just to kind of, yeah, to pick out one of the other people and say, yeah, that person, yeah, there's no real thing that's going to tell you anything about her policies or anything on that,
44:04 Mark: other than a willingness to throw someone else under the bus. Yeah, exactly, yeah, yeah, yeah.
44:10 Jim: But he was specifically calling out people and say I – I think it was um. John delaney was seemed to be called on a lot on in this first debate, which was weird because he's one of the lowest polling candidates. But, um, I spent. I think he said things about other candidates. So jake tapper was like: okay, bernie sanders, um, John delaney has said this about your health care plan, what do you think? And and so delaney got quite a lot of opportunity to, to talk, uh, above some of the other candidates, and the the the moment, I think, that stood out for me on the first night was, um, when delaney was basically saying how we can't, um, we can't kind of reach too far, we can't try to to to do anything that's too difficult. We should be realistic and not go for these kind of fairyland policies. And elizabeth warren just said: you know, know, I don't understand why people go to all the trouble of running for president just to talk about what you can't do and what we won't be able to do and what we shouldn't fight for, which is yeah, yeah, absolutely. They should be there not saying, oh well, you know we'll, we'll do our best, but it's going to be difficult. They should be there saying: this is what we're going to do. We'll shoot for the moon, absolutely, yeah, that's the point.
45:28 [Unclear]: Yeah, kennedy literally shot for the moon, absolutely, yeah. Kennedy didn't say, you know,
45:33 Jim: it was, oh, we'd like to go to the moon, but it's going to be really hard. So, you know, maybe – I don't know – 30, 40 years, we'll probably be able to do it. I don't know. He didn't. You know he was like by the end of this decade. We will do it. Yeah, that's the point.
45:45 Mark: We will do it, we'll go there and bring you back safely.
45:47 Jim: Yeah, so totally agree with Elizabeth Warren. She's she was always one of my top two candidates and she has, I think, had the biggest boost from this round of debates. Um, and, yeah, she, she kind of stood out. Sanders, I think, did pretty well, but he was quite combative with a lot of people. Um, to be fair, I think a lot of people came after him. He was a bit, yeah, but he was more animated this time and certainly John hickenlooper tried to to kind of goad him a bit and got some rise out of him, which is quite amusing. Uh, yeah, he shouted. Yeah, I did
46:22 Mark: find that he, we kind of he rested on his laurels somewhat. Yeah, as you know, the and Biden too, really that they're kind of going well. We're the, you know, we've got years of experience, we are the, the ones that can be trusted just by our presence, and you know, they're not kind of, you know, apart from being goaded about. Well, did you? Did you back those policies on busing students?
46:51 Jim: So, Biden, on the second night he came out um kind of more ready to fight than he was in the first debate. Um, he, he started out that he was first on stage again with cnn's kind of um introductions and and then camilla harris came out and he said to her: you know, go easy on me, kid and um, and she didn't. Really they had a bit of to and fro about uh health care first of of. You know, straight off they were. They were pitted against each other by by the moderators and I think for the first kind of seven or eight minutes they were pretty much the only two people who talked at all, because they were just going back back and forth arguing about stuff and and Biden um accusing uh camilla harris's health care policy of just basically being too expensive, and harris saying that biden's didn't really cover all the Americans. They were left 10 million people uninsured and um, yeah, there were some reasonable points made and and I think both of them did okay and but they were best definitely the targets for basically everyone else. Everyone kind of came up, came for them to try and score points and to try and raise their own profiles.
48:03 Mark: It's an odd experience because, um, we had the similar thing with the leadership conferences, with the uh Tory party leaders, that these guys you kind of don't get to say a get a say on who gets through to the next round, and so all you get to, at the worst you get to be depressed ahead of time as who's going to be the leader. But also there's this sinking feeling that I get over here because we are used to there being a um, an actual physical opposition um in the House of commons and you know who are banded together to fight the government that's in power. And it seems to me that the whole thing about the Democrat debates is very it's like it's the kind of infighting that the Labour Party in this country try not to make too public. And here it is on TV. And it's on TV for almost 18 months.
49:18 Jim: It's by the time they pick a candidate and they're going up against Trump. They've already had all of their kind of flaws exposed.
49:29 Jim: And I mean the question, I think to some extent is how much as the, as the people drop out of the race, will their followers move on to someone else, move on to the kind of more likely candidate to to win, and that will, I don't know. I mean, I guess that happens every time. There's so many more candidates this time than I think they've ever been. That um, it seems like the, the kind of the electorate is more fractured in that way and I hope that they will be able to pick someone who can bring them together and and that in future debates um people see things that they think that, yes, this person is worth following. I know that Elizabeth Warren in the first night um did definitely pick up some of that from people who were thinking, yeah, she's okay, and then um actually people going, yeah, she's my candidate. So I think that in the second debate I think that Biden didn't really do anything particularly wrong. I don't think he probably lost any any followers. Especially, I don't think he did brilliantly. He was, again, I think, only one of the only people who stopped talking when his time was up, just in the middle of a sentence. He was right, as if he really didn't kind of really believe in what he was saying. In a way it kind of gave that impression that he wasn't trying to push it. He just was talking until the moderator said okay, thank you, and then he stopped um, whereas the the others were passionate and wanted to make their point and so when they – the moderators – tried to stop them, they would just keep saying what they had to say until it was said. So that's the sense I got. But harris, who went in um doing well, did well against some of the people who who argued against her, but kind of about an hour in hour and 20 minutes in or so, tulsi gabbard um kind of attacked her on her prosecutorial uh record and and did some damage. I think she harris didn't didn't do brilliantly in rebutting her at the time. Afterwards in a in an interview she kind of brought up gabbard's uh record of kind of apologizing for for bashir al -assad in uh syria and things like that, but didn't mention it at the time. No one mentioned assad or her, her, her kind of pro -russian leanings or anything like that at the time. Um, yeah, and and I think gabbard came away with a slight bump in the polls and harris has lost a few points, so that's interesting. I don't think it'll make much of a difference long term because I don't think that tulsi gabbard will probably make it to the third debate. I don't think she'll have the polling numbers. Um and the. The criteria get a lot stricter for the September debates.
52:18 Mark: The set reminds me of any shiny floor show. You know the. It could be uh, big, big brother. It could be dancing, dancing with the stars, yeah, it could be all of those kind of things and it ultimately it kind of is that, but without the – uh, the people's vote, you know they're, without the, the viewers being able to dial in yeah, yeah, exactly yeah. So you don't get to choose the. You don't get to choose the candidate that goes through to the next round or that gets to leave the big brother House. It's I.
52:59 Jim: I question the value of these, these two debates, these, these ones and the ones in June, because there are so many candidates – there's two nights, 10 people each. A lot of people didn't get really a chance to make any impression at all. Kirsten gillibrand basically said one useful thing – not even useful, just something that went a bit viral when she said that the first thing she would do when she got into the oval office as president was clorox the oval office, but um, she didn't. You know, nothing stood out in terms of policy or anything like like that. Um, jay inslee again only really talked about the environment and, and booker was quite good on climate change in the environment as well, so he kind of took insley's legs away because booker's good on other things too. He was talking about health care and police reform and stuff, and so insley then became a candidate that really only had one policy, that that someone else was also talking about.
53:53 Mark: I guess to a certain extent you think, okay, well, here is the performance of them in diplomatic circumstances, talking about policy, and how do we experience the president anyway? Well, we experience him on TV, you know, and that's what you want. Yeah, I mean, as I've said before, I blame Kennedy for this whole thing – that it becomes about how good you are on Tv and so, to a certain extent, the debates themselves are given that they'll be on for 18 months. They're going to make Tv stars. If you didn't recognize them before, you will by the end of that, because they would have had their own Tv series.
54:48 Jim: Yeah, and Tulsi Gabbard got a significant bump, not just in like a small bump in the polling numbers, but a huge bump in awareness of people looking her up on Google. She was by far the most searched person, partly because she did make an impact and less people already knew about her. She also had, you know, gained the most Twitter followers and things like that. Interestingly she was. She wore a bright white kind of pantsuit, which was – yeah, I mean she did look good in it – um, a bit hairy it was also it was. It was much more tailored than henry's and um, but the interesting thing is her husband, I think, is a video producer and it's one of those things about about videos is the things that draw the eye, as we know as video producers, yeah, are the brightest thing on the screen, the the most in focus, or the thing that moves, and, and tulsi gabbard was the brightest thing on the screen at all times. Basically, so, yeah, yeah, yeah, she, she did, she did draw attention and, um, she, she got definitely a bump. I think there has been some talk in in the more liberal side of things that possibly some of the um, the favorable, considerable searches that she's had and the and the, the internet response has been kind of possibly driven a bit by Russian bots, because the russians have definitely expressed a preference. I don't know, I'm absolutely not saying in any way and some people have said, but I'm not saying that she's she's any kind of right -wing plant or Russian plant or anything like that at all. I don't believe that. But um, but she. She has been – I mean, definitely – sympathetic to assad. She's been sympathetic to Russia. She, she was the, the person who came out saying, uh, after the the damning muller report, she came out saying, well, you know, the report's out now. It exonerates Trump and that's that. We should leave, we should move on. Um, yeah, she is more favorable um to, I think, the, the right, and to to certainly the russians and people like that. So if, if there are going to be um Russian interferences in in this section of the of the election or of the primaries, then it probably is going to be geared more towards her, it seems.
57:20 Mark: So, yeah, yeah, I don't know what that made me think of tony blair and his um seduction of the right -wing press as a way to to get into office. You know, they kind of suddenly got supported by what up till then had supported the Tory party rather than the Labour party. And I think part of his strategy was to tell the press barons and Tory supporters that not much would change. So in that way he was kind of excusing however, many years of thatcher free marketeering and, yeah, not much did change, but but he got labor in, yeah, and we all thought it was great at the time. And then of course, we went to war and and Biden
58:16 Jim: started out before the first debate saying, saying that he's, he said to journalists and and others, you know if, if I get him not very much, it's going to change in kind of everyday life in America. So that's not necessarily a good thing.
58:31 Mark: A lot of people would like us to change, really do want it to change from yeah,
58:35 [Unclear]: yeah, and finally, some things we really don't have time to talk about.
58:40 Jim: Last weekend, America suffered two more mass shootings, in El Paso Texas and Dayton, Ohio. Once again Republicans tried to place the blame anywhere but on guns, with Trump reading disingenuous words from a teleprompter that once again blamed video games, included the phrase “Mental illness and hatred pull the trigger, not the gun” and saw Trump ad lib Toledo when the teleprompter said ‘Texas and Ohio’. The White House barred the press pool from attending his subsequent visits to the affected cities, saying it was about the victims, not a photo op. Of course, because it’s Trump, the White House media team took plenty of photos of a grinning Trump giving his signature thumbs up and made a schmaltzy campaign ad out of the visit. Watching the ad, you can’t even tell that all eight of the victims still being treated in El Paso University Medical Centre refused to meet with Trump.
59:30 Mark: Ohio Sen. Sherrod Brown and Dayton Mayor Nan Whaley were rather complementary about Trump’s visit to shooting victims at a Dayton Hospital on 7th August. At a press conference after Trump and Melania had left Brown said “He was received well by the patients, as you’d expect. They’re hurting.He was comforting. He did the right things and Melania did the right things. And it’s his job in part to comfort people. I’m glad he did it in those hospital rooms.” But these are Democrats and their weasel words are not to be trusted – by 2:32pm the same day Dan Scavino Jr. tweeted in an uncannily Trump way “Very SAD to see Ohio Senator Brown, & Dayton Mayor Nan Whaley – LYING & completely mischaracterizing what took place w/ the President’s visit to Miami Valley Hospital today. They are disgraceful politicians, doing nothing but politicizing a mass shooting, at every turn they can…” an hour and a quarter later Trump added “Their news conference after I left for El Paso was a fraud. It bore no resemblance to what took place with those incredible people that I was so lucky to meet and spend time with.” er he’s denying the good things they said took place wait what.. How fragile must your ego be to pre-prepare and tweet out a rebuttal even when people are nice about you – oh yeah no wait durr!
1:00:55 Jim: Trump just seems determined to kill US agriculture because he can’t admit that trade wars are neither good, nor easy to win. His latest round of tariffs on Chinese consumer goods has caused China to announce they are halting all purchases of US agricultural products and they’ve allowed their currency to drop to its lowest value in over 10 years, leading the Treasury Department to officially designate them as a currency manipulator. This is very bad. According to many economists such as Art Hogan, chief market strategist at National Securities Corporation, exactly how bad it will get is impossible to tell, but the worse it gets, the faster the US will be plunged into a full on recession. And Trump still somehow thinks he’s punishing the Chinese.
1:01:39 Mark: Well, On that subject I’m not one to normally hold with conspiracy theories but when 99% of the USDA USDept of Agriculture’s funds to help bailout farmers affected as a result of the trade tariffs war with China instigated by, let me check, oh the US government end up going to white farmers – 91% of recipients being MALE white farmers I begin to suspect some higher plan at work. Donald Carr, a senior adviser at the Environmental Working Group, told Bloomberg that when bailout funds “continue to overwhelmingly flow to an elite group of the largest farms, wealthy landowners and city residents with no real connection to the day-to-day operations on the land, it’s clear the program is deeply flawed and not delivering aid to those farmers in desperate need.” The USDA said payments have all been made in accordance with our published regulations and existing procedures,” ah well that’s alright then no need to do anything about it – “we were just following orders” anyone?
1:02:43 Jim: Yeah, something like 60 of the bailouts so far have gone to about 10 percent of farmers, and there's supposed to be a cap and on how much individual farmers get. But the the way it works is that multiple individuals who work for the same farm group can all claim the cap up to the level of the cap themselves. So that means that some farms are getting millions of dollars and some farms are getting like 11 dollars,
1:03:15 Mark: and so the ones, the ones that are really in desperate need, the ones that are affected, like the individual farmers – you know, let's face it, non -white farmers are the ones that aren't working in a large consortium, so they will get very little out of the bailout aimed specifically to help those people affected directly by the tariffs.
1:03:36 Jim: It is. It is taxpayer money going to help people who have been hurt by the effects of the tariffs, and the people who are getting the most money are the ones who don't really need the government help. Because they can, they have enough money to weather the storm, whereas the people who are being hit hardest by it, who are losing their livelihood, are the ones who really aren't getting the benefit from it.
1:04:04 Mark: And because the ones that were then, whether the storm will buy up the other farms and be even bigger farms and possibly Trump voters. White male farmers could be.
1:04:18 Jim: If Trump put a bit more thought into his nominations instead of just blurting them out, maybe his pick for Director of National Intelligence, Congressman John Ratcliffe, would have had time to look at his own website and delete the parts of his resume where he’d made stuff up, like his claim that he’d put terrorists in prison despite in fact never having prosecuted a terrorist. Or the claim that he was the prosecutor on US v Holy Land Foundation, one of the nations largest terrorism financing cases, for which he in fact was not even on the prosecution team. When he decided to withdraw from consideration, Trump admitted he had been hasty… no, of course he didn’t. He tweeted: Our great Republican Congressman John Ratcliffe is being treated very unfairly by the LameStream Media. Rather than going through months of slander and libel, I explained to John how miserable it would be for him and his family to deal with these people….Trump’s right, it’s very unfair of the media to report on what people actually do. Shame on them.
1:05:15 Mark: Trump of course is noted for insisting people serving in public office hold the law in high regard, and so it is with former Illinois Governor Rod Blagojevich who continues to serve the remainder of 18 years jail time not least for being caught on tape trying to sell off the appointment to the vacated Senate seat of newly-elected President Barack Obama to the highest bidder. Ah no what am I saying, Rod’s also been on TV – on Celebrity Apprentice season 9 – Trump’s Apprentice!! Trump fired Rod when he couldn’t verify facts about Harry Potter, how times have changed – good ol’ showbiz buddy Trump thinks Rod’s been hard done by, wants to make it up to him and commute his sentence. Yeah great optics Donny great optics, set free a convicted and jailed corrupt politician now, now of all moments! Donny You’re Fired – idiot! Yeah, the.
1:06:10 Jim: The other bit behind this story is that jared kushner – apparently um – has kind of advocated for Trump to commute blagojevich's sentence because blagojevich was – is a Democrat and he thinks jared thinks that Democrats will appreciate this. It's like throwing a bone to Democrats. What he doesn't realize is that Democrats don't like corrupt people. They don't. They don't want blagojevich out just because he used to be a Democrat. No, in general, it doesn't matter whether
1:06:36 Mark: they're on their team or not. They think he should be in prison. Yeah, for doing bad stuff.
1:06:41 Jim: Texas Congressman Will Hurd, the only African American Republican in the House of Representatives, has said he will not be running for reelection in 2020. That makes him the eleventh House Republican, and the sixth just in the last two weeks that have announced they are leaving office next year. Giving up their incumbency reduces the GOPs chances of winning those seats in 2020, but then so does being led by a racist reality TV has-been, so who’s to say how much it really matters. Fans of black Republicans in Congress shouldn’t feel too hard done by, because there’s always the Senate, where you can find Tim Scott and… well, that’s it.
1:07:17 Mark: Ben Carson Secretary of Housing and Urban Development set up for a press conference outside church in Baltimore to appear like he was doing something for the neighborhood Church officials kindly told him to go back to where he came from. Ironic really cos he used to come from round there, working in Baltimore – where he says he was afraid to send kids home because of “rats and an unabated lead problem” and thanked god that he was now in charge at HUD and could do something about it, which he hasn’t apart from roll back Obama-era housing legislation and buying a $31,000 dining room set for his office and $8,000 dishwasher in the office kitchen without notifying congress. Whattaguy whattaguy! What a guy.
1:07:58 Jim: What a guy. So that's all the bad arguments and faulty reasoning. We have time for this episode. You can find the show notes at fallacious Trump .com and if you hear Trump say something stupid and want to ask if it's a fallacy, our contact details are on the contact page and
1:08:11 Mark: if you think we've used a fallacy ourselves, let us know. And if you've had a good time, please give us a review on apple podcast stitcher or wherever you get your podcasts. And you can support the show on our Patreon page at Patreon .com. Slash f Trump, just like our newest patron, miles robinson. Yay, thanks, miles.
1:08:28 Jim: You can also connect with us and other listeners in the the Facebook group at Facebook .com. Slash groups. Slash fallacious Trump.
1:08:34 Mark: All music is by the outburst and was used with permission. So until next time on fallacious Trump, we'll leave the last word to the Donald.
1:08:42 [Outro] That's right. Go home to mommy. Bye, bye, good old showbiz.
1:08:47 Mark: Buddy Trump thinks dan's been hard done by. Wants to make it up to him and commute his sentence. He's done. You mean Rod. Oh yeah, where did that come from? I know, yeah, don't
1:08:59 Jim: do that bit again.
