Definist Fallacy FT#193

ShareBlueskyThreadsFacebookRedditEmail

Show Notes

The Definist Fallacy occurs when someone deliberately redefines a term in a way that’s favorable to their own argument (and is probably a stretch of the real definition)

Trump

We started out by discussing this clip of Trump redefining profit:

Then we talked about this clip of Trump not knowing what temperament means:

And finally we looked at this clip of Trump saying the quiet part out loud:

Mark’s British Politics Corner

Mark talked about these varying definitions of socialism:

Fallacy in the Wild (Sting: George Harrison – What is Life?)

In the Fallacy in the Wild, we looked at this clip from Friends:

Then we discussed this clip from Babylon 5:

And finally, we talked about this clip of Andy Ngo on the Joe Rogan Experience podcast:

Fake News

Here are the statements from this week’s Fake News game:

SpoilerStatement 3 is Fake News. Mark chose number 2

Mark got it wrong this week and is still on 48%!

 

Suing yourself is not a logical fallacy

We talked about the “settlement” in Trump’s lawsuit against the IRS.

 

The stories we really didn’t have time to talk about

  • First off, we have some updates to news stories we covered last episode. The reflecting pool enshittification which was going to cost $1.8 million and take one week is now going to cost $13.1 million, and Trump says it should be finished by July 4, “our target date”, which is more than eight weeks after the project started. Despite previously referring to the contractor as his own “pool guy”, who had worked on his golf club swimming pools, he now claims “I didn’t give out the contract, ‘Interior’ did, to a contractor I did not know, and have never used before.” Maybe this selective amnesia is due to the budget and schedule overruns, or maybe it’s because internal Department of the Interior documents report that bubbles and small holes are appearing in one of the waterproof coatings, and the unevenly applied paint has left the pool mottled in various shades of American Flag Blue. There’s also been concern that Atlantic Industrial Coatings, the non-union firm that was awarded the no-bid contract despite never having worked with the federal government before, may be ignoring the safety of their workers in the rush to get the job finished within seven weeks of the original deadline. Meanwhile the $400 million of taxpayer money we told you Republicans were seeking for Trump’s new ballroom ballooned to a billion dollars, which I can only assume Lindsey Graham announced with his pinkie held up to his mouth. Fortunately, the Senate parliamentarian, Elizabeth McDonough, officially stepped in to cockblock the GOP’s attempt to sneak it in as part of a budget reconciliation package because apparently a führerbunker with a fancy top floor is outside the scope of such a bill. And finally, Kash Patel, keen to prove that the Atlantic made up all that reporting of his drunken shenanigans, has been ordering polygraphs for more than a dozen current and former members of his security detail to find out who leaked the definitely not true stories to Atlantic reporter Sarah Fitzpatrick just before she made them up, which he’ll totally prove in court. Fitzpatrick stands by her reporting, saying that since the article came out, even more people have come forward to corroborate the details. In fact, after he sued her, nevertheless she persisted, publishing a whole new story about Kash’s preferred souvenir that he hands out to people lucky enough to have met him – personalized bottles of Woodford Reserve Kentucky bourbon, engraved with the words “Kash Patel, FBI Director”, and an FBI shield held in the talons of an eagle. Kash has reportedly used DoJ aircraft to haul cases of this narcissism-juice across the globe, handing them out to civilians and staff alike. One bottle was even left behind in an Olympic locker room in Milan, the same trip where his beer-chugging antics reportedly infuriated teetotaler Trump. An  FBI spokeslackey claimed it was just part of a long-standing Bureau tradition, saying “Senior Bureau officials have long exchanged commemorative items in formal gift settings consistent with ethics rules”. However, when a former senior FBI official was asked if any previous director had ever handed out personally branded liquor, he literally burst out laughing. In March, Kash took a case of his bourbon to a Quantico seminar where UFC fighters trained FBI agents in mixed martial arts, which is a weird sentence. When a single bottle went missing, Kash allegedly “lost his mind,” threatening to polygraph and prosecute his own staff over the theft. While regular FBI agents face a strict zero-tolerance policy for alcohol on the job, the Director is using the federal apparatus to protect his stash. Legal counsel for current whistleblowers are now giving agents a bizarre new piece of advice for dealing with the nation’s top law enforcement official: “Run from him.”
  • Trump loves golf – he loves golfers, he loves Arnold Palmer’s weiner! But he only loves golfers that pay him to belong to one of his golf courses – Jeffrey Epstein please stand up! And he loves balls and ballrooms more, so much so the debris from the demolition of the East Wing has been piled up on the nearby 100 year-old public East Potomac Golf Links. Like some huge inside out bunker 30,000 cubic yards of soil and detritus looms over the greens causing golfers to detour around piles of it. An interim report requested by the parks service from a Virginia engineering firm says the soil has tested positive for lead, chromium and other toxic metals, along with PCBs, pesticides, petroleum byproducts and other chemicals that were detected at levels above laboratory reporting limits in soil. The nonprofit DC Preservation League has sued the Trump administration arguing “the Defendants dumped a cocktail of contaminants — and despite indications of the refuse’s contents, they continued dumping it”. Trump’s Interior Department said in an email Tuesday that the soil removed from the White House “was tested multiple times, by multiple parties, and this project passed all standards set by law.” (*scoffs*) and that it is “committed to continuing the relationships we have built with the local golf communities to ensure these courses are safe, beautiful, open, affordable, enjoyable, accessible, and world-class for people living in and visiting the greatest capital city in the world.” Oddly this commitment includes the Trump administration’s plans to renovate the 105-year-old course to make it a professional-level course, including the proposed felling of a dozen or so trees. Yeah nothing says beautiful, enjoyable and accessible like dumping your shit in the neighbour’s garden and then declaring you’ll close it, chop everything down and reopen it as a members-only facility as a way to solve the problem. Will membership include a hazmat suit, geiger counter and face mask? – yeah sure in Trump branded colours of course!
  • Fun fact, the US government still technically has an Office of Government Ethics. I’m guessing it’s run by three monkeys with their hands glued to different parts of their heads. Last week, they released Trump’s latest financial disclosure form, and I’m starting to think this guy might not be playing by the rules. In November, Trump launched the “Genesis Mission,” a Department of Energy initiative designed to use US supercomputers to harness AI for scientific research, and casually slash regulations for his billionaire tech backers along the way. On December 18th, Energy Secretary Chris Wright announced tech startup CoreWeave had joined the programme, and their stock shot up by almost 20%. During the week before the announcement, buried deep inside the 113-page financial disclosures, are two purchases, by Trump, of CoreWeave stock, each worth between a quarter and half a million dollars. We don’t know exactly how much, because disclosure rules only require broad ranges rather than dollar amounts. What we do know is that when he sold his CoreWeave stock the very next fucking day after the announcement, that transaction was in the $1 to 5 million range. Now you may think that sounds like the kind of felony insider trading that usually carries up to 20 years in prison, but actually, it must have just been a lucky guess, as according to a spokesperson for the Trump Organisation, “President Trump’s investment holdings are maintained exclusively through fully discretionary accounts independently managed by third-party financial institutions with sole and exclusive authority over all investment decisions. Trades are executed and portfolios are balanced through automated investment processes and systems administered by those institutions.” But we know that wasn’t true for Thermo Fisher Scientific, a medical supply company. On March 11, Trump toured their facility in Ohio, dragging the executives onto the stage to talk about what an “incredible company” it was, and begged Big Pharma to give them contract work. He didn’t mention that the exact same day, he had personally bought between $15 and $50,000 of Thermo Fisher stock, to add to the $66 to 165,000 worth he’d already bought in the weeks leading up to his visit. We know this wasn’t an automated trade by a clairvoyant investment system because the forms explicitly marked these transactions as “UNSOLICITED.” For anyone who doesn’t speak Wall Street, that means the trade wasn’t recommended by a broker. The client demanded it themselves. That same day, Immediately after leaving Thermo Fisher, Trump flew to Kentucky and gave a speech drooling over Apple, calling them a great company, and announcing that they would be spending hundreds of billions of dollars on new plants in the US. Right on cue, the disclosures show that on that exact day, Trump made another unsolicited purchase of between a quarter and half a million dollars in Apple stock, bringing his total so far that month to between $2 and 7.2 million. He did it again with Micron, buying up to $100,000 in unsolicited stock right before calling into Fox News to declare them “one of the hottest companies.” He did it with Dell, buying at least a million unsolicited bucks in shares before literally telling a crowd in Georgia to “go out and buy a Dell computer.” He even managed to buy up to a million dollars in Nvidia stock precisely a week before his own Commerce Department magically approved chip sales to China. But don’t worry, those three ethics monkeys are on the case and Trump has already faced swift, brutal consequences related to these trades. By law, he was required to report all trades within 45 days, and he missed that window frequently, so they fined him $200.
  • Airwars, a civilian harm monitor, estimated that US drone and air strikes alone killed at least 22,000 civilians – and perhaps as many as 48,000 – in the 20 years after the 9/11 terrorist attacks in 2001, perhaps that’s why Hegseth was clear to say that no nation in history had taken more precautions than the US to avoid civilian deaths and was full of praise for the Pentagon’s civilian harm mitigation and response (CHMR) program, designed to handle training and procedures critical in limiting civilian harm in theaters of war. It was created by Lloyd Austin, then defense secretary, in January 2022, under Joe Biden, following years of deadly US bombing campaigns in Yemen, Iraq, Syria and Afghanistan. No no of course Hogsbreath wasn’t full of praise – he blamed Iranians for hiding missile launchers in civilian areas when asked why the US had bombed and killed 175 people, a majority of them children, at an all-girls school in Minab. The bombing took place the same month that Hegseth’s Pentagon had quietly dismantled that very program which it is legally required to operate in order to prevent and respond to civilian deaths in US military operations, according to its internal watchdog. While the program has not been officially canceled, the inspector general’s report said that funding had ended for a data management platform; committee meetings had halted; and many dedicated personnel had been lost or reassigned. The report, published on 13 May, points to an inflection point in February, when two senior officials – the acting under-secretary of war for policy, Elbridge Colby, and the secretary of the army, Dan Driscoll – separately proposed to Hegseth the program be cut or eliminated. One proposal recommended scrapping its action plan and its underpinning departmental instruction entirely. Then, without waiting for a response, the military began acting as if the cuts had already been approved. Later that month, the US launched strikes on Iran. The US strike on the school in Minab, occurred on 28 February – around the same time as the inspector general found that CHMR’s operations had ground to a halt. Madison Hunke, US program manager at the Center for Civilians in Conflict, said: If Iran is “any indication of the Department’s current approach to civilian harm after gutting 90% of it’s CHMR workforce, it’s hard to imagine what future US operations might look like if these programs are further degraded.” The Trump administration cut peace time funding to foreign aid affecting millions of people so why would they care about preventing deaths during war? Nobel Prize anyone?
  • Some hypothetical questions have dogged philosophers for decades, or even centuries. If a tree falls in the forest, does it make a sound? Can we ever truly know if we’re living in a simulation? The whole Ship of Theseus thing. But earlier this month, YouGov asked what may be the greatest hypothetical question of all time: Could you beat Donald Trump in a fight? For Democrats, of course, this is a fucking easy question, He’s an obese nearly-80-year-old and he’s actively decomposing. 75% of Democrats questioned said they could beat Trump. 19% said not sure, and 5% said Trump would win – I presume that 5% are currently already in hospice care. There was no box to tick to confirm that you’d bloody love to have a go, but that would have been 100%. But for Republicans, it’s a different story. MAGA folk are genetically unable to describe themselves without using the word Alpha, but if they even entertain the possibility that Trump is less physically fit than Ivan Drago, their entire worldview collapses. Sure enough, they are such monumental cucks that only 33% of Republican voting Americans are prepared to claim they could defeat Trump in a fight, and 39% reckon the wheezing lump of trans fats in a bad suit would win. The event that triggered this amazing survey was the Oval Office based signing of a proclamation to revive the Presidential Physical Fitness Award, during which Trump did a totally normal, well-adjusted thing. He turned to one of the kids who’d been brought in for a photo op and asked him “Do you think you could take me in a fight?” Naturally, YouGov looked at this and thought, “This requires a scientific sample size.” So they also asked those same 2,609 Americans who they thought would win in a brawl between Trump and a hypothetical eight-year-old boy. Again, Democrats are skeptical of Trump’s combat skills, and short of a scenario involving a golf club and a highly strategic golf cart getaway, only 26% put their money down on Trump, while 54% say the kid would win, then go back to watching Bluey. And before you say eight is too old for that show, my Mum is 86 today, and she fucking loves Bluey. To put that in perspective, Democrats have way more confidence in a literal eight-year-old than Republicans have in their own grown-adult selves. 72% of those Republicans, by the way, think Trump would crush the eight-year-old who, let’s face it, would be weakened by the stench before he got too close, but 6% are woke enough to admit that the third-grader, or presumably a light breeze, would be enough to topple the melting senior citizen. 
  • On Mother’s Day the White House launched a new website, Moms.gov. On first glance that looks like Mumsnet yeah? A forum for discussing and exchanging views relating to the difficulties in navigating motherhood and the working and political environments, a supportive environment cognisant of and dedicated to, the rights and equalities of women and mothers.Yeah you’re not gonna get that from an administration where at a press conference launching the site Dr. Mehmet Oz warned that “One in three Americans are ‘under-babied,’” and where Trump declared himself the “father of fertility.” At the launch Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. promoted Moms.gov as “one-stop shopping for IVF, for prenatal care, for postnatal care, for nutrition, for baby formula, and of course, for TrumpRx.” It would be more accurate, however, to say that the website is aimed at asserting Trump’s “pro mom” bona fides while preying on vulnerable women with thinly veiled propaganda of an anti-abortion, anti-vaccine, and anti-feminist bent. On pregnancy support for instance the website says, sympathetically, that “navigating pregnancy can feel overwhelming, but you don’t have to do it alone.” Moms.gov then offers a link to “Find Pregnancy Centers Near You,”  the linked website, Option Line, which you’re not told, is operated by the Christian anti-abortion organization Heartbeat International. It directs women away from clinics like Planned Parenthood and toward faith-based crisis pregnancy centers, where they will be bombarded with misinformation and love-bombed with support. The word “abortion” never appears on the Moms.gov homepage, but the message is anti-abortion all the same. As a whole, Moms.gov carries a strong anti-feminist undercurrent. In March, the Trump-allied Heritage Foundation released a new document titled “Saving America by Saving the Family.” Heritage, which previously spearheaded Project 2025, blamed falling fertility rates not only on “the proliferation of birth control,” but also on “more prospects for women to receive higher education and work outside the home, the delayed financial independence of young adults, and the government’s role in old-age security.” Furthermore the only mention of working motherhood on the homepage links to a warning that “workplace exposures, conditions, and tasks can affect workers’ sexual and reproductive health.” With the Trumpfather of fertility the “tradwife” life is the only safe choice for babies and moms. As with all of the MAHA rhetoric voiced by metal tool-shed thrown into a concrete mixer RFK Jr the intent is to flood the search engines and distract overworked underinformed women with Government sanctioned propaganda designed to further their aim of disenfranchising anyone but rich, white, christian men, but then DangerousMysoginistsinPower.gov doesn’t have quite the same Maga needs Moms feel I guess.
  • Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy has decided that the best way to handle a national energy crisis and a chaotic, disaster-prone aviation sector is to return to his true passion: being an MTV reality television star. In a move that perfectly represents the crossover between the current federal cabinet and 90’s trash TV, Duffy dropped a trailer for The Great American Road Trip. It’s a five-part YouTube series following him, his wife, and their nine children as they trek across the country on what he calls a “civic experience” to celebrate America’s upcoming 250th birthday. The trailer features the family snowmobiling, hitting up water slides, and hanging out with a Benjamin Franklin reenactor, Kid Rock, and Trump himself, but it’s OK, because Duffy was working from the road, which in this case means he occasionally glanced at an air-traffic control tower as they sped past. The backdrop to this wholesome family content is that the administration’s war in Iran has sent gas prices skyrocketing to their highest levels in nearly four years. While everyday Americans are having panic attacks at the pump, the nation’s Transportation Secretary is cheerfully telling them to “gas up the car!” Former Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg immediately took to Twitter to call the project “brutally out of touch,” prompting Duffy to counter that the “radical, miserable left” simply hates patriotism and doesn’t want people to learn civics. But some people who already know about civics have been asking questions about how this boondoggle was funded. Duffy and his spokespeople have repeatedly insisted that “zero taxpayer dollars” were used, because the producers formed a brand-new nonprofit called The Great American Road Trip Inc.—an organization whose corporate sponsor list is made up entirely of companies currently under the direct regulatory thumb of Sean Duffy. Toyota, Boeing, and United Airlines – firms that rely on the Department of Transportation for safety approvals, oversight, and a lack of crippling fines – generously footed the bill for the Secretary’s gas, car rentals, lodging, and activities. The trailer even features prominent, unmissable product placement for Toyota, which I’m sure American automakers are super happy about. Donald Sherman, president of Citizens for Ethics and Responsibility in Washington, pointed out that if this is an official work project, “then taxpayer funds should be paying for it, and if it’s a vacation or some kind of personal trip, then certainly industry should not be paying for it.” Being Transport Secretary probably is much more difficult and boring than being on reality TV, so if that means turning the Department of Transportation into a rolling, tax-exempt commercial for the companies you’re supposed to be regulating, so be it.
  • Well Labour received a whipping at the local election polls, acting as a kind of mid-term assessment of how the country thinks the government is doing, the local elections half way through a national administration’s term in office are really about who people want to be in charge of their local councils, there is no direct effect on who is in power. This has led to buyers remorse when fed up racists vote for reform and then find out that their candidate said things about melting down Nigerians to fill in potholes and had to stand down and force another election. Rinse and repeat across the country as newly-elected and sorely underqualified councillors resigned. Like all disappointed footballers, calls are being made within the team to replace the coach after this one-sided scoresheet event. And one Labour MP, of whom no-one had heard, Catherine West said she’d launch a leadership campaign unless Starmer bucked his ideas up. She didn’t, and really neither did he. Instead, to show he was in touch with the people’s present day concerns in post-brexit post-covid, post-Reform Britain Starmer drafted in support from Gordon Brown and Harriet Harman who were last in office three decades ago. Victim of Bloatyhead from the Theme Hospital Game Wes Streeting resigned as Health Minister and has yet to launch a leadership contest, a Labour MP stepped down to enable left-wing man-of-the-people Andy Burnham to be able to stand for election as an MP and thus challenge for the leadership, both Wes and Keir have since announced a full-blown return to the EU as something they’d do which is directly stolen from Andy Burnham’s recent rhetoric and designed to thwart his chances, as is his standing in a seat that voted 60% Leave in the Brexit Referendum and has just elected a Reform Council. As always – never ones to waste a good crisis the Labour Party start falling on each other with knives out.

You can now buy Jim’s book, 2000 Mules and One Big Lie: A Stubborn Conspiracy Theory, and you can buy all our t-shirts, mugs, hats and more at our TeePublic Store, including this week’s fallacy:

That’s almost all for this week, but here’s our AI-aided transcript, which is quite accurate, but not totally:

Definist Fallacy – FT#193 Transcript

Read the full transcript

00:23 Jim: Hello and welcome to Fallacious Trump, the podcast where we use the insane ramblings of the supreme misleader to explain logical fallacies. I'm your host, Jim.

00:31 Mark: And I'm your other host, Mark. A logical fallacy is an error in reasoning that results in bad or invalid arguments, and the logical fallacy we're looking at this week is the definist fallacy, also known as the persuasive definition fallacy. Supreme misleader, nice, just just, yeah.

00:48 Jim: Yeah, I think that was john stewart who originally came up with that one on the daily show, and I still good, yeah, shamelessly so. Yeah, the definist fallacy, or definist fallacy – I'm not sure exactly how it's pronounced because it's not really a word, it's um is. It's coined specifically for this by philosophy types? Yeah, and what this is is when people redefine a term to make it more supportive of their argument, and that may be stretching the definition, the real definition of the term quite dramatically, right, or it may just be defining it in the kind of most favorable term to to their point and ignoring other definitions that aren't as helpful to them, right, yeah? So for our first example, yeah, Trump recently came back from china where he, oh, yeah, handed she his balls on a platter and completely caved to absolutely everything. Yeah, and in 2025 he did similar kinds of stuff. Yeah, and other parts of Asia, and on the plane on the way back from his Asia trip he was asked a question.

01:57 Clip: Trump redefining profit

— So the trip was fantastic. We took in over $3 trillion, really, in profit, if you want to define it that way.

02:06 Jim: Yeah, you can't define it that way if you're using the normal definition of profit. Or, for that matter, the normal definition of $3 trillion, because he visited on this trip. Uh, he visited qatar, Japan and South Korea. Right, and this is his usual thing of saying how much um other countries are investing foreign investment in the U? .s? Yeah, he reckons, by this point he's up to like 20 trillion dollars, which is utter bullshit. The white house's own website, I think at this point, their claim on there is up to about 11, 12 million a trillion. Mother right, but that's also not true. And on the, the white house's website about this trip and the countries that he visited there at the time, that three trillion that he claims is made up of 1, .2 trillion from qatar, 1 trillion from Japan and 450 billion from South Korea. So that's 2, .65 trillion, not over three. Right, and it's still not true. Right, because the qatar one – the white house had previously announced that Trump's agreement with qatar is to generate 1, .2 trillion in Economic exchange between the us and qatar. Not right for qatar to invest 1, .2 trillion in the us? Right, which makes sense, because in 2024, qatar's Gdp was 218 billion dollars, so that that would be six years worth of their entire economy.

03:36 Mark: Right, right, so, and does the exchange in Economic exchanges that include America buying things, spending money in? Absolutely, it does, right, yeah, yeah, yeah.

03:48 Jim: It involves America buying stuff from qatar and qatar buying stuff from America and all together usual kind of trade. Won't still, because he's still lying. But that would add up to 1, .2 trillion, right right, Which is not the US making a profit. The one trillion from Japan, the actual pledge from Japan was 550 billion. And Japan insists that this amount is overwhelmingly made up of loans and loan guarantees, not equity investment. So like a few percent of it was equity invested in the US, whereas the rest of it is like Like yeah, if you sign this thing and agree to buy stuff from us, then we will Act as a guarantor on loans that you need to take out as a country from other countries. Which again, not profit. It's a weird definition of profit. If you want to define it that way. That's not how that works.

04:41 Mark: Well, it's a bit like, it's the same, it's the equivalent of his, as the saying goes. When he says that. You know, when he just makes up a saying, that isn't a saying, and by calling it a saying doesn't make it a saying. And it just leaves you confused. So calling it a profit doesn't make it a profit. And the remainder of

04:59 Jim: the over $3 trillion? The $450 billion from South Korea, that's a $350 billion pledge from South Korea. Which would be equivalent to about a fifth of the country's GDP. So if that was indeed what the South Koreans promised, that's been criticised within the country as over-ambitious. And it's also like there are tensions between the US and South Korea. As there have been for years, because, partly because of Trump's quite chummy relationship with north Korea, yeah, and, and so those agreements that they have are very much in limbo and not kind of guaranteed to happen. Right, the additional 100 billion, because it was not 450 but 350, right, it's been speculated that that is about South korea's promise to increase its U .s energy purchases to 100 billion dollars, but that's not another 100 billion. They've increased what they were already buying, which was like 75 – 80 billion, to 100, right, but so the white house website has just gone. That's the same. It's a yeah, yeah, that's also for an investment. Yeah, so it's a lot less than three trillion.

06:12 Mark: Yeah, none of it's, none of it's, none of it's profit. Yes, even if you define, find it the way that he's defining it – I .e not in terms of what profit actually means – it's still a lie. It's also fracturally wrong, but that that kind of the pledge, counting a pledge as as income, much less profit, you know, as investment profit. That's a bit like when people pledge stuff at the end of a telethon. So, yes, we've got three million dollars pledged in, but it only works if, If you then say, OK, you need to give us the money that you pledged to give us. Just pledging, it doesn't mean the money is exchanged. And I think, wasn't there somebody in the Trump organization who pledged money and then didn't pay it?

07:06 Jim: That's Trump in every interaction he has with a person who he offers money to. That's true. But, yeah, certainly they pledged money to various charities that didn't end up pulling through.

07:18 Mark: Yes, in order to be seen to be, oh, yes, that's right. Didn't we look at something and one of them said, I'm a great supporter of charity. I pledged this amount of money to these many charities. And we were, yeah, keen to look up whether they actually received that. And no, they didn't. So, yeah, so by the – you know, by that definition of donation – if that's how you wanted to find it – then they are big donors, yeah.

07:44 Jim: So our second example for Trump is, uh, when he was on hugh hewitt's, I think, Radio show and hewitt had recently made a statement that he thought that Trump didn't have the right temperament to be president, and so they had a bit of a disagreement about that, and and And Hugh Hewitt kind of clarified what he meant by that, which was simply that no other person had ever had the same kind of temperament as Trump has. And therefore, it was just a completely new type of temperament that would be fine as president. But but Trump went in a slightly different direction on defining temperament.

08:25 Clip: Trump not knowing what temperament means

— I know what to do. I know how to get the debt paid off. I mean, I know things that other people won't have a clue and you need energy. You know, it's interesting. Sometimes the word temperament, it's an interesting word to really define, but part of that word is energy. And I see some of the people and I have great respect for a number of the people that we're talking about – the candidates. Let's call them the candidates, but I have a lot of respect for some of them and I really get to like a few of them. But I must tell you, the word energy is very important. We need great energy. And some of those people, let's just use some, some of those people do not have energy.

09:02 Jim: So energy is not a part of the definition of temperament by any dictionary definition.

09:10 Mark: I don't even share a Latin root or anything.

09:14 [Unclear]: No, not at all. I was looking at it.

09:16 Jim: I think basically the problem here is Trump doesn't actually know what temperament is. I think that's the issue is when, when Hugh Hewitt said that he thought you know. Basically his question was: do you think, am I right, do you think that your temperament would be unprecedented in the oval office? Right, and he was like, let's call it energy,

09:39 Mark: because I could talk about that is temperament, is your emotional response to stuff?

09:45 Jim: How, how you you respond to situations? Yeah, whether you're likely to be aggressive or, you know, upset or calm or that kind of thing, or people, mind you. Yeah, yeah, a ridiculously thin -skinned narcissist with an explosive personality. Yeah, so no interest in anyone other than himself?

10:03 [Unclear]: Yes, yes, yeah, so that kind of.

10:05 Jim: So that's not a good temperament for a president and somewhat unprecedented in the white house. Yes, and it has nothing to do with energy. And also, if it did have anything to do with energy, I mean, to be fair, this was several years before he was actively falling asleep in basically every meeting on camera in the Oval Office. But still, his claim that he had much more energy than all of the other candidates was probably not quite accurate either.

10:30 Mark: Mid-through the thing, he's saying, yeah, let's call them candidates. So he's sort of shoving in an alternative.

10:36 Jim: Kind of redefining candidates.

10:38 Mark: Yeah, yeah, and also some. He says, yeah, let's call it some. Yeah, he just he does that. And then he says: I know a lot of things, you know things that you would, you know, wouldn't even have a clue about. Yeah, the others don't know.

10:53 Jim: The others don't know how to fix the things.

10:55 Mark: No, that he's, that he isn't fixing, all of which goes to prove absolutely the wrong temperament.

11:01 Jim: Yeah, so our final example from Trump: once he did become the candidate – and he was up against other parties – in fact, this was about a month after kamala had become the candidate, after Joe had withdrawn from the race in 2024. Yeah, uh, he was asked about nikki haley and whether she would go on the campaign trail with him, because she had previously been his kind of opponent.

11:25 Clip: Trump saying the quiet part out loud

— Right, nikki haley told our brett baird that Republicans need to stop whining about kamala harris. Focus on courting those independents, those suburban women, the moderates out there. What do you think of that strategy, and would you consider having Nikki Haley on the campaign trail with you?

— Sure, I think that we've done very well. I think that we're hitting a nerve. I think this is a different kind of a race. All we have to do is define our opponent as being a communist or a socialist or somebody that's going to destroy our country. You know, I I fought Nikki very hard. I beat her in her own state by legendary numbers.

12:01 Jim: So I wanted to give a little bit of extra stuff before and after that quote, because it sounds like the exact kind of thing that someone might take out of context. To have an actual soundbite where Trump is saying: all we have to do is define our opponent as a communist or a Marxist or someone who's going to destroy the country. Sounds like something, there's a way you could maybe justify saying that in a different context. But I wanted it to be very, very clear that that was his point. That was what he was saying. It wasn't something that I'd removed the context from. Oh, okay, yeah, yeah, because, yeah, that's his saying. It's Leo, we've got an easy fight to win. All we need to do is is deceptively define our opponents. Basically, wow – is define them as communists who are going to destroy the country, which is amazing. I didn't – I hadn't heard at the time that he'd said this, and I'm surprised he said it out loud because, yeah, that's exactly, obviously what Well, that's their game plan. Is define your opponents as something that everyone hates.

13:05 Mark: And then they haven't got to bother doing anything. Well, then he'll come in and say, oh, come in and solve it. Or their policies or anything like that. We'll just define them as that. Wow, that's a bit like when Lee Anderson let slip something or other before he joined reform about oh yeah. Well, last time we had Corbyn and socialism and this time we haven't, so all we're going to have to do is play the racist card. Yeah, it was the culture wars thing. Yeah, that's all we've got left, so we'll do that. It feels like the curtain's gone back and we've had a glimpse at the reality and there's Trump saying that and you're thinking: did he really say that? What was that? No, no, that was it.

[Sting: Mark's British Politics Corner] And now is the time, I think, for Mark's British Politics Corner.

Mark: Well, speaking of communists, I thought. Being an inveterate leftist, I thought I'd have a look at how politicians use and abuse the definition of socialism and being a socialist over here. In particular, the Labour party. Here's Jeremy Corbyn speaking at the oxford union in December 2022, so three years after he was ousted as leader, and here he is passionately defining socialism. Socialism is surely about the kind of society you want to live in. Do you want to live in a society where there is universal health care, where there is a protection against a total destitution and poverty and every child gets to go to school? Those people opposite that spoke will have you believe that, somehow or other, there's something normal and natural in living in a society whereas the dog eats dog, the poorest go to the go to hell and the richest do. Well, there isn't.

14:48 [Unclear]: There isn't at all.

14:50 Mark: So there's Corbyn pretty much defining what socialism on the Labour left is and how it fires him up, and, of course, he was ousted as leader after the defeat in 2019, partly because Boris and the right -wing media said: well, these are people that could destroy your country because they're communists and socialists. And then Starmer was elected as leader and, after ousting John McDonnell and Jeremy Corbyn from the Labour Party, Starmer declared that the party is now unrecognizable from the party of 2019. I did that for a reason: because we got rejected as bad, badly – as we did in 2019. But he also said what Jeremy Corbyn and John McDonnell have brought to our country in the last few years is making us more comfortable with a radical vision. So here's our favourite representative of workers' interests, Mick Lynch, former General Secretary of the Rail and Maritime Workers' Union, defining socialism for Starmer as the new leader of the Labour Party's radical vision in 2023.

15:52 Clip: Definitions of socialism

— He should be saying something about workers' rights. He should be saying stuff about funding the NHS national care service, looking after people who are struggling in the Housing market, council houses for the masses, controlling rents, addressing all sorts of stuff about what's going to happen in the imbalance in our society. He's not saying any of that. He won't dare mention the word socialism. I want to hear that word mentioned frequently and I want to see a redistribution of wealth in our society that's

16:20 Mark: not dissimilar to um corbyn's stance on what socialism is. So So socialists are not backwards in coming forward, about talking about what socialism is and listing all of those things. So this is what socialism means to me and all that. And it's about redistributing the wealth, the kind of rhetoric that Zach Polanski was using in the Green Party. And then he was accused of stealing it from Labour. But they don't do that. They don't talk about in terms of the, the big lynch just um spelled out, and in fact, in may 2024, uh, it appears Starmer had listened to lynch's words and was possibly a bit worried about the left wing of labor voters in the upcoming general election. That was happening at the end of that year, and he said he was a socialist, as did, uh, shadow chancellor rachel reeves.

17:18 Clip: Definitions of socialism

— We're kind of – I would describe myself as a socialist. I'd describe myself as a progressive. I'd describe myself as somebody who always puts the country first and party second.

— I've always called myself a social democrat. And what I mean by that is that I believe that children, from whatever background they come from, should get an equal start in life to the opportunities that our country offers. I believe in strong public services to support people all through their lives, from the cradle to the grave. And I believe that work should always pay and offer security to people. So that's how I would describe myself.

17:57 Mark: There's Starmer saying that his socialism, yes, I always call myself a progressive socialist. His definition is putting country before party. And part of Reeves' definition of her. What does she call herself? Social Democrat is making work, pay to offer security, both of which you could probably read in a Cameron One Nation Tory manifesto. Country Before Party.

18:23 Jim: They're not typically contained within the definition of social democrats, do they?

18:29 Mark: And similarly Wes Streeting. More of him later. One of Labour's most prominent centrists also describes himself as a democratic socialist, defining that as being a mainstream European social Democrat. Which is not the same thing. Not least because it's very difficult to define what social democrats are in Europe as well. Perhaps he's just going for the mainstream bit. Yeah, so this is all pretty much on the same day. Shadow Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds weighed in, which somewhat troubled his interviewer Emma Barnett on Radio 4's Today programme.

19:07 Clip: Definitions of socialism

— Yes, I would describe myself as a Christian socialist.

— Some may be concerned by what you mean, saying you're a socialist. Sakeer Starmer said he was also a socialist yesterday. How is that different to Jeremy Corbyn being a socialist?

— Well, look, that feels a bit sort of academic as a debate, I think.

— You may say it's an academic point, but there are a high number of people around your table – the shadow cabinet table – who were also around that same table with Jeremy Corbyn. And Jeremy Corbyn said he was a socialist. And now Sir Keir Starmer yesterday said at the beginning of this general election campaign, he too is a socialist. And our listeners this morning are hearing that the shadow business secretary is a socialist. They may not have any issue with that. They just want to understand what is the difference between those two.

— No, look, they will want to know how people describe their own Politics, the values that they have got, but they'll also want to know what they want to do. That's what people will judge any politician on.

20:01 Mark: So it kind of sidesteps is saying, well, that's a bit of an academic distinction. You know, you both call yourself socialists. That would be an ecumenical matter. Yes, yeah, but if they're both socialists, why is caught? Why was Corbyn thrown out of the party and why was john mcdonald thrown? Thrown out of the party? Yeah, and why was it thrown out of the party?

20:23 Jim: Yeah, I'm more troubled by Christian socialist.

20:27 Mark: Yes, yes, well, he has a long history of talking: yes, exactly, that's kind of it's, it's a way of using the word socialist in in a way that isn't. It doesn't mean socialist, I think. So you can call yourself yeah. Does that mean that? Then that brooks no, no, dissent. If you say I'm a Christian socialist, that leaves. You can't touch that because you're it very much.

20:54 Jim: Yeah, it very much. Feels like he's trying to say I'm a socialist, but not one of the bad ones.

20:58 Mark: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. So, yes, so, but so he's left it up to how politicians describe their own Politics and the values. They've got to be what people judge politicians on. So let's hear from some people judging politicians. When they were interviewed on Politics, Joe judging Starmer and Labour Party on those values and calling themselves socialists.

21:21 Clip: Definitions of socialism

— What is that? Did he define it? No.

— Bit of a liar, isn't he, really?

— He's not actually telling, he's not actually saying who he is, because I've read Marx. So I know what it is. And a lot of people say they know what socialism is. I haven't got a bloody clue. I would say, yeah, he's definitely a socialist. He's clearly someone who cares about public services and cares about workers.

— Generally the Labour Party, are a bit too socialistic in a way, I guess, for me at the moment, making everyone being equal when you know in principle it's a good idea, but in actual fact it's not possible, I would say, at the moment.

— It's just like, how are you self-identifying as a progressive socialist and then going back and U-turning and all these things?

— It's got to be centre-middle ground, like it were with Blair and Brown. They're not left-wing, they don't work.

— Keir Starmer, like, is a bit of a centrist. Can I swear? Bit of a centrist wanker.

22:19 Mark: There you go. I love that the way the guy that has red marks says, yeah, people that think they're socialists, they haven't got a clue, really. And then it cuts to somebody who says, oh, yeah, he's definitely a socialist. And then that woman who says, yeah, they're a bit too socialistic. All this people being equal stuff. It's all very well in principle. Yeah, what is that?

22:42 Jim: I've never really understood that. Uh, that thing of I'd like, I think I get it. I get when people say it's lovely to think like that, but yeah, in practice it doesn't work because people take power for themselves and all that kind of stuff. I understand that angle, but she was going like, yeah, it's not possible. Yeah, yeah, well, maybe if we tried. Yeah, yeah, well, if anyone tried at all.

23:07 Mark: That was corbin's point at the beginning when he said: people think, swallow this narrative – that it's a natural state of Affairs that the rich get richer and the poor get poorer. You know on the back so that. But it isn't natural at all at all. And, incidentally, Marx defines socialism as a society characterized by the common ownership of the means of production, where production is organized to meet Human needs rather than for profit. However you define profit, ultimately leading to a classless and stateless society. He emphasizes that socialism aims to overcome alienation and promote individual freedom and autonomy. So it's not mindless. We're gonna.

23:45 Jim: We're gonna talk about statelessness a bit more later.

23:48 Mark: Ah, there we go. Yep, and finally, in october 2025, the Tories began slinging a socialist, socialist slur in the unlikeliest direction. Here's Shadow Housing Secretary James Cleverley speaking at an event at the Institute of Economic Affairs. That's the think tank that advised Liz Truss.

24:07 Clip: Definitions of socialism

— The second that he thinks there are more votes to be had in disillusioned blue -collar workers who want state subsidies to state and outs. His patriot Reaganite instincts desert him. Nigel Farage is not a racist, but he is a socialist. What?

24:30 Mark: And, in a similar vein, Shadow Education Secretary Laura Trott told the BBC's World at One that Reform UK is a socialist party further to the left than Jeremy Corbyn. So we've gone all the way around. How the fuck are they figuring that? I know. Well, I think it was, you know. As soon as he sees the fact that disillusioned blue -collar workers who are looking for state subsidies and state handouts did he call them? As soon as he sees those as a vote, catching, he'll appeal to them. You won't find me talking about state subsidies. That's just calling him a craven vote grabber, not a socialist. Well, that's kind of, but he's at the Institute of Economic Affairs, so you can't talk about state subsidies and state handouts, because that's just socialism. Further to the left than Jeremy Corbyn. Yeah, so I'm not really any clearer on what socialism is, but I think I'm clearer on people defining it to meet their own ends.

25:44 [Sting: Fallacy in the Wild (What Is Life)]

26:53 Mark: George Harrison there asking the defining question: what is life?

26:59 Jim: So in the fallacy in the wild, we like to talk about the fallacy of the week from a non -political perspective, and our first example this week, as in all the best weeks, comes from friends, yay, and this is an episode where chandler and Monica have have got together. They got together in london and, uh, this is before they've kind of formalized their relationship. Chandler hears that a male nurse has asked Monica out and doesn't want to seem jealous and clingy, uh, so tells her that it's. It's fine if she wants to go out with him, because they're just goofing around. It's, you know, it's not anything serious. Which she understandably takes poorly. And so later on, he says this.

27:40 Clip: Friends

— So are you really going to go out with that nurse man?

— Well, you and I are just goofing around. I thought, why not just goof around with him?

— You know, I don't know if you've ever looked up the term goofing around in the dictionary. Well, I have. And the technical definition is two friends who care a lot about each other and have amazing sex and just want to spend more time together. You know, but if you have this newfangled dictionary that gets you mad at me, then we have to you. You know, get you my original dictionary.

28:27 Jim: Yeah, so he redefines the term that he ill-advisedly used earlier to make it a better argument for him.

28:35 Mark: Knowing full well that she will remember absolutely everything he's said and everything he's done, yeah, because he's Monica. We know that.

28:48 Jim: He's saying his best. He's not good at relationships.

28:50 Mark: Yeah, but it's a newfangled dictionary. Well, if you've got the newfangled one.

28:56 Jim: So, our second example comes from Babylon 5. Second episode in a row that we've used an example from Babylon 5. That usually happens when I'm binging a show. Are you? But in this case, it just happens. I think the last time was the first Babylon 5 example we've used. And it just happened that this was also another good one from that show. So this was an episode where the space station gets a new political advisor assigned by EarthGov, which by this point is becoming a totalitarian dictatorship under President Clark. Right, under President Trump. He sent this person to Babylon 5 to help them to also think in the same way. So she has dinner with Sheridan and tries to explain this to her.

29:45 Clip: Babylon 5

— How are things here on the station?

— Fine.

— Fine.

— Status quo. We have had some problems with the lurkers, but nothing…

— Lurkers?

— It's our version of the homeless. In many ways, we have the same problem Earth does.

— Earth doesn't have homeless.

— Excuse me?

— We don't have the problem. Yes, there are some displaced people here and there. But they've chosen to be in that position. They're either lazy or they're criminal or they're mentally unstable.

— They can't get a job.

— EarthGov has promised a job to anyone that wants one. So, if someone doesn't have a job, they must not want one.

— Poverty?

— It's the same.

— Crime?

— Yes, there is some, but it's all caused by the mentally unstable. And we've just instituted correctional centers to filter them out at an early age.

— Prejudice?

— No, we're just one happy planet. It. Well, all right, there's the marzies, but that won't change until they stop fighting the Earth rule.

— And when exactly did all this happen?

— When we rewrote the dictionary. Captain, you're a good man, you're a fine soldier, a leader. You understand that sometimes, before you can deal with the problem, you have to redefine it.

— You can't deal with the problems by pretending they don't exist.

— There's no need to embarrass our leaders by pointing out the flaws in our society that they're aware of and dealing with in their own way.

31:23 Jim: Yeah, so she's pretty upfront about it. Yeah, she's like. It's like, yeah, these, these things that that are potentially seen as bad things. You just have to define them as not the bad things. You can't tackle the

31:37 Mark: problem until you you redefine it. Yeah, yeah, yeah, and I like, I like that one. Yeah, uh, everyone's got a job if they want one. So if they don't have a job, it must be because they don't want one, so it's their fault, absolutely, yeah, yeah,

31:51 Jim: that's a bit of secular reasoning there.

31:53 Mark: Yeah, yeah, Trump also subscribes to the. Don't embarrass me by asking me questions about things that I'm not doing, questions about things that aren't going well aren't going well. Yeah, yeah, yeah, we just don't do that we'll just Just accept their explanation and move on.

32:12 Jim: So our final example is from the Joe Rogan experience, the podcast. Ah, yeah. One of the most popular podcasts in the world. Yay! And this was when right-wing journalist Andy Ngo was on. This example was kind of flagged up by our friends at the No Rogan experience, Marsh and Cecil, on a recent episode.

32:33 Mark: Second most popular podcast, absolutely.

32:35 Jim: Uh, when they looked at Andy neo's interview, they talked about this as reframing, which is completely fair and fitted in better with what the other examples that they were using about that episode. But I think it fits in pretty clearly here with the definist fallacy, because what is happening here is that Andy neo is trying to talk about how bad antifa is and Joe gets Jamie, his assistant, to look up the definition of fascism, right, and feels like Like being anti -that is probably a good thing.

33:03 Clip: Andy Ngo on the Joe Rogan Experience

— Yeah.

33:04 Jim: So Andy has to redefine what anti-for-Ashley is against.

33:09 Clip: Andy Ngo on the Joe Rogan Experience

— Pull up the definition, Jamie, so we can just read what fascism, what the actual word fascism means. Form of radical right-wing authoritarian ultra-nationalism characterized by dictatorial power, forcible suppression of opposition, and strong regimentation of society. And of the economy which came to prominence in early 20th century Europe.

— Fascism, as defined by political theorists who have been researching this for decades. It has a particular definition in meaning and that's um. I think that summarizes it pretty well. I'm very concerned that people use it so flippantly to just refer to the right or to even authoritarianism, like there's much more to it than just being authoritarian. There's all those other components and I need it needs. It's important to state that antifa is not just opposed to the far right or the right. They're also against liberal democracy. There's a reason why they hate the police so much, hate border enforcement and hate the rule of law. It's they're against the concept of the nation state as we understand it and they're working to dismantle that, to delegitimize it.

— No, they're not. No, that's a lie.

34:25 Jim: Yeah, yeah, they are against fascism, yeah,

34:29 Mark: yeah, and any. And you don't have to have all, you don't have to tick all the boxes to have fascistic tendencies in your government structure, absolutely.

34:39 Jim: And yeah, there is a reason why they're against the police and border patrol and that reason is because the police and border patrol currently are being fascists. Yeah, a lot of cases. Yeah, in a lot of the things they're doing – suppressing because they are being, yeah, yeah, controlled by a fascist government. Yeah, who is making them do fascist things like crushing dissent and killing people for protesting and things like that? Antifa is a is not an organization. Yeah, there are organized, organised areas, like in in local areas. There are people who organise and tell right, they have Facebook groups or they have you know email lists or whatever of people that might want to go out and protest – yeah, to protest against fascism. But it isn't a central organisation. It isn't one thing. It is, it is a concept. It is people who are generally against fascism. Yeah, that's the one thing. It's like atheists. Atheists can disagree about all kinds of things. The one thing they all agree with is that there isn't proof of a God. That's that's the thing that makes them atheists. The thing that makes people antifa is that they are anti -fascists. They aren't anti the nation state or anti the rule of law or any of those things, because that wouldn't be a someone who is antifa. The thing that makes them antifa is they are against fascism because what he's defining?

36:06 Mark: He's defining the police as an outcrop of policing by consent in a democratically elected and liberally run administration. Yeah, he said they're against liberal democracy. What the fuck? Where is the liberal democracy currently being? If it was, then the police wouldn't be cracking heads and cracking down on people and shooting processors in the back.

36:30 Jim: It would be nice to have a bit of liberal democracy for them to see whether they're against it or not.

36:36 Mark: Yeah, I suspect that they wouldn't be because it seems to be that a lot of this kind of big antifa… I think they'd be well up for that. Yeah, it's a big antifa liberal-democrat overlap, I would think, in my Venn diagram of good things. Those Venn diagrams are very circular.

36:56 Jim: It's not even concentric circle. But the thing is, Andy Ngo realised that if he continued to just say Antifa are bad – and he had that up against the definition of fascism – that's not going to work. That's a really bad argument. So you've got to. You have to either redefine fascism itself or redefine what Antifa are.

37:17 Mark: If they call themselves anti-orth, you know, anti-authoritarianism, just change the name. They're not an organisation. God.

37:27 Jim: I do want to stress that I cut out a little bit in the middle of that clip because I think that clip makes Joe sound actually quite responsible because he was looking up the definition of fascism. The bit I cut out because it wasn't about this fallacy, but Joe was basically saying, well, that basically defines the left. So he's also completely wrong. But he did at least find out what the definition was. And then he was saying, well, yeah, they're trying to crush any dissent and that kind of thing. aren't they? Because they don't like it if you say racist slurs and things like that. So, yeah, he's completely wrong. Because he's awful. But Andy Neal is also completely wrong.

38:08 Mark: And he's also trying to redefine fascism as further left-wing than Corbyn. It's the same kind of thing that Laura Trott said.

38:17 [Sting: Fake News] Yeah. So we're going to play Fake News, folks. I love the game. It's a great game. I understand the game as well as anybody. As well as anybody.

38:26 Jim: Yes, it's time for Fake News. Here's the game where I read out three Trump quotes, two of which are real and one I made up, and Mark has to figure out which one is fake news.

38:32 Mark: See, I think we should give diligent consideration to what we mean by winning with this game. It's about the appreciation of being able to spend one more day on this beautiful planet of ours, in the knowledge that we can come together to take part in playing, to enjoy the challenge and the intellectual rigour with which it's created, rather than anything to do with who got more than who. So that, that's the true meaning of winning. Oh, that's what it's about. I was wondering. It's laboring under a misapprehension all this time.

39:07 Jim: So, yeah, this collection of statements from Trump – it's actually from the same White House press conference that he did last time, that we were talking about last time. Because if you remember, he was mentioning the Save America Act and how actually Democrats are totally for that. So this follows on not very long after that, in that little rant. And he got somehow onto Gavin Newsom. Who had recently done a book tour event in Atlanta. So, statement number one. Do you know in California, if you ask a person to show their identification, they have the right to put you in jail? If you're an official and you say, may I please see your identification, you're subject to going to jail. That's how crazy it's gotten. With a low IQ person, you know, because Gavin Newsom has admitted that he is a, that he has learning disabilities. Honestly, I'm all for people with learning disabilities, but not for my president. I don't want. I think a president should not have learning disabilities.

40:06 Mark: Okay, oh, the irony of the lack of self -awareness. That's a bit like stuart lee's: you can get arrested and thrown in jail just for saying your English these days. Wow, yeah, okay, I wonder what he was going to call him.

40:24 Jim: Yeah, statement number two: yeah, and I know it's highly controversial to say such a horrible thing – the president of the united states, Gavin newscom, admitted that he has learning disabilities, dyslexia, everything about him is dumb. But then he looked at the audience and said: but I'm smarter than you, or something like that. That was pretty stupid. So now, on top of everything else, I call him a racist because it happened to be a black audience. I will tell you this. I think it was the worst interview I've ever seen of any Human being in my life. Number three: yeah, I mean, they don't even ask him difficult questions like I get. They ask him what's his favorite color and he does so badly. He can't answer a question and he can't even read. He said it. He said he can't read because he has learning disabilities. I can read. I was given on a difficult test and I aced it three times. Let me tell you, Gavin Newscum couldn't do it – no way he could do it, and there were some hard questions on there. They start out easy, but they get hard. Let me tell you, I do a lot of, I read a lot.

41:31 Mark: no, oh, my, I was giving and I aced it. There was some bad. Yeah, I can read.

41:38 [Unclear]: I can well, yeah, barely.

41:40 Mark: Yeah, whoa, this is the IQ test he's talking about. Out. There was some hard questions. They start out easy, but they get hard. Yeah, man, woman, yeah, it's not an iq test.

41:51 Jim: Uh, it's a. It's a, it's a cognitive, cognitive impairment.

41:55 Mark: Yes, not an iq test like he maintains. Yes, I've been, I've bought into the propaganda. That and the fact that you can read, yeah, okay, okay. See that the worst interview I've ever seen of any Human being in my life. Life is kind of Trump -sized hyperbole, but is it allure?

42:21 Jim: I want to know what the worst interview he's seen of a non-human animal is. Non-human animal, yeah.

42:28 Mark: Yes, a non-human being. Okay, he said he can't read, but I can read. See, I'm drawn to the, I was given a difficult test and I aced it. And he would say stupid things like they start easy, they get hard, in order to prove how brainy he is. Okay, I'm. I'm plumping four because of that hyperbole of the and dyslexia, would he say dyslexia. I'm gonna go for number two as the one you made up, okay.

43:00 Jim: So of the other two, which are you more convinced by?

43:02 Mark: More convinced by one?

43:05 Clip: Trump, played during Fake News

— Okay, and number one because,

43:08 Mark: just because I want to appear, yeah is real.

43:11 Clip: Trump, played during Fake News

— Do you know, in California, if you ask a person to show their identification, they have the right to put you in jail. If you're an official and you say, may I please see your identification, you're subject to going to jail. That's how crazy it's got with a low iq person. You know, because Gavin newscom has admitted that he is a, that he has learning disabilities, disabilities. Honestly, I'm all for people with learning disabilities, but not for my president. I don't want. I think a president should not have learning disabilities.

43:42 Mark: Okay, wow, he sounds like he's half asleep there. Wow, what was he gonna say with a low iq person. You know, because Gavin news comes admitted that he is a, that he has learning. Yeah, it's not great.

43:56 Jim: Not, he did, he did. Uh, recently when, When he was being asked about his ballroom by a female reporter, like one of those ones that he does out on the lawn when he's heading for Marine One. Basically, he was saying that she was dumb for not understanding that the budget had gone up because he'd increased the size of the ballroom. And he said, are you a… And he absolutely was going to use the R slur. He absolutely was going to, but he stopped himself and said, are you a dumb person? So it would not surprise me at all, but it really like, yeah, you could, yeah, you could hear it in the air, yeah, um, so, yeah, I wouldn't be at all surprised if that was what he was. Yeah, thinking he might say, yeah, but he's still mentally capable enough to stop himself from saying that on camera.

44:50 Mark: Oh well, there you go, and there's. Grateful for small mercies.

44:53 Jim: That's what we want from a president, isn't it? Yeah, to be just about mentally capable of avoiding using actual slurs on camera.

45:01 Mark: Yeah, that's what I want. I think a president should not have – yes, yes, he should not have a – uh, a library of of abusive terms that he meets. It meets out to the press. Oh, oh, no, yeah, wait, that's already happening. Yeah, yeah, so

45:20 Jim: is it true? Do you think that in California, if you ask a person to show their identification, they have the right to put you in jail?

45:28 Mark: I suspect. I suspect it's not accurate and that is untrue.

45:32 Jim: It's not a fully complete version of that law. Okay, because there is a law. There is a law in California. Yeah, to try and prevent that, because they don't want over zealous local politicians from enacting rules to require identification. That's what the law is about. It's not about individual kind of poll workers asking for identification, because there are some instances in which identification is required, but, like for general voting in, in most cases it's not required and nor should it be. And and so this law in California, sb 1174, basically says: a local government shall not enact or enforce any charter provision, ordinance or regulation requiring a person to present identification for the purpose of voting or submitting a ballot at any polling place, vote center or other location where ballots are cast or submitted, unless required by state or federal law. So in cases where there is identification required, they're still allowed to do that, but a local politician can't say in our county voter ID is required. That's all it is. It isn't suggesting local officials would be put in prison for saying can I see your identification? That's not a thing.

46:54 Mark: No, of course not. How does he… I guess. I guess it's because, in a kind of groundhog day kind of way, I wake up every day and then think: how does he get away with this stuff, forgetting that he's done so his entire life? For that moment, that blissful moment when I'm, when I before I remember all that – you think, oh, how's he getting away with that? Oh yeah, then the whole world tumbles in and you go: yeah, that's how, because he's in charge.

47:22 Jim: Well, I predict you're gonna feel yourself questioning that more times. This episode, as we, as we continue into the, is not a logical fallacy section on the headlines: yeah, yeah, yeah, oh yeah. How the fuck does he get away with any of this shit? Yeah, is a question that I've asked myself a few times this week, just this week alone. So you also think that number three is real, yes, and number three, yes, it's fake news.

47:56 Mark: Oh nice, oh, bloody hell. So that means worst interview I've ever seen of any Human being in my life. Ever kind of that is

48:05 Jim: hyperbole, is actually real thing.

48:06 Clip: Trump, played during Fake News

— He really said yes, and I know it's highly controversial to say such a horrible thing. The president of the united states, Gavin newscombe, admitted that he has learning disabilities, disabilities, dyslexia. Everything about him is dumb. But then he looked at the audience and said, but I'm smarter than you or something like that. It was pretty silly. So now on top of everything else, I call him a racist because it happened to be a black audience. I will tell you this. I think it was the worst interview I've ever seen of any Human being in my life.

— Okay, wow, so, wow.

48:44 Jim: He also called Gavin Newsom the president of the united states in that yes section.

48:51 Mark: Right, yeah, so you know, I think we shouldn't have a president while he's talking about the guy being an idiot. So he said. He says he's got learning disabilities, dyslexia. I don't suppose that newscom said that everything about him himself is dumb, because that's a Trump thing. To add on to that, that's the conclusion that he also didn't turn to

49:17 Jim: the audience, no, and say that he was smarter than them. Yeah, yeah, so this happened. What? What happened was that, uh, Gavin Newsom was at a book tour event in Atlanta because he wrote a book, a memoir, as politicians are want to do when they often seek higher office, and it's It's been suggested that Gavin Newsom will be running for president, probably the next time he gets the chance. So he wrote a memoir. He went around promoting it. He was at a book tour event in Atlanta, which he was interviewed by Atlanta Mayor Andre Dickens. And part of his memoir talks about his struggles with dyslexia and how that's made it difficult for him, but that he's managed to achieve stuff and that if you have dyslexia, that's something you can do too. And it's like you know hard but you can still do stuff. And he said in the interview. He said I'm I'm not trying to impress you, I'm just trying to impress upon you, I'm like you. I'm no better than you, I'm a 960 sat guy. So he was specifically saying to the audience: not, I'm smarter than you. Yeah, but I'm not like a super smart guy. I struggled at school. Yeah, I'm like everyone. I'm I'm like the general population. I'm average. I'm not saying I'm better than you. The right wing attacked him for that, because in saying I'm like you, I'm average, he was supposedly attacking a black audience because the right wing, being massive racists, assumed that because it was in Atlanta, it must have been a mainly black audience that he was attacking. King. Yeah, Atlanta Mayor Andre Dickens, who is black, yeah, defended him on on instagram and posted photos of the audience at this event, which was easily 75 white, probably over that, and and absolutely no reason to assume that in Gavin Newsom's head he was like: well, this audience is all black, so they're pretty stupid. I should try and claim I'm stupid too, so they embrace me as one of their own right. Yeah, yeah, but yeah, but the racist right wing were like: yeah, that's probably what happened, probably what happened.

51:32 Mark: We won't don't have to check for facts or anything. Yeah, ironically, the dumb people do think that Trump is like one of them and that's why they vote him. They vote him in.

51:43 [Unclear]: Yeah, that's weird.

51:45 Jim: Yeah, yeah, he's constantly talking about how he's not Not one of the elites from the literal Oval Office.

51:54 Mark: Yeah, and building statues to himself and things like that. No, I'm just like you. I'm not a Caesar by any means.

52:08 Jim: So we do have a few social contestants who may or may not have done better than you. Let's see.

52:14 Mark: Well, let's see. As I say, it's nothing to do with who got more than who. It's not about that. That's not what winning means.

52:23 Jim: Yeah, absolutely, victory can be defined many ways. Yes, so on Facebook, Amy says I first thought that number two had to be fake news because he refers to Gavin Newsom as president of the United States, but then I thought that Jim wouldn't give such an obvious clue and the actual president is demented. I'm guessing that number one is fake news just because number three references one of his favorite subjects: his stellar performance on various cognitive tests.

52:50 Mark: Yeah, that's what drew me in.

52:53 Jim: Yes, yeah, andrew said I think it's number one, the reason being that surely not even Trump could say that about people with learning difficulties. Or am I being naive?

53:03 Mark: Well, yeah, yeah, that that you know. Just enjoy that moment when, where you think: surely, surely he doesn't mean that. Surely he's not going to say that. Surely not. Just live in that moment.

53:17 Jim: And on Patreon, Jeremy says, Two, has to be two. I don't think he cares enough about the disability to actually name it. I imagine someone told Trump that Newsom is getting social media traction with his dyslexia. Trump said, what's that? And locked on to disability half of that diagnosis, showing again how he forgets the whole learning part.

53:39 Jim: Rene Z said, numbers one and two sound familiar. Number three sounds like a mash of Trump's hatred of Newsom and making fun of Newsom's dyslexia. Trump's bragging about how well he can read, even though he doesn't read anything. And Trump's bragging about how well he does on the cognitive decline test and how often he takes them. Not a good thing, Donald. Number three is fake news.

53:59 Mark: Yeah, there is that. Yeah, not a good thing. Keep your heart moving on about it. And there are difficult ones. They get hard towards the end. There was.

54:08 Jim: There was a. There's a video game lawyer – whose name momentarily escapes me, uh – who used to claim that he was the only lawyer who'd officially been, um, judged sane by the court, by florida courts, right, jack thompson. His name was and, and the reason that he was the only lawyer who'd been officially judged sane is that he's the only lawyer who people had attempted to sanction as as being insane and failed for his reaction to various video game lawsuits, and so the court was forced to weigh in and go. No, he's not insane, he's just like that.

54:47 Mark: there you go.

54:51 [Unclear]: So it's still on Patreon.

54:53 Jim: Yeah, becca says: I think number two is fake. I've gotten to where I don't really puzzle it out. I say it in my head, in Trump's voice, and then if any of them jump to jim's voice, I call that one fake. If none of them do, or more than one does, I just go with my gut. But it's all pseudoscience with a bit of astrology mixed in. But at this point, Jim is good enough that that mumbo-jumbo is as accurate as any other method.

55:14 Mark: Excellent.

55:16 Jim: Richard Thunder Hopkins says, I'm going with number one is fake news. I think just because they can throw you in jail for voting for Democrats by mail. I think going to jail for an ID check is too easily disproven. Not that he'd ever correct his stunt on anything. Double down, Donald. Triple D. Just like the peanuts. Mmm, peanuts.

55:34 Mark: Oh, thankfully a shiny thought distracted him towards the end there.

55:42 Jim: scott says I live in California and hardly ever get arrested for asking to see, and it's nice. The greedy turd thinks Gavin Newsom is president. But since Donald gets his facts so horribly wrong, so very often I'm going with number three being the one Jim made up, because the cognitive test that tacky mctaco tits cannot help but brag about just about seems to be low hanging fruit. And finally, yeah, like nick says, this is a tough one because I feel like I've heard all of these at some point or another. Right, I think this must be a gym chop shop special. I'm pretty sure that he said number one and I know that he's referred to garrison, to Newsom, as president at some point. So we'll call number two true, which means I'm saying unconfidently that three is fake. I'm also going to say that it's ironic for him to talk about someone with learning disabilities becoming president, but he has learning inabilities, which is totally separate.

56:31 Mark: Yes, a very important distinction. Wow, oh, there you go well abroad. You successfully hoodwinked. Oh, yeah, large majority tried all of them. Very good, and

56:50 Jim: it's time for the part of the show that, this week at least, is called: suing yourself is not a logical fallacy, because a while ago now Now, someone from the IRS – not the IRS as a whole, but a brave individual – leaked Trump's tax returns to the press so that we could see that he barely paid any income tax at all. And that he had massive business losses, like he's the worst business person ever. He sued the IRS because they allowed that leak to happen, basically. Or they weren't careful enough to make sure it didn't happen. So he sued the Irs and the Treasury Department and then became president again and that lawsuit continued, meaning that Donald Trump, the, the private citizen, was suing Donald Trump, the president, essentially because in his not at all separated administration, yeah, the Treasury Department and the Irs answer, answer completely to him. Yeah, and also because the Irs and the Treasury Department were represented in that lawsuit by the Department of Justice – yeah, which is also completely beholden to Donald Trump and is run by currently his former personal lawyer, Todd Blanche. Yeah, he is in control of both sides of that lawsuit. Yeah, so he said – that's why I say suing himself – yeah, and he sued them for For $10 billion, because that's how much he valued his reputational harm of people finding out how little income tax he paid. Because it wasn't not true. He paid like $750 in income tax and lost billions of dollars in his shitty businesses. But people finding that out when he was supposed to release his tax records and promised he would release his tax records when the IRS had finished auditing him, people discovering the truth about him was apparently $10 billion worth of reputational harm.

58:53 Mark: Because that might prevent him from, you know, rising up the kind of corporate ladder which certainly wouldn't allow him to become the President of the United States.

59:03 Jim: Of course not. In my opinion, he's overvaluing his reputation.

59:10 Mark: Goodbye, several orders of magnitude.

59:13 Jim: Yeah, well, it's a bit like when people thought that strongly of him before.

59:18 Mark: Yeah, well, it's also like he sued the. That was the same reasoning for suing the bbc for the edit they made on his january the 6th riot encouragement speech. Yes, yeah, because it put two

59:35 Jim: parts of the riot encouragement a bit too close together.

59:38 Mark: Yeah, yeah, and they said that was damaging my reputation and And I think the argument on the side of the BBC was: well, it was. It was never broadcast where you are. And it certainly didn't affect your chances during the election because you're now president again.

59:55 Jim: Which is a good argument. On the BBC's part. But the handy thing about suing yourself is that you don't have to make good arguments on either side. Because either way you win. And if you control which pockets that money goes into, that's helpful to you. Of course. But here's the thing. Because it's actually in the fucking US Constitution that a lawsuit has to be between two different people, not the same person. Like, the parties can't be the same person. There was going to be a ruling by a judge on this to say, well, this is bullshit, you can't do it. So the week before that ruling was due, he got rid of the judge. Department of Justice announced that they were settling the lawsuit, which is something you do if you think you're going to lose, right? Whereas what was going to happen was the lawsuit was going to get thrown out as bullshit. Yeah, I say, settle.

1:00:57 [Unclear]: Here's the thing. Yeah, that's how it's being reported.

1:01:00 Jim: That's what they said was happening. That's how lots of media organizations are reporting it as this is. There's a settlement between the DOJ and Trump. But it's, at best, an out-of-court settlement. What usually happens when lawsuits get settled is that both parties write up a settlement agreement and that agreement gets signed off on by the court. The court looks at it and goes, yeah, this seems fair. Everyone's done all the due diligence, all the signing of the right documents and all that kind of stuff. It's fine. What has happened here is the Doj has said we'll do something, and Trump, in response to that, has agreed to drop the 10 billion dollar lawsuit right, and the thing that the Doj has has decided, has agreed to do for that, yeah, is stuff which Trump wanted them to do right. So it's not. It's not a settle. It hasn't gone to a court. It happened to avoid this lawsuit being thrown out. Yeah, no, No court has seen it. No judge has signed off on it. It is just the Department of Justice deciding off their own backs to do a thing. And the thing they're doing is setting aside $1 .776 billion from an amorphous slush fund that they have for paying off settlements for frivolous lawsuits, essentially to make them go away. Yeah, they're gonna. They're moving that from their frivolous lawsuit account to a specific fund which is going to be distributed among people who claim they've had the Doj weaponized against them, that they claim that they've been targeted politically by the Department of Justice, right by which they mean people who are Trump supporters who've been targeted by the Department of Justice. Yeah, yeah, I .e. the Jan 6th people and people like them.

1:03:03 Mark: So you've only got to claim it? Well, there's a process.

1:03:09 Jim: You've got to claim it. I presume you have to at least fill in the form or something.

1:03:15 Mark: Can't just turn up and go, yeah, I was.

1:03:17 Jim: But the process is that it will be decided by a committee of five people, who will be appointed by Todd Blanche, Trump's pet Attorney General, and can be fired by Donald Trump at any time for any reason. So they'd probably better do what he wants them to do.

1:03:40 Mark: Which is give them money to recompense them.

1:03:44 Jim: Also, the oversight on this will be a courtly report which only goes to the attorney general, and it isn't required to give any of the their reasoning or processes for awarding any payments to people or name any of the people that they've given any money to. So it is a completely hidden black box of giving money to people. Trump likes wow,

1:04:11 Mark: dressed, dressed up as.

1:04:13 Jim: And he has total control over it.

1:04:17 Mark: And this has been approved?

1:04:21 Jim: Well, there's no one to approve it. Approve it. Because the Justice Department have just said they're going to do it to make the lawsuit go away. No court has looked at it or signed off on it or agreed to it. Even though there was no need to make the lawsuit go away.

1:04:35 Mark: Because it was never going to be it.

1:04:37 Jim: Because it was a stupid bullshit lawsuit that wasn't going to go anywhere.

1:04:40 Mark: And that's the Department of Justice.

1:04:44 Jim: So he's just basically made this thing up. This is just a thing that Todd blanchard's gone. Well, we could – I suppose we could – just give almost 1, .8 billion to to people that you that literally fight on your behalf, that literally, yeah, build gallows and chant, hang mike pence, because it's something you wanted them to do, yeah, and

1:05:04 [Unclear]: even though you had to spend

1:05:05 Jim: 20 days in prison, yeah, and and therefore they'll, they'll get a payout, which surely makes people more likely to do exactly that kind of shit in the future, rather

1:05:16 Mark: than prevent it. Well, it also, and it also legitimizes the notion that the Justice system has been weaponized by the Democrats, because you're, if you're setting up an anti -weaponization, because, yeah, Why would they be paying money out to people if they

1:05:37 Jim: hadn't been victimized?

1:05:40 Jim: If the DOJ hadn't been weaponized against them.

1:05:43 Jim: And because there's no requirement for them to reveal the reasoning or process behind any of the claims. If a person like I don't know, say James Comey, who is currently being prosecuted for taking a photo of some shells on a fucking beach speech, were to put in a claim, they could just say no, no,

1:06:08 Mark: No because because? Yeah, because he votes for the wrong side. Yeah, yeah, but man, it gets worse. Oh my God, I thought you could say: but there's a glimmer of light, but no, no, no, no, there's no glimmer of light, it is fully dark.

1:06:27 Jim: So, yeah, the day after they announced that this thing was happening, that they were just basically making this this black slush fund for Trump supporters who have done crimes and then been prosecuted for those crimes – yes, under the law – Todd Blanche put out an addendum right to this settlement agreement, which again isn't a thing. It starts. It says: the settlement agreement in Trump v internal resume service has created the anti -weaponization fund. That's what they're calling it. The settlement agreement directed the attorney general to issue an order establishing funding and any other relevant requirements for the fund. The settlement agreement did not direct the attorney general to do that. The direct. The attorney general wrote the things he was going to do and called it a settlement agreement. It didn't direct them to do anything, no, but here's the thing: on top of that fund that they're creating of 1, .8 billion dollars, yeah, it says the united states releases, waves, acquits and forever discharges each of the plaintiffs, that's Trump from and is hereby forever barred and precluded from prosecuting or pursuing any and all claims, counterclaims, causes of action, appeals or requests for any relief, including injunctive relief, monetary relief, damages, examinations or similar or related reviews, appeals, debt relief costs, attorneys fees, expenses and or interest, whether presently known or unknown as of the effective date of the settlement agreement, or that have been or could have been asserted by defendants against any of the plaintiffs or related or affiliated individuals. So the defendants are the IRS and the Treasury Department. So they are, according to this paragraph, forever barred and precluded from doing anything about any of the financial crimes Trump committed up to this point by this agreement. They cannot prosecute. They can't even audit him or the Trump organization. Because the plaintiffs in this case were Donald Trump and the Trump Organization. So this is basically saying, from this point forward, they have been handed an immunity specifically for any tax fraud. They've done up to this point. There is literally nothing you can do about it.

1:08:54 Mark: Or any they will do in the future.

1:08:57 Jim: It says as of the effective date of the settlement agreement. So it doesn't preclude them from prosecuting him for future tax fraud. But up to May 19th, 2026, everything he's done is protected. There is nothing that the DOJ can do about it. Except for another president going in and the DOJ ripping this up because it's bullshit and doesn't mean anything.

1:09:29 Jim: So it doesn't actually preclude them from doing it. It's basically saying top -notch is saying the IRS now if they've got any audits against the Trump organisation or Trump, they've got to stop them and that's it. There's nothing they can do about it, even if they find massive fraud, which they inevitably would if they started looking into anything that Trump has ever done. And they had already, I'm sure.

1:09:50 Mark: And that was inevitably demanded by the agreement. There was nothing to do with Tom Blanche. The agreement told me to do it.

1:10:00 Jim: It directed him. Directed him to do it.

1:10:05 Mark: Yeah, wow, yes, it's not Trump saying okay, so stop them doing that and write that in legalese so it doesn't sound like me. Oh my God. So I guess that is the small glimmer of hope. Is the next DOJ will just come in and look at this stuff and said, well, that's not the law. That's not law. You can't just make law up.

1:10:34 Jim: This is the DOJ equivalent of an executive order. They've just written it, and it's not been approved by Congress. It's not been looked at by a court. It's just Todd Blanche signing a thing and going, yeah, we're not going to do anything about any of the crimes you've committed.

1:10:49 Mark: For fear of whatever. Without fear or favor. Because it'll be.

1:10:56 Jim: He'll go the same way as pan bondi. It'll be, yeah, yeah. Well, when was the last time you heard about pan bondi? Oh yeah, the dow is back over 50 000 and we haven't heard anything. Pan bondi recently.

1:11:08 Mark: Yeah, so, yeah, yeah, so that, yes, it is taken out of the glare of publicity. That's well. That is fate worse than death for Trump. So perhaps he's imparted that to all of his acolytes.

1:11:20 Jim: But, yeah, basically he – he had short of them agreeing to pay him the 10 billion dollars he initially asked for, which he claimed would have been donated to charity. Yeah, right, essentially, he definitely told Todd Blanche to do this. There was no question that this was something that they were like. Oh no, what are we going to do about this lawsuit that we're definitely going to lose? Maybe we could try this and the and there was like negotiation on both sides. No, Todd Blanche was Bugs Bunny in the baseball cartoon where he's playing all the bases. He was being Trump's lawyer and the DOJ lawyer for this case and was like swapping seats to go. Well, I suppose we could set up a slush fund and then, moving to the other side of the table, going: yes, I think that's a good idea. It's just such fucking bullshit.

1:12:09 Mark: Ahead of the entire thing being thrown out by somebody else that wasn't a Trump acolyte. A light, yeah, and that judge

1:12:17 Jim: who was going to throw it out, yeah, has has now dismissed that, that challenge, that case, uh, and said, well, now it's moot because there is no lawsuit, there's no kind of pending case now. So I can't, I can't throw it out because there's nothing to do. They've, they've settled, they've agreed, not, they've withdrawn. Essentially, what's happened is trying to withdrew the thing and then disguised it as

1:12:38 Mark: a settlement, yeah, by making up other laws, wars, okay, yeah, yeah, uh, but you know, not a fascist government as, oh, no, no, no, no would say, and one day it will be. Finally and finally, some things

1:12:57 Jim: we really don't have time to talk about. First off, we have some updates to news stories we covered last episode. The reflecting pool enshittification which was going to cost $1.8 million and take one week is now going to cost $13.1 million, and Trump says it should be finished by July 4, “our target date”, which is more than eight weeks after the project started. Despite previously referring to the contractor as his own “pool guy”, who had worked on his golf club swimming pools, he now claims “I didn’t give out the contract, ‘Interior’ did, to a contractor I did not know, and have never used before.” Maybe this selective amnesia is due to the budget and schedule overruns, or maybe it’s because internal Department of the Interior documents report that bubbles and small holes are appearing in one of the waterproof coatings, and the unevenly applied paint has left the pool mottled in various shades of American Flag Blue. There’s also been concern that Atlantic Industrial Coatings, the non-union firm that was awarded the no-bid contract despite never having worked with the federal government before, may be ignoring the safety of their workers in the rush to get the job finished within seven weeks of the original deadline. Meanwhile the $400 million of taxpayer money we told you Republicans were seeking for Trump’s new ballroom ballooned to a billion dollars, which I can only assume Lindsey Graham announced with his pinkie held up to his mouth. Fortunately, the Senate parliamentarian, Elizabeth McDonough, officially stepped in to cockblock the GOP’s attempt to sneak it in as part of a budget reconciliation package because apparently a führerbunker with a fancy top floor is outside the scope of such a bill. And finally, Kash Patel, keen to prove that the Atlantic made up all that reporting of his drunken shenanigans, has been ordering polygraphs for more than a dozen current and former members of his security detail to find out who leaked the definitely not true stories to Atlantic reporter Sarah Fitzpatrick just before she made them up, which he’ll totally prove in court. Fitzpatrick stands by her reporting, saying that since the article came out, even more people have come forward to corroborate the details. In fact, after he sued her, nevertheless she persisted, publishing a whole new story about Kash’s preferred souvenir that he hands out to people lucky enough to have met him – personalized bottles of Woodford Reserve Kentucky bourbon, engraved with the words “Kash Patel, FBI Director”, and an FBI shield held in the talons of an eagle. Kash has reportedly used DoJ aircraft to haul cases of this narcissism-juice across the globe, handing them out to civilians and staff alike. One bottle was even left behind in an Olympic locker room in Milan, the same trip where his beer-chugging antics reportedly infuriated teetotaler Trump. An FBI spokeslackey claimed it was just part of a long-standing Bureau tradition, saying “Senior Bureau officials have long exchanged commemorative items in formal gift settings consistent with ethics rules”. However, when a former senior FBI official was asked if any previous director had ever handed out personally branded liquor, he literally burst out laughing. In March, Kash took a case of his bourbon to a Quantico seminar where UFC fighters trained FBI agents in mixed martial arts, which is a weird sentence. When a single bottle went missing, Kash allegedly “lost his mind,” threatening to polygraph and prosecute his own staff over the theft. While regular FBI agents face a strict zero-tolerance policy for alcohol on the job, the Director is using the federal apparatus to protect his stash. Legal counsel for current whistleblowers are now giving agents a bizarre new piece of advice for dealing with the nation’s top law enforcement official: “Run from him.”

1:16:32 Mark: Trump loves golf – he loves golfers, he loves Arnold Palmer’s weiner! But he only loves golfers that pay him to belong to one of his golf courses – Jeffrey Epstein please stand up! And he loves balls and ballrooms more, so much so the debris from the demolition of the East Wing has been piled up on the nearby 100 year-old public East Potomac Golf Links. Like some huge inside out bunker 30,000 cubic yards of soil and detritus looms over the greens causing golfers to detour around piles of it. An interim report requested by the parks service from a Virginia engineering firm says the soil has tested positive for lead, chromium and other toxic metals, along with PCBs, pesticides, petroleum byproducts and other chemicals that were detected at levels above laboratory reporting limits in soil. The nonprofit DC Preservation League has sued the Trump administration arguing “the Defendants dumped a cocktail of contaminants — and despite indications of the refuse’s contents, they continued dumping it”. Trump’s Interior Department said in an email Tuesday that the soil removed from the White House “was tested multiple times, by multiple parties, and this project passed all standards set by law.” (*scoffs*) and that it is “committed to continuing the relationships we have built with the local golf communities to ensure these courses are safe, beautiful, open, affordable, enjoyable, accessible, and world-class for people living in and visiting the greatest capital city in the world.” Oddly this commitment includes the Trump administration’s plans to renovate the 105-year-old course to make it a professional-level course, including the proposed felling of a dozen or so trees. Yeah nothing says beautiful, enjoyable and accessible like dumping your shit in the neighbour’s garden and then declaring you’ll close it, chop everything down and reopen it as a members-only facility as a way to solve the problem. Will membership include a hazmat suit, geiger counter and face mask? – yeah sure in Trump branded colours of course!

1:18:42 Jim: Fun fact, the US government still technically has an Office of Government Ethics. I’m guessing it’s run by three monkeys with their hands glued to different parts of their heads. Last week, they released Trump’s latest financial disclosure form, and I’m starting to think this guy might not be playing by the rules. In November, Trump launched the “Genesis Mission,” a Department of Energy initiative designed to use US supercomputers to harness AI for scientific research, and casually slash regulations for his billionaire tech backers along the way. On December 18th, Energy Secretary Chris Wright announced tech startup CoreWeave had joined the programme, and their stock shot up by almost 20%. During the week before the announcement, buried deep inside the 113-page financial disclosures, are two purchases, by Trump, of CoreWeave stock, each worth between a quarter and half a million dollars. We don’t know exactly how much, because disclosure rules only require broad ranges rather than dollar amounts. What we do know is that when he sold his CoreWeave stock the very next fucking day after the announcement, that transaction was in the $1 to 5 million range. Now you may think that sounds like the kind of felony insider trading that usually carries up to 20 years in prison, but actually, it must have just been a lucky guess, as according to a spokesperson for the Trump Organisation, “President Trump’s investment holdings are maintained exclusively through fully discretionary accounts independently managed by third-party financial institutions with sole and exclusive authority over all investment decisions. Trades are executed and portfolios are balanced through automated investment processes and systems administered by those institutions.” But we know that wasn’t true for Thermo Fisher Scientific, a medical supply company. On March 11, Trump toured their facility in Ohio, dragging the executives onto the stage to talk about what an “incredible company” it was, and begged Big Pharma to give them contract work. He didn’t mention that the exact same day, he had personally bought between $15 and $50,000 of Thermo Fisher stock, to add to the $66 to 165,000 worth he’d already bought in the weeks leading up to his visit. We know this wasn’t an automated trade by a clairvoyant investment system because the forms explicitly marked these transactions as “UNSOLICITED.” For anyone who doesn’t speak Wall Street, that means the trade wasn’t recommended by a broker. The client demanded it themselves. That same day, Immediately after leaving Thermo Fisher, Trump flew to Kentucky and gave a speech drooling over Apple, calling them a great company, and announcing that they would be spending hundreds of billions of dollars on new plants in the US. Right on cue, the disclosures show that on that exact day, Trump made another unsolicited purchase of between a quarter and half a million dollars in Apple stock, bringing his total so far that month to between $2 and 7.2 million. He did it again with Micron, buying up to $100,000 in unsolicited stock right before calling into Fox News to declare them “one of the hottest companies.” He did it with Dell, buying at least a million unsolicited bucks in shares before literally telling a crowd in Georgia to “go out and buy a Dell computer.” He even managed to buy up to a million dollars in Nvidia stock precisely a week before his own Commerce Department magically approved chip sales to China. But don’t worry, those three ethics monkeys are on the case and Trump has already faced swift, brutal consequences related to these trades. By law, he was required to report all trades within 45 days, and he missed that window frequently, so they fined him $200.

1:22:07 Mark: Wow, let that be a lesson to him.

1:22:10 Jim: Yeah, I reckon Susan Collins will be saying, well, he's probably learned his lesson.

1:22:14 Mark: Yeah, and also the IRS can't investigate any of that.

1:22:19 Jim: Well, it would be the SEC who would investigate this, I don't know if they're part of the Treasury Department. They probably are, in which case that's, yeah.

1:22:27 Mark: Well, it will come under Todd Blanche's next amendment that the agreement will force him to write.

1:22:35 Mark: Air Wars. Airwars, a civilian harm monitor, estimated that US drone and air strikes alone killed at least 22,000 civilians – and perhaps as many as 48,000 – in the 20 years after the 9/11 terrorist attacks in 2001, perhaps that’s why Hegseth was clear to say that no nation in history had taken more precautions than the US to avoid civilian deaths and was full of praise for the Pentagon’s civilian harm mitigation and response (CHMR) program, designed to handle training and procedures critical in limiting civilian harm in theaters of war. It was created by Lloyd Austin, then defense secretary, in January 2022, under Joe Biden, following years of deadly US bombing campaigns in Yemen, Iraq, Syria and Afghanistan. No no of course Hogsbreath wasn’t full of praise – he blamed Iranians for hiding missile launchers in civilian areas when asked why the US had bombed and killed 175 people, a majority of them children, at an all-girls school in Minab. The bombing took place the same month that Hegseth’s Pentagon had quietly dismantled that very program which it is legally required to operate in order to prevent and respond to civilian deaths in US military operations, according to its internal watchdog. While the program has not been officially canceled, the inspector general’s report said that funding had ended for a data management platform; committee meetings had halted; and many dedicated personnel had been lost or reassigned. The report, published on 13 May, points to an inflection point in February, when two senior officials – the acting under-secretary of war for policy, Elbridge Colby, and the secretary of the army, Dan Driscoll – separately proposed to Hegseth the program be cut or eliminated. One proposal recommended scrapping its action plan and its underpinning departmental instruction entirely. Then, without waiting for a response, the military began acting as if the cuts had already been approved. Later that month, the US launched strikes on Iran. The US strike on the school in Minab, occurred on 28 February – around the same time as the inspector general found that CHMR’s operations had ground to a halt. Madison Hunke, US program manager at the Center for Civilians in Conflict, said: If Iran is “any indication of the Department’s current approach to civilian harm after gutting 90% of it’s CHMR workforce, it’s hard to imagine what future US operations might look like if these programs are further degraded.” The Trump administration cut peace time funding to foreign aid affecting millions of people so why would they care about preventing deaths during war? Nobel Prize anyone?

1:25:10 Jim: Some hypothetical questions have dogged philosophers for decades, or even centuries. If a tree falls in the forest, does it make a sound? Can we ever truly know if we’re living in a simulation? The whole Ship of Theseus thing. But earlier this month, YouGov asked what may be the greatest hypothetical question of all time: Could you beat Donald Trump in a fight? For Democrats, of course, this is a fucking easy question, He’s an obese nearly-80-year-old and he’s actively decomposing. 75% of Democrats questioned said they could beat Trump. 19% said not sure, and 5% said Trump would win – I presume that 5% are currently already in hospice care. There was no box to tick to confirm that you’d bloody love to have a go, but that would have been 100%. But for Republicans, it’s a different story. MAGA folk are genetically unable to describe themselves without using the word Alpha, but if they even entertain the possibility that Trump is less physically fit than Ivan Drago, their entire worldview collapses. Sure enough, they are such monumental cucks that only 33% of Republican voting Americans are prepared to claim they could defeat Trump in a fight, and 39% reckon the wheezing lump of trans fats in a bad suit would win. The event that triggered this amazing survey was the Oval Office based signing of a proclamation to revive the Presidential Physical Fitness Award, during which Trump did a totally normal, well-adjusted thing. He turned to one of the kids who’d been brought in for a photo op and asked him “Do you think you could take me in a fight?” Naturally, YouGov looked at this and thought, “This requires a scientific sample size.” So they also asked those same 2,609 Americans who they thought would win in a brawl between Trump and a hypothetical eight-year-old boy. Again, Democrats are skeptical of Trump’s combat skills, and short of a scenario involving a golf club and a highly strategic golf cart getaway, only 26% put their money down on Trump, while 54% say the kid would win, then go back to watching Bluey. And before you say eight is too old for that show, my Mum is 86 today, and she fucking loves Bluey. To put that in perspective, Democrats have way more confidence in a literal eight-year-old than Republicans have in their own grown-adult selves. 72% of those Republicans, by the way, think Trump would crush the eight-year-old who, let’s face it, would be weakened by the stench before he got too close, but 6% are woke enough to admit that the third-grader, or presumably a light breeze, would be enough to topple the melting senior citizen.

1:27:59 Mark: my God. On Mother’s Day the White House launched a new website, Moms.gov. On first glance that looks like Mumsnet yeah? A forum for discussing and exchanging views relating to the difficulties in navigating motherhood and the working and political environments, a supportive environment cognisant of and dedicated to, the rights and equalities of women and mothers.Yeah you’re not gonna get that from an administration where at a press conference launching the site Dr. Mehmet Oz warned that “One in three Americans are ‘under-babied,’” and where Trump declared himself the “father of fertility.” At the launch Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. promoted Moms.gov as “one-stop shopping for IVF, for prenatal care, for postnatal care, for nutrition, for baby formula, and of course, for TrumpRx.” It would be more accurate, however, to say that the website is aimed at asserting Trump’s “pro mom” bona fides while preying on vulnerable women with thinly veiled propaganda of an anti-abortion, anti-vaccine, and anti-feminist bent. On pregnancy support for instance the website says, sympathetically, that “navigating pregnancy can feel overwhelming, but you don’t have to do it alone.” Moms.gov then offers a link to “Find Pregnancy Centers Near You,” the linked website, Option Line, which you’re not told, is operated by the Christian anti-abortion organization Heartbeat International. It directs women away from clinics like Planned Parenthood and toward faith-based crisis pregnancy centers, where they will be bombarded with misinformation and love-bombed with support. The word “abortion” never appears on the Moms.gov homepage, but the message is anti-abortion all the same. As a whole, Moms.gov carries a strong anti-feminist undercurrent. In March, the Trump-allied Heritage Foundation released a new document titled “Saving America by Saving the Family.” Heritage, which previously spearheaded Project 2025, blamed falling fertility rates not only on “the proliferation of birth control,” but also on “more prospects for women to receive higher education and work outside the home, the delayed financial independence of young adults, and the government’s role in old-age security.” Furthermore the only mention of working motherhood on the homepage links to a warning that “workplace exposures, conditions, and tasks can affect workers’ sexual and reproductive health.” With the Trumpfather of fertility the “tradwife” life is the only safe choice for babies and moms. As with all of the MAHA rhetoric voiced by metal tool-shed thrown into a concrete mixer RFK Jr the intent is to flood the search engines and distract overworked underinformed women with Government sanctioned propaganda designed to further their aim of disenfranchising anyone but rich, white, christian men, but then DangerousMysoginistsinPower.gov doesn’t have quite the same Maga needs Moms feel I guess.

1:30:56 Jim: I think we should still buy DangerousMisogynistsInPower.gov just so they don't.

1:31:02 [Unclear]: Because they can't just do it, yeah. Just, you know, because they will. Yeah.

1:31:10 Jim: Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy has decided that the best way to handle a national energy crisis and a chaotic, disaster-prone aviation sector is to return to his true passion: being an MTV reality television star. In a move that perfectly represents the crossover between the current federal cabinet and 90’s trash TV, Duffy dropped a trailer for The Great American Road Trip. It’s a five-part YouTube series following him, his wife, and their nine children as they trek across the country on what he calls a “civic experience” to celebrate America’s upcoming 250th birthday. The trailer features the family snowmobiling, hitting up water slides, and hanging out with a Benjamin Franklin reenactor, Kid Rock, and Trump himself, but it’s OK, because Duffy was working from the road, which in this case means he occasionally glanced at an air-traffic control tower as they sped past. The backdrop to this wholesome family content is that the administration’s war in Iran has sent gas prices skyrocketing to their highest levels in nearly four years. While everyday Americans are having panic attacks at the pump, the nation’s Transportation Secretary is cheerfully telling them to “gas up the car!” Former Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg immediately took to Twitter to call the project “brutally out of touch,” prompting Duffy to counter that the “radical, miserable left” simply hates patriotism and doesn’t want people to learn civics. But some people who already know about civics have been asking questions about how this boondoggle was funded. Duffy and his spokespeople have repeatedly insisted that “zero taxpayer dollars” were used, because the producers formed a brand-new nonprofit called The Great American Road Trip Inc.—an organization whose corporate sponsor list is made up entirely of companies currently under the direct regulatory thumb of Sean Duffy. Toyota, Boeing, and United Airlines – firms that rely on the Department of Transportation for safety approvals, oversight, and a lack of crippling fines – generously footed the bill for the Secretary’s gas, car rentals, lodging, and activities. The trailer even features prominent, unmissable product placement for Toyota, which I’m sure American automakers are super happy about. Donald Sherman, president of Citizens for Ethics and Responsibility in Washington, pointed out that if this is an official work project, “then taxpayer funds should be paying for it, and if it’s a vacation or some kind of personal trip, then certainly industry should not be paying for it.” Being Transport Secretary probably is much more difficult and boring than being on reality TV, so if that means turning the Department of Transportation into a rolling, tax-exempt commercial for the companies you’re supposed to be regulating, so be it.

1:33:37 Mark: Yeah, fair enough. Well Labour received a whipping at the local election polls, acting as a kind of mid-term assessment of how the country thinks the government is doing, the local elections half way through a national administration’s term in office are really about who people want to be in charge of their local councils, there is no direct effect on who is in power. This has led to buyers remorse when fed up racists vote for reform and then find out that their candidate said things about melting down Nigerians to fill in potholes and had to stand down and force another election. Rinse and repeat across the country as newly-elected and sorely underqualified councillors resigned. Like all disappointed footballers, calls are being made within the team to replace the coach after this one-sided scoresheet event. And one Labour MP, of whom no-one had heard, Catherine West said she’d launch a leadership campaign unless Starmer bucked his ideas up. She didn’t, and really neither did he. Instead, to show he was in touch with the people’s present day concerns in post-brexit post-covid, post-Reform Britain Starmer drafted in support from Gordon Brown and Harriet Harman who were last in office three decades ago. Victim of Bloatyhead from the Theme Hospital Game Wes Streeting resigned as Health Minister and has yet to launch a leadership contest, a Labour MP stepped down to enable left-wing man-of-the-people Andy Burnham to be able to stand for election as an MP and thus challenge for the leadership, both Wes and Keir have since announced a full-blown return to the EU as something they’d do which is directly stolen from Andy Burnham’s recent rhetoric and designed to thwart his chances, as is his standing in a seat that voted 60% Leave in the Brexit Referendum and has just elected a Reform Council. As always – never ones to waste a good crisis the Labour Party start falling on each other with knives out.

1:35:36 Jim: My favorite reform councillor who's recently resigned is the one who resigned because voters has discovered his gay only fans account. Wow, but mainly because, like, only the people who voted him in, yeah, had a problem with it, right.

1:35:51 Mark: Everyone else is like, yeah, fine, wow, but he had to resign because the people he's ripped. Well, what that or that? And also, there's a, there's an a council. There's the youngest council leader also got elected to lead another council. He's 19 and he's now in charge large of two.

1:36:12 Jim: Yeah, yeah, he was because he, because he didn't realize he was on the ballot for for both councils at the same time. Yeah, because that's how professional these reform politicians are.

1:36:22 Mark: So he's gonna do it, despite the fact he's gonna run both of them, oh yeah, or be a cancer in both.

1:36:27 Jim: Is that well a thing you can do?

1:36:32 Mark: but they're just gonna do it. Yeah, yeah and then. And then it's not like rules exist, no, So well, I mean, you know if Farage is a socialist, yeah.

1:36:44 [Unclear]: There you go.

1:36:46 Jim: So that's all the bad arguments and faulty reasoning we have time for this week. You'll find the show notes at fallacioustrump.com. And if you hear Trump say something stupid and want to ask if it's a fallacy, our contact details are on the contact page.

1:36:56 Mark: If you think we've used a fallacy ourselves, let us know. And if you've had a good time, please give us a review on Apple Podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts. Or simply tell one other person in person about how much they'd like our podcast. And you can support the show at Patreon .com slash ftrump, just like our strawman level patrons Chris Ward, Adam Mike Smith, Scott LT, Richard Thunder Hopkins, Mark Reiche and Amber R. Buchanan, who told us when we met her at QED we could just call her Amber. And at QED in 24 I met the listener who recognised us at QED the year before because we keep using her full name all the time. And last year we attempted to understand the rooting of the plumbing in the cupboard in the Mad Hatter's house while contemplating the interconnectedness of all things and our true Scotsman level patrons, chuck gray, renee zed, janet luetta and our top patron, Kaz Toohey. Thank you ever so much, everybody, for your continued patronage. We really do appreciate it, thank you.

1:37:45 Jim: You can connect with those awesome people as well as us and other listeners in the Facebook group at Facebook .com slash groups – slash fallacious Trump. Or in the Discord at fallacious Trump .com slash Discord. All music.

1:37:56 Mark: Goodbye the outbursts. And was used with permission, so until next time on fallacious Trump. We'll leave the last word to the Donald.

1:38:04 [Unclear]: That's right. Go home to mommy. Bye. Bye.

Share this episodeBlueskyThreadsFacebookRedditEmail

Never miss a fallacy

New episodes every couple of weeks. Subscribe free wherever you listen, or support us on Patreon.

Also on Pocket Casts, Android and RSS.